How Would You Have Prevented The Demise Of Dallas?

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
You get called up to take the position of these producer of Dallas at the start of season 9 - the dream season. As the person running the show, how would you try to stop Dallas from beginning it's downhill slide? You've just lost one of your three biggest stars. What steps do you take to see to it that doesn't hurt the success of the show?

I would bring William Smithers up into the main cast - a greater adversary for Ewing Oil than Cliff ever was. Feature him regularly and then you have the Ewings fighting someone who not only wants to put them out of business but has far greater ability to pose a threat than Cliff ever did.

Wendell was vastly underutilized. I'd make him, instead of Cliff, the Ewing's main rival. William Smithers did an amazing job of portraying Jeremy Wendell. He'd pose a whole new set of problems than Cliff had. Wendell was smarter than Cliff, more experienced than Cliff, and ran a bigger company than Ewing Oil.

That puts the Ewings in the position of the underdogs, which would work well with having JR mature and grow as a human being, becoming a more ethical, better man. That would give JR an interesting character arc.

The one weakness of the JR character was that he really never had a character arc. You could say stripping him off his competency and having him make dumb decisions was a character arc but I wouldn't; I'd call it bad writing.

Since Bobby has just died, that gives JR the impetus to reassess his life and make a definitive decision that he wants to become a better man. He'd have a difficult time making the changes he wants to make, which would make for a good story. The struggle of him being tempted to be the way he always has been, but to ultimately make the rational decision that he will have a better life if he stops being that way and starts treating people better.

Here's a character that they used to advertise as "the man you love to hate." That was because the audience found certain qualities in him likable, but still hated a lot of the things he did. So now you have a character the audience always wanted to like but had mixed feelings about liking because of his treatment of others, his underhanded schemes and tactics. As JR goes through a period of personal growth and betters himself, the audience now feels justified in liking him and he becomes a more popular character than ever. There's nothing people like better than seeing a good story of a man in search of redemption and finding it.

This change in JR makes it possible for him and Sue Ellen to finally have a chance to have a successful marriage and even have more kids. I'd have them have another child, a daughter, because I always thought it would be interesting to see how JR would raise a girl.

Seeing JR and Sue Ellen continue to constantly fight had gotten old; something needed to be done. Personally, I'd have been tempted to have JR divorce Sue Ellen, gain sole custody of John Ross since he was the parent who was actually functional, and marry Mandy. But it's not about what I want to see, it's about what I think the fans would want to see, and for some reason they liked Sue Ellen, so keep her, have her and JR begin rebuilding their marriage into something good and have a daughter.

I would not offer Patrick Duffy the chance to return. If Larry Hagman asks me to bring him back as a favor I'd tell him, we can't make a mockery of the show just so you can have your friend back on the show - he's an adult and he's made a decision. We made plans around that decision and we're sticking to our lo range plans. Without vision you perish.

Pam is now in a position where she has been given the role of watching over Christopher's share of the company until he becomes an adult. She and JR and Jeremy Wendell are the three people at the center of the conflict now. That makes it interesting because you have JR and Pam, neither of whom naturally like the other, having to learn how to effectively work together to fight off Jeremy Wendell and Westar.

Since JR was the way he was for so long, he'd still have the ability to be devious and even cruel when it's needed - when protecting his family and company from Jeremy Wendell. He would be capable of doing certain things that someone like Pam wouldn't be able to do, and wouldn't know how to do, although she'd admit they're necessary actions.

This is actually a much better way to show virtue - to show that while JR has the capacity to act that way, and while he's often tempted to act in a malevolent way, he chooses not to be that kind of man anymore except in situations where the safety of his family or his company are threatened. You could say Gary was virtuous because he never hurt anyone but that's not virtue because Gary couldn't hurt anyone if he tried; he's like a rabbit or some other harmless little animal. It's having that ability to be a monster and even the temptation to be one, but using one's own volition to consciously choose not to that is virtuous. That's what's so impressive and admirable.

I'd have Westar buy Cliff's company (Cliff's one condition for selling is he gets to still run his company while answering to Jeremy) so that Cliff would still be an adversary to the Ewings and he would still be pulling that divisive crap he always did with Pamela. Since Jeremy is now Cliff's boss, Jeremy has a real headache with having to oversee Cliff. Seeing Wendell as Cliff's boss and seeing the endless amount of frustration a man as goofy as Cliff would cause a man as serious as Wendell would be comedy gold. I wouldn't actually have it played as straight comedy, but just as the type of comedy Dallas always had to some extent.

