How should oldDALLAS have ended?

How should the original DALLAS have ended?


  • Total voters
    19

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
I don't like bad endings so I wouldn't choose any of those. Bobby didn't want to be in the oil business anymore so it would make sense to have Bobby own the ranch and JR own Ewing Oil. That way each of them could be happy.
Most here on Soapchat agree that Conundrum was a horrible way for Dallas to end. There were no happy endings there. We were left with the idea JR had shot himself. I didn't like the "It's a wonderful Life" overtones of the final episode but I do envisage a burnt out JR Ewing doing exactly what he had done by pulling back on the trigger, raising the pistol and leaving us the impression he shot himself. As far as we knew that was it for Dallas. No more.....

.....until the reunion movies and we learnt JR was alive and well and still up to mischief. Granted the reunion movies weren't crash hot either and so we bid farewell to Dallas once again with still no happy ending until.....

.....along comes TNT Dallas. It started off well but soon fell flat when true believers discover this is not Dallas or about the Ewing family but a new show called Mexico with guest appearances from the Ewing family. Did we receive a happy ending? No. We get the incredulous idea from Cynthia Cidre she wanted a dead Ewing to tempt TNT in giving her another season.

Despite Dallas being granted multiple opportunities for happy endings we haven't been afforded that luxury. I don't mind Dallas being given such treatment because we never know if it will be resurrected again.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
Maybe not but it's about giving the audience the ending they want. To give them closure and properly tie up all the loose ends.

I did try to apply some logic to my first post since otherwise I would have put JR/SE back together again and also Ray & Donna. I know that's what most fans wants and I prefer those pairings too. But since the show had put Sue Ellen with Don, Ray with Jenna and Donna with Andrew Dowling I decided to go with those pairings since it seemed more logical they would still be together considering what we'd already seen on the show.
I don't know. Women seem to want their stories to have happy endings. But a lot of us feel a bit cheated because most happy endings tend to feel so forced.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
So seeing tragedy bestowed upon people you like is your idea of great TV?
Absolutely. It's why I tuned in each week. There was something magnetic watching rich people suffer. As Miss Ellie so eloquently put one time; "We may be wrong and we may be right but we're Ewing's we stick together, and that's what makes us unbeatable.

The Ewing family, mostly JR, did not hesitate in turning on each other but GOD forbid if any outsider took on the family.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
There was something magnetic watching rich people suffer.

Seriously? I guess the old adage is right: "You like to hear somebody is doing well but you don't want to hear they're doing better than you."

As Miss Ellie so eloquently put one time; "We may be wrong and we may be right but we're Ewing's we stick together, and that's what makes us unbeatable.

Wow,I just referred to that same scene in my previous post in this thread.. It's a memorable scene!
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
I would have ended the series at the end of the Dream Season, after slightly extending the infamous shower scene to have the man in the shower rip off his 'Bobby suit', revealing himself to be Pam's first husband, Edison Faraday Haynes. Instead of shrieking in horror as the audience would expect, Pam giggles and cackles and joins Ed in the shower. "We finally did it! We finally got rid of Bobby Ewing and that irritating blockhead Mark Graison!", she sneers in a villainous voice.

The scene abruptly cuts to JR and Lucy in the Southfork living room solemnly playing a game of backgammon, with Miss Ellie and Ray in the background playing a mournful concerto on piano and violin, Sue Ellen conducting vigorously. Cliff is in the corner of the room with a football helmet on, attempting to juggle three cats. In the other corner we see both Digger Barneses standing, carefully passing back and forth what appears to be a small walrus.

Harv Smithfield sashays down the staircase in a bathrobe, surveys the scene, and declares it to be “magnificent, simply magnificent.”

The camera pans out and a slick transition reveals we've been watching the slide show projected by the three kidnappers from Season 1 in their shabby hideout, and have been since the beginning of that episode all those years ago. The camera freezes on the one they called Al, and the end credits appear, Philip Capice, et. al., along with the dramatic flourish from the stock music they used in the 'Who Shot JR?' year.

Viewers and critics are so baffled that it's still talked about 30 years later and remains one of the most watched videos on YouTube. Despite persistent rumors over the years of a new Dallas continuation, there has yet to be a follow-up to the original.
 
Last edited:

tommie

Telly Talk Hero
I'm one of the few that are fine with Conundrum, but either way it should've ended with JR getting his well-deserved comeuppance.

If you want you can add a wishy-washy epilogue how JR led out his life on simpler terms, but that wouldn't have been true to his character really.
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I would have ended the series at the end of the Dream Season, after slightly extending the infamous shower scene to have the man in the shower rip off his 'Bobby suit', revealing himself to be Pam's first husband, Edison Faraday Haynes. Instead of shrieking in horror as the audience would expect, Pam giggles and cackles and joins Ed in the shower. "We finally did it! We finally got rid of Bobby Ewing and that irritating blockhead Mark Graison!", she sneers in a villainous voice.

