Dallas, Dynasty or Knots Landing? The battle of the big three

First of all, welcome to the site!

As you explore our little corner of the internet, you will see we've literally been discussing the topic of your post for about thirty years. So it might be difficult to boil it all down to a few posts. Every bit of minutiae regarding those three (plus Falcon Crest, plus many others) has been tossed around in one form or another for so long we really might have trouble narrowing down our opinions (or shutting up once we get started :)).

That said, I've always been a Knots Landing fan above all other nighttime soaps, with FC landing in second. Dinner at the Gibson house circa S7 would have been stressful, especially since the place had Val, Ben, Lilimae, Joshua, Cathy, and the twins all stacked up in a 3/2.
 

Chestersmiles

Telly Talk Newbie
Thank you for the welcome, Daniel Thirty years? Well, I seem to have arrived rather late to the party! Haha. I’ll have plenty of catching up to do. Knots Landing certainly had its fair share of family troubles, and dinner at the Gibson house sounds like it would require a strong cup of coffee and a good deal of patience! I’ll be interested to see what I’ve been missing all these years.
 

Monzo

Telly Talk Star
which family would you least like to have dinner with?
Since I assume I would merely be a guest—and hosts generally try to put their best foot forward—I suspect there wouldn’t be any major issues with the Ewings or the Carringtons (though with Blake, you never know when his patience might snap if one of his children says something he perceives as provocative). The family I would least like to have dinner with, however, is the Averys. I can vividly imagine how Richard, with his passive-aggressive manner, manages to make every guest feel uncomfortable. Laura would likely be on the receiving end of snide remarks from Richard—the kind a guest really doesn’t want to hear—and he was also quite capable of confronting others directly. If you get a taste of Richard’s own particular brand of unpleasantness as early as the appetizer, it’s bound to be an agonizingly long evening.
 

ClassyCo

Telly Talk Warrior
Three soaps, endless affairs, family feuds and enough backstabbing to make a knife factory nervous
Dallas, Dynasty or Knots Landing? Which was your favourite? And be honest, which family would you least like to have dinner with?
I have a feeling J.R. might need to be seated at the children’s table
Welcome to Telly Talk!

I have a question: Where's FALCON CREST in your question?

To answer your question, I'll say KNOTS LANDING is my overall favorite. It has some of my favorite characters and storylines for a primetime soap, and it retains creative consistency practically the entire way through its 14-season run. Sure, there are some dips along the way, but I feel like the showrunners handled such downturns relatively well.

DALLAS, at its peak, is a better show than KNOTS LANDING, even though I feel like DALLAS made much bigger mistakes. The whole "dream season" and once Pam was gone, it really went downhill. And it never recovered. That said, J.R. is one of TV's finest characters, and the "Who Shot J.R.?" cliffhanger is iconic.

As many have stated, DYNASTY had the most potential, but squandered it more so than any of them. The first couple of seasons are good, and the final season is as well, but everything in between is just a parade of ups and downs and misguided mess.

FALCON CREST was better than DYNASTY.
 

Seaviewer

Telly Talk Warrior
Given my screen name, this will be no surprise, but . . .

1. Knots Landing
2. Dallas
3. Falcon Crest
4. Dynasty
5. The Colbys
 

Frank Underwood

Telly Talk Champion
Dallas was the first of the "big 4" I discovered back in 1996 when I was just 13. It's interesting because I find that it has some of the absolute best and some of the most dreadful seasons out of all the primetime soaps. Still, the half a dozen or so seasons that were firing on all cylinders are still excellent television IMO. That, combined with the power of nostalgia, leaves me placing it at number 1.

Knots Landing is easily #2, and in all honesty, I feel it holds up the best. There were dips, to be sure, but they were rare and not nearly as jarring.

Dynasty would probably come in at number 3, particularly seasons 1, 2, and 9. I rank season 1 especially high, although I know some people aren't big on it because Alexis hadn't arrived yet. I never saw much of the spinoff series, The Colbys, so I can't really rank it.

I guess that leaves Falcon Crest at #4, although it and Dynasty are rather interchangeable for me in terms of ranking. The first 3 seasons of Falcon Crest were excellent, and I was even amused by the much-despised season 9, although it was bizarre at times and didn't feel like Falcon Crest anymore.

I suppose I'd least like to have dinner with the Ewings. They're fun to watch, but JR would be complaining the entire time about how he hates having moochers and outsiders at the table.
 
Last edited:

ClassyCo

Telly Talk Warrior
1. Dynasty
2. The Colbys
3. Falcon Crest
4. Dallas
5. Knots Landing
Mine would be...

1) Knots Landing
2) Dallas
3) Falcon Crest
4) Dynasty

I haven't seen enough of THE COLBYS to weigh it more, nor have I seen enough of FLAMINGO ROAD or PAPER DOLLS (which, of course, those aren't on the ballot anyway). FALCON CREST isn't either, but hey...
 
Top