If It Ain't Broke...

ClassyCo

Telly Talk Warrior
If it ain't broke, don't fix it.

A fairly cliche comment, wouldn't you say? But does it hold to some great truth?

Was there any point within the original Dallas story where there was an attempt to fix something that wasn't broken? If so, where do you believe those 'points' were?
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
When Donna Reed stepped off that plane.
 

ClassyCo

Telly Talk Warrior
When Donna Reed stepped off that plane.
Contrary to popular opinion, I actually liked Donna Reed's performance as Miss Ellie. While she wasn't the original Mama that we had grown use to seeing with the seasoned cast, she provided a fresh perspective that, while it didn't give Miss Ellie any more depth, provided something of interest. (To me, anyways.) Along with that, too, I always felt that Reed possessed more the "look" of a Ewing matriarch, especially when you here the stories of how Jock and Digger fought for her. Now, I love Bel Geddes, but she wasn't the looker Reed was in her younger days, nor did she age as well, either. In saying all this, I do often find myself pulling for the underdog, and Reed was definitely the underdog here. The odds were against her from the get-go. She was fired, treated shabbily, and casually tossed aside. What a shame.
 

Victoriafan3

Telly Talk Addict
Bringing Bobby back? The show was still #6 in the ratings before this. It would’ve carried on fine once Angelica’s over the top ostrich feathers and Matt’s emerald nonsense had left the building. Without such a huge stretch of believeability and betrayal of the viewers of a dream and a loved character mourned. And VP might have stayed longer perhaps? Who knows. Pam would’ve had to keep Christopher’s shares in Ewing Oil to keep up the tension at Ewing Oil though
 
Last edited:

ClassyCo

Telly Talk Warrior
Bringing Bobby back? The show was still #6 in the ratings before this. It would’ve carried on fine once Angelica’s over the top ostrich feathers and Matt’s emerald nonsense had left the building. Without such a huge stretch of believeability and betrayal of the viewers of a dream and a loved character mourned. And VP might have stayed longer perhaps? Who knows. Pam would’ve had to keep Christopher’s shares in Ewing Oil to keep up the tension at Ewing Oil though
Many side with the "dream" as being the downturn to Dallas. Some, on the other hand, feel that Season 10 (per DVD count) fixed it, while Pam's departure was the final nail in the coffin.
 

Angela Channing

Telly Talk Veteran
Contrary to popular opinion, I actually liked Donna Reed's performance as Miss Ellie. While she wasn't the original Mama that we had grown use to seeing with the seasoned cast, she provided a fresh perspective that, while it didn't give Miss Ellie any more depth, provided something of interest. (To me, anyways.) Along with that, too, I always felt that Reed possessed more the "look" of a Ewing matriarch, especially when you here the stories of how Jock and Digger fought for her. Now, I love Bel Geddes, but she wasn't the looker Reed was in her younger days, nor did she age as well, either. In saying all this, I do often find myself pulling for the underdog, and Reed was definitely the underdog here. The odds were against her from the get-go. She was fired, treated shabbily, and casually tossed aside. What a shame.

I love this post and completely agree.

I've never thought recasting Miss Ellie with Donna Reed was a mistake, in fact, I think it was more of a mistake to switch back to Barbara because it reduced the credibility of the show and gave the impression of desperation.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
I've never thought recasting Miss Ellie with Donna Reed was a mistake, in fact, I think it was more of a mistake to switch back to Barbara because it reduced the credibility of the show and gave the impression of desperation.
The whole exercise with the switcharoo hurt the credibility of Dallas I'll agree but the resurrection of Bobby Ewing was a desperate times call for desperate measures that killed the credibility of Dallas in my opinion. I could never take the show seriously after this point.
 

ClassyCo

Telly Talk Warrior
I love this post and completely agree.

I've never thought recasting Miss Ellie with Donna Reed was a mistake, in fact, I think it was more of a mistake to switch back to Barbara because it reduced the credibility of the show and gave the impression of desperation.
I agree. In the long run, it may have been better had they kept Reed.
The whole exercise with the switcharoo hurt the credibility of Dallas I'll agree but the resurrection of Bobby Ewing was a desperate times call for desperate measures that killed the credibility of Dallas in my opinion. I could never take the show seriously after this point.
Yes, the cast changes did hurt the show for sure. Bobby's resurrection was definitely more desperate, though, I'll agree there. That was one story line I don't think the majority was expecting from a show of Dallas stature.
 

Chris2

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Bringing Bobby back? The show was still #6 in the ratings before this.
The show was ranked #6 for the whole season, during 86-86. However, that overall rating was based on the strength of the ratings during the earlier part of the season, plus the season finale. By the latter half the season, the show had dropped out of the top 10 and some weeks wasn’t even in the top 15. The ratings were significantly off during the last half of the season, and it was clear that the audience was disappearing.
 

