How Would You Have Prevented The Demise Of Dallas?

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
I read this and was wondering what caused you to miss that particular season. Is that the only season you haven't seen or are there any others you haven't seen?

I might have seen a snippet or two as a kid, but the last story line I remember at all was Wes Parmalee. As an adult I watched the early Jock years out of curiosity, then watched the excellent middle years after discovering Soapchat. I watched the Dream Season a couple of months ago. I remember seeing Angelica Nero and Sue Ellen hitting rock bottom as a kid, but not much else.

I'm on the West Coast in coronavirus lockdown mode here, and have been binging the later years for fun - with low enough expectations, I'm finding it enjoyable. I just watched the range war episodes yesterday! I still haven't seen anything past the first half of season 12... the untherfit sa eating Tommy McKay just arrived and I'm looking forward to Michelle and James and the rest of the parade of latter-season lowlights I mainly know from Swami's ABC characterizations!
 
Last edited:

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
I might have seen a snippet or two as a kid, but the last story line I remember at all was Wes Parmalee. As an adult I watched the early Jock years out of curiosity, then watched the excellent middle years after discovering Soapchat. I watched the Dream Season a couple of months ago. I remember seeing Angelica Nero and Sue Ellen hitting rock bottom as a kid, but not much else.

I'm on the West Coast in coronavirus lockdown mode here, and have been binging the later years for fun - with low enough expectations, I'm finding it enjoyable. I just watched the range war episodes yesterday! I still haven't seen anything past the first half of season 12... the untherfit sa eating Tommy McKay just arrived and I'm looking forward to Michelle and James and the rest of the parade of latter-season lowlights I mainly know from Swami's ABC characterizations!

Range war storyline wasn't bad, the only drawback from that was it paved the way for the exit of Wendell. But the arrival of the newbies will not fill you with delight, I can confidently predict.

Swami
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
Range war storyline wasn't bad, the only drawback from that was it paved the way for the exit of Wendell. But the arrival of the newbies will not fill you with delight, I can confidently predict.

Swami

I don't know, having just witnessed a shirtless Tommy McKay chugging and smashing a bottle of booze on the Southfork balcony and screaming like Stallone in Rambo after being turned down by April, I have to say it works pretty well as absurdist farce for brief moments!

gikZyWU.png

yhtesao.png


I can't imagine how disappointing and frustrating it must have been to see this nonsense as a long-time Dallas fan as it originally aired, though.
 
Last edited:

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I'm on the West Coast in coronavirus lockdown mode here, and have been binging the later years for fun - with low enough expectations, I'm finding it enjoyable. I just watched the range war episodes yesterday!

@Taylor Bennett Jr. Without giving anything away, have you seen the suprise sting from the range war? When the family gathers to sign section 40 over to Carter Mckay?

I love it! Classic Dallas even in the later years.
 
Last edited:

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
@Taylor Bennett Jr. Without giving anything away, have you seen the suprise sting from the range war? When the family gathers to sign section 40 over to Carter Mckay?

I love it! Classic Dallas even in the later years.

yep, I've been plowing through this season at an alarming rate!

(faster than JR plowing a field at Haleyville, anyway!)

(edit: oh good lord, now Clayton has amnesia!)

(edit 2: 'Granny' Beaumont appears!)
 
Last edited:

Michael Torrance

Telly Talk Mega Star
As Homer wrote, fate decides one's death, but we decide how we face it. The changing landscape of TV and society in general, diluting the importance of broadcast networks and the single TV set around the living room, together with the natural fatigue that sets in after years, were entropic forces no show, no matter how popular, could withstand. But it could have chosen to go out with dignity.
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
yep, I've been plowing through this season at an alarming rate!

(faster than JR plowing a field at Haleyville, anyway!)

(edit: oh good lord, now Clayton has amnesia!)

(edit 2: 'Granny' Beaumont appears!)

You will do plenty of fast-forwarding any time you see Granny Beaumont, Tommy McKay and Rose McKay - on balance they are the three absolute worst.

Swami
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
You will do plenty of fast-forwarding any time you see Granny Beaumont, Tommy McKay and Rose McKay - on balance they are the three absolute worst.

Swami

I found Tommy McKay more convincing than James.

I don't know, having just witnessed a shirtless Tommy McKay chugging and smashing a bottle of booze on the Southfork balcony and screaming like Stallone in Rambo after being turned down by April, I have to say it works pretty well as absurdist farce for brief moments!



I know Tommy McKay gets a lot of flack for not being believable, badly acted, whatever you want to call it, but I'll put it this way: You'd like to think that a guy getting that upset over being turned down would be absurd, but I've spent enough time in nightclubs to know that there are people who after drinking half a fifth of Jack Daniels will absolutely act that crazy, and over even less.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
I agree there should have been development in JR’s character and this could have provided a better relationship between him and Sue Ellen, more like the role Jock and Miss Ellie had once played in the family (but then they’d need more family than just John Ross) - and a lot of good story telling to get there. And I like the more children idea, especially a daughter. I didn’t even have an issue with JR having an older child (or children), if they choose better actors and wrote a better story.

