“New Miss Ellie on Dallas/August 30, 1984.”

JR Ewing Fan

Telly Talk Active Member
What character would that have been? Perhaps a Southworth? I'm only curious because if Donna's other character had just dropped into Southfork unannounced it would have been just as confronting - if not more - since Miss Ellie would not have been present.
They dropped Jamie and Jack in out of nowhere. They could have figured something out.
 

JR Ewing Fan

Telly Talk Active Member
Btw, if what she said in the article is true, it’s sad how things deteriorated so quickly. I know that Susan Howard was the only cast member to go to her funeral when she died.

Even though I’m sure everyone has seen this clip a thousand times, you can just tell it was a big F-up. DR was NOT Miss Ellie and it wasn’t her fault at all.

I do recall that when she was fired and she found out BBG was rehired she started making potshots at BBG’s appearance in regards to her “sack dresses,” and frumpiness. This could be why the cast might have felt alienated against her because she was insulting their “mama.” Reed def took the insults to a personal level and I think that really hurt her credibility with the cast.

I think she did it because she was hurt. People say things they shouldn't out of desperation.
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
They dropped Jamie and Jack in out of nowhere. They could have figured something out.

it’s preposterous that after precisely zero mentions in the first several years of the series, all of a sudden there was a second Ewing there in the wildcatting days that were the basis for the entire premise of the show... just as an excuse to introduce the replacement “hot girl” from Three’s Company! (at least Bobby got to make a series later with the original)
 
Last edited:

Chris2

Telly Talk Dream Maker
If they had to retcon the Jock/Digger story with Jason just to introduce Jamie, you’d think they could have done better with casting than Suzanne Somers’ failed replacement.

I would have had Donna play Ellie’s sister, Miss Nellie.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
They should have given what BBG asked for -- a relaxed work week (think about how brief Reed's work week became when they kept cutting her back in the scenes) and her raise (which she presumably got when they brought BBG back). Or at least put Ellie on ice, in a medical facility, until the terms could be worked out.

Donna Reed should have done FALCON CREST during the 84/85 season instead, as the dithery sister of Lana Turner, who descends on the Tuscany Valley after the air crash death of her son, Cliff Robertson. Maybe that would have even allowed Reed to live.

1c72ede3e909173c383d03483db9d099.jpg
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
like watching a bloody awful am-dram production of Dallas where everyone had been bickering to make sure they got a line.
A good observation. The dubbing clearly doesn't help either. In fact the scene now feels rather amateurish by Dallas standards. Instead of the new Miss Ellie being introduced in a subtle way it was if the writers and producers showed intent on giving everyone the one finger salute. I cannot imagine what Barbara Bel must have been feeling sitting at home watching that scene.
 
Last edited:

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
I cannot imagine what Barbara Bel must have been feeling sitting at home watching that scene.
Apparently, she didn't. Despite the mythology that she sat jealously watching another actress in her role and then angrily picked up the phone and demanded her part back.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
she didn't
Perhaps not but given Dallas was still the hottest series on television you'd expect a close family member or friend of Barbara to bring it to her attention. I'd feel absolutely gutted knowing I had put my heart and soul into a role (and winning an Emmy no less) only to watch someone snaffle the role right under my feet. And all because of what? Lighter duties? A share in the pot of gold Dallas was bringing in?
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
A good observation. The dubbing clearly doesn't help either. In fact the scene now feels rather amateurish by Dallas standards. Instead of the new Miss Ellie being introduced in a subtle way it was if the writers and producers showed intent on giving everyone the one finger salute. I cannot imagine what Barbara Bel must have been feeling sitting at home watching that scene.

yeah, at least it’s often plausible that the dialogue could have been recorded live (I don’t think the live audio is used often if ever, is it?), but the airport scene isn’t even in the ballpark - they seriously mailed that one in.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
I can’t even see DR being another character. She was simply too “polished” for a show like Dallas. She simply wasn’t going to work, no matter what the circumstances were.
On second thoughts I could envisage Donna playing Herbert Wentworth's spinster sister. I see this character as being an ice queen, something I believe could have suited Donna's persona.
 

B.J. Ewing

Telly Talk Fan
I always see her as Jenna's aunt, arrived in Dallas to witness her niece's wedding. She's friendly with Clayton, while Ellie recuperates in a hospice someplace after suffering a "spell" -- perhaps that psych ward committal that nuDALLAS was so enthusiastic about.

I pictured her as Cherie Simmons-Southworth, the wife of Garrison, who was seen in Dallas: The Early Years. If the Southworths would have known Garrison was alive, Southfork Ranch would have gone to him and not Miss Ellie. Garrison only returned to die there and left things as they were. But would Cherie have thought the same way? I think she never divorced Garrison, but ran away, pregnant of course. And she would bring her offspring back to Southfork to claim the ranch, who was rightfully hers.
 

TJames03

Banned
On second thoughts I could envisage Donna playing Herbert Wentworth's spinster sister. I see this character as being an ice queen, something I believe could have suited Donna's persona.

Why do people say that Reed was an ice queen? Fabares and Petersen said that she was a wonderful person and she did a lot of charity work and worked for numerous peace causes in the 60’s/70’s.
 

Chris2

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Perhaps not but given Dallas was still the hottest series on television you'd expect a close family member or friend of Barbara to bring it to her attention. I'd feel absolutely gutted knowing I had put my heart and soul into a role (and winning an Emmy no less) only to watch someone snaffle the role right under my feet. And all because of what? Lighter duties? A share in the pot of gold Dallas was bringing in?

It was the money - my guess is that they would have agreed to the shorter week if it hadn’t been accompanied by a request for a raise, too.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
It was the money - my guess is that they would have agreed to the shorter week if it hadn’t been accompanied by a request for a raise, too.
But it was probably when her contract was up. And they knew about her heart surgery. Instead we got a mess which was obvious as soon as it was announced, and we're still talking about 35 years later.

They probably hired Donna Reed -- and then extended her contract by two years -- because they thought she was healthier than BBG and might last longer.

1451789675705.jpg
 
Last edited by a moderator:

TJames03

Banned
If Reed has stayed, the show would have been in trouble when she died in ‘86. Would BBG return to take the late Reed’s place? Kill Ellie off finally? Miss Ellie Mark 3??
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
and we're still taking about 35 years later.
I'd be curious to know if it was the Miss Ellie recast or Bobby spinning in the shower which infuriated viewers the most. Has a thread/pole ever been conducted on Soapchat between these two colossal errors? It could be argued how both bookend each other.
 

TJames03

Banned

Reed made a HUGE mistake in trying to get the new season without her from being filmed. In one fell swoop, she alienated EVERYONE from actors to writers and producers to cameramen, etc. I know she was angry, but that blew any and all credibility hat she may have had with the cast. I cannot imagine the tension on the set had she managed to prevent the new season from being filmed and then went back to the role!!!!!!
 
Top