I don’t see how Bobby in any way was responsible for Rebecca’s death

Chris2

Telly Talk Dream Maker
What in the world was Rebecca doing, trying to keep JR from getting the refinery? She was poking her nose into someone else’s business. She was acting all high and mighty for someone who abandoned her young children to a drunken murderer. And Pamela was ridiculous for blaming Bobby.
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
Cliff was far more responsible, if he had been fighting his own battles instead of sending his mother to do it.

Swami
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
What in the world was Rebecca doing, trying to keep JR from getting the refinery? She was poking her nose into someone else’s business. She was acting all high and mighty for someone who abandoned her young children to a drunken murderer. And Pamela was ridiculous for blaming Bobby.

I’d say it was Pam’s own quilt over the situation which lead her to blame Bobby. She too backed her brother’s stupid fight against the Ewing’s, a fight her mother got dragged into. She then found herself for the first time independently wealthy, with money which certainly belonged more to Katherine than her and Cliff.
 

pete lashmar

Telly Talk Addict
Bobby was in no way responsible for her death, but Pam saw it all as a bigger picture.

But let's face it, Rebecca was just the worst parent wasn't she? She leaves her young children, never ever making contact, even though they are both in the public eye and well known.

She spends time with Pam, making a bond, but always seem to want to know Cliff more. She does everything for Cliff and Pam is kind of left out a bit.

Then she dies and these 2 people she's known for just a year or 2 get two thirds of everything - poor Katherine just gets a 3rd and she's known her all her life.

Rebecca was just the worst.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
What in the world was Rebecca doing, trying to keep JR from getting the refinery? She was poking her nose into someone else’s business. She was acting all high and mighty for someone who abandoned her young children to a drunken murderer. And Pamela was ridiculous for blaming Bobby.

When people who had no business getting involved in the contest for Ewing Oil started interfering in it, that was like putting gasoline on a fire. There was nothing good that was going to come from Rebecca or Donna or Ray getting involved in it and it only ended up hurting anyone who stuck their nose in something that was none of their business.

Miss Ellie's fear was that Bobby and JR competing would tear the family apart, which was kind of silly because we'd seen the two of them be very competitive with each other from the start of the show. Did you notice how Bobby could just punch people out whenever he felt like it and never had to suffer any consequences for it? Ellie should have taken a look at that. If Bobby's parents hadn't taught him that it was entirely unacceptable to physically attack family members just because he'd never learned to control his temper, that was their shortcoming as well as Bobby's. The idea that Ellie had this idyllic, peaceful family that was somehow going to be ruined by a business contest showed how oblivious Ellie really was.

Rebecca was just the worst parent wasn't she? She leaves her young children, never ever making contact, even though they are both in the public eye and well known.

She spends time with Pam, making a bond, but always seem to want to know Cliff more. She does everything for Cliff and Pam is kind of left out a bit.

Then she dies and these 2 people she's known for just a year or 2 get two thirds of everything - poor Katherine just gets a 3rd and she's known her all her life.

Rebecca was just the worst.

Rebecca was the worst, just an atrocious mother. I don't know how a woman can abandon her children. She even left them in the care of a drunk!

I don't know any way she could have made up for all those years of depriving them of a mother. To leave them out of the will would just have made matters worse.

Katherine never complained about not getting enough money and I can see why. She'd been the only one to have had the benefit of actually having parents and then to want all the money too? Even Katherine didn't try that. That would have been really pathetic.
 
Last edited:

pete lashmar

Telly Talk Addict
That would have been a great storyline actually @Kenny Coyote - Katherine fighting the will - especially knowing what Cliff is like with money and power - and where would Pam have fitted in, what would she have done...? But too repetitive after Jock's will.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
That would have been a great storyline actually @Kenny Coyote - Katherine fighting the will - especially knowing what Cliff is like with money and power - and where would Pam have fitted in, what would she have done...? But too repetitive after Jock's will.

That would have taken things in a different direction, but my God, Katherine would have looked so pathetic, wanting more than half a billion dollars and not even having the sense to realize that Pam and Cliff had been deprived of a mother while they were growing up. Leaving Pam and Cliff their fair share of her money was the least Rebecca could have done at that point.

