Bobby and Pam's Marriage During The Contest

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
The reason I used that phrase is that Bobby felt as if he lost part of himself during the contest. He lost part of his soul. And I agree with you that he was able to regain the "Good Bobby" that we all know.

Do you remember the scene during the contest when Bobby was feeling bad about all of the dirty tricks. He walked into J.R.'s office and J.R. was upbeat and going on about something.

Bobby's comment to J.R?

"You seem pretty chipper for a man who just ruined the lives of half a dozen people."

Wow, I don't remember that scene at all? Do you have any idea what episode it was, or approximately where it as in the 6th season?

Anyway, from what I gather, Bobby was grudgingly adapting to become what he had to be to have a chance at winning the contest. It bothered him and obviously doing those things didn't bother JR.

And yes, I'm glad Bobby regained his business ethics, which was nice to see. He'd never been a saint though. He was ready to (what he thought was) take his bother's son, never tell him about it and raise it as his own without his brother ever knowing. I think that's far worse than blackmailing Hicks! Isn't it interesting how when Pam found out what Bobby had done, that he'd been willing to do something that bad, she never once questioned his ethics or accused him of not being the man she married? It looks to me like, Bobby being unethical was alright with Pam, as long as it was done to get something Pam wanted. When Bobby did something far less unethical to get something he wanted (winning the contest) then all of the sudden she tells him the Bobby she married would rather be dead than blackmail Hicks. Wow! That says something about Pam doesn't it?
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Wow, I don't remember that scene at all? Do you have any idea what episode it was, or approximately where it as in the 6th season?
We did a rewatch over the summer, and really enjoyed the Battle for Ewing Oil storyline, so it will be my pleasure to go back and find that scene.

I believe it is the episode "A Ewing is a Ewing".

And that episode title tells us something. When Bobby gets down in the mud, people see him as no better than J.R. As the episode states, "A Ewing is a Ewing".

Here is the picture of Bobby at the moment he realizes what he has done:
critique-dallas-episode-119-a-ewing-is-a-ewing-2.jpg


And I don't know how to give proper credit, but I'll try.

This excerpt is from Chris Baker:

Like J.R., Bobby shows he’s also willing to use people to get what he wants. In “A Ewing is a Ewing’s” memorable final scene, Pam arrives for dinner with Bobby at an out-of-the-way restaurant, but she’s unaware the only reason he asked her out for the evening is so he can spy on Wendy and Hicks, who are drinking on the other side of the room. Bobby isn’t just using Wendy; he’s using his wife too.

I suppose I should be disappointed in Bobby, but I’m not. It’s rather satisfying to see him shed his good-guy veneer, at least for a little while. Or maybe it’s just that after everything else that goes down in this episode, seeing Bobby dabble in prostitution and blackmail doesn’t seem so bad.
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
We did a rewatch over the summer, and really enjoyed the Battle for Ewing Oil storyline, so it will be my pleasure to go back and find that scene.

I believe it is the episode "A Ewing is a Ewing".

Thank you!

And that episode title tells us something. When Bobby gets down in the mud, people see him as no better than J.R.

Yes, and it's a shame for him that they see it that way because there's a big difference between initiating dirty tactics to try to gain an unfair advantage over your competitor, and responding to dirty tactics in a way necessary for the sake of self-preservation. That's the principle that is used to distinguish between assault and self-defense. One is an unlawful initiation of force and the other is the right to protect yourself from that initiation of force. What's do people expect of Bobby - that he'll just let JR kick his ass?
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Kenny, do you or any others remember an exchange between Pam and Bobby that went something like this:

Pam: Why are you in this fight? Why not let J.R. win the contest and you can run Southfork or start your own oil company?

Bobby: Pam, if you think I can just give up on the contest that Daddy set up, then you didn't know Daddy very well. And you don't really know me, either.

Does this sound familiar? I'm looking for that scene now.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Kenny, do you or any others remember an exchange between Pam and Bobby that went something like this:

Pam: Why are you in this fight? Why not let J.R. win the contest and you can run Southfork or start your own oil company?

Bobby: Pam, if you think I can just give up on the contest that Daddy set up, then you didn't know Daddy very well. And you don't really know me, either.

Does this sound familiar? I'm looking for that scene now.

Yes, I do remember that and I think I could find it for you - I don't know how quickly I can find it -- it could be tonight or it could be few days, but I'll do my best. It's the one where he explained to Pam "You don't understand what drove Jock Ewing, and I don't think you understand what drives me either."
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Very interesting timing today! Most of you know that we started a re-watch over the summer. We're continuing the re-watch and today was the episode where the BD Calhoun and CIA scandal hit the newspapers and it definitely made me think of this thread.

Bobby and Pam are watching the news and the story comes up again.

Bobby tells Pam:

"What have we turned into? All this deception and lies. And then we moralized to try to cover everything up. It just doesn't stop. I've had it Pam. I've had it right up to my ears. I'm getting out. J.R. has disgraced the name of Ewing Oil and I stood right beside him and let him do it. I'm going to sell my shares of Ewing Oil. Every last one of them. They just don't mean anything anymore."

