Dallas Aftershow: 41st Anniversary of Who Shot JR!

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
One thing James mentioned that we don't talk about enough:
It's the brilliant set up that made the Who Shot J.R. storyline so compelling. One by one, J.R. ruins people's lives. One by one those people swear revenge on him.

It was great fun that summer for each of us to talk about who we thought pulled the trigger.

You could go to Las Vegas and bet on who shot J.R. They even had professional gamblers setting the odds:

Dusty Farlow 2:1 odds
Cliff Barnes 3:1 odds
Kristin Shepard 4:1 odds
Vaghn Leland 4:1 odds
Alan Beam 6:1 odds
Marilee Stone 8:1 odds
Sue Ellen 25:1 odds

Remember that they doled out the evidence over several episodes the following season, so the odds changed. When they found Sue Ellen's fingerprints on the gun, she became the 2:1 favorite by odds makers.
 
Last edited:

DallasFanForever

Telly Talk Supreme
Interesting that Dusty was the original odds on favorite as being the one who pulled the trigger! I never realized this.
 

darkshadows38

Telly Talk Star
i was 2 years old when this aired so don't remember anything that was going let alone on tv in (1980) now (1981) i do remember some of but (1980)

the 1st i heard of this i had no idea it even copied it at all was in Season 6 of the Simpsons i think? and they did the Who Shot Mr. Burns ? storyline and they i think had a contest if recall and i think they did the same thing where they drew different people doing it but it was Maggie that's my favorite thing the simpsons ever did the show back than was Brilliant it's so not that way now sadly and there's now no joke 700 episodes now of it! i was 11 years when it started i'm 42 now
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Interesting that Dusty was the original odds on favorite as being the one who pulled the trigger! I never realized this.

I can’t believe Dusty Farlow’s odds was that high.

As a guy who spends a lot of time in Vegas, I can tell you why Dusty Farlow was high on the oddsmaker's lists.

It couldn't be a main character who shot J.R. because the writers wouldn't send a main character off to jail. In other words, it couldn't be Sue Ellen because she is too important to the show.

A secondary character, such as Dusty, could go off to jail and the show would continue just fine.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
As a guy who spends a lot of time in Vegas, I can tell you why Dusty Farlow was high on the oddsmaker's lists.

It couldn't be a main character who shot J.R. because the writers wouldn't send a main character off to jail. In other words, it couldn't be Sue Ellen because she is too important to the show.

A secondary character, such as Dusty, could go off to jail and the show would continue just fine.

I hear what you’re saying and that definitely makes sense, but they had his odds over Leland, Merilee, Beam and Kristen? Did they think Dusty was in THAT much love with Sue Ellen that he’d kill JR?
 

Jabari Lamar

Telly Talk Fan
Interesting that Dusty was the original odds on favorite as being the one who pulled the trigger! I never realized this.
Me neither (although James is my brother, I did not start watching Dallas with him until several years later, I was still a bit too young at this time), but looking back, it makes, at least at the time. As a rival for Sue Ellen's affections, he had been built up enough as a significant character but not indispensable. Someone like Alan or Vaugh would have almost been a cop-out, but Cliff or Sue Ellen were too big to lose. So I get it.

Of course, in hindsight, if it had been him then obviously Clayton's further involvement on the show would have not developed as it did, so it's for the best that it wasn't Dusty.
 

Jabari Lamar

Telly Talk Fan
wasn’t Dusty still in recently-revived, wheelchair-bound form at the time? It would have been a hell of an achievement to somehow get to the Ewing Building, get to the elevators and roll on into the office, sneak up on JR, and pull out a gun and shoot him
He could have been faking it, precisely to through everyone off his trail. That certainly would have been a good "soapy" type of reveal, when we suddenly see his jump to his feet, able to stand perfectly.
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
asn’t Dusty still in recently-revived, wheelchair-bound form at the time? It would have been a hell of an achievement to somehow get to the Ewing Building, get to the elevators and roll on into the office, sneak up on JR, and pull out a gun and shoot him
Reminds me of J.R.'s line to Sue Ellen:

"Maybe your boyfriend can rescue you in one mighty hobble."
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
For any of you who were around for the original run, this discussion is EXACTLY what we all talked about every day that summer. It was great!

Some people saying it HAD to be Vaughn Leland. Others saying it couldn't possibly be Alan Beam. Everybody had their own ideas and it was great fun over the summer to argue discuss with everybody!
 
Last edited:

Jabari Lamar

Telly Talk Fan
For any of you who were around for the original run, this discussion is EXACTLY what we all talked about every day that summer. It was great!
It does sounds like it would have been a fun time for fans, I've often wished I was older and tuned into that whole thing at the time.

