Appraisal of season 3 (DVD4)

the-lost-son

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I've just rewatched season 3 (DVD4) after "Who shot JR?" for the 2nd time in total and I truly enjoyed. I think the majority here regards seasons 4-6 (DVD 5-7) as Dallas' glory years and some (myself included) sometimes wondered how this season maintained No. 1 in the Nielsen ratings. I enjoyed it more now than before for the following reasons:

1. The follow-up after who shot JR is great. When I watched it first, it felt they stretched the storyline, but now I can appreciate the great work they put into it. First JR turning his head in hospital (insinuating it was, SueEllen who shot), SueEllen in jail, the great revelation "Jock Ewing - jail baby :)

2. All these great long-term additions - Afton, Mitch and especially Clayton and Rebecca. That's the way to introduce characters. Show them to audience, leave it alone for 10 episodes, and then they re-enter the scene you feel like knowing them for years. The licorice scene wouldn't have worked if we had met Rebecca only 2 episodes prior. And we get first information on Katherine.
Take a look at that Jamie, Jack and Jason. :)

3. I liked the writing with its focus on business (Venezuelan oil, refinery, gas station owners, distributors, oil rig explosions) and family. It was not a bad thing that due to the writer's strike the season's episodes got reduced to 23.

4. There were some amazing acting performances which I'd like point out:
- Linda Grey managed to portray 3 (!) love interests convincingly - JR, Clint (I liked that really, she deserved a good - admitted boring - guy (like Pam did with Mark in the dream season) and Dusty.
I enjoyed her scenes with Dr. Elby is well. She is such a complex character whose insecurities, frustrations were pointed out perfectly.
- the licorice scene by Ken Kercheval - what can I say? Terrific performance from both of them
- Jim Davis had his best year then.
4th son, Takapa, conflicts with JR, Ellie and especially Bobby.
- the iconic cliffhanger was unexpected and shocking, I liked it that they added Cliff in the middle of it.

I didn't mind Alex Ward (he reminded me of Mark Graison, the rich, white knight night), but it was too long.
The whole Lucy&Mitch storyline did not work for me - they met in episode 1/2, wedding in episode 13, split up in 23. Mitch leaving in a huff became stale like Bobby canceling dinner with Pam.
I disliked Leslie Stewart though, the character, the storyline and the casting choice.

I loved it, loved it, loved it that Miss Ellie and Jock got their reconciliation in time (before Jim Davis' death) but I have the following theories if Jim Davis could have been part of the next season:
- The writers were obviously determined to shake things up regarding the control of Ewing Oil. (Voting meetings in the living room next season and Jock substituting JR/Bobby as the president of Ewing Oil had been done frequently already.)

So I think - with Jim Davis in board - the reconciliation would have been postponed for some time.
It's an interesting outline - a divorce between Ellie (100% owner of Southfork) and Jock (100%owner of Ewing Oil)

There could have been a scenario between Miss Ellie and Jock sharing Ewing Oil, putting both JR and Bobby in the middle and/or a shake-up at Southfork and Jock controlling parts of it now.

I'm pretty sure Ray would have been featured more with Jim Davis around with more land deals (Ray's insecurities, his need to prove himself) and conflicts between the two of them.

A reconciliation in the long run was unevitable though (like Sue Ellen&JR, Bobby&Pam) but I'm pretty sure with Rebecca and Clayton around things would have gotten much more complex.

Does anyone agree?
 
Last edited:

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
It's a weird year, to be sure. The highest-rated season in the show's history, due to opening with the 'WSJR? ' storyline (a global event in 1980) and yet the pacing is so leisurely, it's sometimes maddening.

The plots seem to be okay.

I've often wondered what could have been different in order to tighten it up a bit: JR and Sue Ellen paranoid that Kristen is stalking them (when it turns out to just be Dusty) before she bites it in the swimming pool?

The oft-repeated stock music score by uncredited John Scott (due to a composers' strike industry-wide) is effective in ways, but it goes on for 2/3 of the year, and the tired cues really begin to drag.

I always find Miss Ellie's "I'm a whore and a bitch and a slut and a c***" speech in the Krebbs' living room near the end of the season to be a little bizarre. Did Katzman really view women this way??

dallas-biggroup.jpg
 
Last edited by a moderator:

DallasFanForever

Telly Talk Supreme
Definitely not one of my favorite seasons of original Dallas. I feel that after the whole WSJR mystery is solved things take a downward turn for awhile. I never could get into the Leslie Stewart storyline.

I didn’t like the idea of Miss Ellie and Jock splitting up. It was just hard to believe for me as they had already stayed together through so much. But I was so glad they reconciled storyline wise before Jim Davis died.

I do enjoy the end of the season. I love Pam and JRs confrontation on the stairs over John Ross belonging with his mother and not him, as well as the cliffhanger of who dies in the pool.
 

the-lost-son

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I always find Miss Ellie's "I'm a whore and a bitch and a slut and a c***" speech in the Krebbs' living room near the end of the season to be a little bizarre. Did Katzman really view women this way??
I assume they wrapped up this storyline on short notice. In the last 4-5 episodes Jim Davis started to look different, his detoriating health became visible (I did not notice that the 1st time around). It came quite unexpectedly.
I do enjoy the end of the season. I love Pam and JRs confrontation on the stairs over John Ross belonging with his mother and not him, as well as the cliffhanger of who dies in the pool.
That was great.
Fun fact. In the German version Jr's quote (a drunken slut who run away) was completely cut.

There was another quote:
JR Ewing:
[after Mitch walked out on Lucy] Lost another one, did you, sugar? Hell, I got to hand it to you, you sure can pick them. A pansy, a crook, and an up-and-coming pauper. You are a veritable magnet for losers and failures.

