Didn’t Patrick owe it to the fans to insist on no dream

Grangehill1

Telly Talk Fan
Patrick chose to leave the show. He wanted to be killed off. And then when things didn’t work out he wanted to come back.

Of course he was being offered vast sums of money but shouldn’t he have thought about the lunacy of Bobby dying being written off a as a dream whilst negotiating his return? And insisted on another way?

You’ve got to have some ego to effectively say f@&k you to the audience and think you’re more important than all of the other actors and their storylines and the audiences’ emotional investment in the story.

But then that was Dallas wasn’t it? Larry, Leonard and Patrick ran the show the way they wanted to and didn’t care about the audience
 

CeeCee72

Telly Talk Star
I blame the producers more than the actors. So what if Patrick wanted Bobby to die? He was an employee; one that was leaving the show no less. He should have been told no way. Period.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
The producers should have shown a backbone and not killed Bobby off on-screen despite Patrick Duffy’s wishes.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Patrick chose to leave the show. He wanted to be killed off. And then when things didn’t work out he wanted to come back.

Of course he was being offered vast sums of money but shouldn’t he have thought about the lunacy of Bobby dying being written off a as a dream whilst negotiating his return? And insisted on another way?

You’ve got to have some ego to effectively say f@&k you to the audience and think you’re more important than all of the other actors and their storylines and the audiences’ emotional investment in the story.

But then that was Dallas wasn’t it? Larry, Leonard and Patrick ran the show the way they wanted to and didn’t care about the audience

The way I see it, Larry could not rehire Patrick. Patrick could not rehire Patrick. Leonard Katzman could and did rehire Patrick so the buck stops with Katzman.
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
How else were they going to bring him back? Bringing him back as another character, in my view, would have been far less plausible.

Swami
 

Seaviewer

Telly Talk Warrior
t shouldn’t he have thought about the lunacy of Bobby dying being written off a as a dream whilst negotiating his return? And insisted on another way?
Good point. If he was able to insist on the death scene on his way out, his influence should have been even stronger if they wanted him back so badly.
How else were they going to bring him back? Bringing him back as another character, in my view, would have been far less plausible.
Not necessary. Bobby was in the much-discussed coma - without dreaming. Maybe JR knew and kept it a secret for whatever reason. Maybe Bobby was revived and kept it secret for his own reasons. Either would be more plausible than the dream.
 

Sarah

Moderator Emerita
I find it incredibly unfair to say they didn’t care about the audience. I’ve met both actors on several occasions and both care a lot about their fans.

There was much more to it than just Patrick not carving out a movie career. Larry wanted him back as did the fans. Ratings suffered without Bobby.

Far far more ludricrous plots exist in Soapland - The Colbys flying spacecraft is probably one of if not the worst.

It was a production decision and although Larry has clout, it was a decision made with other executives.

There are parts of the outcome of the dream that I don’t like and would change but honestly I don’t see half the fuss about it. Especially since we got to keep Bobby.
 

CeeCee72

Telly Talk Star
Killing Bobby on screen was a mistake. But making the previous season a dream was a bigger mistake.

Sure, any other way they brought him back would have been unrealistic (like the coma idea) but it wouldn't have been as bad as wiping out the whole season.

People tend to think all we lost was the ridiculous Nero story and that silly emerald mine. No. We lost much more.

Donna and Ray's storyline with Tony was the best work those actors had ever done on that show. It was wiped out and instead we had to sit through a cliche breakup and threatened custody battle over an unborn baby.

SE's recovery from alcoholism was incredibly well done. That character grew and changed. She finally learned to make her own way, not totally dependent on JR for emotional fulfillment. She focused on being a good mother. She made peace with Patricia. She got a job she was good at. She was happy for the first time in that character's history.

JR's growth as a character was amazing that season. The sweet relationship he had with John Ross was wonderful. We got to see him SLOWLY mature enough to realize his family was more important than his schemes. His care and concern for Mandy when he ended things was so mature. His slow pursuit of SE and his willingness to let her decide for herself what she wanted her life to be was almost sweet. He grew personally while still being the cutthroat in business that he'd always been.

All of that was tossed away for a cheap shower reveal and an easily resolution. So, instead we're stuck with SE just "deciding" not to drink anymore, Ray and Donna in another weak storyline, and a reconciliation of JR and SE brought about by and outside threat (Calhoun) and not their own growth and maturity.
 
Last edited:

Sarah

Moderator Emerita
I agree about JR and Sue Ellen @CeeCee72 - I didn’t specifically mention it because people here know how I feel about them ;) I was gutted at the outcome. I loved their dream reconciliation. So many of the dream storylines were so well handled.

Then to be stuck with Mandy for longer :tv:

They definitely should have continued many of the good parts from the dream, specifically JR and Sue Ellen’s growth.
 

Michael Torrance

Telly Talk Mega Star
Ratings suffered without Bobby.

I agree with those who say it was the show's fault for succumbing to Duffy's demand that he die on screen. But I disagree that ratings plunged because he left. Ratings plunged because the show's plots the following year were lackluster and the tone changed. If viewers left in droves because Duffy left, they sure did not come back when he returned. Ratings dropped in the dream season, and then continued lower in the following season. I am sure some people did tune in for him, but the overall flaw was negative as there were also the disgusted fans who felt disrespected by the dream.

But all of that is not the actor's fault. Frankly, I think the departing team had a "let them deal with it" attitude when they decided to acquiesce to Duffy's demand, and then the joke was on them when Katzman returns and he is the one who has to deal with it--and as it turns out, badly.
 

Sarah

Moderator Emerita
See, I think if you're a huge fan, you will stick with it regardless. I did feel very sad when JR and Sue Ellen hadn't actually reconciled, but I just got on with it and there was never any question of me staying on as a fan.

