I love the
Soaps & Serials books. They do more or less go by what was seen on the screen but with adding a few more details.
I like the Laura Van Wormer books but they can't be taken as Canon since some of the details doesn't add up. For instance in the Dallas book she claims that Gary was born before Jock left for the war, which would be around 1942 or 1943. But in the Knots Landing book she states that Gary's birth year was 1945. So some things doesn't add up!
I completely dismiss the Raintree book as a piece of fiction that didn't have much to do with the show. I mean Lucy was not JR's daughter!
I think that book was a piece of Fanon at best.
Which brings me to the original question. I am familiar with the expression
Canon before as it was used in the fanculture books that I read while studying media and communication/film studies at the University in the first decade of the 2000s. But I have not kept up with the literature since I completed my master thesis in 2014 so I have never heard of the expressions
Fanon and
Headcanon before. So is headcanon similar to an alternative universe?
Then as for Dallas. I consider everything that happened on Dallas (1978-1991) and everything that happened on Knots Landing to be canon, with the exception of that Bobby never died on Knots Landing either. I dismiss that detail since Bobby is alive in the Dallas universe and although Knots never went back on that he died and there is a separation between the shows at that point, I need Bobby to be alive there too to be able to have the characters interact with each other in a Dallas fanfic I'm writing:
http://www.soapchat.net/threads/dallas-in-the-90s.596/
I consider that fanfic to be an alternative universe of what happened after both shows went off the air. It's set in 1995 so the reunion movies or Knots mini-series reunion are not a part of it's canon. But everything that happened on the shows are except for the dream season and that Bobby never died on Knots Landing either. I guess you can call it a
headcanon since in my head it's what really happened after the shows went off the air. But I prefer the term alternative universe.
Because of this I consider Dallas TNT (2012-2014) to be an other alternative universe that is a bit separate from the original Dallas. The show is still Dallas and I guess it's the official continuation of what happened to the Ewings after Dallas went off the air. But since it has not stayed true to everything that happened on the original Dallas and changed a lot of details I prefer to think of it as an alternative universe. It is still Dallas. But it's a darker version of Dallas than the original show. Naturally since that also ended on a bad note I wrote another fanfic last year to tie up the lose ends. So for that story everything that happened on Dallas TNT is canon (+ most stuff that happened on the original show):
http://www.soapchat.net/threads/dallas-tnt-forgiveness.8581/
But if there are stuff from the original show and Dallas TNT that doesn't match, Dallas TNT's version is what goes. So well I guess you can call this another piece of
headcanon...
Then as for
Fanon. I guess JR having an illegimate daughter has become Fanon. It was established on Dallas TNT and most fans have accepted it as being true even though we never met the girl. The idea of the daughter is also used in lots of fanfics that picks up after Dallas TNT. Although the idea was actually used already in the Return to Southfork fanfic that was written in the 1990s where JR had a daughter with Mandy that was called Jillian. So I guess some could argue that the idea of JR's daughter was actually borrowed from fanfics by Dallas TNT. But for that arguement to hold the writers on Dallas TNT would have had to have read RTS and I don't think they ever did. But yeah it's an interesting thought!
But well to answer your main question, to me
Knots Landing and
Dallas belongs to the same universe and if I were to dismiss my Dallas fanfic as what really happened after the shows went off the air I would include the original shows and their reunion movies in the same universe too. But dismiss Dallas TNT.
I guess technically Dallas and Dallas TNT could also be seen as a part of the same universe. But I think Dallas TNT was too contradictory to be a true continuation of the original story.
Just my two cents. Thanks for bringing up this interesting topic for discussion
@Mel O'Drama 