This also keeps Pam somewhat "in the middle" because she has a loyalty to Christopher and Bobby's memory, but she also loves Cliff and he's fighting for the other side - for their enemy. Cliff would no doubt try to convince Pam to come over to their side and he might even make a convincing argument to Pam, which makes her have a tough time deciding whether she should listen to Cliff, or do what she thinks Bobby would have wanted - help protect Ewing Oil - the legacy his father left him and the legacy he wanted to leave for his son.

I'd keep John Beck and bring him up into the main cast. He played Mark Graison very well, and in Bobby's absence, Pam would need some romantic interest, so who better than Mark for that?

Sue Ellen wouldn't be fighting with JR anymore so she'd have to have something to do. As her marriage to JR improves I'd have her ask JR to teach her the oil business. He could put her in some sort of position she would be suited for, maybe public relations, and then she could interact with Pam at work as well. They'd both be learning the business together - Pam out of loyalty to Christopher and what Bobby left him, and Sue Ellen out of a desire to have a better understanding of what JR does for a living and to help him in any way she can.

I'd have Ray and Donna stay together, and work out their problems, they'd have Margaret, but remain married. Again, it's about what I'd think the fans would want and they seemed to like Ray and Donna as a couple. Ray would still struggle with his self-esteem and I'd bring in Punk Anderson in a bigger role as sort of a father figure to Ray. He'd help Ray with that and do for Ray more or less what Jock would have if he had lived longer. I thought Morgan Woodward as Punk was very good and there was a friendship between Ray and Punk that they never saw through to its full potential which they now would.
 
Last edited:

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
These are excellent ideas, Kenny! This would have kept Dallas fresh.
I would have also had more of Pam and JR going head to head at the office. What she lacked in oil know-how she could make up(to a degree) in sheer determination and courage.
I would have also had Donna give birth to the Down's Syndrome baby. I know this is controversial, but I think Dallas could have done it in a tasteful way, as they did previous unheard of(at that point) plots.
It would have been a bold move and it would put a human face on people with Down's Syndrome. Dallas did it with gays, alcoholics, and those with breast cancer. They could do it with those with Down's Syndrome.
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
These are excellent ideas, Kenny! This would have kept Dallas fresh.
I would have also had more of Pam and JR going head to head at the office. What she lacked in oil know-how she could make up(to a degree) in sheer determination and courage.
I would have also had Donna give birth to the Down's Syndrome baby. I know this is controversial, but I think Dallas could have done it in a tasteful way, as they did previous unheard of(at that point) plots.
It would have been a bold move and it would put a human face on people with Down's Syndrome. Dallas did it with gays, alcoholics, and those with breast cancer. They could do it with those with Down's Syndrome.

Thanks Jimmy! As for Pam and JR - I didn't go into it in any detail, but when I said:

She and JR and Jeremy Wendell are the three people at the center of the conflict now. That makes it interesting because you have JR and Pam, neither of whom naturally like the other, having to learn how to effectively work together to fight off Jeremy Wendell and Westar

I was envisioning plenty of tense moments between the two of them as they engage in the process of learning how to work together in a productive manner. I certainly think there would be times when Pam when say:"This doesn't sound right to me" and then they'd argue it out, with JR sometimes convincing her a particular move was crucial, and sometimes Pam would have to prevail, where she'd hear JR out and then say: "I think we can achieve that in a more ethical way." She'd proceed to present her idea and JR would grudgingly admit she had a good idea so OK, they'd go with her idea.

I think in that type of relationship it would be important for JR to let Pam win sometimes, to agree to use her ideas (as long as it made sense). It's not entirely unlike a man-woman romantic relationship where the man can't always expect to have his way, sometimes he's got to let her "win", let her decide what they're going to do, if she's going to feel like a successful woman and be happy in the relationship. Just like we want to feel like successful men, they want to feel like successful women. If either side tries to just run right over the other and not give an inch, the other will feel resentful after a while and it will lead to unhappiness and likely a break-up. Each side has to be able to have some give and be open for some compromise.

