The body in the Southfork swimming pool

the-lost-son

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
The 3rd season (WB4) had high standards to meet after „Who shot JR“
The season ended without knowing the dead person‘s identity. Possibilities included Kristen, Pam, Sue Ellen

A question for the original viewers back then. Did you ever doubt that the body was not Kristen? It seems so obvious as she joined the series only a few episodes before (and her character somehow ran its course). Furthermore SueEllen or Pam seemed indispensable. Or were there any other possibilities I might have overlooked?

The real question is/should have been to a greater extent if JR was responsible for her death (which has been dealt with/discussed here multiple times). It was resolved way too quickly. I wonder if Jim Davis health status changed the general outcome of this storyline. As stated in Barbara Curran‘s book they delayed the death of Jock later in the season in order to avoid two deaths in a row. Maybe with Jim Davis still alive this whole storyline would have played out differently.

It‘s a mystery to me why we didn‘t get a flashback scene about what happened that night later on. It was a headscratcher anyway why one‘s former mistress should show up in your home, make it to the second floor, in your bedroom, on the balcony and then (breaking the handrail) back in the pool to drown, the other person showing finally up on the balcony only after she drowned. I have not watched the episodes prior to this scene, but I don‘t remember any clues towards a possible drug addiction of Kristen. They did flashback scene when JR/Bobby got shot. These storylines didn‘t need much explanation about how it was commited anyway.
A flashback scene would have truly helped to get some closure there.
 
Last edited:

tommie

Telly Talk Hero
I'm far too young to have watched it originally, but seasonal cliffhangers like this were still a new thing, so I suspect that any outcome felt possible especially internationally were US soap operas weren't broadcast and Dallas was the first taste of the format.
 
After the huge global news story of Who shot JR in 1980, this Cliff hanger felt rather flat as it was published that Mary Crosby was leaving the show so it wasnt a huge surprise

S3 original 1980-81 came in for criticism in UK for being Dull after all the excitement of the year before

Newspapers had headlines like "RIP Dallas" and "Dallas the crashing Bore" - but luckily the next season in 81-82 (S4 original) came back better than ever!
 

James from London

International Treasure
A question for the original viewers back then. Did you ever doubt that the body was not Kristen? It seems so obvious as she joined the series only a few episodes before (and her character somehow ran its course). Furthermore SueEllen or Pam seemed indispensable.
I was young and unsophisticated in the ways of television and didn't know anything about actors' contracts and whatnot, and so anything seemed possible. When last seen, all the three women were wearing white and the woman in the pool was wearing white, and that was exciting enough for me.

It wasn't until nobody died in the Southfork fire that it finally occurred to me, "Oh yeah, of course they're not gonna kill off any of the famouses."
 

James from London

International Treasure
It‘s a mystery to me why we didn‘t get a flashback scene about what happened that night later on
This way, we were left with the tantalising possibility that JR really did bump her off.
 

the-lost-son

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
This way, we were left with the tantalising possibility that JR really did bump her off.
Agreed. But it wasn‘t really left a mystery to ponder about. It was dealt within 2-3 episodes and when forgotten about it. Let‘s move to the divorce and the fight with the Farlows.

They very rarely did „not„ show dramatic events and just talk about it Instead. The only other example I can think of was the final talk between Wes Parmalee and Miss Ellie. It did not really work for me there either.

Actually watching Ray (in a flashback) taking his nephew off life support is much more emotional than just talking about it.
 
Last edited:

DallasFanForever

Telly Talk Supreme
I do like the fact that they left it a little ambiguous though. I like the fact that we were always left to wonder if he killed her or not. For example, the scene at the Southern Cross when J.R. tells Sue Ellen about Kristin’s death and she accuses him of killing her. It was his word against that of a dead woman and no one could prove it either way. And as a viewer I felt the sane way. I thought he did it but there was no way I could prove it cause we simply never get to see it. And I like the mystery of it.
 

the-lost-son

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I also think jR killed Kristin, possibly by accidentally pushing her off the balcony. It was good that they left it a mystery :)
At that time it would have been too much to ask the audience to accept a killer as one of the main characters. Censorship played a role as well (I once read that they had to avoid the word „gay“ during the Kit Mainwaring-storyline).

Thinking about it I am growing fond of the idea of JR as the swimming-pool-drowner. They could have revisited that storyline. Especially during the last seasons, he could have drowned one every episode, JR turning Dexter.
The Beaumonts, the McKays...one by one. And then some crossovers to Knots Landing and Falcon Crest for the final seasons...plenty to do there.

And finally his masterpiece drowning the Ramoses and the Rylands...
 

Jabari Lamar

Telly Talk Fan
After the huge global news story of Who shot JR in 1980, this Cliff hanger felt rather flat as it was published that Mary Crosby was leaving the show so it wasnt a huge surprise

S3 original 1980-81 came in for criticism in UK for being Dull after all the excitement of the year before

Newspapers had headlines like "RIP Dallas" and "Dallas the crashing Bore" - but luckily the next season in 81-82 (S4 original) came back better than ever!
Interesting. That was a bit before my time, but I can see how that reaction would have made sense. The phenomenon of Who Shot J.R.? would have definitely set a high-bar for Dallas cliffhangers that must have felt impossible to meet at the time. I can see why some in the press considered this a big letdown in comparison.
 

Seaviewer

Telly Talk Warrior
There was some confusion surrounding the screening of this episode here.
Dallas had been preempted that week but whatever was supposed to be on didn't go ahead and they ended up screening Dallas instead.
I wasn't watching whatever but somehow happened to tune in for the second half. Since it wasn't supposed to be on, it hadn't been promoted as the season finale and at the end I squirmed around trying to see who it was - not realising that that was actually the cliffhanger question for the year.
Fortunately they repeated the whole episode the following week when it all became much more clear.
 

Brian Kinney

Telly Talk Addict
A question for the original viewers back then. Did you ever doubt that the body was not Kristen? It seems so obvious as she joined the series only a few episodes before (and her character somehow ran its course). Furthermore SueEllen or Pam seemed indispensable. Or were there any other possibilities I might have overlooked?
No. Everyone guessed Kristin. A a very big difference to "Who Shot J.R." where I personally had two or three strong options and my friends had others.
 

the-lost-son

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I‘ve just finished watching this episode. Kristen had made a few phone calls, one to Jordan Lee and one to an unkown person (revealed later in season 4 - christopher‘s biological father). I would have preferred if they had left more clues to other suspects of Kristen‘s death than JR. They should have played out this storyline much longer. Kristen was an iconic character.

It‘s weird/funny that JR is having a drink on the balcony while Cliff is dragging a corpse out of his pool. I had an ex-girlfriend once whose brother didn‘t like me. I wouldn‘t have watched him drowning in my pool from the balcony with some bourbon...but well...one can never know.
 

CeeCee72

Telly Talk Star
I didn't know Mary Crosby wasn't coming back, so I wasn't for SURE it was her. But, even as young as I was, I KNEW they couldn't kill off Pam or Sue Ellen.

To be honest, I thought it was going to end up being the maid (Teresa). I liked Kristen and didn't want it to be her.

As far as whether or not JR killed her, I tend to think he didn't. As bad as he was, I just can't see him standing on the balcony and doing nothing while she drowned.

Could be wrong about that though.
 
Top