Dallas Let JR And Sue Ellen's Marriage Go On Far Too Long

When Would You Have Liked To See JR And Sue Ellen Decide To Divorce For Good?

  • Season nine after JR cheats on Sue Ellen with Mandy

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Season ten after JR cheats on Sue Ellen with Mandy

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    8
  • Poll closed .

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
In the early years of Dallas, there were some great scenes with JR and Sue Ellen that clearly added to the value of the show. We didn't know if JR and Sue Ellen were going to be able to fix their marriage or not. There were fiery, emotional scenes between Sue Ellen and JR. There were also times when JR and Sue Ellen were on very good terms and it looked as if they maybe had found a way to make their marriage work. Maybe JR was done cheating on Sue Ellen and maybe Sue had summoned the will to overcome her excessive drinking.

Inevitably, the happy times would backslide into profound unhappiness once again and we would witness more of the same animosity between JR and Sue Ellen was we had already seen done before, and in my opinion, done better. How many times can you watch a couple decide that this is the last straw, the marriage is irreparably damaged and they're going to get a divorce? Once? Twice? Three times? Four times? When does it get to the point where seeing more of the same gets to be too much of the same type of content and you decide you'd really like to see something new and fresh instead?

In season six they were on good terms until Sue Ellen found her husband in bed with Holly Harwood. They'd been divorced , gotten remarried and then this happens. I'd like to think that any reasonably bright woman would, at that point, say to herself: "I've done everything I possibly can to make this marriage work and it just does not work"!

Then season seven comes and JR tries to be a good husband but Sue Ellen won't let him. She's not even sleeping in the same bedroom as her husband, and she calls that a marriage? I guess there's no accounting for how little some people will settle for! In a demeaning storyline for the character, Sue Ellen cheats on JR with a boy who is young enough to be her son and apparently wears clothes that are approximately the same size clothes her son wears! It wasn't exactly a high point for Sue. Finally, by the end of season seven Sue Ellen has seen the mistake she made in romancing a schoolboy and is finally back in bed with JR.

This could have been the beginning of a marriage where the two people involved did what was necessary to make it work, but that's not what happened. We saw JR and Sue Ellen continue to fight, to try to hurt each other, we saw Sue Ellen go back to drowning herself in vodka, and it just went on an on, through season eight, through season nine and season ten. In my opinion that's just too much of the same thing! I don't enjoy watching a man and a woman both miserable and both trying to make each other miserable.

Is watching a couple in abject misery your idea of quality entertainment? It's not mine. I think JR and Sue Ellen's marriage contributed to some classic Dallas moments and it certainly served its purpose but at some point, enough is enough! If you're like me and you get tired of seeing a husband and wife trying to hurt each other in season after season, their marriage went on far too long. It was ugly to watch a man and a woman inflict cruelty on each other, year after year, just for the sake of trying to make what had become a brutally dysfunctional marriage last.

I wish they'd had JR and Sue Ellen be bright enough to come to the realization that the two of them being married just didn't work. When Sue Ellen found JR in bed with Holly Harwood, that should have been it. How could either of them, at that point, think they still had a marriage worth trying to save? Watching a husband and wife continue to hurt each other in the worst ways is not enjoyable; it's just not good! Watching a man and a woman in abject misery just isn't my thing.

When would you have liked them to come to the realization that their marriage simply did not work?
 
Last edited:

CeeCee72

Telly Talk Star
The writers had many opportunities to solve the JR/Sue Ellen marital problems, but they chose not to - probably because they thought the couple's drama was compelling (and it was) and partly I think because neither character "worked" well as part of another couple (partly due to the chemistry between LH and LG).