Re: the Down's Syndrome storyline you would have stuck with - I think it would be risky. There's a chance that just as you say, it would have put a face on people with Down's Syndrome and be a bold move. I don't know if the general public would have found it too depressing - that would be my concern. Dallas is primarily escapist entertainment people use to forget about their problems for a while and enjoy the show. If your "escape" is dealing with children with those serious type of problems, would the fans feel it was a downer? I don't know. I realize they went into some very heavy issues, but those were with adults dealing with those issues. To see a child dealing with such a heavy issue -I think it would have been a little too much, but maybe not - it would be bold! In this current time I don't think it would be too much, but back then, it's my gut instinct that the mainstream public weren't quite ready to have their escapist entertainment include a child with Down's Syndrome.
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
A few key points:

1: Clearly Victoria had made her mind up to leave so it is unlikely she could have been persuaded to change her mind. However, full consultation with her in terms of her exit storyline perhaps might have made her more open to a return.

2: Do whatever it takes to retain Linda, Donna, Steve and Charlene - and others like William Smithers.

3: Quarantine the newbies (Michelle Stevens, Tommy McKay, Granny Beaumont and Rose McKay, the standout performers in utter awfulness) to Antarctica.

Swami
 

Augustus355

Telly Talk Newbie
I would’ve kept the show more about business deals and relationships rather than the personal relationships. The relationship between Ray and Jenna ruined both those characters. They were unbearable to watch together. Sue Ellen and Nicholas Pierce was the cheesiest relationship and equally as unwatchable. Bobby and Tracey would’ve ruined both those characters. The best episodes that ran after season 8 were about business deals. The dynamics between Wendell/McKay/J.R. and Bobby were great.
 

lbf522

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I agree in regards to Nicholas Pierce who was an arrogant jerk and them making him a mobster was silly. I was glad when JR threw him over the bannester. I agree bringing Patrick Duffy back would not have been my idea either. They killed Bobby onscreen and there would have been no way to bring him back realisticly.

I liked the dream season. I liked JR and Jack's relationship as well as JR and Cliff ending the Barnes-Ewing feud. Loved Cliff and Jamie being close and JR being the patriarch of the Ewing Family.

What I would have done is yes I agree that Jeremy Windell would have been a good enemy for the Ewings to fight. Someone to give them a real battle.
 

Seaviewer

Telly Talk Warrior
Victoria had made her mind up to leave so it is unlikely she could have been persuaded to change her mind.
How much of her decision was based on the downgrading of her character after Duffy's return? A year of a strengthened Pam battling JR at the office might have made for a different outlook on her part.
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
I agree in regards to Nicholas Pierce who was an arrogant jerk and them making him a mobster was silly. I was glad when JR threw him over the bannester. I agree bringing Patrick Duffy back would not have been my idea either. They killed Bobby onscreen and there would have been no way to bring him back realisticly.

I liked the dream season. I liked JR and Jack's relationship as well as JR and Cliff ending the Barnes-Ewing feud. Loved Cliff and Jamie being close and JR being the patriarch of the Ewing Family.

What I would have done is yes I agree that Jeremy Windell would have been a good enemy for the Ewings to fight. Someone to give them a real battle.

Getting rid of Wendell was another bad mistake.

Swami
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
How much of her decision was based on the downgrading of her character after Duffy's return? A year of a strengthened Pam battling JR at the office might have made for a different outlook on her part.

Well they wouldn't have been battling each other, per se, since they weren't in a contest between each other like Bobby and JR were (which was a highly unnatural situation). Pam and JR would have been working together to make Ewing Oil maintain its success. Pam was given the job of overseeing Christopher's shares until he became an adult, since they were his shares but he was a child. Pam wanted to leave Christopher a successful company, and JR wanted to leave John Ross successful company. Their goals were both to leave Ewing Oil in good shape for their sons, so it's not as if they'd have been battling - they would have been working together to achieve the same goal.

Pam and JR would have had to have learned to work together and that would have been fun to see - how do these two very different personalities learn to co-exist?

If you want to apply the word "battle" to the situation, the battle would have been for the two of them to figure out a way to put their personality differences aside and work together peacefully in a productive way for the good of the company and the for the good of their sons.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Getting rid of Wendell was another bad mistake.

Swami

Wendell had such a different type of personality from anyone else in the show - very cold and calculating. It was very tough to make him show any emotion, especially to make him show he was upset, since he always tried to appear to have no vulnerabilities.

That's why I came up with the idea of Wendell buying Cliff's company, under Cliff's single stipulation that he still got to run that company and have Jeremy as his boss. Cliff and Wendell were absolutely nothing alike! Seeing the headaches a man as goofy and impulsive as Cliff would have caused Jeremy would have been very entertaining to watch. To say Cliff would have tested Wendell's patience is an understatement!

