Why Weakening JR Wrecked Dallas

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
I was also surprised when I first watched it, but that's one of the few things about TNT Dallas that made sense. Cliff had allowed bitterness, jealousy and revenge to consume him and it took its toll! It would have had to. Nobody can allow all those negative emotions to fill their mind and not have it eat them up from the inside.

Cliff could have had a good life as a capable lawyer, but he threw his career away going after an unbeatable opponent that crushed his political career when he kept attacking them and they had to - it was self-defense. Cliff could have done anything in law that didn't involve the Ewings but he wouldn't.

We saw how it had already affected him. When we first saw Cliff, he seemed to be a relatively normal, bright guy with a promising future. Then he started ruining his life by allowing all those negative thoughts to fill his mind. He couldn't keep a woman because he was so inconsiderate to them. He probably even talked to them about JR when they were in bed! He could not have a conversation without saying "JR" because Cliff was absolutely obsessed.

He started acting goofy (which he had not done before) and we saw him him adopting weird awkward physical mannerisms. He was mentally crumbling.

Now imagine the progression of that from the end of the original show to the start of TNT Dallas. All that negativity had absolutely eaten him up from the inside; it had consumed his soul. He had become exactly what you would expect a man would become of he allowed his mind to filled with bitterness, jealousy and vengeance. It had consumed anything good that had once been within him and what was left of the man was what you saw in TNT Dallas.

You could understand it up to a point, but that doesn't account for how, seemingly without care, he was prepared to sacrifice Pamela and her babies. That goes beyond bitterness.

Swami
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
I had no problem with JR being kind of burned out in the last couple of seasons. It happens. I had a much bigger problem with the show around him doing the same thing.
 

pete lashmar

Telly Talk Addict
Instead of the ridiculous storyline with LeeAnn De La Vega they should have concocted a plot where a few of J.R's old rivalries came together to set him up for a big fall. For me, seeing the jail door close on J.R would have been a very fitting end to the original series - and seeing old faces would have been a nice thank you to long term fans.

I should also add - although I hated the LeeAnn De La Vega plot, I loved seeing Barbara Eden in the show but such a shame they gave her a lousy storyline.
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
Instead of the ridiculous storyline with LeeAnn De La Vega they should have concocted a plot where a few of J.R's old rivalries came together to set him up for a big fall. For me, seeing the jail door close on J.R would have been a very fitting end to the original series - and seeing old faces would have been a nice thank you to long term fans.

I should also add - although I hated the LeeAnn De La Vega plot, I loved seeing Barbara Eden in the show but such a shame they gave her a lousy storyline.

There was an element of that in the last few episodes, remember Dusty coming back to play a part in thwarting JR's plans to take over West Star.

Swami
 

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
There was an element of that in the last few episodes, remember Dusty coming back to play a part in thwarting JR's plans to take over West Star.

Swami

They also missed a trick by not getting Barbara Bel Geddes back for the last few episodes.

Miss Ellie should've arrived & given her son JR a strong talking to.

Her return would've been great dramatically for the show.

The Producers really did Barbara a disservice by only offering her a four episode deal for the final season. :(
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
For me, seeing the jail door close on J.R would have been a very fitting end to the original series - and seeing old faces would have been a nice thank you to long term fans.

I’m somewhat piggybacking The Godfather 2 ending, but IMO, a more symbolic ending would have been a silver haired JR, all alone, sitting at the dining room table after thinking about just how cruel he really was over the years. He’d be thinking, “was all the double dealing really worth it in the end?”

I think it would have been a powerful scene because even though the Ewing’s were a dysfunctional family, the dining room was a place that they all came together and in the end, JR drove everybody away.
 
Last edited:

pete lashmar

Telly Talk Addict
I’m somewhat piggybacking The Godfather 2 ending, but IMO, a more symbolic ending would have been a silver haired JR, all alone, sitting at the dining room table after thinking about just how cruel he really was over the years. He’d be thinking, “was all the double dealing really worth it in the end?”

I think it would have been a powerful scene because even though the Ewing’s were a disfunctional family, the dining room was a place that they all came together and in the end, JR drove everybody away.
Well that is kind of what they did, he'd driven everyone away and then Joel Grey turned up :(
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
Barbara deserved a full season with strong storylines, not the feeble offering she was given.

Swami
 

pete lashmar

Telly Talk Addict
Barbara deserved a full season with strong storylines, not the feeble offering she was given.

Swami
It's a great shame that they never had board meetings with people to make deals, I would have loved to have seen Ellie leading the clan with something like that. The shares idea worked when Jock went to South America, but seeing Miss Ellie as head of the board would have been great - and we know that BBG would have been brilliant at it.
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
It's a great shame that they never had board meetings with people to make deals, I would have loved to have seen Ellie leading the clan with something like that. The shares idea worked when Jock went to South America, but seeing Miss Ellie as head of the board would have been great - and we know that BBG would have been brilliant at it.

Yes, we only really saw them on the occasions they tried to vote JR out as president.

Swami
 
Top