Donna Reed, "She Just Wasn't Mama"

Angela Channing

Telly Talk Veteran
I can't remember whether it was Larry Hagman or Patrick Duffy who said that in relation to Donna Reed taking over the role of Miss Ellie but I often wondered would they have had said the same thing had Mary Martin had been cast in that role?

When Barbara Bel Geddes decided to retire there was some speculation as to who would be the new Ellie and it was reported that Larry had suggested his mother, Mary Martin, for the role. Do you think the cast and the viewers would have accepted her as Miss Ellie? When Barbara decided to come out of retirement to go back to the role would that have dared to sack Larry's mother? It would have been interesting to see how the producers had handled that situation.
 

Sarah

Moderator Emerita
Ooo interesting. Yes Mary Martin was suggested and I think she would have been softer and more down to earth like Barbara was in the role.

I highly doubt Mary would have been sacked, so it's interesting to think about what could have happened. Yikes.
 

Ukdallasfan

Telly Talk Fan
Mary Martin would have been as unsuitable for the role as Donna Reed was. Donna was too ladylike and not earthy enough. Mary would have been too brash and blousy. I always feel bad for Donna at the way she was treated and it was only right that she won substantial damages after she was sacked. The problem was that Barbara had become synonymous with the role :)
 

Ukdallasfan

Telly Talk Fan
No, I wasn’t sad to see her go because she was just, well, wrong in the role. However, I do think she was treated badly. I read that she had to sue or threaten to Sue before Lorimar would pay her prospective loss of earnings which was poor form on their part. Barbara’s return was very welcome though :)
 

Sarah

Moderator Emerita
No, I wasn’t sad to see her go because she was just, well, wrong in the role. However, I do think she was treated badly. I read that she had to sue or threaten to Sue before Lorimar would pay her prospective loss of earnings which was poor form on their part. Barbara’s return was very welcome though :)

My understanding is if you sign a three year contract then yes you would be entitled to loss of earnings. I also like how you capitalised your second 'Sue' :p
 

Angela Channing

Telly Talk Veteran
Was anyone (fan) upset to see her leave?
Yes, I was. Although I preferred Barbara as Ellie, I thought once the role had been recast they should have stuck with their decision and I was looking forward to seeing what new Donna would brought to the character and the different direction they would have gone with Ellie.

Had Mary Martin taken over the role of Ellie, I would have thought the same thing.
 
Last edited:

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
Was Barbara fired? I never heard that before. I always thought it was a combination of wanting to retire for health reasons and the show's producers refusing to increase her salary, either way I always believed it was her decision to leave.

Regardless of what people have heard, BBG asked for a raise and a reduced workweek (due to lingering health issues) in 1984. The executives said no, and kept telling her representatives that they were bringing in another actress and were moving ahead. Her agents took it as a bluff, and once BBG realized it was for real, she got on the phone herself but it was too late.

Reed started getting cut back very quickly in her scenes because they obviously weren't working. And far from "sitting at home that season resenting watching another actress in her role" and jealously picking up the phone and asking to have her part back (the common fiction used to make BBG look bad) she didn't watch the show that year, and the producers quietly approached her to ask her to come back before Reed was released.

miss-ellie-ewing-tv-characters-photo-u3
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Jock Og

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
I also felt sorry for Donna. Barbara Bel Geddes was a hard act to follow and of course she was, furthermore always will be Miss Ellie Southworth Ewing Farlow. Donna as an accomplished actor in her own right chose to portray the Ewing matriarch, in a way she perceived the character should be. However for millions the character was well known; as a down to earth, homely yet not to be messed with mother to J.R., Gary and Bobby.

As I said before Donna should have been given a new role, if TPTB wanted to fill the void left by Ellie e.g. Jason Ewing's wife or a relative to Sue Ellen or some other important character. If Mary Martin had been in Donna's shoes would things have worked out differently. Maybe, maybe not but I don't think Larry would have stood for it.


A furniture company's delivery van is at Southfork. Clayton has just parked his blue Rolls Royce Silver Spirit behind J.R.'s olive green Mercedes SEL. Ellie played by Donna Reed arrives to tell the furniture company's employee where to put her purchases, (a scene from season 7; DVD-8, 1984 - '85):

Ellie signs the delivery docket: "Thank you!"

Ellie to Clayton: "For us, it's a new set of bedroom furniture. Donna helped me choose it yesterday and I got them to deliver it today."

Clayton seems surprised: "Bedroom furniture."

Ellie: "I thought it was time for a change."

Ellie and Clayton kiss.

The Ewing matriarch then gives her orders to the delivery man: "Follow me and I'll show you where to put everything."

J.R. c/w trademark Stetson and briefcase in hand, appears on the patio: "Hey mama what's going on?"

Ellie smiling: "A new set of bedroom furniture for Clayton and me."

She walks off to get everything arranged.

J.R. squares up to Clayton: "Oh really! How about that."

J.R.: "Well I have to hand it to you. You're not here a week and you're changing things around already."

Clayton: "For your information it was mother's decision and since it's our bedroom and not yours, it is really none of your business. Is it?"

J.R. chuckles and in his best English accent, replies to his stepfather: "I suppose not!"

