Dream Season - Again

Laurie Marr

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
As you know, I was waxing lyrical about how fabulous the show looked in the early part of the Season. Then we get halfway and references to Los Gatos and Martinique signal the nosedive.

It’s difficult to be too withering about what a mess the last dozen episodes were. At Southfork the women are either baking cookies, sniffing freshly cut flowers or laying the table in the kitchen. Donna is learning sign language, Ray has no storyline whatsoever, Sue Ellen looks fabulous and routinely congratulates herself on her transformation; Jack chuckles incessantly; Jenna arouses not even a hint of sympathy with her endless Stepford Wives turn…..on and on it bumbles. Pam gets a new face in Columbia and JR is mired in a Marinos shipping ‘mystery’ that has such a weak payoff once we get to the much anticipated Martinique.

Still, everyone tells everyone how much they are loved. It’s even more of a mess than I remember. Nevertheless, we have that weirdly prophetic line of Cliff’s in one of the many stupefyingly boring longeurs in Los Gaaaaaaaa-tos: ‘Bobby’s dream has become Pam’s nightmare.’ Quite.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
And yet the new writers this season set out to make the women "stronger."
 

Laurie Marr

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I don’t think I saw much of that, tbh. It’s a half conceived cross between Dynasty and Knots. Ellie has never been more Mumsy and in the next scene we have Angelica wielding a gun in a Travilla constructed piece of glam. It isn’t even camp enough to be funny. The episodes are just dull and lack any consistent tone.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
Leonard Katzman called the dream season "a Woman's Show" derisively -- and while there seems to be little question that he was comparatively disinterested in the female characters (look how Miss Ellie was marginalized and then pushed out during the later years despite being the only remaining original female character), he wasn't entirely wrong in that "a Woman's Show" tends to swoon and praise and flatter the women superficially while simultaneously denying them any genuine strength; meanwhile, the plotlines ramble and go nowhere.

Which is why Katzman also called DYNASTY "a Woman's Show" -- and most of it indeed was (except for Seasons 1, 2 & 9, which are terrific) because most of DYNASTY did exactly the same things: swooning and praising and flattering the women superficially while simultaneously denying them any genuine strength; meanwhile, the plotlines ramble and go nowhere.

After all, in contrast, KNOTS LANDING was always chock full of strong women -- strong, not just "prominent" -- and strong plotlines, so it was, by definition, the furthest thing from being "a Woman's Show." And thank goddess.

Which is why KNOTS outlasted the others.

Perversely, the same writing team who'd previously done such good work on KNOTS came in to run the dream season of DALLAS. But in making the transition, they forgot what they'd done right on KNOTS (presumably because they didn't have David Jacobs supervising their work on DALLAS) and, determined to "reform" DALLAS and its chauvinistic ways, just tossed in a dollop of overdressed DYNASTY-esque "glamour" and then mixed in a KNOTS-ian dose of pseudo-character-driven introspection (which wasn't very KNOTS-ian at all).

So we wound up with the mess that was the dream season.


Jeezus, who are all these people??
2bdb3cbe4ad8756aa71702f33d28374b.jpg
 
Last edited:

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
There were a lot of things I loved about the dream season. Sue Ellen's journey to sobriety was outstanding. I enjoyed the Donna/Ray/Tony storyline. JR's transformation felt real to me.

I liked Sue Ellen's journey too, that year. But the first half of the season -- the on-location episodes -- were experimental and rawer and full of potential. The problem was mostly with the second half of the dream season, when the writers realized the didn't really have a story they want to tell (anymore) so it all just starts to ramble and unravel.

It's been pointed out before that Ray & Jenna's baby story was played for easy sentiment and then they traded in the Down's Syndrome plot for a more visually-comfortable one like deafness (i.e., adorable Tony).

I can accept JR's transformation, temporarily, because the family's zonkers over Bobby being dead.

Unfortunately, add in Marinos, Emerald mines, and Jenna's hysterics and it's really hard to watch at times.

But Bobby loved emeralds!!

And they couldn't get a picture of those kids with their eyes open???

Even they were bored.
 

Holly Harlot

Telly Talk Newbie
As you know, I was waxing lyrical about how fabulous the show looked in the early part of the Season. Then we get halfway and references to Los Gatos and Martinique signal the nosedive.

It’s difficult to be too withering about what a mess the last dozen episodes were. At Southfork the women are either baking cookies, sniffing freshly cut flowers or laying the table in the kitchen. Donna is learning sign language, Ray has no storyline whatsoever, Sue Ellen looks fabulous and routinely congratulates herself on her transformation; Jack chuckles incessantly; Jenna arouses not even a hint of sympathy with her endless Stepford Wives turn…..on and on it bumbles. Pam gets a new face in Columbia and JR is mired in a Marinos shipping ‘mystery’ that has such a weak payoff once we get to the much anticipated Martinique.

Still, everyone tells everyone how much they are loved. It’s even more of a mess than I remember. Nevertheless, we have that weirdly prophetic line of Cliff’s in one of the many stupefyingly boring longeurs in Los Gaaaaaaaa-tos: ‘Bobby’s dream has become Pam’s nightmare.’ Quite.
I didn't buy the character of Jack at all and thought he ruined the whole season. The notion that he was an exact doppelganger was a joke and the Martinique intrigue was silly. I also thought the Tony storyline was sickeningly saccharine, and I say that as the mother of a disabled person.
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
no matter what the official records say, I still consider Bobby’s love of emeralds, as well as Jamie’s midseason near-death and late-season almost certain death, to be canon… and also in the “post-dream real world”, though Angelica and her minions didn’t come to Dallas as part of a Dimitri Marinos doppelgänger scheme, they’re absolutely bumbling around somewhere acting “strange and European”
 
Last edited:

Grangehill1

Telly Talk Fan
I’ve always loved the dream season. Yes some of it is absurd but every character has a journey and end up in a different place to where they started the season.

