Dallas - Understanding The Phenomenon - Part One

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I briefly touched on this subject in a post of mine from a few days ago Now I want to really take a look at what it was that made Dallas turn into not just another successful prime time drama but a one of a kind phenomenon that TV never had before or since.


It seems incredible that the Dallas continuation ran for a mere 40 episodes – less than 2 full seasons worth of original Dallas. One reason was in an incompetent showrunner who didn’t have a thorough understanding of the show’s history because she was too lazy to watch it in entirety. When I think of how many of us watch all the Dallas episodes repeatedly for the sheer enjoyment of it, it’s really awful that she couldn’t even summon the self-discipline to make herself watch it for the sake of her own career and all the people whose careers were depending on the Dallas continuation succeeding..


Since Cynthia Cidre was not a fan of Dallas, when she was offered the job she accepted it just so she could create her own project, and then use the Dallas name for publicity, visibility, and a guarantee of a huge audience for the debut of her project. To put it bluntly, she prostituted the Dallas name in the hope of making her own project a hit show. 7 million viewers in the USA alone tuned in for its debut. They immediately found out they’d been deceived with the promise of a continuation of the story of the family they’d grown to know and love in the 1980s and by the next week, half of that audience for the debut failed to return. From there it was just a constant downhill slide in the ratings until the plug was pulled on TNT Dallas after its 40th episode.


Those reasons for the Dallas audience abandoning the show fraudulently billed as a “Dallas continuation” are all valid but the biggest reason was that the showrunner or producer, whatever you want to call her, never understood what made Dallas the phenomenon it became. When you don’t understand how something works, you can never redo it.


Why did the original Dallas become such a massive success? That’s what I want to explore now. I’ve given it a lot of thought over the years. It’s not simple. If it were, people would have redone it successfully and they wouldn’t have waited 20 years to try. What network wouldn’t want a successful continuation of the most successful dramatic TV series of all time?


You can’t plan a phenomenon. It cannot be done. A phenomenon is something that for some reason, the fans grab ahold of and then with their enthusiasm and passion for the product they turn it into a phenomenon.


A pehomenon grows organically. It’s not manufactured in some TV network’s office. The story of how Dallas became a phenomenon is that it at least partially happened by mistake. The TV executives, producers, and such had decided that two characters would be the main stars of Dallas – Bobby and Pam. They initially tried that and you can see it in the very early episodes. Then the phenomenon began to grow organically – driven by the fans. The fans were intrigued by the character J.R. Ewing. They loved watching him every week to see what he would do next. It’s a testament to the wisdom of the people in charge of Dallas at the time that they actually listened to the fans! Can you imagine if the people in charge of TNT Dallas had listened to the fans? It might still be on the air today if they had.


The people producing the original Dallas then started writing more scenes for J.R. Ewing, because they were bright enough to give the people what they wanted. It seems like common sense, but it’s a surprisingly rare quality in the industry. They tempered their desire to give the people with what they wanted with wisdom. They didn’t just change all their plans and make a series strictly about J.R. Ewing.

To be continued....
 
Last edited:

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Why did the original Dallas become such a massive success? That’s what I want to explore now.

I'm excited to watch this thread. While waiting for Part 2 of your installment, may I suggest that the first few seconds of the Dallas opening theme pull us in right away. Let's dissect the opening:

First, a very normal highway. But wait! Where is this highway leading? What city is that back there? And the drum beat opens the orchestra to let us know something very big is happening in that city.

Second, the camera does exactly what we want it to do-- get closer to the city and see what the anticipation is about. Why, the excitement must be all about this city-- or is it?

Third, the tri split screen starts scrolling. What is this in between the shots of the city? Oil wells? Cattle? Then more glamour shots of the city, flanked by shots of farm buildings with rusty roofs and a tractor plowing up a field. There must be more to this then just a city. But how much more?

Fourth, the tri screen starts introducing the actors. Interesting that there seem to be glamour shots, but also nitty-gritty action shots as well. Who are these people?

Fifth, after showing us the locations and the characters, the camera pans up to Southfork. We just know something big is happening in there. We can't wait to see what it is!

So even before watching a single episode, we are filled with anticipation knowing that something big is happening.
 