Question: How was the reveal received? Did Kristin seems like a good choice, were fans satisfied with that answer?
 

Ukdallasfan

Telly Talk Fan
I remember that summer really well and it was great! People were wearing Who Shot JR T- shirts and pretty much everyone had an opinion as to who did it. I seem to recall that many of my family and friends said it had to be Kristen. The arrival of the film reels with season four was even featured on the BBC national news. It was so exciting. Not many around me said it had to be Sue Ellen- too obvious I think. After Kristen, the money seemed to be on Cliff or Alan Beam. Good memories :)
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Question: How was the reveal received? Did Kristin seems like a good choice, were fans satisfied with that answer?

I remember that summer really well and it was great! People were wearing Who Shot JR T- shirts and pretty much everyone had an opinion as to who did it. I seem to recall that many of my family and friends said it had to be Kristen.

I remember going to Dallas parties to watch for the reveal. What was well received was that J.R.'s shooter couldn't be brought to justice because she was carrying J.R.'s child. What a twist!
 

Jabari Lamar

Telly Talk Fan
What was well received was that J.R.'s shooter couldn't be brought to justice because she was carrying J.R.'s child. What a twist!
That’s interesting. On the one hand, while it obviously worked out in the way it lead to the addition of Christopher to the show, with some good storylines along the way, I have to say that in retrospect the way Kristin was handled post-confessions seems pretty lame. All that and there’s no trial or anything? She just gets away with it? And how dumb were the rest of the family to really believe the story she and J.R. concocted, that she was obsessed with him and chased after him but he rejected her and that’s why she shot him and now J.R. just wanted to forgive and forget the whole thing? In particular ,would Jock and Miss Ellie really be just fine with letting the woman who almost murdered their son go free? I feel like there had to have been a better way to handle that.
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
All that and there’s no trial or anything? She just gets away with it? And how dumb were the rest of the family to really believe the story she and J.R. concocted, that she was obsessed with him and chased after him but he rejected her and that’s why she shot him and now J.R. just wanted to forgive and forget the whole thing? In particular ,would Jock and Miss Ellie really be just fine with letting the woman who almost murdered their son go free?

You make great points here, Jabari. What was great about Dallas is that it hinted at the power of J.R. Ewing without explicitly saying it. For example:

How dumb were the rest of the family to really believe the story she and J.R. concocted, that she was obsessed with him and chased after him but he rejected her.


It's not that the family was dumb. It's that Jock in particular had past dalliances with the ladies and knew there was more to the story than J.R. was letting on. And Miss Ellie knew J.R. only too well. The both of them knew it was better to let sleeping dogs lie than to have J.R.'s misdeeds aired in public.

All that and there’s no trial or anything? She just gets away with it?

Again, the power of J.R. Ewing. He had the wealth and power to sweep an attempted murder under the rug.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
You make great points here, Jabari. What was great about Dallas is that it hinted at the power of J.R. Ewing without explicitly saying it. For example:

How dumb were the rest of the family to really believe the story she and J.R. concocted, that she was obsessed with him and chased after him but he rejected her.


It's not that the family was dumb. It's that Jock in particular had past dalliances with the ladies and knew there was more to the story than J.R. was letting on. And Miss Ellie knew J.R. only too well. The both of them knew it was better to let sleeping dogs lie than to have J.R.'s misdeeds aired in public.

All that and there’s no trial or anything? She just gets away with it?

Again, the power of J.R. Ewing. He had the wealth and power to sweep an attempted murder under the rug.

I respectfully disagree with you on that. You might want to believe that, but that’s not how it was played out on the show. Later on, Jock even told Miss Ellie that he believed Kristen should have went to jail and why would a pretty girl like her want a married man?

Miss Ellie and Jock knew JR, but they were incredibly naive at times when it came to him.
 
Last edited:

Jabari Lamar

Telly Talk Fan
What I’m saying is that I guess it worked out in the long-run, because of the stories that spun out of the reveal of Kristin, most notably the whole story of Christopher, but I think if I’d been watching the show at the time I would have been a little disappointed and considered it a bit of a cop-out that Kristin wasn’t arrested and jailed (or maybe killed herself to avoid prison). But it is what it is.



It's like how I said Dusty would have made a great choice as the shooter, and that would have likely satisfied me at the time, but in retrospect it’s better that he wasn’t as that would have deprived us of continued stories with him and Sue Ellen, the eventually addition of Clayton to the family, the drama over his mother, all the way up to his dramatic guest-appearance in the second-to-last episode of the series when he showed up to help screw J.R. out of taking over Westar.
 
Top