My own personal view of SE and JR is that they were both horribly damaged, emotionally insecure characters. Neither of them was capable of loving anyone else, so they stuck it out with each other. In spite of all the horrible pain they inflicted on each other, they shared a deep emotional bond. SE was the only woman JR ever was shown to truly care for and JR was clearly the love of SE's life

My personal preference would have been to see both characters be allowed to continue the emotional growth they began in season. 10 after BD Calhoun. Tearing it all apart in that horrible Kimberly Cryder storyline was a huge missed opportunity. But..since it had to go that way, that's the point where I would have preferred to see SE walk away (without the degrading revenge plots).
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Definitely Season 6, depending on the circumstances, I think everyone deserves a second chance, but that's it. It would have been good for JR to see Sue Ellen happy with someone else. Which is how it should have been with Dusty.

I think the big mistake Dallas made here is thinking that they absolutely had to keep Linda Gray on the show when they didn't. They could have had JR and Sue Ellen fix their marriage and then fine, Linda Gray stays on the show, that's one way they could have gone. They obviously did not want that because they had every opportunity to do it and chose not to. OK, so they did not want the marriage to work, that's OK too, but then end it! Don't just make us keep watching the same things happen over and over again. They're fighting. Then they're getting along but only for a little while and then they're fighting again. OK, we get it, the marriage does not work!

If that's the story they wanted to tell, that the marriage did not work, then have Sue Ellen marry Dusty. Then Sue Ellen might not have as vital a role in the story anymore, but that's alright because she served her purpose in those first 6 years or whatever it might be. Just because a character was needed in the first six years doesn't guarantee that their story will always require that character. It's whatever the story requires. It's a mistake to keep a character no matter what, if you have nothing important in your plans for that character to do.
 

CeeCee72

Telly Talk Star
I think the big mistake Dallas made here is thinking that they absolutely had to keep Linda Gray on the show when they didn't. They could have had JR and Sue Ellen fix their marriage and then fine, Linda Gray stays on the show, that's one way they could have gone. They obviously did not want that because they had every opportunity to do it and chose not to. OK, so they did not want the marriage to work, that's OK too, but then end it! Don't just make us keep watching the same things happen over and over again. They're fighting. Then they're getting along but only for a little while and then they're fighting again. OK, we get it, the marriage does not work!

If that's the story they wanted to tell, that the marriage did not work, then have Sue Ellen marry Dusty. Then Sue Ellen might not have as vital a role in the story anymore, but that's alright because she served her purpose in those first 6 years or whatever it might be. Just because a character was needed in the first six years doesn't guarantee that their story will always require that character. It's whatever the story requires. It's a mistake to keep a character no matter what, if you have nothing important in your plans for that character to do.

I think you're focusing a bit too much on how we had to watch JR/SE do the "same things over and over." I don't feel that's the case.

Yes, it seems like everytime their marriage imploded, it was over him having an affair. And yes, it seems as if everytime after it imploded, we had to watch SE battle alcohol and JR chase her to try to get her back. But....

1. Watching SE turn to booze everytime JR hurt her is actually pretty realistic. She was an alcoholic. That's what they do. And every time, she dealt with it/overcame it differently.

2. Each affair was different in its own way. Holly was the most devasting, because SE truly believed in JR. Her reaction afterward was gut wrenching and the work LG did there was some of the finest acting we ever saw on Dallas. JR's reaction was different too. He was truly sorry. If there was one act in his life he could take back at that time, I believe it would have been having SE catch him in bed with Holly. We learned a lot about JR's character there. He wasn't sorry for the affair so much as he was sorry for how much seeing it had hurt SE. The way he treated her afterwards, it was almost...sweet. It's one of the few times JR ever battled any guilt for his actions whatsoever. The affair with Mandy was the only one that ever posed any real threat to SE's place in JR's life. It was fascinating to watch him try to build and honest to God relationship with someone other than SE (rather than just having a lusty or business based affair) and it was even more fascinating to watch SE's reaction to it. I don't count season 9...it was all a dream, so none of that ever happened. In season 10, I enjoyed watching SE get mad enough FINALLY to fight back. That scene between SE and Mandy at the restaurant where Mandy tells her JR wants her "in bed and out" because she's "years younger" and Sue Ellen has a "problem with alcohol" is golden. SE was furious. Watching her make the decision to fight back, not only for her position as Mrs. JR Ewing but for JR himself was something I truly enjoyed. She seduced JR to prove he DID still want her, then set about getting Mandy out of his life once and for all. I found myself cheering for her and I found JR's slow melting towards her added a new layer to his character. The emotional maturity both characters achieved in late season 10 was beautiful and it's not something either could have done apart from the other. Then came the Kimberly Cryder affair. And it was just one big, sloppy mistake. I found JR's decision to do it unconvincing and SE's reaction to it to be ridiculous. To me, that was the beginning of the downward slide for "Dallas."