Echos of the discussions we are having on this board right now.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Yes! Thank you. That's the line I was looking for.

Alright @Lastkidpicked, I found the episode you're looking for. It's from season 6 episode 13 - "Mama Dearest."

Bobby: Pam, I appreciate the fact that ya sympathize with Momma, but you don't understand what this competition between JR and me is all about!

Pam: Yes I do, but how much power do you or JR have to have? As far as I'm concerned, you don't have to be president of Ewing Oil. We have more money than we can ever spend! You can be president of any company!

Bobby: That's not it. That's not it at all. Pam, you don't understand what drove Jock Ewing, and I don't think you really understand what drives me either. When I was at The University, makin' the football team just wasn't enough. I had to be varsity. I had to be captain. I had to make All-Southwest Conference, and I did, I did all of that. When you and I met, I wasn't just a road man for Ewing Oil; I was the best road man for any oil company! Because that's what Daddy expected, and that's what I expect from myself. And JR and I are a lot alike because he's not gonna take second best either. Ya see, that's why Daddy turned away from Gary: The Ewings must succeed and Gary didn't care about that, but Pam, JR and I do! Now Daddy chose that the future of Ewing Oil is gonna be in the hands of the son strong enough to run it and that's the way it's gonna be!

What an impressive scene that was! The words I put in bold print are what I consider the key phrase in this whole conversation. Bobby isn't just doing it because Jock would expect it; he's doing it because it's what he expects of himself. That's the way he has to live so that his life has meaning. Bobby enjoys a challenge and gets great satisfaction from excelling - that's what Pam doesn't understand. It's not about the money for Bobby, it's about living in his life in a way that is meaningful to him. Bobby derives satisfaction from excelling in his chosen field of work and from his achievements that are the result of competing at a very high level - whether it's football or the oil business.

It's the satisfaction Bobby gets from being able to take part in the challenge Jock gave him, the opportunity to prove he is the son most capable of running Ewing Oil that is so appealing to him! If Bobby were to back way from it and just hand over the keys to the kingdom to JR, to Bobby that would be like a forfeit. It would be admitting that he doesn't have what it takes to compete at the highest level, to concede that JR is the better man and there's no way Bobby can feel good about himself if he does that.

This is a turning point in Bobby and Pam's marriage. He's always been there for her when there was something she needed to do to live her life in a way that's meaningful to her. Now Bobby has something highly important to him and it's Pam's turn to be supportive of him as Bobby goes after what gives him satisfaction in life and makes his life meaningful. This is something Bobby needs to do if he's going to derive satisfaction from his life, much like having a child was the only thing that mattered to Pam at one point in her life. Pam now has the opportunity to reciprocate and be there for Bobby just like he has always been there for her, or she can just give up on the marriage and walk away. She's got that choice.
 
Last edited:

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
What an impressive scene that was! The words I put in bold print are what I consider the key phrase in this whole conversation. Bobby isn't just doing it because Jock would expect it; he's doing it because it's what he expects of himself. That's the way he has to live so that his life has meaning. Bobby enjoys a challenge and gets great satisfaction from excelling - that's what Pam doesn't understand. It's not about the money for Bobby, it's about living in his life in a way that is meaningful to him. Bobby derives satisfaction from excelling in his chosen field of work and from his achievements that are the result of competing at a very high level - whether it's football or the oil business.

Thank you for finding that, Kenny!

And believe it or not, we can tie this back to Cliff Barnes of all people. It wasn't the money that drove him. When he received a check for his five percent of Ewing Oil, I thought he would be thrilled. $54 million! But he wasn't happy at all. In fact, he said,

"Fifty four million dollars. Is that what my life's work has come to? I'm sorry Daddy. I let you down. You really deserved it. But I was close, really close. You don't know how close I was! No, wait a minute. I was better than close, I had it. Then they took it away, but I had it. Not a big piece, only five percent. Not even enough to repay a callous on your hand, or one drop of sweat you poured out for the Ewings."

Listening to Cliff say this with a check for $ 54 million in his pocket goes to show it really is not about the money for a lot of these people.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Thank you for finding that, Kenny!

And believe it or not, we can tie this back to Cliff Barnes of all people. It wasn't the money that drove him. When he received a check for his five percent of Ewing Oil, I thought he would be thrilled. $54 million! But he wasn't happy at all. In fact, he said,

"Fifty four million dollars. Is that what my life's work has come to? I'm sorry Daddy. I let you down. You really deserved it. But I was close, really close. You don't know how close I was! No, wait a minute. I was better than close, I had it. Then they took it away, but I had it. Not a big piece, only five percent. Not even enough to repay a callous on your hand, or one drop of sweat you poured out for the Ewings."

Listening to Cliff say this with a check for $ 54 million in his pocket goes to show it really is not about the money for a lot of these people.

Hey, that's a clever tie-in to Cliff @Lastkidpicked! Cliff wanted his share for reasons that once again weren't for the money. Cliff always told people his motive was getting what rightfully belonged to his father, and in this scene we see that that is at least one of the reasons. Still, I always felt like Cliff was also doing it out of bitterness and jealousy. Cliff was consumed in bitterness, which led to him being so self destructive. That's why Cliff couldn't ever keep a woman.

