David Jacobs Leaving Dallas For Knots Landing

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
David Jacobs, the man who created the concept of Dallas and the characters as they originally appeared, left Dallas when it was still in its early stages and went on to do Knots Landing.

What do you think could have caused him to leave a show which he created, that had the level of actors it had in its main cast cast, with such a great concept and that had already been renewed? Why would he give up such a great situation and take a gamble like that, to create another series with a cast of actors who as far as I know had less credentials, were less known, and a concept that might or might not catch on with the public?

Do you think he regretted it later? He left a show that went on to become one of the most successful TV drama series of all time. It set records in the ratings. I don't know how David Jacobs reacted to that but most people would be kicking themselves in the ass for leaving something that went on to achieve that magnitude of success.
 
It's well documented that Jacobs created Knots Landing first. Then he was asked to create more of an epic saga and serendipity took care of the rest. When he was asked to do a spin-off, he dusted off the series he'd wanted to do in the first place: his original Scenes From A Marriage concept.

He's gone on record as saying:
I wanted to do art and [Michael Filerman] wanted to do trash. And together we did television

As a rule, Knots had more creativity than Dallas. I hasten to add that this isn't a criticism of Dallas, but I think it was in an audio commentary or featurette that Jacobs himself observed that Dallas basically had the same story each year, which was the fight for control of Ewing Oil. As a writer who by his own confession wanted to do "art" perhaps he saw more opportunities to be creative on Knots. More opportunities to put his stamp on it.

He had nothing to prove by that point. Perhaps it just came down to the fact that the ratings were less important to him than finding creative satisfaction in what he did. I don't think he regretted it for a second.



a concept that might or might not catch on with the public?

That's a risk for any new series. But one that's significantly lessened with a hit like Dallas under the belt.




another series with a cast of actors who as far as I know had less credentials, were less known

Did anyone know who Linda Gray or Charlene Tilton were before Dallas? Were Ken Kercheval or Steve Kanaly household names?

Knots, like Dallas, featured a range of experiences and backgrounds in its cast. Old school film stars; Broadway (and off-Broadway) actors; character actors who'd appeared in small film roles; and younger "finds". The casting on both shows was more or less impeccable.

Besides, Don Murray and Julie Harris's CVs pre-Knots aren't anything to shake a stick at.
 

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
David Jacob's desire to do "art" was definitely conveyed in Knots Landing. I always felt the show held a certain amount of respect for the intelligence of the audience, even in its final year. Dallas, a great show seemed to lose that respect. Some would say with Bobby's death and later resurrection, but I see that regard for the audience starting to crumble after season 7.
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
David Jacobs, the man who created the concept of Dallas and the characters as they originally appeared, left Dallas when it was still in its early stages and went on to do Knots Landing.

What do you think could have caused him to leave a show which he created, that had the level of actors it had in its main cast cast, with such a great concept and that had already been renewed? Why would he give up such a great situation and take a gamble like that, to create another series with a cast of actors who as far as I know had less credentials, were less known, and a concept that might or might not catch on with the public?

Do you think he regretted it later? He left a show that went on to become one of the most successful TV drama series of all time. It set records in the ratings. I don't know how David Jacobs reacted to that but most people would be kicking themselves in the ass for leaving something that went on to achieve that magnitude of success.

Think of it in terms of music. Imagine someone with some skill and talent looking to 'make it' in the business in that era, and not just as a sideman. He makes a demo recording of his band doing his tunes in the style he loves to play and shops it around without a ton of success.

Finally, a record company gets back to him with a nice contract offer under the condition that he start out with a record in a different vein that he doesn't hate, but isn't all that into. He decides he has to take the opportunity and writes new music, hires an appropriate band and makes the record. It's still his product, but it's not a real reflection of who he considers himself to be as a musician. Over time, the record starts getting some airplay and sales, then absolutely takes off due to one huge 'hit song' that he'd written kind of as an afterthought.

He's now in a position to either ride out the new superstar career for all it's worth, or parlay the early success and status into a nice long career doing the music he wants to play. He never makes the top of the charts again, but enjoys a nice Knots Landing-level career - successful records, tours, etc., and a more than comfortable living.

Why would he regret choosing that path?
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
It's well documented that Jacobs created Knots Landing first. Then he was asked to create more of an epic saga and serendipity took care of the rest. When he was asked to do a spin-off, he dusted off the series he'd wanted to do in the first place: his original Scenes From A Marriage concept.

Now that you mention it, it sounds very familiar that he developed KL first. I wasn't sure though because Dallas made its debut earlier.

I think it was in an audio commentary or featurette that Jacobs himself observed that Dallas basically had the same story each year, which was the fight for control of Ewing Oil.

Yeah but there are a thousand different stories you can tell about a ranching family in the oil business.

Think of it in terms of music. Imagine someone with some skill and talent looking to 'make it' in the business in that era, and not just as a sideman. He makes a demo recording of his band doing his tunes in the style he loves to play and shops it around without a ton of success.