4. Not only do I think it would have been a mistake to let LG go any earlier, but I think letting her go when they did has a huge mistake. SE made JR more human. As awful as he was to her, as bad as their marriage was a times, she was the ONLY character we ever saw him open himself up to emotionally. She was the only one he ever felt guilty for hurting. She was the only woman he ever loved...and he said so himself on multiple occasions. In the end, SE did some truly awful things to JR. She cost him Weststar. She tricked him into marrying Cally. She made that stupid movie. She SHOT him - and yet he still willingly accepted her presence in his life - and it had nothing to do with her being John Ross's mother. It was because he needed her. If couldn't love her, her needed to fight with her. And the chemistry between the two actors never dulled or faded. Losing SE's character weakened JR's and it was, to me, the greatest mistake the show ever made.
 
Last edited:

Angela Channing

Telly Talk Veteran
None of the above.

She should never have gone back to him after her first divorce. JR deliberately tired to make her start drinking again, he impregnated her sister, was continually verbally and mentally abusive towards her and subjected her to constant coercive control. It just wasn't credible that she would go back to him after all that. They should have done what they did with Valene in Knots Landing and have her marry someone else and try to move on with her life. This would have given JR another rival and opened up new possibilities for storylines for both him and Sue Ellen.
 

CeeCee72

Telly Talk Star
None of the above.

She should never have gone back to him after her first divorce. JR deliberately tired to make her start drinking again, he impregnated her sister, was continually verbally and mentally abusive towards her and subjected her to constant coercive control. It just wasn't credible that she would go back to him after all that. They should have done what they did with Valene in Knots Landing and have her marry someone else and try to move on with her life. This would have given JR another rival and opened up new possibilities for storylines for both him and Sue Ellen.

I agree it would have been good to see her move on. I'm just not sure Dusty was the right one. He had a lot of his own baggage.

But yes, seeing JR being the one to have to deal with HER moving on would have been priceless.
 

pete lashmar

Telly Talk Addict
I think you need to see how Sue Ellen evolved due to her relationship with J.R. What once made her turn to booze became something she learnt from, instead of hitting the bottle she started to react differently, taking a leaf out of J.R's book - firstly with the Valentine's Girl, then teaming up with Kimberley Cryder to stop him getting Weststar and then making the movie.

Her evolution was because time and time again J.R had let her down, cheated on her and lied to her - finally, after 2 marriages and numerous reconciliations she finally realised that she needed to be pro-active rather that reactive.

She loved J.R very much, he was the love of her life, but eventually she had to take positive action rather than negative. People's lives twist and turn depending what obstacles are in their way, and how they deal with them. The Sue Ellen we see leaving Dallas is not the same one that we saw clinging onto a bottle of vodka.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I think you need to see how Sue Ellen evolved due to her relationship with J.R. What once made her turn to booze became something she learnt from, instead of hitting the bottle she started to react differently, taking a leaf out of J.R's book - firstly with the Valentine's Girl, then teaming up with Kimberley Cryder to stop him getting Weststar and then making the movie.

Her evolution was because time and time again J.R had let her down, cheated on her and lied to her - finally, after 2 marriages and numerous reconciliations she finally realised that she needed to be pro-active rather that reactive.

