A Real Dallas Conundrum

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Unlike the series finale of that name, there was a conundrum in Dallas which became evident within the first few episodes of the entire series. It's something I call a conundrum because it is "a confusing and difficult problem or question."

It seemed very important to JR that he and Sue Ellen provide the first male Ewing grandson to Jock and Ellie, and the thought of Bobby and Pam beating them to accomplishing that seems to worry both JR and Sue Ellen. So why is it then, that JR seemed to reluctant to take the necessary steps to ensure that he and Sue Ellen had a son before Bobby and Pam?

JR cheated on Sue Ellen a lot and that was made very obvious. But Sue Ellen still wanted JR to make love to her. She begged him to make love to her and he responded with "I'll buy you a puppy." Clearly JR found Sue Ellen to be an attractive woman an d she was a former Miss Texas after all. When she was in the hospital after having the car accident after escaping from the sanitarium while drunk and pregnant, JR and Bobby were by her side and JR said how even then, in that banged up and bruised condition she still looked beautiful.

So if she was still attractive to JR, why din't he try harder to get her pregnant so that they'd produce the first male grandson for Jock and Miss Ellie and of course the first male heir to Ewing Oil? I'm not saying he would have had to quit cheating on her - something he just couldn't help himself from doing and a major character flaw, but hat doesn't explain why he still couldn't have been also trying to get Sue Ellen pregnant.

JR and Sue Ellen seemed legitimately frightened that Bobby and Pam would accomplish it first yet JR wasn't willing to take the necessary steps. Why not, since having a song before Bobby and Pam did was so important to him and despite his cheating, he did find his wife attractive? It was a conundrum, wasn't it?
 

Presea

Telly Talk Addict
Unlike the series finale of that name, there was a conundrum in Dallas which became evident within the first few episodes of the entire series. It's something I call a conundrum because it is "a confusing and difficult problem or question."

It seemed very important to JR that he and Sue Ellen provide the first male Ewing grandson to Jock and Ellie, and the thought of Bobby and Pam beating them to accomplishing that seems to worry both JR and Sue Ellen. So why is it then, that JR seemed to reluctant to take the necessary steps to ensure that he and Sue Ellen had a son before Bobby and Pam?

JR cheated on Sue Ellen a lot and that was made very obvious. But Sue Ellen still wanted JR to make love to her. She begged him to make love to her and he responded with "I'll buy you a puppy." Clearly JR found Sue Ellen to be an attractive woman an d she was a former Miss Texas after all. When she was in the hospital after having the car accident after escaping from the sanitarium while drunk and pregnant, JR and Bobby were by her side and JR said how even then, in that banged up and bruised condition she still looked beautiful.

So if she was still attractive to JR, why din't he try harder to get her pregnant so that they'd produce the first male grandson for Jock and Miss Ellie and of course the first male heir to Ewing Oil? I'm not saying he would have had to quit cheating on her - something he just couldn't help himself from doing and a major character flaw, but hat doesn't explain why he still couldn't have been also trying to get Sue Ellen pregnant.

JR and Sue Ellen seemed legitimately frightened that Bobby and Pam would accomplish it first yet JR wasn't willing to take the necessary steps. Why not, since having a song before Bobby and Pam did was so important to him and despite his cheating, he did find his wife attractive? It was a conundrum, wasn't it?
The JR in the old days was really cold and could pretty much have cared less about having Sue Ellen in bed, and even admitted to her that he was going to keep cheating. Then, he suddenly cares about her not finding out about his affairs. I guess they were trying to make him more sympathetic as a character, but it pretty much fell flat since he kept cheating over and over again anyway and just expected to be forgiven with a fakey little "I'm sorry" speech. As for the sex, JR usually seemed much more interested in doing it with Sue Ellen when she didn't want it. It was all about the chase. Since Sue Ellen was displaying genuine interest in creating a baby during the early seasons, it probably wasn't near as exciting for JR. And when they had their brief "make-up" periods, it did not take long for JR to start wanting other women again.
 

tommie

Telly Talk Hero
Hadn't JR and Sue Ellen been married for about a decade by then?

We don't know if they actually know if they actually had tried to get pregnant pre-1978. They might have been trying for years and years and either they weren't able to concieve or Sue Ellen kept miscarrying (let's get real: considering baby John Ross basically spent nine months in vodka it was a miracle she was able to carry full term and not suffer serious side effects) which would explain why their relationship eventually went sour. Fertility clinics weren't as common and I'd imagine for someone like JR to test his sperm count wouldn't have been an option.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
So why is it then, that JR seemed to reluctant to take the necessary steps to ensure that he and Sue Ellen had a son before Bobby and Pam?
Upon reflection it does appear odd. I'm reminded of an early scene between Jock and JR, outside the house talking. We hear an obvious Bobby and Pam upstairs in their bedroom enjoying the benefits of early marriage bliss. Jock - more or less - tells junior he better get his romance on to produce a Ewing heir. JR's reaction is puzzling. His body language suggests he takes offence at Jock's intrusion in his personal love life but dare not speak out of turn against his daddy. Watching the early seasons of Dallas I've always been of the opinion Ewing Oil was truly JR's baby. Miss Texas and producing a Ewing heir was less important to JR but pleasing his daddy and momma was.

It's why I believe viewers were so captivated by the character of JR. We watched this bastard have his wicked way with ladies without a moral compass only to witness his persona change when he returned to Southfork. But the one thing he should have been doing, which was inseminating Miss Texas, he couldn't. Then there is the scene where Miss Texas believes a sexy under garment may do the trick only for JR's swimmers shrink in horror that his wife is dressed exactly like the whores his swimmers have no issues gushing forth.