Hey @Lastkidpicked , I haven't seen you weigh in on this thread yet - I'd be interested to see what you think! Whether you agree or disagree with the ideas I lay out in the OP, either is fine with me, I just want to see what you have to say about it and to find out what further ideas you may have to contribute - how would you have prevented the demise of Dallas under the conditions specific in the opening post? You usually come up with a different perspective than I or anyone else has in these types of things, so I'm curious to see what your ideas are!
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
Wendell had such a different type of personality from anyone else in the show - very cold and calculating. It was very tough to make him show any emotion, especially to make him show he was upset, since he always tried to appear to have no vulnerabilities.

That's why I came up with the idea of Wendell buying Cliff's company, under Cliff's single stipulation that he still got to run that company and have Jeremy as his boss. Cliff and Wendell were absolutely nothing alike! Seeing the headaches a man as goofy and impulsive as Cliff would have caused Jeremy would have been very entertaining to watch. To say Cliff would have tested Wendell's patience is an understatement!

Hey @Lastkidpicked , I haven't seen you weigh in on this thread yet - I'd be interested to see what you think! Whether you agree or disagree with the ideas I lay out in the OP, either is fine with me, I just want to see what you have to say about it and to find out what further ideas you may have to contribute - how would you have prevented the demise of Dallas under the conditions specific in the opening post? You usually come up with a different perspective than I or anyone else has in these types of things, so I'm curious to see what your ideas are!

I'm not sure if Wendell would have entertained that, he saw how easily Cliff's emotions clouded his judgement.

Swami
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Great idea for a thread, Kenny!

May I offer a historical perspective around the last few years of Dallas?

1979: After many years of prosperity, we are in the middle of a recession. Times are tough and nobody seems to have any answers. Nothing is getting done.
And along comes Dallas, with it's powerful and wealthy family and multi million dollar deals. And J.R. Ewing who, agree with him or not, he gets things done. This could get interesting!

Early 1980s: We enjoy watching J.R. as he schemes to get over on his enemies and build Ewing Oil into an even more powerful empire. His underhanded antics are "must see TV" on Friday nights. And the cliffhangers! It becomes cool to stay in on Friday nights to see what will happen next.

BUT. . .

Mid to late 1980s (The time we are talking about now):
The rich are getting richer, and the working class people are suffering for it. Wealthy companies are buying each other and laying off workers by the thousands. The top CEO's are handing each other million dollar bonuses while cutting the pay of the working folks who built the company. In 1987 Gordon Gekko announces "Greed is good". To the rest of us, "No, greed is NOT good!"

Suddenly, watching J.R. destroy people's lives to make a few extra dollars is not good entertainment.

So, if you are a writer on Dallas, what do you do?

You set up an enemy for J.R. where his usual schemes won't work

William Smithers did an amazing job of portraying Jeremy Wendell. He'd pose a whole new set of problems than Cliff had. Wendell was smarter than Cliff, more experienced than Cliff, and ran a bigger company than Ewing Oil.

Here is what makes Jeremy Wendell such a great adversary for J.R-- The usual moves that J.R. makes are powerless against Jeremy.

--Blackmail him by threatening to go to his bosses with some dirt?
Won't work. Jeremy is CEO of Weststar. He IS the boss.

-- Put him in a compromising position with a call girl?
So what? Jeremy is single. Nobody would care.

-- Bribe him?
Won't work. Jeremy already has plenty of money.

So J.R.'s usual tactics are nothing but a nuisance to Wendel. In fact, I love when Jeremy has that slightly exasperated, "Oh, hello J.R." tone. It drives J.R. crazy!
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
you guys might be on to something with Wendell - perhaps even more so than I am with my 'bring back Ames and Garr' strategy.
I had a picture flash into my mind of Guzzler standing on a street corner holding up a banner saying "Bring back Ames and Garr".
 

Sarah

Moderator Emerita
I find your defence of JR as the functional parent extremely odd - Sue Ellen always put John Ross first in ways JR never did. Sue Ellen for the most part was a wonderful mother - they both were. To say JR is the ‘functional’ parent is both wrong and really unfair.

And this thing you have about him marrying Mandy. Why would you want him to marry someone who in Deborah Shelton’s own words was a ‘manipulative homewrecker’? You talk a lot about the sanctity of marriage @Kenny Coyote - so why would you want this to happen? JR would not treat Mandy ANY differently than he did Sue Ellen. You seem to have rose tinted spectacles when it comes to Mandy - she was full of her own importance and was having an affair with a married man. It’s a bit hypocritical.