Towards the end there’s a sense of finality about it as if things are coming to an end. JR finally gets Ewing Oil, he and Sue Ellen are happy, the Barnes Ewing feud is over. The show could have finished then.

What I’ve always loved to know is what was the plan if the production team had stayed on into season 10 and Katzman and Duffy hadn’t returned.

The cliffhanger would have been Jock (?) returning but had the writers written themselves into a corner with everything else?

Jamie would have died so would Cliff have turned on JR again?
Sue Ellen would have been injured so would that have caused problems with their marriage?
But where could Pam and Mark go? And JR had Ewing Oil to himself so what would have happened there? And Ray and Donna, happy with their adopted child.

everybody seemed to have been written into a corner in season 9
 

Bobby Southworth

Telly Talk Fan
Top Poster Of Month
I’ve always loved the dream season. Yes some of it is absurd but every character has a journey and end up in a different place to where they started the season.

Towards the end there’s a sense of finality about it as if things are coming to an end. JR finally gets Ewing Oil, he and Sue Ellen are happy, the Barnes Ewing feud is over. The show could have finished then.

What I’ve always loved to know is what was the plan if the production team had stayed on into season 10 and Katzman and Duffy hadn’t returned.

The cliffhanger would have been Jock (?) returning but had the writers written themselves into a corner with everything else?

Jamie would have died so would Cliff have turned on JR again?
Sue Ellen would have been injured so would that have caused problems with their marriage?
But where could Pam and Mark go? And JR had Ewing Oil to himself so what would have happened there? And Ray and Donna, happy with their adopted child.

everybody seemed to have been written into a corner in season 9
I always felt like the later episodes of the dream had a sense of finality.. up until what happened to Sue Ellen in the series finale. I would be curious to know how far in advance they knew it was going to be a dream, and if that's why these episodes were written in this manner. Of course, if they knew much in advance about the dream resolution, would they have still began the Ben Stivers story?

As far as where Mark and Pam had to go. I know I've read speculation that he was going to be killed off, but then you have to wonder..with JR digging into his past, was this going to lead to a new plot, or was this building into him being murdered?
 
Last edited:

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
I agree there was an overriding idea of reconciliation........hence, very little drama.

Yes, there were endless maudlin reconciliation moments -- between characters who either would never normally reconcile, or they reconcile too fast -- because the writers had become bored by their own storylines and didn't know where they wanted to go with those stories. So, by definition, all dramatic tension ceased because the storyline ceased (and ceased in a contrived and perfunctory fashion).

I always felt like the later episodes of the dream had a sense of finality.. up until what happened to Sue Ellen in the series finale. I would be curious to know how far in advance they knew it was going to be a dream, and if that's why these episodes were written in this manner. Of course, if they knew much in advance about the dream resolution, would they have still began the Ben Stivers story?

As far as where Mark and Pam had to go. I know I've read speculation that he was going to be killed off, but then you have to wonder..with JR digging into his past, was this going to lead to a new plot, or was this building into him being murdered?

Katzman wrote several scripts for them during the dream season (and was billed as "creative consultant") but had no power over the plotlines -- until the end of the year when he was tracking the scripts because they knew he was returning to DALLAS with Duffy (and Paulsen). Who knows if he slipped in those "dream"/"nightmare" references himself... Peter Dunne's writing team supposedly came up with the Ben Stivers character, and Katzman liked it and kept him around, renamed him and darkened his hair.

To be fair, nothing Peter Dunne did in the dream season was any worse than the crap Leonard tossed us during the closing years of the show.

And let's face it: when you pointlessly recast the Emmy-winning matriarch of the biggest drama series in global TV history at the peak of its popularity, and then eradicate an admittedly-flawed entire season as "a dream" in one two-minute scene, you've damaged your show's karma irrevocably.

Or, as Susan Howard phrased it, "the audience abused again."
 

Grangehill1

Telly Talk Fan
I always felt like the later episodes of the dream had a sense of finality.. up until what happened to Sue Ellen in the series finale. I would be curious to know how far in advance they knew it was going to be a dream, and if that's why these episodes were written in this manner. Of course, if they knew much in advance about the dream resolution, would they have still began the Ben Stivers story?

As far as where Mark and Pam had to go. I know I've read speculation that he was going to be killed off, but then you have to wonder..with JR digging into his past, was this going to lead to a new plot, or was this building into him being murdered?
I don’t think anyone knew in advance. I always assumed the last episode was delivered and the on the Friday the old team were let go and on the Monday Katzman came back. The first thing he did was shoot the Bobby in shower scene that was tacked onto the last episode.

I don’t think there’s anything in the last eps that indicate it’s a dream.

somewhere out there is the original cliffhanger with Ellie finding out Ben was Jock (which was shot again the next season)
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
don’t think anyone knew in advance. I always assumed the last episode was delivered and the on the Friday the old team were let go and on the Monday Katzman came back. The first thing he did was shoot the Bobby in shower scene that was tacked onto the last episode.

No, that's not what happened.
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
the end of the Dream Season is the first time I recall JR and Sue Ellen acting in any way that wasn’t completely toxic toward one another. The periods in previous seasons when Sue Ellen was on JR’s side — after he was shot and during the battle for Ewing Oil — always read as delusional and very temporary.

This time, though, it was all completely unironic “how was your day, honey?” and “Sue Ellen, I’m scared.” When I made it to the end of the Dream Season a handful of years ago for the first time since it aired, I finally understood, maybe a bit, where all the “JR and Sue Ellen: greatest love affair ever!!” fandom might have come from.
 
Last edited:
Top