Lucy Ewing Cooper:
At least I can't do any worse than Sue Ellen, can I?

They "translated" pansy into "married man in the German version. :)
 
Although I loved it at the time - it wasnt as "exciting" as the previous S2 (DVD 3 cough splutter) (im original Dallas fan)

It came in for criticism in the UK press with newspapers printing headlines such as

7CG4YGF.jpg


FBISdqQ.jpg


qzf393i.jpg


With hindsight some of the plots were dull, Susan Flannery as Leslie S was a snooze fest as was Sue Ellen and Mogadon man Clint

But I did enjoy Miss Ellie and Jock fighting over Takapa and Donna and Ray marrying.. Lucy and Mitch will always be my fav SF wedding and It did give us wondeful John Randolph as Miss Ellies divorce lawyer even for 1 scene

I would still take S3 original over the last 3 years as it had a great core cast and supporting actors who could A C T unlike the final years which had neither.
 

Chris2

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Awful. The musicians were on strike, so they studios had to cobble together scores from stock music. It was also awful on Knots, The Waltons, and Eight is Enough (other Lorimar productions).

There’s just something arid about this season. I thought the Who Shot JR resolution was disappointing. Of course it would be Kristen, because she was the easiest to write out. I was just a kid, and I could see that coming a mile away. But I’ll give them credit - JR’s recovery story and Sue Ellen’s arrest were fun. There was also far, far too much Lucy and Mitch. Lucy is dull enough on her own and then they managed to find a romantic partner for her who was even duller. She needed a partner with a little more of an edge (like Mickey).
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
1. The follow-up after who shot JR is great. When I watched it first, it felt they stretched the storyline, but now I can appreciate the great work they put into it.
The highest-rated season in the show's history, due to opening with the 'WSJR? ' storyline (a global event in 1980) and yet the pacing is so leisurely, it's sometimes maddening.
I believe it was @James from London who first pointed out that if you are trying to get friends to watch Dallas, the first few episodes of this season are not really the place to start. It's a great season, but starts out kind of slow.

Once things start moving , there are some great storylines. One of my favorite scenes is with J.R. and Sue Ellen. It's the one where Bobby buys the refinery and J.R. tells Sue Ellen,
"I'm gonna bring Bobby down. I'm gonna cut him out. . . If I have to destroy Ewing Oil to do it."

The scene is at the 4:30 mark


The two reasons I love this scene is because it shows that J.R. is willing to burn Ewing Oil to the ground as long as he gets to rule over the ashes.
It also shows how great a team J.R. and Sue Ellen can be when they team up together.
 
Last edited:

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
The plotting seems acceptable, even necessary, but there's something 'off' about the flow.

More and more, I come to the decision that the main problem is that deathly-repetitive stock score used during the composers' union strike -- it's ponderous and drags terribly.

Sometimes one can underestimate how much music affects how a drama feels. I don't think it's a coincidence that the season tends to pick up towards the end... in fact, that seems to happen with the very episode the regular composers return with original scores.


s-l400.jpg
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Mustard

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
Season 4 DVD is a bit of an odd one. Enjoyable but safe, for the most part. The resolution to "Who Shot J.R.?" early on in the season is very good, but a lot of the season is like they know Jim Davis is badly ill, and are waiting to get through that before they go for bold storylines again. The whole Leslie Stewart storyline ended up being bizarre, and didn't really go anywhere.
 
Last edited:

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
The plotting seems acceptable, even necessary, but there's something 'off' about the flow.

More and more, I come to the decision that the main problem is that deathly-repetitive stock score used during the composers' union strike -- it's ponderous and drags terribly.

Sometimes one can underestimate how much music affects how a drama feels. I don't think it's a coincidence that the season tends to pick up towards the end... in fact, that seems to happen with the very episode the regular composers return with original scores.


s-l400.jpg

The next season, 81/82, was somewhat slow-paced as well, but it wasn't as bad. But could you imagine all those helicopter landings and take-off from the Southern Cross, all those aimless scenes at Sue Ellen's new townhouse, or Pam's trip through the MeadowLarkBrook Institute all set to those uncredited stock musical cues by John Scott?

It would be unbearable!

1629258635396.png

Although scene is far from aimless...
f234bfbc3edce6c748e7128c1ee54865.jpg
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
a few things stood out to me that hampered the season:

- I realize the composers were on strike, and the stock music they chose might have fit the low-key nightmarish aftermath of JR's shooting... but why did they use only that one episode's worth of material?? Was there some legal restriction? After a few episodes it didn't fit the material at all. (I still prefer it to some of John Parker's corny-ass 'jazzy' moments though)

I'd love to hear that score it in its original context. I think I read it was from an episode of Gunsmoke (or am I making that up? I never would have guessed you'd hear something so modern and arty on a long-running western like that.)

- Jim Davis's tragic illness really began to take hold as the year went on. He was still vigorous in the early Texas episodes, but starting around Lucy's wedding he began to to deteriorate rapidly. It took all the steam out of the major storyline with his split from Miss Ellie, and cast a pallor on the second half of the season.

- the 'alternative love interests' of Pam and Sue Ellen were uninspiring to say the least. Alex Ward was no Mark Graison and Clint Ogden was no Dusty Farlow.

- the Leslie Stewart storyline might have had some promise in theory - a woman who could match JR blow for blow in the boardroom and the bedroom - but the execution and chemistry just wasn't there.
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
The Leslie Stewart storyline might have had some promise in theory - a woman who could match JR blow for blow in the boardroom and the bedroom - but the execution and chemistry just wasn't there.
Thank you! I was trying to figure out what seemed "off" on this otherwise promising storyline. The chemistry simply wasn't there. It wasn't believable to us as an audience.
 
Top