The JR and SE dynamic can’t be matched for chemistry and entertainment. Marrying JR with Mandy would doom Dallas to the one thing you say in your title you are wanting to avoid. Just look what happened to the show once JR started his affair with Kimberley. As I have always said and maintain, parting JR and Sue Ellen permanently led to Dallas’ demise.
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
The JR and SE dynamic can’t be matched for chemistry and entertainment.
This is very true. Whether they are teaming up against outsiders or whether they are fighting each other, J.R. and Sue Ellen have always been the heart of the show. Plus, Larry Hagman and Linda Gray play off each other very well.
 

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
I would've stopped Philip Capice from leaving & giving Leonard Katzman total authority on the show.

Both of them should've been joint Executive Producers.

I really feel Dallas worked best when both these guys where producing the show. :)
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I find your defence of JR as the functional parent extremely odd - Sue Ellen always put John Ross first in ways JR never did. Sue Ellen for the most part was a wonderful mother - they both were. To say JR is the ‘functional’ parent is both wrong and really unfair.

And this thing you have about him marrying Mandy. Why would you want him to marry someone who in Deborah Shelton’s own words was a ‘manipulative homewrecker’? You talk a lot about the sanctity of marriage @Kenny Coyote - so why would you want this to happen? JR would not treat Mandy ANY differently than he did Sue Ellen. You seem to have rose tinted spectacles when it comes to Mandy - she was full of her own importance and was having an affair with a married man. It’s a bit hypocritical.

The JR and SE dynamic can’t be matched for chemistry and entertainment. Marrying JR with Mandy would doom Dallas to the one thing you say in your title you are wanting to avoid. Just look what happened to the show once JR started his affair with Kimberley. As I have always said and maintain, parting JR and Sue Ellen permanently led to Dallas’ demise.

JR is the functional parent, notice the emphasis on the word "the." Sue Ellen is a sometimes functional parent. You cannot count on her, can't depend on her because you never know if she'll be able to think rationally or be drunk out of her mind. Hell, she even drank while pregnant! I'm not just talking about a sip or two of wine- she drank copious amounts of alcohol while pregnant.

"Marrying JR with Mandy would doom Dallas to the one thing you say in your title you are wanting to avoid." - Maybe so, but you'll notice, having them marry was not part of my plan. I said I considered it and decided against it - deciding to keep JR and Sue Ellen married.

You prefer that JR and Sue Ellen stay married. In light of that, you could have responded to me in one of two ways: You could have agreed with my decision to keep JR and Sue Ellen or ignored that and focused in what I said I wouldn't do.

You chose the latter. Why would you focus primarily on what I said I would not do instead of on what I said I would do?

Seems to me you're just looking for a fight. Then go and find yourself a fight. Just know it won't be with me.
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
In honor of this thread, I did a rewatch of the last few seasons and was pleasantly suprised! I'm even going to claim that some of the episodes have the flavor of the early years.

If you watch the episodes surrounding the Range War, you will see there is some good writing and good acting. And they payoff is great!

To refresh your memory:

George Kennedy, who was famous for his role in Cool Hand Luke, appeared on the show.
MV5BYjM0N2Q5MTQtOTY5OC00MDE5LWFiNGMtMmJiZDc2ZTc2ZTdkXkEyXkFqcGdeQXVyMjUxODE0MDY@._V1_.jpg


In Dallas, Kennedy played Carter Mckay, who bought Ray's ranch. This led to some wonderful acting (quiet and underplayed acting) by Kennedy and and Howard Keel as the two were instant friends.

images


upload_2020-3-19_13-39-14.jpeg

Then we discover that Mckay is not what he first appeared to be. A range war breaks out that involves actual shooting and even killing(!).

We are treated to a great line by Miss Ellie. It is suggested that "The women and children" move off Southfork until the range war is over. Miss Barbara Bel Geddes delivers her powerful line, "There is no force on heaven or earth that can move me off Southfork."

We discover who is backing Carter Mckay, and the decision is made that not even the Ewings can fight this new enemy. Miss Ellie decides to give up section 40, and the family agrees.

Then, the payoff! I won't post it here in case you want to watch it fresh, but the episode is "The Sting" and while some parts are a bit over the top, the actual sting and the payoff are well worth it.

It's a fun episode. Or as @Kenny Coyote would say,

"It was a helluva ride!"
 
Last edited:
Top