Did Punk Anderson Sell The Ewing’s Out?

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
In the Episode “Barbecue 3” all the oilmen, including Punk, were at an establishment contemplating about what to do about JR. They all pretty much said that there’s no way to get a hold of JR until Punk suggested that he’ll be at the Ewing BBQ and “we” could confront him there.

Later at the BBQ, Punk is talking to Ray about what’s about to go down. Not once did he say that it was “HIS” idea. Punk was kind of being a Punk if you ask me. At least man up to it.

Knowing his relation with the Ewing’s and Jock in particular, wasn’t that selling out his good friends? I know I wouldn’t have suggested a bunch of angry people to confront my best friends son on their own property.
 
Last edited:

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
In the Episode “Barbecue 3” all the oilmen, including Punk, were at an establishment contemplating about what to do about JR. They all pretty much said that there’s no way to get a hold of JR until Punk suggested that he’ll be at the Ewing BBQ and “we” could confront him there.

Later at the BBQ, Punk is talking to Ray about what’s about to go down. Not once did he say that it was “HIS” idea. Punk was kind of being a Punk if you ask me. At least man up to it.

Knowing his relation with the Ewing’s and Jock in particular, wasn’t that selling out his good friends? I know I wouldn’t have suggested a bunch of angry people to confront my best friends son on their own property.

Yes you would have thought out of loyalty to Miss Ellie that Punk wouldn’t have aligned with what was in many ways a protest inspired and whipped up by Cliff.

Swami
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Yes you would have thought out of loyalty to Miss Ellie that Punk wouldn’t have aligned with what was in many ways a protest inspired and whipped up by Cliff.

Swami

That was kind of sloppy writing, wasn't it? Why would all these experienced oilmen participate in anything led by Cliff? Cliff was primarily a lawyer. That's what he'd done for a living until his mother gave him a job running her Tool and Die company and then fired him. So in season 6, this season, she buys him his very own oil company. Cliff has been in their business just long enough to have a cup of coffee and all these experienced oilmen are letting him lead them?

As administrator of the will, Punk's job was to remain impartial regarding Bobby and JR. For him to get involved with a group of oilmen who were against JR, and by default in favor of Bobby winning, that was a conflict of interest for Punk to be helping them find a way to confront JR.
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
That was kind of sloppy writing, wasn't it? Why would all these experienced oilmen participate in anything led by Cliff? Cliff was primarily a lawyer. That's what he'd done for a living until his mother gave him a job running her Tool and Die company and then fired him. So in season 6, this season, she buys him his very own oil company. Cliff has been in their business just long enough to have a cup of coffee and all these experienced oilmen are letting him lead them?

As administrator of the will, Punk's job was to remain impartial regarding Bobby and JR. For him to get involved with a group of oilmen who were against JR, and by default in favor of Bobby winning, that was a conflict of interest for Punk to be helping them find a way to confront JR.

Plus Punk should have known Cliff's only reason for getting involved was to get at JR, he wasn't bothered about the other oilmen's concerns.

Swami
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Plus Punk should have known Cliff's only reason for getting involved was to get at JR, he wasn't bothered about the other oilmen's concerns.

Swami

Right, because for Cliff it wasn't business; it was personal. The idea of them confronting JR because he wasn't charging enough for his product was business related because he was cutting into their profits. For the rest of them it wasn't personal. They'd have been just as mad at Bobby if he'd done it, but it would be his right to do it. It was JR's right to charge what we wanted for his product.


https://definitions.uslegal.com/r/restraint-of-trade/
 
Last edited:

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
It makes you wonder why the cartel boys actually listened to Cliff on that occasion. The likes of Andy Bradley said on more than one occasion - at different times - "Come on Cliff we don't want any trouble with JR".

Swami
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
It makes you wonder why the cartel boys actually listened to Cliff on that occasion. The likes of Andy Bradley said on more than one occasion - at different times - "Come on Cliff we don't want any trouble with JR".

Swami

I'm surprised they even allowed Cliff to have a say in their cartel. He'd never been an oilman until that year! I didn't find it believable that they'd would put any stock in his opinion until he'd gained experience. Of course Cliff gets the "Oilman of The Year Award" for his first year in the business because of a a drill bit that he had no hand in designing, wasn't even aware it existed until after Katherine found out about it, and then did everything he could to make sure it didn't get tested. I don't know what he contributed to the Tundra Torque that warranted him receiving the "Oilman Of The Year" award. Katherine made more of a contribution to that drill bit becoming a success than Cliff did! At least Katherine voted to let Bobby test it.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
Plus the very ethics of everyone of these players, including a Punk, is called into question. JR was providing a lower price to the consumer - he was acting as the free market capitalist, whatever his reasons were, he was the good guy. They were colluding, calling for centralized control of prices, price fixing - all things which are illegal and anti-American. The cartel as it operated was a criminal activity. Kind of much to think any of them hold a moral high ground to JR.
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
Plus the very ethics of everyone of these players, including a Punk, is called into question. JR was providing a lower price to the consumer - he was acting as the free market capitalist, whatever his reasons were, he was the good guy. They were colluding, calling for centralized control of prices, price fixing - all things which are illegal and anti-American. The cartel as it operated was a criminal activity. Kind of much to think any of them hold a moral high ground to JR.

Yes, it does seem there was an element of sour grapes from Cliff & the cartel. If they had been the ones doing what JR was doing, would they have been complaining so much?

I think not.

Swami
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
Yes, it does seem there was an element of sour grapes from Cliff & the cartel. If they had been the ones doing what JR was doing, would they have been complaining so much?

I think not.

Swami

If JR had pushed for an investigation regarding collusion they might have been a bit more distracted from their hypocrisy as the wronged party.
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
If JR had pushed for an investigation regarding collusion they might have been a bit more distracted from their hypocrisy as the wronged party.

And it's not as if Cliff hadn't previous form with regards to a vendetta against the Ewings, he only took the post at the OLM to use it as a means of thwarting them at every possible opportunity.

Swami
 
Top