My take on it is that she was still very much reactive. Did Sue Ellen have a genuine interest in getting into the lingerie business? No, it was a reaction to JR seeing Mandy. Was teaming up with Kimberly a pro-active move to improve her quality of life? No, because she didn't want to own Westar - she was reacting to JR wanting to control Westar. Did she have a genuine passion for the movie business that she was pursuing to improve her quality of life? No, she was reacting to how JR had treated her in their marriage and instead of utilizing all that time and effort to do something to improve the quality of her life, she did it just to make JR's life worse. What was her movie about? JR. She was physically free of him and was determined to still stay just as mentally occupied with JR as she'd ever been. That doesn't leave room for much else.

You can't make your life good by making your ex-spouse's life bad! Life doesn't work that way. After all those years, she had failed to learn that living well is the best revenge. She wasn't using her time and effort and money to make her life good; she was using it to make JR's life bad. That's an incredibly juvenile mentality for a woman of her age. Cally was far younger but had far more common sense. She got as far from JR as she could, found a man she loved, married him and was leading a life that appeared to be one designed to maximize her quality of life - it had nothing to do with trying to hurt JR. Cally realized the marriage didn't work and she moved on. That's what a mature person does.

In any failed marriage there is some fault on both sides. For whatever combination of reason a marriage just doesn't happen to work out, but a sensible, intelligent well adjusted person moves on! They work on making their new life as good as it can be. They don't waste time trying to hurt the person they were married to, because that is their past! Or it should be. Well adjusted people don't allow themselves to be consumed with hatred because when you do that, you have little or no room for anything positive. When you allow your mind to be filled with hatred it makes it impossible to be at peace. JR didn't dwell on all the times Sue drank and cheated with Ray and Cliff and Dusty and Clint and all the rest, he didn't dwell on her trying to murder him; JR simply moved on with his life and tried to make the best of it. That is pro-active. Refusing to be stuck in the past and moving ahead in life is pro-active.

I found it quite sad that even after foiling the Westar takeover, even after shooting JR, Sue Ellen still could not let go of revenge. She'd shot him and that wasn't enough? Do you think her son ever looked at her the same way again after finding out she tried to murder his daddy? What would releasing that movie or even finding out she'd made a movie only to embarrass his daddy do to the way John Ross would look at Sue Ellen? She was throwing every chance at happiness away with both hands all so she could continue to pursue her insatiable lust for revenge.
 

pete lashmar

Telly Talk Addict
Sue Ellen was a very damaged person, and damaged people cling onto things that drive them - for Sue Ellen it was alcohol at first then revenge.
 

CeeCee72

Telly Talk Star
My take on it is that she was still very much reactive. Did Sue Ellen have a genuine interest in getting into the lingerie business? No, it was a reaction to JR seeing Mandy. Was teaming up with Kimberly a pro-active move to improve her quality of life? No, because she didn't want to own Westar - she was reacting to JR wanting to control Westar. Did she have a genuine passion for the movie business that she was pursuing to improve her quality of life? No, she was reacting to how JR had treated her in their marriage and instead of utilizing all that time and effort to do something to improve the quality of her life, she did it just to make JR's life worse. What was her movie about? JR. She was physically free of him and was determined to still stay just as mentally occupied with JR as she'd ever been. That doesn't leave room for much else.

You can't make your life good by making your ex-spouse's life bad! Life doesn't work that way. After all those years, she had failed to learn that living well is the best revenge. She wasn't using her time and effort and money to make her life good; she was using it to make JR's life bad. That's an incredibly juvenile mentality for a woman of her age. Cally was far younger but had far more common sense. She got as far from JR as she could, found a man she loved, married him and was leading a life that appeared to be one designed to maximize her quality of life - it had nothing to do with trying to hurt JR. Cally realized the marriage didn't work and she moved on. That's what a mature person does.