The scene abruptly cuts to JR and Lucy in the Southfork living room solemnly playing a game of backgammon, with Miss Ellie and Ray in the background playing a mournful concerto on piano and violin, Sue Ellen conducting vigorously. Cliff is in the corner of the room with a football helmet on, attempting to juggle three cats. In the other corner we see both Digger Barneses standing, carefully passing back and forth what appears to be a small walrus.

Harv Smithfield sashays sown the staircase in a bathrobe, surveys the scene, and declares it to be “magnificent, simply magnificent.”

The camera pans out and a slick transition reveals we've been watching the slide show projected by the three kidnappers from Season 1 in their shabby hideout, and have been since the beginning of that episode all those years ago. The camera freezes on the one they called Al, and the end credits appear, Philip Capice, et. al., along with the dramatic flourish from the stock music they used in the 'Who Shot JR?' year.

Viewers and critics are so baffled that it's still talked about 30 years later and remains one of the most watched videos on YouTube. Despite persistent rumors over the years of a new Dallas continuation, there has yet to be a follow-up to the original.

So basically, you would have liked for David Lynch to have been the producer for Dallas? I don't know if he would have been available. He was probably saving those types of ideas for his then upcoming series Twin Peaks:

 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
"We finally did it! We finally got rid of Bobby Ewing and that irritating blockhead Mark Graison!", she sneers in a villainous voice.
Oh! Did Pam kill Katherine and replace her with robot-Katherine, programmed to kill Bobby? Maybe they could show her head sitting on a shelf (bleep bleep...must...kill..bleep)
 

Richard Channing

Eternal Member
So seeing tragedy bestowed upon people you like is your idea of great TV? Then what would you call seeing people you like confronted with adversity and battling it, emerging triumphant at the end of the story? Bad TV?

No, that's also good TV. But it's about balance. Just cause I like the Ewings doesn't mean I want to see them win all the time. I like my neighbours and don't want anything bad to happen in their lives, but they're real people. But the Ewings are fictional and watching them go through hard times makes for good drama. Just cause I may like each member of the Ewing family individually and the family as a whole doesn't mean I always want them to come on top. You seem to view them more like a sports team you support, so it's go team Ewing, but I think the whole premise of the show is the trials and tribulations of the Ewing family, not hurrah! the Ewings are happy and have come out on top.

If they were constantly at war with each other, if the Ewings didn't love each other and all they wanted to do is destroy each other, they wouldn't be much of a family would they?

I didn't say they were constantly at war with each other. I said constantly at war with someone, either each other, or their enemies.

When Jock died, JR started to feel like there was no point in going on. What made great TV wasn't seeing Jock's death destroy JR and make him stop caring about everything. What made great TV was seeing JR, with Bobby's help, see that he did have reasons to go on and his son was on of those reasons. It's not the tragedy that makes great TV - it's seeing the Ewings react to tragedy and ultimately rise above the way they felt when the tragedy initially struck. Watching them find a way to deal with the tragedy and persevere, to watch them then continue on despite all the hardship is what made it great TV!

I'm glad you brought that season up because it's a perfect example of how tragedy does make great TV. The season with the battle for Ewing Oil after Jock's death was one of the best seasons ever of Dallas. Yet it saw the Ewing family turn on itself and almost decimate itself. And it was gripping. Those last 4 episodes from when Sue Ellen catches JR in bed with Holly were some of the best episodes ever of Dallas, and why? Because the Ewing family were impolding and leaving a trail of destruction in their wake. The finale which resulted in the fire was great TV and great drama, not because the Ewings were rising above anything or succeeding, it was because everything was falling apart. It didn't matter what happened next season, or if they overcame their obstacles, the family spiraling out of control was riveting drama.
 
Last edited:

ArchieLucasCarringtonEwing1989

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
For me I would have ended DALLAS in 1987 with Pam and Christopher leaving Texas to start a new life elsewhere.

JR married Mandy Winger, Sue Ellen marries Dusty, Donna and Ray stay together while Jenna, Charlie and Lucas relocate to Europe, Lucy returns pregnant with her first child.

However the OP stated that the show still had to end in 1991 so here would be my 1991 ending:

JR runs Ewing Oil and Bobby becomes the sole owner of Southfork.

Cliff and Bobby receive news that Pam did indeed die two years earlier in 1989, as a result the family decide to hold a memorial service for her.

Ellie, Clayton, Lucy, Sue Ellen and Ray all return for this event.

Bobby struggles to deal with her death, knowing he never got to say goodbye properly to her, JR is the one to comfort him, and reminds him that Pam wouldn’t want Bobby to stand still and give up,

The final scene would be of Bobby and Christopher standing by her grave as he tells Christopher about how they met, we then see a montage of old scenes from over the years, as the camera pans away from Southfork for the final time as the Ewing’s embrace the 1990s
 

Toni

Maximum Member
I know that almost everybody still working on "Dallas" at the time just felt the 1990-1991 was gonna be the last year, but I think that, if they had just known it for sure and had been given the opportunity to give it the best closure possible like some shows do nowadays, things might have turned out much better though not perfect.

