How Would Dallas Had Been Different If Jim Davis/Jock Had Lived For Its Entire Run?

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
The obvious one is there would be no fight for Ewing Oil. There probably wouldn’t be a Clayton. At least not in a prominent role.

Would he still rule the Ewing clan with an iron fist as both JR and Bobby got noticeably older?

Jock vs Jeremy Windell would have been something. Remember, Windell and JR became enemies while Jock was still on the show.

I believe as the show went on, he and Ellie would have become recurring characters like Ellie and Clayton did. I can’t imagine Jock going around solving mysteries, but I can see his role being greatly diminished.
 

the-lost-son

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
It‘s always tragic and sad when Jock is sitting in the limousine (ready for his 2nd honeymoon) and telling Punk that“the boys will take care of business“.
Although it was really devastating I think that without the character of Jock, Dallas got its best storylines and overall seasons (4-6/5-7DVD).

Due to Jim Davis failing health the takapa storyline ended abruptly. I wonder if the producers intended a different outcome or if this story arch was intended to be stretched.

It‘s hard for me to think of more storylines for Jock (apart from the ones he got - bypass, marriage problems, sorting out his sons, running EwingOil once more), but at that time the producers managed to produce the best TV ( unrivalled in my opinion). So I‘m sure they would have found storylines, maybe cattle or politics, which would have suited the character.

It‘s still amazing how they pulled this storywriting out of their hats when this major character/actor left the stage.
 
Last edited:

Monzo

Telly Talk Star
I assume sooner or later Jock & Miss Ellie would have gotten divorced because of a younger woman Jock fell in love with it. So maybe there still would have been room for Clayton and a divorced lonely Ellie. There could have been conflict if Clayton still helped Sue Ellen keeping Jock's grandson from the Ewings.

I wouldn't be surprised if many seasons later Jock would have been thrown together with Jenna, because writers would always find a way to keep Priscilla Presley on the show.
 
Last edited:

Jock's Ghost

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
haha. Ugh. I didn't mind PP, but Jenna was mostly garbage. Had they not screwed up bobbys death and Resurrection, she could might have fit in somewhere.
 

tommie

Telly Talk Hero
I think we would've seen a far darker side to him than we got post-humously. JR got his attitude from somewhere, which the Takapa storyline showed.
 

Michelle Stevens

'The Lovely Michelle'
I'm of the opinion that if Jim Davis had lived and portrayed Jock until the series end in 1991 that his legacy would have surely been diminished by the writers. I believe that one of the reasons Jock was held in such esteem by many is that we only had him for the first quarter or so of the series and for the most part he was never written doing anything too far out of character, besides him briefly separating from Ellie over Takapa. There was always a mystery to Jock and his early exit kept that generally intact.
 

tommie

Telly Talk Hero
I'm of the opinion that if Jim Davis had lived and portrayed Jock until the series end in 1991 that his legacy would have surely been diminished by the writers. I believe that one of the reasons Jock was held in such esteem by many is that we only had him for the first quarter or so of the series and for the most part he was never written doing anything too far out of character, besides him briefly separating from Ellie over Takapa. There was always a mystery to Jock and his early exit kept that generally intact.
I agree and in all honesty, even if we ignore the dire later seasons, it was obvious with Takapa that the writers were open to explore the darker side of Jock's personality. It's fairly obvious JR didn't get to be the way he was because Jock only talked about fluffy kittens. Or for that matter that Gary was such a damn alcoholic - it wouldn't at all surprise me if there would've been more of a tie-in there if Jim hadn't passed away.
 

Jabari Lamar

Telly Talk Fan
I don't know, but I don't think the show would have been as good. I know this seems kinda cruel to say but in retrospect I honestly think that Jim Davis' death was one of the best things to happen to the show. With Jock there firmly in charge of the family and the company many of the great storylines that came from the fights afterward never would have happened, including many of J.R.'s best schemes. Jock being dead and being a symbol, a legacy, for his sons to fight over and try to live up to was better, storywise, than having him actually be there as a living person.
 

DallasFanForever

Telly Talk Supreme
It is sad to say but I would have to agree that Jock’s death definitely contributed to the show’s success. His death and the subsequent terms of his will cast such a huge shadow over the show and changed the lives of so many characters forever. As much as I hated losing Jock so early in its run, it really did benefit the show long term. So many great scenes from those glory years would’ve never even happened.
 

Jock Og

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
Jock's death was a real shot in the arm, for the primarily oil based Texas saga. As sad as Jim loosing his cancer battle was it provided TPTB to utilise Jock post death to drive epic stuff, from late 1981 right through to the mid decade. Had Jim / Jock not went to oil fields up in the sky then supposedly the divorce from Ellie would have materialised; from Takapa versus D.O.A running the course.

I would like to have watched more scenes between Jock, Punk Anderson and Pat Powers. Those three up against Jeremy Wendell could have been interesting T.V. Of course with J.R.'s daddy still around the eldest Ewing offspring just might not have been able to build on his iconic role, to the same extent. Can you imagine that? No doubt there would have been funny scenes with the patriarch and Rebecca Wentworth, then later Lady Jessica Montford.


J.R. goes into Jock's office, looks around his desk and then stands looking at his father's infamous portrait, (a scene from season 4; DVD-5, 1981 - '82):

"I'm sorry daddy! I let you down. I just flat give up. Back there at the swamp you were gone. It was all over. It didn't seem like there was anything left going on for me. I almost forgot. You left us something. You left us the company. You built Ewing Oil from the ground up and whatever it took you did it for Ewing Oil.

I am going to do the same. I am going to pass it bigger and stronger to my son. I'm back Daddy! Nobody is going to take Ewing Oil away from me; or my son or his son." As J.R. finally glances at Jock's portrait he remarks:

"I swear to you, by god, I'm going to make you proud of me!"

Freeze frame; fade to black, the closing credits and the theme tune blasts out over Southfork.
 

Chris2

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Echo everyone else’s comments. The death of the Ewing patriarch (separate from the sad death of Jim Davis) drove so much story. One of my favorite episodes is “Head of the Family,” the episode that has Bobby trying to hold the family together while JR and Ray are struggling with coming to terms with Jock’s death. There’s a very clever pivot at the end when JR realizes that he will now build the business for his son (as opposed to his father) and JR retains the motivation for his deeds. I also like the scene in the bedroom where JR says, “It’ll never be the same, Bob.” One of the few times I feel sorry for him.
 
Top