In any failed marriage there is some fault on both sides. For whatever combination of reason a marriage just doesn't happen to work out, but a sensible, intelligent well adjusted person moves on! They work on making their new life as good as it can be. They don't waste time trying to hurt the person they were married to, because that is their past! Or it should be. Well adjusted people don't allow themselves to be consumed with hatred because when you do that, you have little or no room for anything positive. When you allow your mind to be filled with hatred it makes it impossible to be at peace. JR didn't dwell on all the times Sue drank and cheated with Ray and Cliff and Dusty and Clint and all the rest, he didn't dwell on her trying to murder him; JR simply moved on with his life and tried to make the best of it. That is pro-active. Refusing to be stuck in the past and moving ahead in life is pro-active.

I found it quite sad that even after foiling the Westar takeover, even after shooting JR, Sue Ellen still could not let go of revenge. She'd shot him and that wasn't enough? Do you think her son ever looked at her the same way again after finding out she tried to murder his daddy? What would releasing that movie or even finding out she'd made a movie only to embarrass his daddy do to the way John Ross would look at Sue Ellen? She was throwing every chance at happiness away with both hands all so she could continue to pursue her insatiable lust for revenge.

Bad writing. Horrible. Atrocious. Destructive.

And that's why by the time SE left, I was glad to see her go. The writers destroyed her every bit as much as they destroyed JR.

The Valentine thing I didn't mind. She and JR were still married and it felt like she was fighting for her husband.

But the Weststar thing? Nope. She wouldn't have done that to John Ross. She KNEW that was the ONE thing JR would NEVER forgive her for. She wouldn't have done it for her son's sake.

Shooting JR? Nope. She wouldn't have done that to John Ross.

Tricking JR into marrying Cally? Nope. She wouldn't have done that to John Ross.

Making that stupid movie and following a man she barely knew out of the country? Nope and Nope. She wouldn't have done that to her son.

Seeing a pattern here? The writers destroyed the character they had spent years building. They did the same thing with Pam when they had her abandon her son (something Pam would NEVER do) and to JR is turning him into a weak clown.

That's why for me, the Dallas I loved ended in Season 10. I don't know who those characters were in the later seasons, but they weren't the ones I had been watching for so many years.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Bad writing. Horrible. Atrocious. Destructive.

And that's why by the time SE left, I was glad to see her go. The writers destroyed her every bit as much as they destroyed JR.

The Valentine thing I didn't mind. She and JR were still married and it felt like she was fighting for her husband.

But the Weststar thing? Nope. She wouldn't have done that to John Ross. She KNEW that was the ONE thing JR would NEVER forgive her for. She wouldn't have done it for her son's sake.

Shooting JR? Nope. She wouldn't have done that to John Ross.

Tricking JR into marrying Cally? Nope. She wouldn't have done that to John Ross.

Making that stupid movie and following a man she barely knew out of the country? Nope and Nope. She wouldn't have done that to her son.

Seeing a pattern here? The writers destroyed the character they had spent years building. They did the same thing with Pam when they had her abandon her son (something Pam would NEVER do) and to JR is turning him into a weak clown.

That's why for me, the Dallas I loved ended in Season 10. I don't know who those characters were in the later seasons, but they weren't the ones I had been watching for so many years.

I felt the same way about pretty much everything you just described. Dallas stopped developing their characters and started destroying them. I think the producer was burned out from having to do the whole job himself, since Phil Capice was no longer his co-producer and Katzman just decided, the easiest way to create drama would be to destroy everything they'd built. It created drama, but a kind of drama nobody wanted to see.

You're right, she wouldn't have shot her son's father.

Getting involved with Cally was just so far beneath her that frankly I felt embarrassed for Sue Ellen. Can you imagine JR befriending Nick Pearce or Don Lockwood? JR had more than his fair share of flaws but he wasn't petty and he wasn't stuck in the past. When Sue Ellen finally left him he didn't devote the rest of his life to trying to wreck her life; he actually moved on like an adult would!

Of course they stripped JR of all his competency in business but that's a separate issue.

Maybe the only thing I disagree on is the Valentine story because for one, I didn't believe that JR couldn't figure out who owned it when he tried to buy it and was refused by Mr Valentine. The JR we once knew would have had the name of the owner that same day.