Last edited:

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme

pete lashmar

Telly Talk Addict
I think it's far too difficult to crack the code on why DALLAS so such a global hit because different aspects appealed to different people.

For some it was the characters, for others the plots, for others the money & for many it was all 3.

It was also allowed to grow from a weekly drama into a dynamic soap, it was given time to tell stories, not rush them.
 

Justine

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
It seems incredible that the Dallas continuation ran for a mere 40 episodes – less than 2 full seasons worth of original Dallas. One reason was in an incompetent showrunner who didn’t have a thorough understanding of the show’s history because she was too lazy to watch it in entirety.

In terms of the numbers of episodes per season, I don't think it's fair to compare Dallas TNT to Dallas. In the days when Dallas was a hit show, there were only a handful of channels available on the television - in 2012, there was such a varied amount of competition that, in order to succeed, series like Dallas needed to condense a season into a handful of episodes so that storylines were short/concise and viewers didn't become bored.

ITA with your point about Cidre, however. She didn't show any consideration or respect for Dallas' history and that's why the continuation failed.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
In terms of the numbers of episodes per season, I don't think it's fair to compare Dallas TNT to Dallas. In the days when Dallas was a hit show, there were only a handful of channels available on the television - in 2012, there was such a varied amount of competition that, in order to succeed, series like Dallas needed to condense a season into a handful of episodes so that storylines were short/concise and viewers didn't become bored.

ITA with your point about Cidre, however. She didn't show any consideration or respect for Dallas' history and that's why the continuation failed.

That's an interesting point, Justine. Are you new to this forum? I don't recall seeing your name until very recently so if you are new to the forum, welcome! I hope you have a good time here :)

It's true that we had a lot less TV channels back then. When did your neighborhood first get cable TV? Our neighborhood, for whatever, reason took forever to get cable TV which pissed me off because I'd heard about MTV and wanted to see what all the talking was about! But cable TV wasn't available in our part of Potomac - a Maryland suburb of Washington D.C. - until 1989! So until 1989 we had about six channels including CBS. We had the three big networks, a public TV station, and two local channels that aired mostly syndicated shows, sports and movies.

What I find absolutely tremendous is that Dallas did as well as it did despite that it had what is generally considered a sh***y timeslot - Friday nights at 9PM. Other TV channels were the least of Dallas's competition. It's competition was the things people tend to do on Friday nights - restaurants, move theaters, and nightclubs. How many TV shows, whether in the 1980s or in 2012, can you think of that had such a fascination for its fans that they would rather stay home in a Friday night and watch it instead of go out and do something?

Eventually people had VCRs with timers and they could set the timers to record Dallas while they went out, but when Dallas began in 1978, the VHS machine was practically unheard of and prohibitively expensive. In fact, Betamax was more popular than VHS in 1978. I don't know if the Betamax or VHS matches of the late 70s even had timer recording as a feature. It didn't really matter because they were so expensive back then that very, very few families had a VCR when Dallas began or even in the fall of 1980 when the record breaking episode aired in which we found out Kristen shot JR. 83 million viewers in The United States alone watched Dallas that night. They could have been watching ABC or NBC, but much more significantly, those 83 million people could have been having a late dinner at a restaurant, they could have been at a bar or a nightclub with live entertainment, they could have been out on a date, they could have been at a sports event, at a movie theater, or anything else people like to do on Friday nights and instead they chose to stay home and watch Dallas. I find that a hell of a lot more impressive than being a Monday night show where your main competition is just other TV shows, don't you?
 
Last edited:

Justine

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
That's an interesting point, Justine. Are you new to this forum? I don't recall seeing your name until very recently so if you are new to the forum, welcome! I hope you have a good time here :)

Kind of new, but not really. I was on the forum before it crashed, but I hadn't posted in a couple years even before that. I posted under MrsSuperman93 and, as you may have gathered from the username, I was born in '93 so I've always had a wide variety of channels available. You're right, though. It's very impressive that such a number of viewers stayed in on a Friday and watched Dallas.
 

