Cast culls

Grangehill1

Telly Talk Fan
Aside from the end of season 8 when the show lost Bobby and Lucy, I think there were three other cast culls during the shows run through caused more damage

Beginning of season 7 - in the space of a few episodes we lost the original Miss Ellie, Mark, Katherine and Afton.

End of season 10 - we lost Pam, Donna, Mandy and earlier Jack and Jamie

End of season 13 - Miss Ellie, Lucy, Clayton as a regular and we were about to lose April

I remember at the time really feeling the loss of Katherine and Mark etc at beginning of season 8. All of a sudden Pam and Cliffs family and partners had all gone. And I think that’s partly responsible for the sluggish feel of season 8.

what does everyone think. What culls caused the most damage?

season 11 was terrible so maybe losing Pam and Donna en masse didn’t help
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
I remember at the time really feeling the loss of Katherine and Mark etc at beginning of season 8. All of a sudden Pam and Cliffs family and partners had all gone.
I cannot recall my thoughts when Dallas first aired however whenever I do a re-watch of the series I enjoy the second power base beginning to blossom with Pam, Mark, Cliff, Afton and that meddling half-sister, Katherine. We witness this power shift between the two warring families as the Ewing family is slowly left to disintegrate. I was excited to see where this story would take us but between this season and the next it was like someone ripped up the scripts.
 

Monzo

Telly Talk Star
I remember at the time really feeling the loss of Katherine and Mark etc at beginning of season 8. All of a sudden Pam and Cliffs family and partners had all gone. And I think that’s partly responsible for the sluggish feel of season 8.
With me it's just the opposite: It was smart to let Mark and Katherine go because they would have become useless if they had stayed. Until they decided to keep Jenna Dallas had a great timing when it comes to lettting go of supporting characters so that they won't overstay their welcome.

Losing Pam & Donna at once was biggest damage to me. I guess April wouldn't have become such a big character if both hadn't leave and if Jenna didn't quit a year later, too. They might have written April out at the end of season 11 if there were still enough female veterans.
 
VP leaving did the biggest damage to the show as the character of Pam was central to so many stories, she was the most important female member of the cast

the lynch pin to
Barnes V Ewing, Bobby V his family, the back history of Digger V Jock, Digger and Ellie, Pam V Cliff

Susan Howard leaving was sad as she was one of the best actresses on Dallas and breaking up with Ray and moving to Washington was what Donna may have done, but its was 3 seasons too early for me

They might have written April out at the end of season 11

oh if only that were true, end of S9 original would have been better!
 

DallasFanForever

Telly Talk Supreme
Tough question cause I think so many departures hurt the show long term and overall but I would definitely have to go with Pam and Donna leaving after season 9. Two of the core family characters leaving at once really hurt. The loss of Sue Ellen after season 11 was also an immense one that the show did not recover from, as well as Miss Ellie and Clayton after season 12. I know he came back for a few scenes but I’m not counting the final season. But even the loss of those three characters didn’t hurt the show as much as Pam and Donna leaving at the time imo because they left when the show was still very good. By the time Sue Ellen, Miss Ellie and Clayton departed the show it was already on its last leg
 

Miss Texas 1967

Telly Talk Addict
With me it's just the opposite: It was smart to let Mark and Katherine go because they would have become useless if they had stayed. Until they decided to keep Jenna Dallas had a great timing when it comes to lettting go of supporting characters so that they won't overstay their welcome.

Losing Pam & Donna at once was biggest damage to me. I guess April wouldn't have become such a big character if both hadn't leave and if Jenna didn't quit a year later, too. They might have written April out at the end of season 11 if there were still enough female veterans.
They truly didn't seem to know what to do with Jenna after the Bobby breakup. Does anyone know if Priscilla and Shalane had contracts that had been agreed upon before the storyline was decided? They stuck around longer than necessary. We didn't keep following Dusty or Mandy after their similar relationships tying them to the main cast ended.
On the other side I would have liked to have seen Morgan Brittany back for a few more episodes when she reprised her role as Katherine after Pam disappeared. She appears and then goes and it's all very mysterious and then enough time passes that Bobby just forgets about it.
I'd have liked to have seen Donna at least mentioned a bit more after she left town too, she had a direct tie to a character who was still on the show.
 