Second, I don't know how Sue Ellen thought she had a marriage worth saving at that point, after all the problems they'd had. She wasn't even sharing a bedroom with JR during the Valentine story. Besides, she moved out the very next season so ultimately, the whole Valentine deal failed at saving her marriage.

The movie was absolutely childish and a massive waste of time and money that should have been spent bettering her life - not trying to hurt a man who she'd already shot and divorced. Sue Ellen was so hopelessly stuck in the past that by the time Linda Gray left the show that I was as glad to see her go as you were.

She had contributed to classic Dallas stories, and been a vital character for a certain period of time, but obviously not vital indefinitely. By the time she left they had no idea what to do with her. They tarnished the Sue Ellen character so badly with the things you described that when she finally left it was a relief!
 

CeeCee72

Telly Talk Star
@Kenny Coyote

I had the same thought about JR finding out who owned Valentine. Had to suspend some disbelief there.

Part of SE thinking she still had a marriage to save then goes back to her unhealthy views of herself and her relationship with JR. It seemed in character to me. SE always thought of JR as "hers" or "her husband" even when she insisted they live separate lives. Part of it was who he was and what being his wife gave to her. Part of it was because she truly loved him and couldn't figure out a way to exist without him.

I have to disagree that JR was never petty about SE. He went after the Farlows. He set Peter up (not to mention got Lucy drunk just to enjoy her scene making SE uncomfortable). The difference between their pettiness is he always had a goal in mind when he was pretty to her - get her back in his bed or get John Ross back at Southfork. He didn't do it just to be spiteful (he saved that behavior for Cliff).

And I do agree that by the time SE left Dallas it was a relief. And that's hard for me to say because I loved her character. But what they did to her? I just wanted her gone so I didn't have to watch it every week. And I admire LG as an actress for leaving. She'd been begging for several seasons not to be forced to do such drivel. She could have stayed. Her personal relationship with LH meant he would have insisted she stay if that was what she wanted.

But as I have said before, as bad as they destroyed JR, by the last episode I didn't even care if that guy shot had been him shooting himself in the head and putting us ALL out of our misery.
 

Ukdallasfan

Telly Talk Fan
I loved the chemistry between them and wish they could have made it as a couple. However, I agree that the plot devices used became nonsensical the longer the show went on. For me, the first big insult was the Kimberley Cryder affair. It never made sense because JR and Sue Ellen had finally found happiness and, supposedly, mutual respect, but, next minute, he’s proposing marriage to Kimberley and trying to drive Sue Ellen to dislike and divorce him. It was ridiculous. I would have much preferred their marriage to have developed further, matured and grown. That would have been a much better way forward for both characters, for the actors’ own happiness and that of the fans. Larry and Linda obviously loved working together and the fans loved to see that. Then, Cally- what can I say? I just hated that plot development and, for me, sadly the show would never be the same.
 

Miss Ellie Fan

Telly Talk Member
I thought they were a great couple and the best to watch on the show.

I didn’t enjoy watching them with anyone else and thought it was really out of character for both how they behaved when JR met that awful Kimberley - he loved Sue Ellen and I don’t think he would have left her for anyone let alone that annoying woman.

Dallas really wasn’t Dallas after that - JR needed Sue Ellen and when she left him he became a stranger to me, the viewer.
 

Jock's Ghost

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I down even mind the Peter storyline as it showed she was just as cunnincunning as JR.
But a victim if they can not control or lose control of their circumstances. SE asked for her misery in the latter years. Making her an alcoholic was a good idea but why not keep it going until she spirals out. In the early years I felt bad for SE as JR made it impossible for her to leave with her son and she loved her son so she was stuck. I'd have not remarried them, at least not so quick. Marry her to Clayton instead. He dies of a heart attack, inherits his fortune. Her alcoholism kicks in. With JRs help, she squanders it. Shes helpless.
 
Top