The Underrated Storylines

Tullamore

Telly Talk Active Member
Hi guys

As the title above suggests are there storylines in the show which you feel deserve more credit? Could they have been highlighted more? Which ones were overrated?
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
As the title above suggests are there storylines in the show which you feel deserve more credit? Could they have been highlighted more? Which ones were overrated?
I'll start.
Wes Parmalee
None of the viewers I knew ever bought into the Parmalee as Jock storyline. Sure, there were a few coincidences, but nothing compelling enough to make us believe that Jock really could have come back. So they tied that storyline up in a neat little bow by showing that Parmalee was an imposter after all.
No payoff, just kind of an anticlimactic ending to an idea that fizzled out.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
None of the viewers I knew ever bought into the Parmalee as Jock storyline.

This viewer included. Nothing in this story-arc made sense, and where was the pay off? As Dallas was one of the most watched TV Series around the globe everyone watching it knew Jim Davis had passed away. The writers respectfully payed homage to his character of Jock by weaving an interesting story that permeated throughout the following two seasons. Why then would the writers think it clever to re-visit the idea Jock was still alive? As the story unfolded before our eyes viewers let their frustrations know we were not buying it, and as you rightly pointed out, "they tied that storyline up in a neat little bow."
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
And it was only quelled because Bobby was returning with Irish soap
HA!
The other issue with the Wes Parmalee storyline is when they found it wasn't working, they dropped it cold. They could have done something better. Imagine this:

--J.R. mentions to one of his henchmen that Parmalee needs to be taken care of. This conversation is left ambiguous as to what J.R. meant.
-- Evidence starts to mount that yes, Parmalee could really be Jock, who made his way back to Dallas.
-- Punk Anderson starts to believe and goes to J.R. and Bobby
-- Before Punk, Bobby, and J.R. have a chance to react, both Parmalee and the henchman disappear.

Was Parmalee killed? Did the henchman simply arrange to have Parmalee roughed up and dropped off a few hundred miles away? Did Parmalee get the word and take off on his own?

And now you have a great conversation piece. Some viewers (and characters) believing Parmalee was an imposter. Some viewers (and characters) believing that Jock really had made his way back to Dallas.

It would be a great conversation starter on forums exactly like this one. . .
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
Now to add my thoughts on this thread. After Bobby was shot in JR's office he was left temporarily (in hindsight) blind. He grants Donna temporary Power of Attorney which puts Donna squarely in Ewing Oil - and in JR's firing line. I thought, finally, the writers are handing Donna an integral story. Donna may not have known a lot about the oil industry but she had brains and was well aware of JR's manipulations.

Bobby's blindness in my opinion could have been fleshed out more. His frustrations dealing with it could have been "Emmy" winning material if only the writers didn't feel the need to have him miraculously regain his sight. Kind of reminded me of that other awful cancer story in TNT Dallas. One minute Bobby is on the operating table, the next banging heads with JR.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
When Bobby was blind for 5 minutes those glasses were so big they had their own postcode/zipcode

Which reinforces my opinion this story was rushed. Putting those Jackie Onassis glasses on was a cop out. Bright lights! Bright Lights. It also highlighted Patrick's sometimes flawed acting. Often Dallas was ahead of its time when it came to social issues, for example; Miss Ellie's mastectomy. Brilliantly written and acted out by all those involved. It also helped this was further investigated when she began her relationship with Clayton. Again this showed the viewer something deep and personal which affects people throughout their lives. The same could also be said when Donna and Ray discover she is carrying a Down's Syndrome baby.

It would have been better if Bobby had been left blind for the majority of the season, how he handled the situation and the effect his blindness had on other characters, in particular JR. The writers were clearly showing the softer side to JR after Bobby was shot, although others will argue he may have been more concerned for his own welfare after discovering the shooter was still out there.
 

pete lashmar

Telly Talk Addict
Not sure really where to put this - but I've got up to Season 12 (DVD) - Mission To Moscow on my 8th re-watch, and there's a scene being filmed for Sue Ellen's movie in the Southfork living room. When they cut Don walks around the back of the set to see Sue Ellen, who's in another of the Southfork rooms.

For me, seeing behind the sets, how the sets are jigsawed together, with all the cameras and lighting really takes me out of the show - did anyone else feel like this?
 
Last edited:

Justine

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I really liked the season 8 storyline of John Ross put into therapy until it turned out to be the start of the dumb Peter and Sue Ellen affair storyline.:re: Obviously it was rare for mental health - let alone, children's mental health - to have been discussed in the 80's but there could have been a whole conversation about the effect J.R. and Sue Ellen's dysfunctional dynamic had on John Ross that wasn't reduced to him being the reason they reconciled, or treated like a possession to fight over when they divorced.
 

