A new one, after all these years!

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
As Dallas fans I figured we'd heard and seen everything there was to hear and see about the show, but I saw a quote today that I hadn't seen before.

Many of us remember Friday nights, hearing the voiceover on TV: " Stay tuned for Dallas, with J.R. Ewing, the man we love to hate!"

But then today I saw a quote I hadn't seen before:
"Do we like hating J.R.? Or do we hate the fact that we like him?"

Very interested to hear your thoughts on this.
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Maybe it was a case of both!
HA! You could be right, depending on which schemes J.R. was up to.

Durning some of his more fun schemes, such as getting back at Vaugn Leland, he was the Magnificent Bastad that we loved to hate.

But during some of his other schemes, I hated that I liked him!

One thing for sure, J.R. was always entertaining. . .
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
"The man you hate to love" is the more accurate of the two although it's still not completely accurate. If there was anyone who was just someone we hated or even "loved to hate" it would be Cliff because he has so many bad qualities and is without JR's redeeming qualities. He's a bitter, cheap little man who is obsessed with revenge and nobody loves that. Nobody wants to be like Cliff. Yet I've never heard of Cliff referred to as someone people "love to hate." Ken Kercheval did a fine portrayal of the character too. He helped a lot in making the show great. But Cliff just isn't the kind of character that would ever have many fans.

JR had many likable qualities whereas Cliff did not. That's why it was so fun watching JR grind Cliff into the dirt when Cliff needed it. Since people also realized JR had many bad qualities they felt guilty for liking him and from there comes the expression "The man people hate to love." You can't help but admire his success, his competence and his enjoyment of life - qualities Cliff just didn't have. Cliff was a loser and people love a winner. Basically, either way the phrase in question is worded, it's a marketing ploy. While "The man you love to hate" is less accurate" it's the more catchy phrase and people still pick up on the meaning well enough that it works. Personally, I like the character because he's so entertaining and he's the best at what he does. "Be the best" was 1980's doctrine and JR Ewing personified it. But "The man you feel guilty for liking" isn't a very slick catch-phrase is it?
 
Last edited:

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
There's also the idea that you can't root for the Ewings without rooting for JR.
It doesn't really matter whether Cliff was right or wrong, JR represented Ewing Oil, and Ewing Oil is what made the Ewings rich Ewings.
Attacking Ewing Oil is attacking the Ewing family.
In essence, you couldn't afford to want/hope/like JR to lose, as it would affect the other Ewings as well.

That's why the outsider villains, those who fought our happy TV families, were far more dangerous and unlikeable than the family villains.
I found it hard to feel sorry for anyone who was stupid (or greedy) enough to deal with JR, however his role within the family is what made him a truly unlikeable character.
It was a bizarre but not uncommon construction. He was his own person but also a representative, and how much you like or hate him is just a matter of plot.
 

Chris2

Telly Talk Dream Maker
J.R., while not a good person, had a lot of charm and a sense of humor. The show was also smart enough to pit him against people who were equally bad or worse (such as Vaughn Leland and Jeremy Wendell). So it was easy to root for him in many storylines.
 
Love to hate, most certainly. It's a pantomime thing, isn't it? The charismatic villain comes on and stage whispers their nasty scheme to the audience who enjoy booing and hissing as the villain attempts to carry out their plan. It's cathartic and so much more fun than cheering on Cinders and Buttons.

Sue Ellen may (or may not) have hated to love him, but I've never felt any sense of conflict around it. It was fun all the way.
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Nobody wants to be like Cliff.
You make a very good point here. Love him or hate him, there were times when many of us would want to be J.R. or Sue Ellen, and have their money and their power. But nobody wanted to be Cliff.

In essence, you couldn't afford to want/hope/like JR to lose, as it would affect the other Ewings as well.
And this is how the show started out. J.R. was a sympathetic character. He was the one who had to do the dirty work while the family enjoyed the wealth that this brought them. But then Larry Hagman played it to the hilt and turned J.R. into the Magnificent Bastard and took the show in a whole new direction.

The show was also smart enough to pit him against people who were equally bad or worse (such as Vaughn Leland and Jeremy Wendell).
Jeremy Smithers did a great job with the Jeremy Wendell character. I love his exasperated delivery when he sees J.R. coming his way and Jeremy knows something bad is about to happen. "Oh, Hello, J.R.".

The charismatic villain comes on and stage whispers their nasty scheme to the audience who enjoy booing and hissing as the villain attempts to carry out their plan. It's cathartic and so much more fun than cheering on Cinders and Buttons.
For some reason, your post reminds me of when Donna pushes J.R, in the pool. We're expecting J.R. to explode with anger, but instead he just laughs, and while treading water calls out, "Well, don't go away mad, darlin'!

Her last scene with Bum on TNT Dallas shows a lot of conflict. I thought it was beautiful.
I wonder how different the dynamic would have been between J.R. and Sue Ellen if she had an ally on her side. Could have made for a whole new storyline there.
 
Last edited:

Chris2

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I love the scene with J.R. in the pool, laughing, and calling out to Donna, “Don’t go away mad!” That charming bastard.
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I love the scene with J.R. in the pool, laughing, and calling out to Donna, “Don’t go away mad!” That charming bastard.
There is a flurry of interviews around 2011 and 2012 with Larry Hagman as he was generating buzz for TNT Dallas. You would really enjoy those interviews because he's like a grandfather telling stories around a campfire.

One of the things he said it that the writers would plan for him to deliver a threatening line loudly, sometimes shouting the threat. But Larry would read the script, then deliver the line in a quiet, even tone.

"That made the threat even more scary!"

Damn, I miss that magnificent bastard. . .
 
Top