Donna Reed, "She Just Wasn't Mama"

Seaviewer

Telly Talk Warrior
The change in wardrobe, hair, and personality all happen unorganically.

It's not unusual for writers and producers to make changes to a character when it is recast, they did it with Jenna.
That may be the key mistake. If they want changes, they should create a new character. If they truly want to bring a character back but cannot get the original actor, the replacement should be as alike as possible, forget about getting a big name. As discussed in the Bold & Beautiful thread, Felicia and Hope are examples of how it can be done right. I think Nancy Olsen would have been a good choice but she was doing Paper Dolls.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
but would they have treated Mary Martin any differently had she been cast in the role?
I believe they would have. If the producers had managed to cast Mary Martin as Miss Ellie I suspect the writers would have been under enormous pressure to make the character work. They still could have went with the same story that Clayton had taken Miss Ellie away from Southfork and the airport scene. But from this point forward her character should have been beefed up, much like when she returned to Dallas while Jock went onto Washington. By this stage we knew Jim Davis had passed yet the writers put the character of Miss Ellie in the thick of it. The same could have occurred with Bobby's blindness. Miss Ellie could have demanded from JR all deals had to require her signature while Bobby was recuperating.

My only stipulation would have been for Mary Martin to mimic some of Barbara Bel Geddes traits...her look and style. Donna Reed's was too much Dynasty for my liking. But I think your right Angela. If the viewers accepted Mary Martin in the role and she was given strong material and mimicked Barbara Bel it would have been difficult to unseat her.

To clarify:
  1. I loved Barbara Bel Geddes as Miss Ellie. NO ONE should have replaced her.
  2. I felt really bad for Donna Reed. It was an impossible task.
 

Chris2

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Barbara was not fired. She and her representatives chose not to accept the producers’ offer in terms of salary and workweek. They told her if she didn’t accept, they would replace her and they did. That’s not the equivalent of being fired.
 
Last edited:

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
Barbara was not fired. She and her representatives chose not to accept the producers’ offer in terms of salary and workweek. They told her if she didn’t accept, they would replace her and they did. That’s not the equivalent of being fired.

Yeah she was let go because Lorimar wouldn't agree to an increase in her salary but a cut to her hours of work.

Not fired as such, but dropped from the cast.
 

xab

Telly Talk Fan
I won't ever understand how Donna Reed could have been hired as a recast Miss Ellie in the first place. No offense to the lady, she was a great actress and had nothing to prove to anybody. She would have been a great Miss Ellie #1, a strong and classy "daughter of Alamo" (Being a farmer's daughter doesn't mean you have to get stuck into sack dresses) but Miss Ellie #1 happened to be BBG and she was a down to earth woman and had nothing to do with those southern belles we came across all along the seasons (coucou from France, Miss Kimberly Cryder ;) ) . Miss Ellie could have been written a thousand ways, but the way she was originally written fitted BBG big time, and certainly not Betty White (whom I worship) or Angela Lansbury ! Donna Reed could have been a perfect Lady Jessica Montford, but you don't have to be a genius casting director to understand she's no Miss Ellie...

WHO does think into TPTB's brain...?

And why recasting anyway ? And why so quickly ? We could have waited a season or two to cheer Miss Ellie back home. I love the character, I would have missed my substitute granny, but to be honest, she was not the core of the show. By this time JR was... Why the hurry ?
 
Last edited:

Monzo

Telly Talk Star
I just watched an episode of Murder, She Wrote and there was a woman screaming at Jessica Fletcher: "I know who you are! Miss Ellie!!!" Of course, what followed was an argument that Jessica was not Miss Ellie, but this scene makes me wonder that instead of giving Angela Lansbury her own show in 1984 CBS could have used her as Miss Ellie recast. Any chance viewers would have accepted her? I think Angela Lansbury would have been closer to original Ellie than Donna Reed was.
 

DallasFanForever

Telly Talk Supreme
I just watched an episode of Murder, She Wrote and there was a woman screaming at Jessica Fletcher: "I know who you are! Miss Ellie!!!" Of course, what followed was an argument that Jessica was not Miss Ellie, but this scene makes me wonder that instead of giving Angela Lansbury her own show in 1984 CBS could have used her as Miss Ellie recast. Any chance viewers would have accepted her? I think Angela Lansbury would have been closer to original Ellie than Donna Reed was.
Angela would’ve been closer to the original Miss Ellie than Donna Reed was, yes, but I still don’t think it would’ve worked. BBG was just way too iconic in that role already for anyone else to take it over and have success, so I don’t think Angela would’ve been accepted either.
 

the-lost-son

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
Larry Hagman and Mary Martin denied both any interest in Mary Martin joining the show.

I'd like to quote the godfather for this:
It's not personal, it's strictly business.

The role of Miss Ellie was essential to the whole concept of Dallas. She was the authority to "keep JR from running will." (Barbara Curran's book). Her role became even more important when Jock died. BBG wanted a lighter schedule which was denied - and rightly so. The decrease in quality with the matriarch gone/put to the sideline can be seen in the last seasons.