Victoriafan3

Telly Talk Addict
The show was ranked #6 for the whole season, during 86-86. However, that overall rating was based on the strength of the ratings during the earlier part of the season, plus the season finale. By the latter half the season, the show had dropped out of the top 10 and some weeks wasn’t even in the top 15. The ratings were significantly off during the last half of the season, and it was clear that the audience was disappearing.
Like I said nice the silly emeralds and Marino’s silliness has finished it could have improved and gone on well. The first half the season had good ratings and worked fine without bobby
 
Last edited:

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
Bringing Bobby back? The show was still #6 in the ratings before this
Yes, that was an obvious "fix".
Several people here have described how the show could have survived without Bobby, by focussing on the JR-Pam feud.
The ratings were significantly off during the last half of the season, and it was clear that the audience was disappearing.
But was that because Bobby wasn't in it?
I like Angelica & The Eurovision Troopers, but the story dragged on.
For me once BBG was Miss Ellie again I never really gave Donna Reed a second thought.
I think it's safe to say that most viewers preferred BBG, so that was a fix because it was broke. But I don't think they hired Donna Reed because they thought she would be a better Miss Ellie (correct me if I'm wrong).
 

Mustard

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
Contrary to popular opinion, I actually liked Donna Reed's performance as Miss Ellie. While she wasn't the original Mama that we had grown use to seeing with the seasoned cast, she provided a fresh perspective that, while it didn't give Miss Ellie any more depth, provided something of interest. (To me, anyways.) Along with that, too, I always felt that Reed possessed more the "look" of a Ewing matriarch, especially when you here the stories of how Jock and Digger fought for her. Now, I love Bel Geddes, but she wasn't the looker Reed was in her younger days, nor did she age as well, either. In saying all this, I do often find myself pulling for the underdog, and Reed was definitely the underdog here. The odds were against her from the get-go. She was fired, treated shabbily, and casually tossed aside. What a shame.

Donna Reed's Miss Ellie looked more like a typical oil baron's wife, but the point of Barbara Bel Geddes' Miss Ellie is that it's her love of the land, her ranching upbringing and casual clothes that is her passion and has never left her despite her becoming an oil baron's wife.

Many side with the "dream" as being the downturn to Dallas. Some, on the other hand, feel that Season 10 (per DVD count) fixed it, while Pam's departure was the final nail in the coffin.

In my view:

Season 8 DVD showed the relationship between Philip Capice and Leonard Katzman hitting breaking point, and a decline in quality compared to previous seasons. Donna Reed's presence, and the lack of emotional range in her portrayal of Miss Ellie, sums up a lot of the malaise. Nevertheless, the season finale is an all-time classic.

Season 9 DVD (the dream season) is a return to form and showing Dallas what its future should be. We see sides to characters that we have seldom seen before after Bobby's death, Mark returns, Cliff and Jamie are a good team, Jack is a great character yet should have been more involved at Ewing Oil, and the potential was there to have Pam create alliances to defend herself at Ewing Oil. I also liked the Emerald Mine in Colombia and Angelica Nero in Martinique storylines.

Season 10 DVD is mostly a decline, particularly in terms of some characters' personalities and the overboard amount of sexism, but there are still a couple of excellent storylines, namely the B. D. Calhoun storyline to blow up Saudi oil fields for J.R., and the Nancy Scotfield trying to shut down Ewing Oil storyline. Of course for many people, the dream revelation at the start of the season and the resetting of a year's worth of storylines, was too much to take anyway. People invested feelings in Bobby's death for a year, and were now told that it never happened. Ewing Oil getting shut down by the Justice Department, combined with Pam's car crash at the end of the season and Victoria Principal having gone after this, does symbolize the end.

Season 11 DVD still has a lot of the old structure, but without Pam it doesn't link up well anymore.

Season 12-14 DVD had J.R. weakened considerably, and things go from bad to worse.

The show was ranked #6 for the whole season, during 85-86. However, that overall rating was based on the strength of the ratings during the earlier part of the season, plus the season finale. By the latter half the season, the show had dropped out of the top 10 and some weeks wasn’t even in the top 15. The ratings were significantly off during the last half of the season, and it was clear that the audience was disappearing.

The audience disappeared far faster in the following seasons. With hindsight, 1985 was when US soaps peaked in the ratings as a general trend, but there were people behind the scenes at Dallas eager to settle scores with Philip Capice for Leonard Katzman's reduced role on Dallas, and there was no benefit of hindsight regarding the ratings in 1986, just a decline on the year before.
 

Seaviewer

Telly Talk Warrior
I think it's safe to say that most viewers preferred BBG, so that was a fix because it was broke. But I don't think they hired Donna Reed because they thought she would be a better Miss Ellie (correct me if I'm wrong).
I agree. What was broken was that with BBG ill there was no Miss Ellie. Whether Donna Reed was a good fix is an entirely different argument.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
That was one story line I don't think the majority was expecting from a show of Dallas stature.

Those first several seasons of Dallas did (in my view) change the way we viewed television. It did become must watch event television. And just about everyone was watching it. The purists may have snubbed their collective noses that a show like Dallas (a primetime soap) was a roaring success however, it's rare for a TV series to have that attraction to both male and female viewers.
 
Top