Michael Torrance

Telly Talk Mega Star
I believe that going out on a Friday at 9 p.m. was and for the most part still is something younger ages do. Parents in their late 30s, 40s, and 50s, and elderly people, were no more likely to be going out on a Friday then than now. The Dukes of Hazzard, which preceded Dallas in that slot, was a top 20 Nielsen hit for its first four seasons despite the Friday night slot. Some shows that had been hurt in that slot in previous decades (like Star Trek) were often hurt because their target audience was out having fun. I think in fact VHS started hurting Dallas and networks in general in the mid-to-late 80s rather than other venues earlier, creating the Friday night death slot perception (which was still not always true). People could rent a movie and stay home with the children or with friends, and that was a cheap alternative to watching what was offered on TV.
 
Last edited:

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
Isn't 9 p.m. a little early to go to bars and clubs?

I always moved heaven and earth to watch Savannah before I was going to do my hair and stuff.
 

tommie

Telly Talk Hero
In terms of the numbers of episodes per season, I don't think it's fair to compare Dallas TNT to Dallas. In the days when Dallas was a hit show, there were only a handful of channels available on the television - in 2012, there was such a varied amount of competition that, in order to succeed, series like Dallas needed to condense a season into a handful of episodes so that storylines were short/concise and viewers didn't become bored.

ITA with your point about Cidre, however. She didn't show any consideration or respect for Dallas' history and that's why the continuation failed.

When it comes to episode orders, cable also tend to have shorter seasons in general since they don't follow the normal September-May rules of broadcast. Add that it's pretty unheard of that broadcast (primetime) shows these days can get 30+ episodes per season. Even Greys Anatomy, that usually have slightly longer seasons, only tend to extend to 25 per season.
 

Michael Torrance

Telly Talk Mega Star
When it comes to episode orders, cable also tend to have shorter seasons in general since they don't follow the normal September-May rules of broadcast. Add that it's pretty unheard of that broadcast (primetime) shows these days can get 30+ episodes per season. Even Greys Anatomy, that usually have slightly longer seasons, only tend to extend to 25 per season.

Yeah, currently networks only have 10 episodes for November-February-May, a couple in September, and then another 12 sprinkled around the rest of the 9 month calendar.
 

Michael Torrance

Telly Talk Mega Star
Isn't 9 p.m. a little early to go to bars and clubs?

It depends. When on vacation in the Greek isles, people actually wake up at 11 p.m. to take a shower, get dressed, and then go out well after midnight. When I lived in some god-forsaken place in Georgia, Wendy's had this ad campaign "Wendy's: eat great, even late." In the rest of the US, that did mean well after midnight. In my redneck hamlet, it meant 11 p.m.
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I believe that going out on a Friday at 9 p.m. was and for the most part still is something younger ages do. Parents in their late 30s, 40s, and 50s, and elderly people, were no more likely to be going out on a Friday then than now.

If you go out at all, chances are you go out on a Friday or Saturday since most people have to get up early for work Monday through Friday. Younger people go out the most but that's the worst demographic for a show like Dallas to lose. The 18 - 35 year old demographic is the most coveted demographic to advertisers.

Isn't 9 p.m. a little early to go to bars and clubs?

Yes, it is for nightclubs. In my experience the most popular time to arrive at a club is around 10 - 11 PM. It depends some on the local laws regarding how late alcohol can be served. If last call is at say, 1:45 AM, then getting to the clubs by 10 PM gives you four hours to drink which should be enough. If there's live entertainment then when you get there mostly depends on who you're going to see. Bands might go onstage as early as 9PM or as late as 12:30 or 1:00.

When on vacation in the Greek isles, people actually wake up at 11 p.m. to take a shower, get dressed, and then go out well after midnight.

Interesting. Are those just the people on vacation or the people who live there too? How late are they allowed to serve alcohol there? That schedule reminds me of when I was in my early twenties, dropping off my girlfriend at work at 9 and picking her up at 4.
 

Michael Torrance

Telly Talk Mega Star
Interesting. Are those just the people on vacation or the people who live there too? How late are they allowed to serve alcohol there? That schedule reminds me of when I was in my early twenties, dropping off my girlfriend at work at 9 and picking her up at 4.

The people who live there work there during these hours if young, or live as far away as possible from all that commotion. The tourists (who are multiple times the number of locals in the summer) sleep after coming back from the beach during the day. Alcohol is served until 4 a.m., but while bars and clubs are good about no longer serving or having music on after that, at the most popular islands they don't send people away either, so customers usually order the last drink at 3:55 and keep on for a while.
 
Top