In season 7 (DVD8) Dallas already became more "glitz", less ranch more Dynasty, a development which hit its climax in the dream season. So they decided for a big name standing for more "oil barons' ball" and less "ranch". But it was impossible to recast Miss Ellie. The character was well introduced and popular for six years. It's not Dynasty, this is a saga and major characters can't be recast. (wouldn't have worked for LH, PD either and didn't work for Margret Michael's Pam. I assume they tested the audience then and it didn't fly. )

So one year later, Duffy leaves the series and it gets empty at Southfork. As they obviously never really knew what to do with Charlene Tilton, they suddenly need familiar faces and contact BBG. (I loved her back. But I have never seen sth. like that - a recast of a major role with the former actress.)

Donna Reed met an impossible task, as a right recast never existed. Every sensible agent would advise to stay away. She was a sweet lady who was on good terms with Howard Keel. They visited each other in hospital. As she died in January 86 it leaves a bitter taste as her last TV experience wasn't nice. But I'm sure it was nothing she had not seen in the decades in the industry before.

I'm dead-set against recasts, but I'm sure without keeping Miss Ellie around Dallas wouldn't have lasted that long. (same goes for keeping Larry Hagman and not recasting him in season 3 or bringing Duffy back).
 
Last edited:

Toni

Maximum Member
I agree. Whatever the merits of Donna Reed specifically, a recast was necessary for the balance of the show.
On the other side, the first tenth episodes of seasons 7 & 8 dvd, all without BBG, are especially good. I´ve always found this a true irony given how much the show depended on the patriarchal figures of Jock and Ellie. Maybe that happened because those seasons were written and / or supervised by such a talented name as David Paulsen.
 
Last edited:

ClassyCo

Telly Talk Warrior
I remember watching DALLAS on DVD and my father walking in one night. He saw the opening credits and noticed that Barbara Bel Geddes was missing. He asked where she was, and after I explained to him that Donna Reed had taken the role, he remembered it all more clearly. My father basically said that if Barbara Bel Geddes was not there as Miss Ellie, then Miss Ellie should have not been there either.

On a more personal level, I actually liked Donna Reed on DALLAS, albeit not as Miss Ellie. DALLAS as a whole seemed to be shifting to a more glamorous outlook (one commentator called it the "DYNASTY creep"), and I think Reed helped move the show in that direction. She was a former glamorous film and television star, and something of a name to publicize as entering television's highest-rated show. The main issue was Donna Reed should not have been brought in as Miss Ellie. She should have been given a brand new character, someone connected to the Ewings. Perhaps she could have played a relative of Miss Ellie, who has an equal compassion for Southfork and the land. That way the character Donna Reed played could still fill the void Barbara Bel Geddes had left vacant without playing the same character. I think audiences might have liked her better that way, and maybe then when Barbara was brought back, Donna could have lingered around, if only on a recurring basis.

I've always been intrigued by how DALLAS and its producers brought in Donna Reed and then casually disregarded her. I understand why the producers wanted Donna Reed; she had won an Oscar for Best Supporting Actress for her role in FROM HERE TO ETERNITY in 1954, and she had starred on THE DONNA REED SHOW from 1958 to 1966, a successful situation comedy series that won Reed a Golden Globe Award for Best Female TV Star in 1963. To the producers' eyes, Donna Reed was bringing some clout to the table. She was a name to publicize as taking over from Barbara Bel Geddes. DALLAS producers brought Reed into their show amidst a lot of publicity, and they quickly signed her to a three-year-deal worth somewhere around two million dollars. They did all this despite the negative response from fans after Reed had taken over the Miss Ellie role, and even after they started reducing her screen time as a result of dissatisfied fans. And then when Barbara Bel Geddes wanted to come back, was asked to come back, or whichever, the producers just tossed Donna Reed to the side. They hoped the whole thing could be whipped under the rug and that Reed would just tuck her tail and go about her business. Of course, she knew better. Reed was angry and probably humiliated that she had been treated so shabbily. She took the DALLAS producers to court and got a sizable settlement for the damages to her name and career.

Had Donna Reed been utilized in a different fashion, all of that could have probably been avoided.
​
1620831147983.png​

I do not think Mary Martin would have done any better in the place of Barbara Bel Geddes than Donna Reed did. Bel Geddes had become synonymous with Miss Ellie. Martin was a musical comedy stage star, and even though I have never seen her in anything, I have my doubts she could have feasibly played Miss Ellie. I understand that Larry Hagman might have wanted to work with his mother, but the issue with Bel Geddes eventually returning would have been a bigger stink in this case. Hagman's mother would have been the replacement, and had the DALLAS producers wanted to boot out their headliner's mother, it might have stirred a pot that did not want stirred. Hagman probably would have showed out and maybe even threatened to quit his hit show. It would have been a tabloid-grabbing mess.
​
1620831441840.png​
 
Top