Monzo

Telly Talk Star
I would have liked to have seen Morgan Brittany back for a few more episodes when she reprised her role as Katherine after Pam disappeared. She appears and then goes and it's all very mysterious and then enough time passes that Bobby just forgets about it.
Her return was a great OMG moment, but i don't think there was any chance for Katherine on the show. They didn't even know to do with likeable returnees Lucy and Afton, but a real closing scene for Katherine to know that she's gone from the show would have been nice.

I still wonder if producers were 100 percent sure Victoria Principal would quit after this season, had they written Donna out, same with Mandy. They could have extended Mandy's family the way the did with April later. Mandy could have had a handsome younger brother who fell in love with Sue Ellen like Nicholas did next season but without all that mob stuff. JR would have been mad if Sue Ellen would get involved with Mandy's brother.
 

Sarah

Moderator Emerita
Her return was a great OMG moment, but i don't think there was any chance for Katherine on the show. They didn't even know to do with likeable returnees Lucy and Afton, but a real closing scene for Katherine to know that she's gone from the show would have been nice.

I still wonder if producers were 100 percent sure Victoria Principal would quit after this season, had they written Donna out, same with Mandy. They could have extended Mandy's family the way the did with April later. Mandy could have had a handsome younger brother who fell in love with Sue Ellen like Nicholas did next season but without all that mob stuff. JR would have been mad if Sue Ellen would get involved with Mandy's brother.
Yeah he wouldn’t have been the only one. :hair:
 

Sarah

Moderator Emerita
In my opinion, Pam was nowhere near as big a loss in comparison to Sue Ellen. The loss of Sue Ellen was massive, and JR’s character was destroyed as a result. By this stage they had been the more interesting and central characters for a long time.

That said, the losses of all major and original women was a huge blow. Donna wasn’t that big a deal in relation to Sue ElIen, Miss Ellie or Pam and I couldn’t give two hoots about developing characters such as Nicholas or the horrid Mandy.

Better storylines were needed for the original cast that we loved. Perhaps then they would have stayed. :cry: Man I wish this forum had existed back then!

We could have got them to listen to us and written better stories from Season 10 onwards!!!
 
Principal’s departure was by far the most damaging - more so even than Duffy’s.

oh absolutely, I loved Pat D in Dallas (back then) but strangely I didnt really miss him during dream season, I think the fact that BBG was back more than made up for it and I actually liked Pam and Mark.

Victoria - after Larry - was the most important actor/actress on the show and it suffered in so many ways when she left. I think a lot of people never thought she would do it, and when she left, she left!!! It was a huge nail in the coffin.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
It was smart to let Mark and Katherine go
Perhaps Katherine because the writers penned her in with her attempts at killing Bobby however I would have liked to see Mark stick around. JR had caused enough problems meddling in the relationship between Bobby and Pam and well his dream of permanently splitting them up worked with the assistance of Katherine. What JR failed to foresee was his creation of another power block; Cliff, Afton, Pam and Mark. I wanted the writers to explore this further and see where it would take us. I wished the character of Mark was explored in the business world rather than creating this playboy lifestyle. Okay it looked good on camera with his flashy cars and polo matches and the actor certainly looked the part but I think Mark was more than a match for Bobby...and JR.

It would have been great to see Mark beat the Ewing boys at their own game by winning some huge oil deal. JR has now come to the realization breaking up Pam and Bobby has caused more harm then good and decides to manipulate the situation in getting Pam and Bobby back together. Of course neither Bobby or Pam are aware of this but that's what made Dallas so fascinating when the writers offered us viewers an inside look what JR was going to get up to next.
 
Top