Having said this, I guess it depends on your own level of fandom, as well as your particular feelings towards a certain character.

If they'd killed Sue Ellen (God I feel sick even saying it :eck: ) I might have felt differently. Fast forward a few years and I certainly began to feel differently once Linda left - I've watched the final seasons without her, once and once only. That was when I began to feel insulted. Without JR and Sue Ellen together, Dallas wasn't the Dallas I knew.
 
Last edited:

Clubsoda

Telly Talk Active Member
I dont get why they didn't tie in Bobby's return with Anjelica Nero?

It could've been plausible that Nero and her cronies had held Bobby captive for that entire year. His flatlining in the hospital could've been explained away as being faked.

Angelica Nero was so ott that this angle could've worked. It would've probably still turned viewers away due to its unrealistic tone but anything would've been better than the dream explanation.
 

CeeCee72

Telly Talk Star
See, I think if you're a huge fan, you will stick with it regardless. I did feel very sad when JR and Sue Ellen hadn't actually reconciled, but I just got on with it and there was never any question of me staying on as a fan.

Having said this, I guess it depends on your own level of fandom, as well as your particular feelings towards a certain character.

If they'd killed Sue Ellen (God I feel sick even saying it :eck: ) I might have felt differently. Fast forward a few years and I certainly began to feel differently once Linda left - I've watched the final seasons without her, once and once only. That was when I began to feel insulted. Without JR and Sue Ellen together, Dallas wasn't the Dallas I knew.

I was never the slightest bit worried that SE would be killed off. I expected her to be burned or concussed or maybe paralyzed temporarily and thought it would have been interesting to see how she and JR dealt with her injuries.

That least scene, Bobby in the shower, I had a bad feeling in my gut things were going to go off the rails.
 

James from London

International Treasure
Of course he was being offered vast sums of money but shouldn’t he have thought about the lunacy of Bobby dying being written off a as a dream whilst negotiating his return? And insisted on another way?

I don't think that's the actor's responsibility. Their job is to deliver the script they're presented with that day as believably as possible. They don't necessarily have the same overarching perspective as fans do.

You’ve got to have some ego to effectively say f@&k you to the audience and think you’re more important than all of the other actors and their storylines and the audiences’ emotional investment in the story.

That's one interpretation. Another is that he was invited back and he said OK. We don't know the exact order of events after that. Say he signs his contract before they tell him it's all a dream - what's he meant to do? Refuse to turn up for work until they change the story? He's gonna put himself in breach of contract for that? Most likely he trusted Katzman - the man who'd turned Dallas into an unprecedented phenomenon in the first place - to do his job.

Larry, Leonard and Patrick ran the show the way they wanted to and didn’t care about the audience

Hmm, I just don't buy that.

If he was able to insist on the death scene on his way out

That's a big if. Did he insist or was it a request - a request that made logical sense? After all, if they all really believed he was going for good then killing him off was surely the best creative decision at the time.

Donna and Ray's storyline with Tony was the best work those actors had ever done on that show.

I didn't like that storyline and by the end of the season, I'd come to kind of hate Donna, who I'd always really liked before.

It was wiped out

I was really pleased.

instead we had to sit through a cliche breakup and threatened custody battle over an unborn baby.

I much preferred that storyline. It felt very poignant and true to those characters.

SE's recovery from alcoholism was incredibly well done. That character grew and changed. She finally learned to make her own way, not totally dependent on JR for emotional fulfillment. She focused on being a good mother. She made peace with Patricia. She got a job she was good at. She was happy for the first time in that character's history.

All true, and as a result she was kind of boring.

Frankly, I think the departing team had a "let them deal with it" attitude when they decided to acquiesce to Duffy's demand

I disagree. 'Swan Song' isn't the work of people who don't care, who have no integrity, who've given up. It's the work of people who are doing their best to turn the situation they've been presented with - Duffy's departure - into 65 minutes of brilliant telly. They couldn't have predicted what would happen next.
 

Sarah

Moderator Emerita
There was talk that she would be left blind :(

I wasn't worried she might die during the dream. I just meant in general :)
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
It could've been plausible that Nero and her cronies had held Bobby captive for that entire year. His flatlining in the hospital could've been explained away as being faked.

I don't know if this is a genuine suggestion or if it's meant to be funny. As someone who never watched any of the other shows like Dynasty or Falcon Crest, I can say that to me, this is sort of what I imagine the storylines on some of those shows might have been like. I know a little but about them just from being on Soapchat for as long as I have. There was one that involved a UFO that may or may not have kidnapped one of the characters. I think it was a mistake for Dallas to think they could get away with something because other soaps apparently got away with outlandish, contrived and convoluted storylines.

Dallas's popularity came from having the wide appeal it did, including people who didn't generally watch soap operas. Dallas got the soap fans while still appealing to people who weren't particularly interested in soap operas. A look at the show's ratings tells me that the less believable Dallas got, the smaller their audience got.

The ratings for season 9 (dream season) and season ten were virtually identical. Does that mean both season 9 and 10 were equally contrived in their own ways? Maybe. Dallas only lost one percent of its audience from season nine to season ten.

I can't blame Patrick Duffy for taking a whole lot of money if Leonard Katzman offered it to him. If someone offered you what would in "today's money" be millions of dollars, would you turn it down because you thought it might hurt their business? Or would you take it because it would be good for you and your family?
 
Last edited:

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
Killing Bobby was fine and gave us one of TV's most memorable moments. Reviving him was also fine. but Duffy and Katzman left and returned at the same time and had no allegiance to the stories that occurred during the interim year (not that they were terribly compelling) so they had no interest in making them work or, more to the point, getting out of the artfully.

As Susan Howard said, the audience abused again.
 
Top