This doesn´t change the fact that Victoria wouldn´t come back but her storyline might have been dealt with differently, maybe not killing her off the way they did off-screen and giving her the chance to share Christopher´s custody with Bobby (a bit like what TNT "Dallas" tried to do). BBG should have returned at least for a couple of episodes at the end, and the family should have been reunited one more time, including Steve Kanaly, Charlene Tilton and Linda Gray, and even Ted Shackelford. Most of them came back eventually for the "Conundrum" fiasco.

There is a difference between creating a proper, bittersweet ending for such a TV show as "Dallas", and a fanficcy one (like what I made up myself after the end of "Dallas" out of frustration): the first one must give an overall tone of balance and fitting the original show´s. As many of you have said here, "Dallas" wasn´t a story about happy endings, so it actually didn´t ask for one. Funnily enough, other Lorimar soaps did have it (like "Knots Landing" and "Falcon Crest")...

If a soap ends with a happy ending, it´s quite probable it will become a temptation for the producers and / or actors to continue. In the abovementioned series, both cases happened: Knots was perfectly wrapped up but was unnecessarily expanded by the "Back to the Cul-de-Sac" mini-series. Falcon had a last-minute re-tooling to give it a proper ending, maybe because of Jane Wyman´s delicate health. Without her the show had no reason to be so it made sense to put the end at that time.

I agree that the audiences must have what they want, but also that nobody wants a show to end when their characters have achieved what they went for at the end. We always ask for more, therefore it depends (or should) on the producers to decide how and when to finish the story. In the case of "Dallas", everything depended on Leonard Katzman (and then co-producer Larry Hagman). As far as we know, both of them would have went on and on with the show. Lenny did that with his next successful series, "Walker Texas Ranger", and Larry played J.R. three more times after the end: both TVM´s and TNT´s "Dallas".

So it was a complicated situation. Probably CBS did them and us a big favor. In recent re-watchings I found the last season one of the most compelling seasons in the latter years. Why? Because in hindsight, and considering what we might have got, there was a balance between drama and comedy, and at least we could say goodbye to Linda, Steve, and others in the very last episode. You know, when the cancelation was official...

upload_2019-5-12_15-12-55.png​
 
Miss Ellie confesses on her death bed that Digger not Jock is JRs father - always said at the time it would be far better than JR and a devil with red eyes who was in cabaret!

Cue Freeze frame to JR - a shocked JR - and her dying wish is that Barnes and Ewings live in harmony and no more fighting, back stabbing et al!!
 

Michael Torrance

Telly Talk Mega Star
Well, no. If you watch a show that's focused on a family and is a soap opera you want drama and conflict, that's what soaps are all about. Just cause I like the Ewings doesn't mean I don't want to see tragedy and misfortune bestowed upon them, of course I do, cause that's great TV. If I wanted to watch a family with good things happening to them I'd watch the Brady Bunch.

A happy ending doesn't make sense for Dallas because Dallas has never been about happy endings, it's been about conflict, revenge and loss. Yes there were good times and great loves and romances, but almost all ended in misery and separation. So wrapping it all up with a nice bow on it at the end would not feel like a logical and organic conclusion to the story of a family who were constantly at war, either with each other or their enemies.

I posted on a Dynasty thread that I believe a soap opera should not have an ending, happy (awfully contrived) or unhappy (more realistic). We join these characters in medias res, and we leave them the same way. A soap opera is a whole fictional world the show creates, and it should be there before and after, be it in the fans' fantasies (and fan fictions) or in future prequels and reunions and continuations. In that sense, I would have preferred an ending that opens up new story possibilities (such as J.R. finding out he was Digger's) which others can follow, be it on screen or off. Whatever implausible plots and devices a show may use, and Dallas' dream resolution took the cake, I find that is the one principle it should not violate, even if the audience demands it like a spoiled child wants ice-cream before dinner: life is an ongoing river, and so if fictional life. In that sense, Conundrum, while not ideal, left things open ended for the future.
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
Peyton Place did it best
upload_2019-5-12_20-45-49.png

But I also liked Abby's return in Knots Landing's finale scene (the "it's like old times" line was a tad cheesy because the scene itself already suggested it).
 

Canon

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I always liked the idea that Dallas ended with the possibility that JR has killed himself, everything else in the episode leading up that may be not so much.

So basically, you would have liked for David Lynch to have been the producer for Dallas? I don't know if he would have been available. He was probably saving those types of ideas for his then upcoming series Twin Peaks

But David Lynch doing Dallas? Yes please!

Dallas18.jpg
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
A scene from NuDallas that also could have worked to end the last episode.

upload_2017-9-21_18-8-47-png.6323

But I'd have the camera pan out to a wider shot, rather than a freeze frame.
 

Ray_Krebbs

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
J.R. is kidnapped and taken aboard his plane. His kidnapper is revealed to be the real Nicholas Pearce, who has his men throw J.R. out of the plane without a parachute. It all ends with J.R.'s screaming and terrified face as he awaits his comeuppance.
 
Last edited:

Sarah

Moderator Emerita
In some magical way if all the original family could rock back up to Southfork, with JR answering the door and them saying something along the lines of,

"OK F that, we tried it out there. Didn't like it. We're home".

;)
 
Top