Dallas Character Bobby's Death Bed Apology

Jock's Ghost

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I agree. So many believable ways this could have been handled differently. I'm not a fan of the actor returning as a different character, but even such was a vast improvement over what they choose to do. To me it was on par with Dallas TNT ignoring the movies - which I agree weren't all that great. Or Dallas 2020 ignoring Dallas TNT (if there were such a thing).

Though I must say one of my favorite TV series endings was when Bob Newhart woke up in bed with Susanne Susan Pleshette and made one series a dream of another. But that was a comedy and it was also the end of a series.

I don't see why Bobby couldn't have been in a comma that year. Certainly it would have been a closed casket funeral (we don't know otherwise and it's plausible considering how bad his face was damaged). It's also plausible that JR had the heart monitor flatlined and then shut off only to move his brother to some place he else. His closest relatives would have been a minor son the doctors would not have consulted with and Miss Ellie and JR and Gary. Gary was not there. Miss Ellie was too distraught. JR makes the decision. No one would have believed that JR could "pull the plug" on Bobby. And JR certainly has the money to put him away somewhere to be in a coma. Instead of the shower scene, a body in a hospital bed, we look down at Bobby's face and his eyes open. We return next season to find Sue Ellen fighting for her life in emergency and Bobby struggling to speak. And JR with a whole lot of explaining to do.
Not bad. I'd rather have had something outlandish yet moderately acceptable than outright bad. The return of one guy should not have titled the show on its axis, yet it did and Katzman and Hagman are to blame. I'd much rather have had something like Bobby's car being found abandoned... they search all season. Had a Patrick said no to a return, kill him. If yes, JR to the rescue. "Not again. My Daddys gone but not my brother!"
Wendell and Katherine are behind it. Anyone of is posting here have posted good to brilliant resolutions. Z
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
Not bad. I'd rather have had something outlandish yet moderately acceptable than outright bad. The return of one guy should not have titled the show on its axis, yet it did and Katzman and Hagman are to blame. I'd much rather have had something like Bobby's car being found abandoned... they search all season. Had a Patrick said no to a return, kill him. If yes, JR to the rescue. "Not again. My Daddys gone but not my brother!"
Wendell and Katherine are behind it. Anyone of is posting here have posted good to brilliant resolutions. Z
Yes so many ways to handle it - and yet everyone mentioned here was a vast improvement to the idea they ran with.
 

Jock's Ghost

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
Just finished watching Swan song and Patrick was great. The episode was emotional in all the right spots. Kinda sad to see Lucy leave without being able to say goodbye to Bobby. Well done. I can't believe they felt they had to erase it with the unnecessary resurrection.
The follow up was equally good. BBG returns and does a noble effort to remain strong for the family. Always good to see Ted as Gary return.
The one that affected me the most with his pain is JR. He lashes out at everyone, Sue Ellen, mostly.
The most cutting was his exchange with Ray and Gary who offered their support and he tells them they areng worthy and as far as hes concerned he's an only child.
His best scene was with John Ross, lying down with him until he fell asleep telling him he had a bad day...... Victoria was excellent in both episodes. I love the lead up scenes when bobby asked her to marry him again.
Its just so frustrating and annoying that all of is undone for no good reason.
 
Last edited:

Jock's Ghost

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
bobby in a coma would have worked so much better. Duffy returns, no big deal. Then when Victoria leaves the next season, shes in a car crash, burned but alive and recast as Margret Michaels. There, saved the series.... we rock!
Imagine Bobby wakes up and he cant talk and has to relearn everything just in time to marry Pam.
The coma would have benefitted JRs storyline as he works to gain total control. Bobby not dead, but incapacitated with Donna watching over things until a permanent solution is reached. JR would scheme to keep her out of the Power of Attorney. Imagine if things were in limbo, JRs hands tied. Scheming off the charts.....damn fools.
 