I also agree with Wendell and a bigger role as the enemy, maybe even the Ewing’s as somehow the good guys, one of those trying to fight off the “greedy” corporate managers trying to take over and gut everything.

And I agree, I’d have loved to seen more of the Andersons, and no reason they couldn’t have had children and grandchildren. I’m sure they did.

The dream was ridiculous and they were better off ending the show then going the route they did, IMO. But I never bought Pam as a rival to JR not do I think I’d buy her as even a reluctantly ally. I also didn’t buy that Bobby would set it up so she would control Christoper’s share of EO, almost a cruel idea for Bobby to do. While not as dramatic as the idea of a “family” business, by this point in a family’s legacy, they’re more apt to diversify and walk away from the business - realistically speaking. For me, by this point I was done with the in fighting of the family and did not buy the Pam involved in business thing.

I would have suggested Clayton miss the Southern Cross and buys it back. He leaves and Miss Ellie goes back and forth as a reoccurring character, turning over the South Fork house to JR and protecting the land, establishing the Ewing Foundation, which would give Sue Ellen more to do.

I would suggest character development for JR, much as you suggest, becoming the head of the family, more like his father, improving things with Sue Ellen and having more children. He’d also need his family’s support to keep control of EO.

I would have Chris’s EO shares in the hands of a professional trust fund manager who sells them to West Star for top dollar and diversifies the money. I’d have Pam and Christopher make a happy exit into the sunset, maybe a role on Knots Landing.

I’d have Wendell help Katherine with her defense and marry her. He’d then help her contest her mother’s will to end up bankrupting Cliff and Pam - before committing Katherine to a sanitarium. Pam thus would be a single working mom trying to raise her son, who happens to be very rich.

I’d have Wendell bring Donna into West Star as a top paid lobbyist, straining her and Ray’s marriage and actually have Ray and JR form a sort of friendship. Donna would end up stuck in the middle between JR and Wendell.

Wendell then would go after other EO shareholders around JR - the idea would be to step by step get closer to the big battle with JR.

I’d introduce Anderson children and grandchildren, other Wendell’s and maybe even children of JR from before he even married Sue Ellen.

Just ideas. But I do think all good things must end.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
But I never bought Pam as a rival to JR not do I think I’d buy her as even a reluctantly ally. I also didn’t buy that Bobby would set it up so she would control Christoper’s share of EO, almost a cruel idea for Bobby to do.

I fully agree Pam couldn't have been a rival to JR because she just didn't have the expertise and skill to do it, nor did she have the love of the business he had. I would have had Pam working with JR, and put them both in the difficult position of having to learn to get along and work together productively to fight off Westar. The idea I had for that was even though Pam didn't have the capability and expertise JR had, just the fact she would have controlled Christopher's 30% would have made it so although she couldn't outdo JR, she could block some of his ideas by voting against them, leaving them at a standstill unless they learned to put their personal differences aside and work together for the good of the company and the good of their sons, who would be there successors one day. They'd both be motivated to leave heir sons a vital company.

That being said, it did seem somewhat out of character for Bobby to leave Pam with the huge responsibility he did. I'd still have him do it because of the unique situation it would have put Pam and JR in which could make for some interesting storylines and entertaining scenes.

It is almost cruel of Bobby, but would make for such good TV that I can overlook it. You're idea is more based n realism than mine and that's good too. I like realism and the only thing about your I'd hesitate to do is to put Christopher's shares with someone who would sell his shares to Westar. Jock was adamant that nobody but a Ewing should ever own Ewing Oil, so I would want to keep the company completely in the Ewing family.

My idea called for Cliff to end up seeing his company to Wendell so on one side you have Wendell and Cliff and n the the other JR and Pam. I'd certainly have Cliff do his best to persuade Pam to sell Christopher's shares to them, to get rid of the stress f controlling hem and to secure Christopher's financial future. Pam would be torn between that and doing what she knew Bobby wanted. I'd have Pam ultimately decide that while the idea of selling to Westar was tempting because it would make life easy for her and get a huge amount of money for his shares, she'd decide some things are more important than money - such as giving Christopher the opportunity to one day run Ewing Oil, just as Bobby had gotten the opportunity to run his father's company.


I’d have Wendell bring Donna into West Star as a top paid lobbyist, straining her and Ray’s marriage and actually have Ray and JR form a sort of friendship. Donna would end up stuck in the middle between JR and Wendell.

I like that idea a lot! It's very unique and full off interesting possibilities. It would create excellent drama for Ray and Donna's marriage. He'd hate the idea of her working for Westar and she would hate the idea of him becoming friends with JR! That's my favorite of the new ideas you had, even though others such as the ones with Wendell and Katherine are good too.
 