He goes to get into his Merc'. However he notices Clayton has him blocked in.

J.R. politely asks Clayton: "Could you arrange to have that blue thing moved out of the way, so I can get my car outta here?"

Clayton throws his Rolls Royce keys at him and replies: "Be my guest!"

J.R. is not amused.
 

Frank Underwood

Telly Talk Champion
I don't understand the fascination some people have with the new direction recasts bring. The change in wardrobe, hair, and personality all happen unorganically.

In contrast, reinventing characters is fine for plays or reboots because they're meant to serve as new interpretations of existing works

That's why I don't think the reaction from the fans and the cast was personal. The problem was BBG spent six years defining the role, and Reed was entirely different.

Reed certainly deserved the full amount of her contract. I do believe the producers made the right call bringing BBG back, but it was on them to pay up for their mistake.

Mary Martin was smart not to take the role. Perhaps she understood the resistance any actress would be met with that took on an established role on a hit show.
 
Last edited:

Jabari Lamar

Telly Talk Fan
When Barbara Bel Geddes decided to retire there was some speculation as to who would be the new Ellie and it was reported that Larry had suggested his mother, Mary Martin, for the role.
It's been so long, but the story I thought I remember was that the producers suggested Mary Martin but that both her and Larry thought it was a bad idea, because of the charges or favoritism/nepotism that would inevitably arise is she were hired, and they didn't want tor risk causing tension with the rest of the cast.

Certainly, publicly, especially back then when there was less access to news about what happened behind the scenes, BBG leaving and being replaced by MM would have looked like Larry was throwing his weight around and got BBG fired in order to replace her with his mother. That wouldn't have looked good.
 

DallasFanForever

Telly Talk Supreme
I do remember hearing the nepotism story before with LH and his mother. Not sure if it was true or just a rumor but their concerns would make sense. Regardless, to me DR and MM were both fine actresses who had great careers, but as the thread states, they just weren’t mama.
 

Frank Underwood

Telly Talk Champion
I find it interesting how invested Reed became in playing Miss Ellie after only one season. Her family all speak of her time on the show as being hell, and they claim that she was treated poorly by cast and crew alike. And yet her husband said Reed's response was "I'm not a quitter" when asked why she didn't just leave the show. Reed also tried to stay on the show after she was fired. She initially tried to shut down production on season 9 (per DVD) until the producers reinstated her in the role. The judge denied her request, so she proceeded to sue for the amount owed per her contract instead. I find it fascinating that she fought so hard to stay, rather than going for the money from the start.

Reed's misplaced anger led her to attack BBG personally. Reed said Larry Hagman preferred "an old brown wren of a woman who blinks a lot" to play his mother.
 
Last edited:

Angela Channing

Telly Talk Veteran
I totally get why many people, including some who worked on Dallas, weren't keen on Donna Reed taking over the role of Miss Ellie but would they have treated Mary Martin any differently had she been cast in the role?

It's not unusual for writers and producers to make changes to a character when it is recast, they did it with Jenna. She was far less scheming, flirtatious and bitchy when Priscilla Presley took over because although Morgan Fairchild could play a character like that in her sleep, I find it harder to imagine Priscilla Presley being believable in a role like that.

I think if Mary Martin had been recast as Ellie, the character would have been written in a different way to how she was for either Barbara or Donna.

So I'm less interested in whether or not it was right to change the personality of Ellie but whether the powers that be would have given Mary Martin longer to establish herself in the role. Personally, I think they would have done more to make the change work by given her stronger storylines and persevering longer with the actress until it worked.
 

Frank Underwood

Telly Talk Champion
I totally get why many people, including some who worked on Dallas, weren't keen on Donna Reed taking over the role of Miss Ellie but would they have treated Mary Martin any differently had she been cast in the role?
As another poster pointed out, nepotism/favoritism would have been inevitable had the producers hired the real life mother of the show's biggest star.
It's not unusual for writers and producers to make changes to a character when it is recast, they did it with Jenna. She was far less scheming, flirtatious and bitchy when Priscilla Presley took over because although Morgan Fairchild could play a character like that in her sleep, I find it harder to imagine Priscilla Presley being believable in a role like that.

I think if Mary Martin had been recast as Ellie, the character would have been written in a different way to how she was for either Barbara or Donna.
The Jenna situation is a bit different. The character hadn't been on the show in four years, and one could argue that Jenna matured a little during that time.

Of course, many fans also argue that Fairchild was the best Jenna, despite only making one appearance.
So I'm less interested in whether or not it was right to change the personality of Ellie but whether the powers that be would have given Mary Martin longer to establish herself in the role. Personally, I think they would have done more to make the change work by given her stronger storylines and persevering longer with the actress until it worked.
Sometimes it just doesn't work, regardless of how hard you try. Had they dug in their heels and refused to correct their mistake, it would have made things worse.

Martin would have likely been treated better and paid promptly upon release, but I predict that they still would have brought BBG back.

As a side note, it's always disappointed me that two of Miss Ellie's most pivotal moments happened during Reed's tenure. The first is the removal of Jock's portrait, and the second was Bobby's deathbed scene. I can only imagine the emotion BBG would have brought to those scenes having had a real life connection to those actors/characters.
 
Last edited:
Top