Last edited:

stevew

Telly Talk Star
Just finished watching Swan song and Patrick was great. The episode was emotional in all the right spots. Kinda sad to see Lucy leave without being able to say goodbye to Bobby. Well done. I can't believe they felt they had to erase it with the unnecessary resurrection.
The follow up was equally good. BBG returns and does a noble effort to remain strong for the family. Always good to see Ted as Gary return.
The one that affected me the most with his pain is JR. He lashes out at everyone, Sue Ellen, mostly.
The most cutting was his exchange with Ray and Gary who offered their support and he tells them they areng worthy and as far as hes concerned he's an only child.
His best scene was with John Ross, lying down with him until he fell asleep telling him he had a bad day...... Victoria was excellent in both episodes. I love the lead up scenes when bobby asked her to marry him again.
Its just so frustrating and annoying that all of is undone for no good reason.
I agree, in fact in the season which followed my only issue is that in the fight with Sue Ellen I would have addressed their insecurities about each other - him only marrying her because oh who she was and her only marrying him because of who is was, not really loving each other. I think it would have been amazing to see once they reach that low, somehow they find the way to pull themselves together to be the patriarch and matriarch of the next generation so that subsequent seasons have almost a history repeating itself kind of feel where JR lives up to being his daddy and other characters take on a bigger role in carrying the show.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
bobby in a coma would have worked so much better. Duffy returns, no big deal. Then when Victoria leaves the next season, shes in a car crash, burned but alive and recast as Margret Michaels. There, saved the series.... we rock!
Imagine Bobby wakes up and he cant talk and has to relearn everything just in time to marry Pam.
The coma would have benefitted JRs storyline as he works to gain total control. Bobby not dead, but incapacitated with Donna watching over things until a permanent solution is reached. JR would scheme to keep her out of the Power of Attorney. Imagine if things were in limbo, JRs hands tied. Scheming off the charts.....damn fools.
I like it. Yes not just a "I'm awake now" but Bobby having to struggle to talk and walk and live again. At the same time Sue Ellen having survived the explosion could be living the same nightmare to regain her life. JR having to face on all fronts control of his company and to care for two of the very few people he loves in this world. Imagine Miss Ellie with another cancer scare and John Ross getting ill - JR would be against the wall.
 

Seaviewer

Telly Talk Warrior
not just a "I'm awake now" but Bobby having to struggle to talk and walk and live again.
Yes, that part's good, but I still don't see why any of it needed to be a dream. Bobby was in a coma - the reason it was kept secret is just a detail - and life went on without him as we saw it.
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
The writing in Swan Song, and the episodes leading up to it are amazing. Here's the best part:

During the original run, before the internet, Soapchat, and Tellytalk, we had no idea that Bobby was going to be hit by a car until it actually happened. It was like a punch to the gut!

So, rewatching it knowing what will happen can't be as good, can it?

It sure can!

Knowing what is coming makes the episodes leading up to Swan Song and then that episode itself even more riveting. Watching these characters thinking everything is getting better and better, while we know what is going to happen.

Even better watching the second (or third or fourth) time around!
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
The one that affected me the most with his pain is JR. He lashes out at everyone, Sue Ellen, mostly.
The season following Bobby's death was the one I anxiously waited for and the returning episode didn't disappoint. I'm not sure who decided to keep Sue Ellen (Linda Gray) out of that hospital scene but there was some forward thinking brilliance happening behind the scenes. Some creative writer had thoughts of the opening scene with JR, Clayton, Miss Ellie (the rightful one) and a happily - I've been on a shopping spree - Sue Ellen returning to Southfork not knowing the hell she was about to confront.

The season without Bobby should have focused heavily on JR, lashing out at everyone and everything.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
The season following Bobby's death was the one I anxiously waited for and the returning episode didn't disappoint. I'm not sure who decided to keep Sue Ellen (Linda Gray) out of that hospital scene but there was some forward thinking brilliance happening behind the scenes. Some creative writer had thoughts of the opening scene with JR, Clayton, Miss Ellie (the rightful one) and a happily - I've been on a shopping spree - Sue Ellen returning to Southfork not knowing the hell she was about to confront.

The season without Bobby should have focused heavily on JR, lashing out at everyone and everything.
I agree as long as there was character development and JR ended the season not destroyed with Sue Ellen locked away, but on top of the world, a new world order for the Ewing’s and an equally dramatic season finally.
 

DallasFanForever

Telly Talk Supreme
I’ve always said if you locked me in a room with a pen long enough I guarantee you I would’ve thought of a better way than what they did to bring Bobby back on the show. Making it a dream would’ve been my last resort. Him dying on camera makes no difference to me. It was 80s soap opera. There would’ve been backlash no matter what was done but the dream resolution turned a lot of fans off for good.
 

Grangehill1

Telly Talk Fan
The writing in Swan Song, and the episodes leading up to it are amazing. Here's the best part:

During the original run, before the internet, Soapchat, and Tellytalk, we had no idea that Bobby was going to be hit by a car until it actually happened. It was like a punch to the gut!

So, rewatching it knowing what will happen can't be as good, can it?

It sure can!