Last edited:

Toni

Maximum Member
As Homer wrote, fate decides one's death, but we decide how we face it. The changing landscape of TV and society in general, diluting the importance of broadcast networks and the single TV set around the living room, together with the natural fatigue that sets in after years, were entropic forces no show, no matter how popular, could withstand. But it could have chosen to go out with dignity.

peggy.jpg

Miss Piggy always tells me that. All the time...​
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
I fully agree Pam couldn't have been a rival to JR because she just didn't have the expertise and skill to do it, nor did she have the love of the business he had. I would have had Pam working with JR, and put them both in the difficult position of having to learn to get along and work together productively to fight off Westar. The idea I had for that was even though Pam didn't have the capability and expertise JR had, just the fact she would have controlled Christopher's 30% would have made it so although she couldn't outdo JR, she could block some of his ideas by voting against them, leaving them at a standstill unless they learned to put their personal differences aside and work together for the good of the company and the good of their sons, who would be there successors one day. They'd both be motivated to leave heir sons a vital company.

That being said, it did seem somewhat out of character for Bobby to leave Pam with the huge responsibility he did. I'd still have him do it because of the unique situation it would have put Pam and JR in which could make for some interesting storylines and entertaining scenes.

It is almost cruel of Bobby, but would make for such good TV that I can overlook it. You're idea is more based n realism than mine and that's good too. I like realism and the only thing about your I'd hesitate to do is to put Christopher's shares with someone who would sell his shares to Westar. Jock was adamant that nobody but a Ewing should ever own Ewing Oil, so I would want to keep the company completely in the Ewing family.

My idea called for Cliff to end up seeing his company to Wendell so on one side you have Wendell and Cliff and n the the other JR and Pam. I'd certainly have Cliff do his best to persuade Pam to sell Christopher's shares to them, to get rid of the stress f controlling hem and to secure Christopher's financial future. Pam would be torn between that and doing what she knew Bobby wanted. I'd have Pam ultimately decide that while the idea of selling to Westar was tempting because it would make life easy for her and get a huge amount of money for his shares, she'd decide some things are more important than money - such as giving Christopher the opportunity to one day run Ewing Oil, just as Bobby had gotten the opportunity to run his father's company.




I like that idea a lot! It's very unique and full off interesting possibilities. It would create excellent drama for Ray and Donna's marriage. He'd hate the idea of her working for Westar and she would hate the idea of him becoming friends with JR! That's my favorite of the new ideas you had, even though others such as the ones with Wendell and Katherine are good too.

Thank you. To me with out Bobby there was no place for Pam. So I would have just got rid of her in a positive way. That’s my opinion and I know not everyone shares it. I also know Jock wanted the company to stay in family hands but it’s unrealistic in most cases and I’m always terribly bothered when a show gets so unrealistic - to me that’s when it jumps from drama to soap. Plus a third of EO in Wendell’s hands automatically makes JR the good guy trying to save his father’s business. Reality here as well, usually these company’s fair better when they bring in outsiders to run them, like with Walmart. The family stays involved but not day to day. Jock attempting such was foolish, but he certainly isn’t alone in such a fools game. It makes for great drama.

I’m sure they were too terrified to get rid of VP as they just lost Bobby, but I felt over all it would have better focused the show on stage 3 (stage 1 up until Jocks death and stage 2 up until Bobby’s).

Also if they insisted PD return I’d have him return as Jack and Jamie’s older brother or some sort before I’d wipe out a whole season. Just another idea.
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
As Homer wrote, fate decides one's death, but we decide how we face it. The changing landscape of TV and society in general, diluting the importance of broadcast networks and the single TV set around the living room, together with the natural fatigue that sets in after years, were entropic forces no show, no matter how popular, could withstand. But it could have chosen to go out with dignity.

Homer may have written that, but not Homer Simpson, who's still on TV after debuting around the time Dallas was undergoing its decline!

9ad964da003de43d377b4fd179f45312.jpg
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
It was one of those moments when you realise that your fav TV show since 1978 is going down the pan!

I actually laughed at that scene as the acting was so bad but i did expect him to turn green and morph into the Incredible hulk

image-asset.jpeg

Which was the thing you thought was bad about the acting, that he got so angry, or that his acting wasn't convincing enough that he really looked angry?

I always thought it was the script's fault, that they told him to do that. If Patrick Duffy's script had asked him to do the same thing, I don't think he would have looked any more convincing doing the same thing, but I'm curious to see what you think.

I think the big mistake they made with that character , Tommy, is that when he came home with the shorter haircut, he acted completely different-he didn't seem like the same guy anymore. I found his acting convincing playing the first persona, but not convincing playing the second persona.
 
Last edited:

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
It was one of those moments when you realise that your fav TV show since 1978 is going down the pan!

I actually laughed at that scene as the acting was so bad but i did expect him to turn green and morph into the Incredible hulk

image-asset.jpeg

His "acting" was so utterly chronic, it defied belief. The closest both the actor and the character of Tommy McKay will ever get to being the toast of the town is sunburn.

Swami
 
I would also have kept Phil Capice as Exec Producer as Dallas worked best with both him and Katzman and I wouldnt have given Larry Hagman so much control or money.
 
Top