Bobby wasn't it for the money either. His motives were far more noble and this was a fascinating story, but it could have been so much better. Not only should Pam know her own husband a lot better, but take a look at this scene from later in the same episode - "Mama Dearest." Even Miss Ellie who is normally intelligent has a scene with Harv Smithfield that makes her look, well, here are the words, you decide how this makes Miss Ellie look:

Ellie: Harv, my family is very important to me. If this contest is allowed to continue, I may not have a family left.

Harv: I'm sorry Miss Ellie, those are the terms of the will. I can't change them.

Ellie: Yes, I know. That's why I want to contest the will.

Harv: I see. Well, of course that is your privilege. If you like, I could recommend a very good estate lawyer.

Ellie: Recommend? What are you talking about?

Harv: Well if you want to contest the will, you'll need a man experienced in that field.

Ellie: But aren't you experienced?

Harv: Well yes, of course, but I can't represent you.

Ellie: But you've been representing Ewing interests for as long as I can remember! What do you mean you can't represent me?

Harv: Miss Ellie, I drew up that will for Jock. It's my obligation - morally and legally - to represent that will.

Ellie: Are you telling me that if I go to court you'll fight against me?

Harv: I have no choice. (looking very pained to have to tell her that)

Ellie: (stands up) I find that very hard to believe. (abruptly turns and walks away)

Harv: (calls) Miss Ellie! (Ellie keeps walking right out the door. Pam is still there. Pam stands up and is about to follow Miss Ellie out the door.) Pamela, please try to explain to her. (Pam looks at Harv directly but says nothing. She turns and walks away)

Is it believable it would be so difficult for Miss Ellie to believe that it's Harv's job to represent the will he drew for Jock? Wouldn't you think she'd be bright enough to understand he's legally obligated to speak for Jock's right to have his will carried out? Harv was Jock's lawyer.

OK, here is Pam's next scene with Bobby after the one where he explained to her his motivations for wanting to compete against JR for the right to run Ewing Oil:

Bobby: Harv Smithfield said you were with Momma when she went to see him.

Pam: Is that why you're sitting here like some kind of ice sculpture?

Bobby: Damn it Pam, it's not a joke. Why are you takin' Momma's side against me?

Pam: I'm not against anything. I'm for what I believe is right. Miss Ellie is right.

Bobby: Pamela, you don't understand.

Pam: Bobby, we don't need all of this. Let Miss Ellie sell Ewing Oil. Spend some time with your family. Let Christopher get to know his daddy.

Bobby: Why are you doing this when I need you beside me the most? Sue Ellen's not fighting JR!

Pam: Sue Ellen and I get along fine right now but I'm not Sue Ellen. Power and money and wealth, they don't mean that much to me! I want a nice ordinary life with my husband. I love you, I love you so much.

Alright, that was just painfully bad writing. After everything Bobby has already explained to her, Pam goes right back to money and power not being important to her. Well great, but Bobby has already explained he's not doing this for the money! Bobby is a type A personality. He loves to compete. He loves to excel in whatever type of work he chooses to do. Having this chance to take the opportunity Jock gave him, to prove he can run Ewing Oil better than JR, continue the legacy his father began and then have the ability to one day hand it down to his son is tremendously important to him. This is who Bobby Ewing is. This is what drives him. How could everything he explained to Pam the last time they talked have gone completely over her head?

For Pam to suggest he give it all up and live an "ordinary" life? Right, Bobby is gonna settle for being "ordinary." That's what he's worked all his life to be - just an ordinary man. You would think Pam has never met him!

The thing is, the type of man Bobby is, is what attracts Pam to him so intensely. She is drawn to that type of highly competitive, highly competent man. Look who she ends up with after leaving Bobby. Does she look for a man who leads "a nice, ordinary life"? No, of course not! She goes right to Mark Graison - another highly driven man who lives to compete and to excel. He's another man who runs a huge oil company his father handed down to him. When he's not at work he competes in polo. He skydives. It's amazing to me that the people in charge of running the show would have conceded to allowing Pam to appear so completely oblivious. Pam's either completely oblivious or she just doesn't mean a damn word she says. Or both.
 
Last edited:

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I can see where an old country woman might not understand that Harv couldn’t represent her. Jock has always handled the business side of the family.

I agree about Pam. But I do think she didn’t like what Bobby was becoming.
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I can see where an old country woman might not understand that Harv couldn’t represent her. Jock has always handled the business side of the family.
We also need to remember that this is a generation where Jock would not have included Miss Ellie on many personal finance issues, let alone business issues.

Bobby: Why are you doing this when I need you beside me the most? Sue Ellen's not fighting JR!

And if you are doing a re-watch, Kenny, then you also have seen a great exchange between Bobby and Sue Ellen.

Sue Ellen tells Bobby that while she doesn't want to see Bobby hurt, she is loyal to J.R. and will be standing beside J.R. during the contest.

This leads Bobby to say, "I don't envy my brother very often, but today maybe I do just a little bit."

A great moment between Bobby and Sue Ellen.
 
Top