“New Miss Ellie on Dallas/August 30, 1984.”

TJames03

Banned
I'd be curious to know if it was the Miss Ellie recast or Bobby spinning in the shower which infuriated viewers the most. Has a thread/pole ever been conducted on Soapchat between these two colossal errors? It could be argued how both bookend each other.

I would say the dream. The Ellie recast was a big bump in the show, but it didn’t destroy its credibility and wholly insult the viewer(s) like the dream did. It even messed with viewers of KL, too, in its insulting nature.

I think the dream resolution was a big factor in VP leaving the show. You couldn’t go back after that mess. Though it is a soap trope, they never should have permanently killed off Bobby. By having Duffy dictate what the writers would write he doomed the show, period.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
I'd be curious to know if it was the Miss Ellie recast or Bobby spinning in the shower which infuriated viewers the most. Has a thread/pole ever been conducted on Soapchat between these two colossal errors? It could be argued how both bookend each other.
Mis-Ellie, Pam's Dream, and Pam's Disappearing and Nobody Noticing was certainly a 1-2-3 punch. The audience abused again, as Susan Howard said.
 

TJames03

Banned
Mis-Ellie, Pam's Dream, and Pam's Disappearing and Nobody Noticing was certainly a 1-2-3 punch. The audience abused again, as Susan Howard said.

Agreed. I was only 12 when VP left the show, but even I was shocked at how blasé the characters were with Pam being burned and vanishing when I saw the episodes in their first-run order.
 

xab

Telly Talk Fan
Agreed. I was only 12 when VP left the show, but even I was shocked at how blasé the characters were with Pam being burned and vanishing when I saw the episodes in their first-run order.

Yes. Except for Miss Ellie... Sue Ellen who was supposed to be her friend didn't give a flying f**k...

Writing a character out of character can be worse than a mis-recast.

Unfortunately they did both with Donna Reed, who didn't deserve this poisoned chalice and the backstabing which came after.
 
Last edited:

TJames03

Banned
Yeah, Reed was poised for failure by certain people before she even appeared, however, her trying to shut down production and cost hundreds of people $$$ that had nothing to do with what was going on doomed her. You don’t do that.
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
I just rewatched much of the Reed season, and while she came on initially more more like Patricia Shepard than Miss Ellie, she kind of reined it in as the season progressed (and the role diminished). Still, she was portraying an utterly different person than what Barbara had established.
 
Top