Knowing what is coming makes the episodes leading up to Swan Song and then that episode itself even more riveting. Watching these characters thinking everything is getting better and better, while we know what is going to happen.

Even better watching the second (or third or fourth) time around!
We did know. Back in 85 it was well publicised Patrick was leaving, it was also well known in advance he’d be killed saving Pam and that Katherine would be driving the car. None of it was a surprise. It was all over the newspapers.

What was a surprise was how well it was structured and shot.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
In my opinion they should of declined PD’s return before they created the dream season. Of course I’ve also said they should have given him a spin off before they let him go too. And if LH said he wouldn’t stay if PD didn’t come back, I’d have said good by to him too. He was very good at JR Ewing but there are plenty of very good actors on Hollywood and before I killed the show I would have found one. If the show died because LH left too better it die from someone else’s action then mine. And the dream season on my opinion was the beginning of the end. It could have lasted longer, even as adult soaps waned because with such a great cast and epic story their was plenty of room to navigate as long as they continued to tell a good story. The dream season was good, what followed proved they’d given up on good, or at least were in the beginning stages of such.
 

Ukdallasfan

Telly Talk Fan
I agree that the dream season was good. Donna and Ray had their most powerful storyline, their baby having Down’s Syndrome, and their acting was top notch. Same with Sue Ellen- she had a proper story arc and Linda was firmly in her stride acting the character. Then, all ruined because Patrick changed his mind. Don’t get me wrong, I loved the character of Bobby and Patrick was perfect for the role but he thought A List movie work beckoned and he made a bad bet there. Despite the bluster Larry would not have left if Patrick had not been permitted to return. He was earning big money and was a global superstar and wouldn’t have risked giving all that up even for his best friend :)
 

Sarah

Moderator Emerita
Linda’s acting in the dream season was just terrific!! Watching her character hit absolute bottom then watching her morph into such a strong woman by seasons end was amazing!! One of the first things I think of when I think of the dream season is Linda. To me she is one of the actors that holds this season together.

She's incredible. I was so upset when it turned out to be a dream.
 

Jock's Ghost

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I’ve always said if you locked me in a room with a pen long enough I guarantee you I would’ve thought of a better way than what they did to bring Bobby back on the show. Making it a dream would’ve been my last resort. Him dying on camera makes no difference to me. It was 80s soap opera. There would’ve been backlash no matter what was done but the dream resolution turned a lot of fans off for good.
There was a story in People Magazine that resolved bobbys death 3 ways. One of them was a mixture of two with an imposter returning. It was too lame and Dynasty like.
The other, better solution was similar to what we discussed in this thread. As Bobby is wheeled to the morgue his eyes his flicker, he's spirited away to some remote far away hospital to recover. Slightly absurd, but not insulting.
 
Last edited:

Jock's Ghost

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
they should have just told Larry to cool his tits and get a grip, "We just killed Bobby off, he's not coming back", He was on a money train and would not have left no matter what he said or did.

And the show lost something with Linda and Victoria, gone. I'm in Dream season episode 3 and so far so good. Mark has returned.... the season finale, we think Bobby is dead, but the opener has him revived, comatose. Mark returns, but is soon discovered to be dying, 6 weeks to live. Pam marries Mark, they have a brief, but wonderful times together- season finale- Mark dies and Bobby wakes up! Boom. why is that not better than a damn dream that impacts and shits on everyone else? ALL of that for ONE character.... Shame on them.
 
Last edited:

stevew

Telly Talk Star
they should have just told Larry to cool his tits and get a grip, "We just killed Bobby off, he's not coming back", He was on a money train and would not have left no matter what he said or did.

And the show lost something with Linda and Victoria, gone. I'm in Dream season episode 3 and so far so good. Mark has returned.... the season finale, we think Bobby is dead, but the opener has him revived, comatose. Mark returns, but is soon discovered to be dying, 6 weeks to live. Pam marries Mark, they have a brief, but wonderful times together- season finale- Mark dies and Bobby wakes up! Boom. why is that not better than a damn dream that impacts and shits on everyone else? ALL of that for ONE character.... Shame on them.
I agree “shame on them” and it’s true. While “Who Shot JR” and the early years took Dallas to the very top of awe when it comes to tv, turning around in the shower wiped that all out for some (not me) and left a stain which not only lead to the decline of the show but the ridicule.

Instead PD provided an opportunity that they missed with BBG - grow the story and the characters so that people continue to watch because it’s ever evolving and leading into new territory.
 
Top