Bobby after Pam

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
I just cannot see Holly Harwood being the one who could have "saved" Dallas"!

Not even the return of Patrick and Barbara Bel Geddes could save Dallas. By then it was all to late. Bad writing, sloppy story arcs and actors who should never have left the casting couch. I don't believe for a moment Holly could have saved Dallas either, but with her history it may have kept the likes of yourself and I around just to see how things panned out.
 

Ms Southworth

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I think we had too much new blood - that was part of the problem, too many new characters we didn't care about. More returning characters with a backstory we already had an emotional stake in would have been better.
You're right! :yep: The show began "sinking" because of too many "new" characters (and because the writers/producers didn't recognize how important all the core cast members were to the longtime faithful viewers)! :cry: Looking back, Dallas should have been given a proper closure when the majority of the core characters were still there! :wink@
Not even the return of Patrick and Barbara Bel Geddes could save Dallas. By then it was all to late. Bad writing, sloppy story arcs and actors who should never have left the casting couch. I don't believe for a moment Holly could have saved Dallas either, but with her history it may have kept the likes of yourself and I around just to see how things panned out.
But Holly Harwood of all people? :frustration: No thank you! :frustration:

I do like the surprising element in your idea for a storyline. And it could have worked very well on other shows ... but just not Dallas, IMO! ;)
 

Tullamore

Telly Talk Active Member
TPTB just could not make up their minds and,in fact the way he went around on the "Bobby Roadshow" I am surprised they didn't try a public message announcement about sleeping around as there were media scare tactics in that era
 
K

Kani Kelly

Guest
Bobby and Phyllis actually sounds okay. Phyllis seemed a lot more normal and down to earth than most of the women in the Bobby Ewing Fan Club. I couldn't see her getting agonizingly weepy or whiny over a break-up or problem with Bobby. Too many women who liked Bobby acted like he was the ONLY guy in the world who was decent, or that it was the end of the world if he didn't want them or broke up with them. That was seriously irritating.
Bobby is god's gift to women in Dallas Universe what a joke.
 

Frank Underwood

Telly Talk Champion
What seriously?? Why would you want Bobby with Holly? She's a hateful bitch. Sorry for the harshness but come on - look what she did to Sue Ellen. I don't get this fascination with her. Someone who goes out of their way to wreck a marriage? April is much prettier, nicer and popular - a good heart, unlike Holly's black one. Yuck. JUST YUCK.
Really? April married Jack for money, lied to the judge to get 50% of his income after their divorce, made out with Cliff while he was married to Jamie, and used Jamie's death to get her hands on 5% of Ewing Oil. How is any of that not hateful? And as a Sue Ellen fan, I thought you'd be particularly upset that she slept with JR while he was still married.

April's character was extremely white washed later on, and it came off as insincere to me. She and Bobby were sickeningly sweet together, and it felt forced.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
I just felt like too many of the women didn't even really know Bobby as a person before they just decided that he is the best guy ever.
His being super-rich may have had something to do with it. Plus, Bobby wasn't paunchy.

April's character was extremely white washed later on, and it came off as insincere to me. She and Bobby were sickeningly sweet together, and it felt forced.
I hated what they later did with April, and her misguided marriage to Bobby -- because Katzman "liked" Wilson -- is symptomatic of how wrong-headed DALLAS got in its closing seasons (and as bad as anything Peter Dunne did with the show when Bobby was ostensibly dead).

People always seem disinterested when I say this, but I really could see Afton with Bobby in the later years of the series: for one thing, there's the built-in conflict of Bobby "taking" Cliff's woman and raising Cliff's daughter, but I can also anticipate a potential chemistry between Duffy and Landers -- plus, Afton's redemption from her initial slutty ways was far more convincing than the shrill, clingy creature April was irritatingly retconned and shoe-horned into.

Patrick+Duffy+Mary+Crosby+Dallas+30th+Anniversary+Hoizd3RusmQl.jpg
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Victoriafan3

Telly Talk Addict
I’d never thought of that coupling, Afton and Bobby. That could’ve worked. She’d have empathy for Pam as well. Good idea. Still think Phyllis would’ve been lovely too. But April. Absolutely no way
 

Frank Underwood

Telly Talk Champion
I hated what they later did with April, and her misguided marriage to Bobby -- because Katzman "liked" Wilson -- is symptomatic of how wrong-headed DALLAS got in its closing seasons (and as bad as anything Peter Dunne did with the show when Bobby was ostensibly dead).
Exactly. You can't force those changes for the sake of liking the actress. They have to happen organically, like it did with Afton and Cliff.

And even though Afton became "nice," she was still street smart. April just became a sickeningly sweet Julie Andrews wannabe. Her edges were completely filed down, which made her dull. I couldn't bring myself to care when she was gunned down in Paris by Erica Kane's henchmen because I had long grown tired of her. If anything, it felt like a mercy killing.

People always seem disinterested when I say this, but I really could see Afton with Bobby in the later years of the series: for one thing, there's the built-in conflict of Bobby "taking" Cliff's woman and raising Cliff's daughter, but I can also anticipate a potential chemistry between Duffy and Landers -- plus, Afton's redemption from her initial slutty ways was far more convincing than the shrill, clingy creature April was irritatingly retconned and shoe-horned into.
I never really thought about it before, but Afton and Bobby could have been an interesting pairing. Pity that Bobby was such a douche to her in the new series.
 
Last edited:

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
And yet Katzman perversely cited April's death as "the biggest mistake" he'd ever made in DALLAS' history.

Say what??

To me, my imaginary Bobby-Afton scenario is just a listening to nature thing. I totally see it.
 