JR Ewing Fan

Telly Talk Active Member
I bought into the Wes is Jock story. I know others that did too. That storyline ending had nothing to do with viewer dissatisfaction. Steve Forrest was only contracted for so many episodes. I think I read he had a Gunsmoke movie he had to go and film. The Wes and B.D. Calhoun stories were the last stories I really enjoyed on Dallas. They left it up in the air as to what each viewer thought if Wes was Jock or not.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
I bought into the Wes is Jock story. I know others that did too. That storyline ending had nothing to do with viewer dissatisfaction. Steve Forrest was only contracted for so many episodes. I think I read he had a Gunsmoke movie he had to go and film. The Wes and B.D. Calhoun stories were the last stories I really enjoyed on Dallas. They left it up in the air as to what each viewer thought if Wes was Jock or not.
I wanted Miss Ellie to expire maybe a year before DALLAS ended, and three or four episodes later have Clayton in a bar with one of the Ewing sons -- maybe Champs-Élysées Ray, home on a visit -- discussing a copy of small obituary someone sent Clayton about an obscure cowhand named Wes Parmalee who'd died on the Canadian horse ranch where he'd been working. The two men grumbling about what a faker he was and how much trouble he'd caused when he was on Southfork, before the topic changes and they never go back to it.

I also wanted to see Lady Jessica's murder spree played straight, like a horror movie, her victims (as I believe JfL suggested) members of the cartel she'd been blackmailing for decades over their supposed parentage of Dusty .
 

TJames03

Banned
But the Parmalee story was not really wrapped up with a bow. What did Ellie and Wes talk about offscreen? Why was Ellie adamant that Parmalee be left alone? How did he fool the xrays, lie detector, etc.?
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
I'd be willing to buy that Wes was Jock based on the x-rays and lie detector tests, etc., but...

It's one thing to come back after a few years in the jungle 15 years younger, a few inches shorter, and with a completely different face, but there's no way in *hell* a man would drastically change the way he pronounces the word 'business', no matter what trauma and procedures he's been through!

the real thing: (go to the :38 second mark if the embedded video doesn't start right there)

the impostor: (at the 29 second mark)
 
Last edited:

Frank Underwood

Telly Talk Champion
I loved the Wes Parmalee storyline and didn't find it overrated at all. The storyline was centered around the family's reaction to his claim that he was Jock, but his true identity was always kept ambiguous. The fact that characters and fans alike are divided as to whether or not he was Jock is a testament to how well structured the storyline was. I honestly didn't mind how it ended. Whether he was really Jock or not, he knew the family would never accept him. And I don't believe he intended to hurt the family, regardless of who he really was.

Personally, I can think of overrated episodes more than storylines. For example, I find the episodes where JR marries Cally and Bobby and JR are stuck in an elevator to be overrated. I know they are from the later years which are generally despised, but I've noticed those two particular episodes receive a lot of praise. I don't get why. They were just slapstick and silly.

On the other hand, I think the tanker collision storyline in season 13 is a bit overlooked. Granted, it didn't help that this was during the James and Michelle era, but the storyline itself really wasn't that bad. It was also the first time Cliff was in a position to really stick it to the Ewings. The ending was a bit of a cop out, but the overall storyline really was decent.
 
Last edited:

Angela Channing

Telly Talk Veteran
For example, I find the episodes where JR marries Cally and Bobby and JR are stuck in an elevator to be overrated.
Totally! The episode where Bobby and JR were stuck in the lift was self-indulgent garbage and don't get me started on that contrived tosh that was JR's marriage to JR.

On the other hand, the Wes Parmalee storyline was up there with some of the best that was in the entire run of the series. The low key was the story fizzled out was the only thing I didn't like about it.

Another underrated storyline was JR being stuck in the asylum. I loved and hated this plotline in equal amounts but there was some really good stuff amongst the rubbish. It went on way too long, was totally unrealistic and seeing JR so powerless was just wrong. However, the situation he was put in allowed us to see another side to JR which I found fascinating. I loved how he was able to gain the confidence and respect of his fellow inmates and establish friendships with them in a way you never saw with his friends in the oil business. It all culminated his beautiful leaving scene in which he gave them all very well thought out parting gifts and one of them hugs him closely. He then gives a flash of the old JR before going when he threatens the doctor in charge of the facility of what he will do if he mistreats his new mates.
 
Top