It was a conundrum, but compelling to watch.
 

pete lashmar

Telly Talk Addict
I always found it very strange that J.R just wasn't interested in having an heir to the Ewing Empire. After Pam announced she was pregnant it was Sue Ellen that got angry and irate about it, J.R was really not that fussed until that point - so I see Sue Ellen as the jealous party for sure and then something clicked in J.R's head.

Even when Pam fell from the hayloft and miscarried it wasn't J.R's intention to harm her, he was simply drunk and was trying to apologise - but then, following the miscarriage he seemed more determined to have the first born grandson.
 

James from London

International Treasure
JR wanted what he couldn't have. When he couldn't have Sue Ellen, that's when he wanted her. The rest of the time, she pretty much repulsed him -- at least that's the impression we're given early on.

As for producing an heir, he probably thought his position as Jock's first born was unassiable until Bobby brought Pam home and she screwed things up by persuading him to take a desk job at Ewing Oil.

According to the Lee Raintree novel, JR could only be aroused orally. I always figured that's what this exchange in 'Spy in the House' refers to:

JR: You're the only one that ever turned me on. The only one that ever knew how.
Julie: You taught me how. You told me what you like. Why don't you teach Sue Ellen? Why don't you tell her?
JR: I don't wanna talk about Sue Ellen.
 

Angela Channing

Telly Talk Veteran
According to the Lee Raintree novel, JR could only be aroused orally. I always figured that's what this exchange in 'Spy in the House' refers to:

JR: You're the only one that ever turned me on. The only one that ever knew how.
Julie: You taught me how. You told me what you like. Why don't you teach Sue Ellen? Why don't you tell her?
JR: I don't wanna talk about Sue Ellen.

I didn't know that. That scene will never seem the same whenever I watch it again in the future.
 

James from London

International Treasure
Well it may not be admissable in court, but it's still a fascinating read.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
That would actually be a great revelation for the closing seasons: Lucy is JR's daughter after he raped Valene/Maureen.

Just about the same time Miss Ellie tells Clayton that JR may be Digger's biological son.

Just about the same time that Bobby learns Pam died of neurofibromatosis, making her a Barnes after all and potentially JR's sister.

Heh. Good times.
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Very interesting points brought up here. And an interesting discussion altogether.

The posters seem to agree that J.R. wants what he can't have, and that applies to his relationship with Sue Ellen. You all might be onto something there.

One of the times J.R. sincerely pursued Sue Ellen was when he was losing her to Dusty Farlow. And that seemed to be jealousy driven, almost as if losing out to another man was more on his mind than losing Sue Ellen in general.

"Maybe your boyfriend can rescue you in one mighty hobble."

BWHAHAHAHAH!
 
Last edited:

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
Very interesting points brought up here. And an interesting discussion altogether.

The posters seem to agree that J.R. wants what he can't have, and that applies to his relationship with Sue Ellen. You all might be onto something there.

One of the times J.R. sincerely pursued Sue Ellen was when he was losing her to Dusty Farlow. And that seemed to be jealousy driven, almost as if losing out to another man was more on his mind than losing Sue Ellen in general.

Maybe your boyfriend can rescue you in one mighty hobble.

BWHAHAHAHAH!

I've just watched those particular episodes last night. Really loving season five & preparing myself for the announcement that Jock Ewing is no more. :(
 

Justine

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
The way I've always pictured it was that J.R. and Sue Ellen did try for a baby early on but, for whatever reason, a baby never came. Issues would have arisen in their relationship pretty soon afterward, because J.R. was almost always at work and then the affairs started and his interest in Sue Ellen dissipated.

As for Bobby's influence, I don't think J.R. really took his little brother seriously until he married Pam. Bobby was a playboy; J.R. had set him up as the "roadman" for the company and he probably didn't foresee that Bobby would settle down for some time. Especially since Gary had been driven off of Southfork, J.R. wouldn't have perceived any time constraints/competition to produce a son and heir. I think he assumed a child would come at some point in the future, but then Bobby turned up with his new bride, Pam, and the pressure was on.
 

Laurie Marr

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I never fully bought the idea that JR was the great lover we heard about. I think his money may have made some of his opportunistic bed partners exaggerate their claims. It also just didn’t fit with his frigidity around Sue Ellen in the early seasons. There’s a possibility that JR may be sexually conflicted in a way that goes beyond the poor state of his marriage.
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
JR wanted what he couldn't have. When he couldn't have Sue Ellen, that's when he wanted her. The rest of the time, she pretty much repulsed him -- at least that's the impression we're given early on.

As for producing an heir, he probably thought his position as Jock's first born was unassiable until Bobby brought Pam home and she screwed things up by persuading him to take a desk job at Ewing Oil.

According to the Lee Raintree novel, JR could only be aroused orally. I always figured that's what this exchange in 'Spy in the House' refers to:

JR: You're the only one that ever turned me on. The only one that ever knew how.
Julie: You taught me how. You told me what you like. Why don't you teach Sue Ellen? Why don't you tell her?
JR: I don't wanna talk about Sue Ellen.
I prefer to agree with the speculation of the fantastic Stacie Ponder on Dallas Reviewed:

http://dallasreviewed.blogspot.com/2014/03/13-spy-in-house.html?m=1

Before I can stop shuddering at the direction this scene is taking, Julie replies, "You taught me how. You told me what you liked." At the risk of driving you to close your browser window and never read Dallas Reviewed again, here's what I decided in light of that conversation: J.R. likes a finger up his ass during sex! Right? I'm going to say YES and let my wild speculation color my viewing of every future episode.​
 
Top