Victoriafan3

Telly Talk Addict
THAT he considers the biggest mistake on the show he ever made??!! Oh dear. No wonder the show withered into an wilted cabbage leaf by the last season or two
 

JRandSueEllenForever

Telly Talk Member
This is another query similar to what I asked before so the answer is prob just bad writing and they didn't care anymore. But why did they not bring Lois Chiles back after Pam left? Was she not available? I'm sure viewers would've accepted Holly a lot more than April. And they changed his character from not accepting a girlfriend who slept with JR, to being ok with April, who had slept with his brother. So they could have just as easily had the same scenario with Holly. Another lost Dallas opportunity. Holly seemed more popular (and to me personally nicer, prettier and better actor) than April so why they not let bobby go out with holly once Pam had gone?

What seriously?? Why would you want Bobby with Holly? She's a hateful bitch. Sorry for the harshness but come on - look what she did to Sue Ellen. I don't get this fascination with her. Someone who goes out of their way to wreck a marriage? April is much prettier, nicer and popular - a good heart, unlike Holly's black one. Yuck. JUST YUCK.

Agreed! Because of Holly, Sue Ellen started drinking again, which ultimately lead to Mickey’s death. She deliberately set out to hurt Sue Ellen and then tried to make excuses (“How was I supposed to know she’d go off the deep end!”) for herself. She was sick.

I liked April. I didn’t like her at first because she was a greedy, gold digging opportunist. But after a while she grew on me. She was lonely and just wanted friends, and so she became this sweet, sympathetic character. I thought she had good chemistry with Bobby too. It seemed like he didn’t pay much attention to her for a long time, but then she grew on him.

I was pissed when they wrote April off right after their wedding, but apparently Sheree Wilson wanted to leave. I think she was pregnant.
 

Presea

Telly Talk Addict
This is another query similar to what I asked before so the answer is prob just bad writing and they didn't care anymore. But why did they not bring Lois Chiles back after Pam left? Was she not available? I'm sure viewers would've accepted Holly a lot more than April. And they changed his character from not accepting a girlfriend who slept with JR, to being ok with April, who had slept with his brother. So they could have just as easily had the same scenario with Holly. Another lost Dallas opportunity. Holly seemed more popular (and to me personally nicer, prettier and better actor) than April so why they not let bobby go out with holly once Pam had gone?

What seriously?? Why would you want Bobby with Holly? She's a hateful bitch. Sorry for the harshness but come on - look what she did to Sue Ellen. I don't get this fascination with her. Someone who goes out of their way to wreck a marriage? April is much prettier, nicer and popular - a good heart, unlike Holly's black one. Yuck. JUST YUCK.

Agreed! Because of Holly, Sue Ellen started drinking again, which ultimately lead to Mickey’s death. She deliberately set out to hurt Sue Ellen and then tried to make excuses (“How was I supposed to know she’d go off the deep end!”) for herself. She was sick.

I liked April. I didn’t like her at first because she was a greedy, gold digging opportunist. But after a while she grew on me. She was lonely and just wanted friends, and so she became this sweet, sympathetic character. I thought she had good chemistry with Bobby too. It seemed like he didn’t pay much attention to her for a long time, but then she grew on him.

I was pissed when they wrote April off right after their wedding, but apparently Sheree Wilson wanted to leave. I think she was pregnant.
"Because of Holly"? Don't you mean because of JR? Sure, Holly played a part here and was a real jerk to just invite Sue Ellen to her house to show her that she was screwing her husband, but it wouldn't have happened at all if JR had just decided to stop being a scumbag and stay faithful to his wife.
 

markymark

Soap Chat Active Member
I thought she had good chemistry with Bobby too. It seemed like he didn’t pay much attention to her for

I know Patrick and Sheree were buddies but unfortunately that chemistry did not translate on screen. For me the Bobby/ April big romance felt forced and lame, and totally unnatural.

For example when April brought Miss Ellie that glass ice bowl and Ellie had to comment what a lovely person she was. It felt like we were being forced to accept this weird woman as part of the Ewing family.
 
Last edited:

Top Jimmy

Telly Talk Active Member
What seriously?? Why would you want Bobby with Holly? She's a hateful bitch. Sorry for the harshness but come on - look what she did to Sue Ellen. I don't get this fascination with her. Someone who goes out of their way to wreck a marriage? April is much prettier, nicer and popular - a good heart, unlike Holly's black one. Yuck. JUST YUCK.
Really? April married Jack for money, lied to the judge to get 50% of his income after their divorce, made out with Cliff while he was married to Jamie, and used Jamie's death to get her hands on 5% of Ewing Oil. How is any of that not hateful? And as a Sue Ellen fan, I thought you'd be particularly upset that she slept with JR while he was still married.

April's character was extremely white washed later on, and it came off as insincere to me. She and Bobby were sickeningly sweet together, and it felt forced.


April also threw herself at Wes Parmalee and was willing to sleep with him in order to help JR (I think that's why she was "befriending" him in some bar). She was really skanky at first, but did become a nicer person. I could see though why people did not like her. I liked her in comparison to Michelle. They almost had to change her personality to have a contrast between the two sisters, and have April be the "good" sister. In defense of Holly, she told Bobby she did not know Sue Ellen was an alcoholic, and I don't think she would have hurt her like that if she had known. She was just trying to get JR out of her life.
 

Toni

Maximum Member
upload_2018-2-18_21-56-28.png​
 

Sarah

Moderator Emerita
I loved April, I really did, I prefer her to Pam. But I'd go so far as to say that BOTH the Ewing men went off the rails when the original ladies left. I know it's mainly due to the writing but let's suspend disbelief here for a second - Bobby not going to look for Pam? JR marrying Cally and going round the bend? What happened to both JR and Bobby after Sue Ellen and Pam left was NOT fun.
 
Top