Clayton - Too Bland To Fit Into Dallas

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
Surely among the many risks (asking Sue Ellen to marry him, protecting her from JR at Southern Cross, standing up to Parmalee, taking Dusty on as his son), the biggest ever risk Clayton took, was marrying into a family where he knew he wasn’t exactly welcome, and stepping into the shoes of a hugely revered father figure?

He shouldn't have said anything to Wes Parmalee, it wasn't his place to do so!

And when he said about disrupting his family, that was a right laugh as JR normally took great delight in referring to him as an outsider. Which to be honest, he was!

On this occasion he went too far, especially when he threatened to track Wes down & kill him! If anything bad had happened to Wes, Clayton would've been the prime suspect. :)
 

Chris2

Telly Talk Dream Maker
That empty threat to track down that “charlatan” Wes Parmesan was just another example of how toothless Clayton was.
 

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
That empty threat to track down that “charlatan” Wes Parmesan was just another example of how toothless Clayton was.

Exactly! I think he was afraid of Wes actually being Jock which would've made Miss Ellie drop him quicker than a barbecued sausage!

Miss Ellie would've given anything to be re-united with Jock. :)
 

Jock's Ghost

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
ZZZZZZZZZzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz. Worthless. Might as well put a cowboy hat and mustache on Lucy as that's what he became. I stuck with Lucy for many years since she WAS one of the core characters, but slowly drifted into mediocrity.

Clayton was excellent as JR's foe and should have stayed that way. When JR is stealing his oil and sitting on all the barrels and making huge deals, THAT is the JR we love and Clayton is a savvy opponent.

If I had my druthers, I'd have left Dusty dead. Sue Ellen marries Clayton, she continues drinking. Clayton drops dead of a heart attack during a battle with JR. SE inherits his fortune and slowly loses it through her drinking and JR's scheming to get John Ross back. No coming back later shitting up the show with boring, pointless story-lines no one, NO ONE watches now.
 

Chris2

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I like that. Or SE inherits his fortune, stops drinking, and becomes the Ewings’ new primary adversary on the show.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
He shouldn't have said anything to Wes Parmalee, it wasn't his place to do so!

And when he said about disrupting his family, that was a right laugh as JR normally took great delight in referring to him as an outsider. Which to be honest, he was!

On this occasion he went too far, especially when he threatened to track Wes down & kill him! If anything bad had happened to Wes, Clayton would've been the prime suspect. :)

How do you figure it wasn’t his place? He was married to a Ellie.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
On this occasion he went too far, especially when he threatened to track Wes down & kill him! If anything bad had happened to Wes, Clayton would've been the prime suspect. :)

Going too far? What would you do if a con man tried to do that to your wife, to your marriage? Just give him a free pass?
 

Pound68

Telly Talk Member
I liked Clayton too and I think Howard Keel was as good a choice as they could have made as long as Miss Ellie was going to get married again. I think he could have been a more vital part of the show if they hadn't tried to play it so safe in the way they wrote the character. Here's an example what I'm trying to describe:

When Clayton wanted to talk about where to live, Ellie acted surprised as if: You're suggesting we should do anything other than have you sell you ranch, leave your business, your town with your friends, so you can move into my ranch, into the house my ex-husband built, to live with adult children?

Yeah, why would that be unreasonable? Ellie makes no sacrifices and Clayton makes all the sacrifices, which apparently to her is reasonable. She's just so out of it! She's oblivious to anything that doesn't involve her desires, while never trying to see anything from Clayton's perspective. I lost some respect for Clayton when he caved in to all her demands.

It's hard for a character to be exciting when he's so agreeable.

I do think he gave up too much. It makes no sense that he just sold The Southern Cross. Dusty can't be on the rodeo circuit forever, won't he want the family ranch? They had helicopters, he could easily fly down to check on things. He should have maintained that property
 

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
How do you figure it wasn’t his place? He was married to a Ellie.

He may have been married to Miss Ellie but it still wasn't his place to interfere. I think he felt threatened by the possibility that Wes was indeed Jock Ewing as borne out by his reaction to Jock's portrait at Southfork a few seasons earlier.

Going too far? What would you do if a con man tried to do that to your wife, to your marriage? Just give him a free pass?

No, I'd sell tickets! Who want's her!!? :innocent:

Seriously though, Wes wasn't a con man, the intention of the writers & Producers was for the character to actually be revealed as Jock.

However because of the backlash they backtracked & wrote the character off as an imposter.

Clayton did do the noble thing & left Southfork to allow Ellie to come to terms with the situation.

Reneging on the original outcome of the storyline & dropping Wes Parmalee/Jock Ewing recast allowed Clayton to get back together with Ellie so no real harm was done to them at all. It just made Steve Forrest's exit rather abrupt & ambiguous with a storyline which although promising unfortunately went nowhere with no proper resolution. :(
 
Top