Finally, a record company gets back to him with a nice contract offer under the condition that he start out with a record in a different vein that he doesn't hate, but isn't all that into. He decides he has to take the opportunity and writes new music, hires an appropriate band and makes the record. It's still his product, but it's not a real reflection of who he considers himself to be as a musician. Over time, the record starts getting some airplay and sales, then absolutely takes off due to one huge 'hit song' that he'd written kind of as an afterthought.

He's now in a position to either ride out the new superstar career for all it's worth, or parlay the early success and status into a nice long career doing the music he wants to play. He never makes the top of the charts again, but enjoys a nice Knots Landing-level career - successful records, tours, etc., and a more than comfortable living.

Why would he regret choosing that path?

That's a great way to explain it, Taylor. Thanks!
 

J. R.'s Piece

Telly Talk Star
“Pauline from: Glasgow, Scotland asks "Did you prefer Dallas or Knots Landing?

David - I didn't run Dallas, I ran Knots Landing. It was my full time job for 14 years, I was more like daddy. Where as Dallas, it was my first and I was actually working as a story editor on another show called 'Family' when Dallas started and so I was a little removed from it. Today I would say my affection for them both is equal but different but my connection with Knots Landing is much tighter.”
http://www.ultimatedallas.com/dallasinterviews/david.htm
 
Last edited:

stevew

Telly Talk Star
Now that you mention it, it sounds very familiar that he developed KL first. I wasn't sure though because Dallas made its debut earlier.



Yeah but there are a thousand different stories you can tell about a ranching family in the oil business.



That's a great way to explain it, Taylor. Thanks!

Hey agree there are a thousand stories they could have told but they got stuck on JR staying JR, womanizing, fighting for EO and then turning out to be a loser. But I agree there was so much more they could have done post Jock’s will. Bobby could have been given his own spin off instead of dying. JR could have moved on to being more like Jock with other children to provide the drama. They could have pushed things in other directions but it’s like they were afraid to change what got them to the top.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
“Pauline from: Glasgow, Scotland asks "Did you prefer Dallas or Knots Landing?

David - I didn't run Dallas, I ran Knots Landing. It was my full time job for 14 years, I was more like daddy. Where as Dallas, it was my first and I was actually working as a story editor on another show called 'Family' when Dallas started and so I was a little removed from it. Today I would say my affection for them both is equal but different but my connection with Knots Landing is much tighter.”
http://www.ultimatedallas.com/dallasinterviews/david.htm

Family was also an excellent show.
 

J. R.'s Piece

Telly Talk Star
When you read interviews with some of the writers on Knots Landing, it sometimes reveals that stories were more likely to emerge from the actions of the characters, rather than forcing them into a particular story. Richard Gollance and David Paulsen mentioned that frequently on Knots Landing, they didn’t always know where the story would be heading in a few episodes time. In his Ultimate Dallas interview, David Paulsen said that David Jacobs was more free-thinking and Knots Landing was more open to ideas from people involved and David Jacobs preferred to write and see where it took him but Dallas was more tightly controlled and Leonard Katzman would have to know where things were going to end up and then write towards that.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
When you read interviews with some of the writers on Knots Landing, it sometimes reveals that stories were more likely to emerge from the actions of the characters, rather than forcing them into a particular story. Richard Gollance and David Paulsen mentioned that frequently on Knots Landing, they didn’t always know where the story would be heading in a few episodes time. In his Ultimate Dallas interview, David Paulsen said that David Jacobs was more free-thinking and Knots Landing was more open to ideas from people involved and David Jacobs preferred to write and see where it took him but Dallas was more tightly controlled and Leonard Katzman would have to know where things were going to end up and then write towards that.
All of which was so obviously the case for anybody who watched both shows. But KNOTS' more leisurely approach, which was its strength, was a disaster when they tried to apply it to DALLAS (as they did during the dream season). DALLAS, although it had subtlety and nuance, didn't have quite as much, so if DALLAS wasn't always on-point plotwise, it tended to fall apart pretty quickly.

Perhaps that was also because DALLAS was essentially about a nuclear family.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Hey agree there are a thousand stories they could have told but they got stuck on JR staying JR, womanizing, fighting for EO and then turning out to be a loser. But I agree there was so much more they could have done post Jock’s will. Bobby could have been given his own spin off instead of dying. JR could have moved on to being more like Jock with other children to provide the drama. They could have pushed things in other directions but it’s like they were afraid to change what got them to the top.

They changed lot about what got them to the top, and not in a good direction. They tried to make everything bigger and more spectacular. They went from having storylines like Cliff being accused of Julie Grey's murder and Pam then moving in with Leann Rees, to having the storyline where they thought they were dealing with a Greek billionaire they'd never met who supposedly looked just like their cousin and then turned out to be dead. Having JR pay someone to blow up oil fields in Saudi Arabia. Then they had to make it even bigger so they took them to Russia.

I don't think that ever works for more than a very short period of time. Once you get to where they're dealing with the Soviet Union, how do they get any bigger than that?
 
Top