Rebecca was already the worst mother ever, to have expected her to not only deprive Pam and Cliff of growing up without a mother, but to then also expect Rebecca to have also deprived them of their fair share of the will, that would have been really awful.
 

pete lashmar

Telly Talk Addict
That would have taken things in a different direction, but my God, Katherine would have looked so pathetic, wanting more than half a billion dollars and not even having the sense to realize that Pam and Cliff had been deprived of a mother while they were growing up. Leaving Pam and Cliff their fair share of her money was the least Rebecca could have done at that point.

Rebecca was already the worst mother ever, to have expected her to not only deprive Pam and Cliff of growing up without a mother, but to then also expect Rebecca to have also deprived them of their fair share of the will, that would have been really awful.

But as a viewer and a fan I would have loved to see that! Also, we would have got to see everyone finally react to Katherine, which we really didn't get. Katherine was a great character but in my opinion was never utilized to her full potential. Katherine Vs Pam could have been fantastic TV, with Cliff doing everything he could to keep all that money.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
But as a viewer and a fan I would have loved to see that! Also, we would have got to see everyone finally react to Katherine, which we really didn't get. Katherine was a great character but in my opinion was never utilized to her full potential. Katherine Vs Pam could have been fantastic TV, with Cliff doing everything he could to keep all that money.

It could have been a lot of fun. To see a woman be that greedy and become just as hated as you'd imagine she'd become could have worked well. I think there was certainly a lot more they could have done regarding Katherine vs Pam. All that build-up just a slap to the face? Yeah, I think they could have gone further with it. I'd just hope that at some point Bobby would actually treat Katherine the way she needed to be treated, instead of just letting her go and taking her at her word that she'd turn herself in.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
Bobby was in no way responsible for her death, but Pam saw it all as a bigger picture.

But let's face it, Rebecca was just the worst parent wasn't she? She leaves her young children, never ever making contact, even though they are both in the public eye and well known.

She spends time with Pam, making a bond, but always seem to want to know Cliff more. She does everything for Cliff and Pam is kind of left out a bit.

Then she dies and these 2 people she's known for just a year or 2 get two thirds of everything - poor Katherine just gets a 3rd and she's known her all her life.

Rebecca was just the worst.

I’d only add, and it appears 100% of that money was created by Katherine’s father. Shame he didn’t protect it better.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
When people who had no business getting involved in the contest for Ewing Oil started interfering in it, that was like putting gasoline on a fire. There was nothing good that was going to come from Rebecca or Donna or Ray getting involved in it and it only ended up hurting anyone who stuck their nose in something that was none of their business.

Miss Ellie's fear was that Bobby and JR competing would tear the family apart, which was kind of silly because we'd seen the two of them be very competitive with each other from the start of the show. Did you notice how Bobby could just punch people out whenever he felt like it and never had to suffer any consequences for it? Ellie should have taken a look at that. If Bobby's parents hadn't taught him that it was entirely unacceptable to physically attack family members just because he'd never learned to control his temper, that was their shortcoming as well as Bobby's. The idea that Ellie had this idyllic, peaceful family that was somehow going to be ruined by a business contest showed how oblivious Ellie really was.



Rebecca was the worst, just an atrocious mother. I don't know how a woman can abandon her children. She even left them in the care of a drunk!

I don't know any way she could have made up for all those years of depriving them of a mother. To leave them out of the will would just have made matters worse.

Katherine never complained about not getting enough money and I can see why. She'd been the only one to have had the benefit of actually having parents and then to want all the money too? Even Katherine didn't try that. That would have been really pathetic.

I disagree. It was obviously Katherine’s Father who created the money. And there were hints that she was up set, statements like Cliff a d her father’s company. In fact more than likely Herberts estate would have been trust to protect it from taxes, but such would have also protected it for her only child. Now if Rebecca sine his was part of the work of creating this fortune, I might agree a d certainly as his spouse is entitled to something, even something she can pass on, but what she did is out of the norm, and would not be expected of the way such vast estates are managed. Pathetic was taking a share of man’s money from your sister, whether she complained or not.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
It could have been a lot of fun. To see a woman be that greedy and become just as hated as you'd imagine she'd become could have worked well. I think there was certainly a lot more they could have done regarding Katherine vs Pam. All that build-up just a slap to the face? Yeah, I think they could have gone further with it. I'd just hope that at some point Bobby would actually treat Katherine the way she needed to be treated, instead of just letting her go and taking her at her word that she'd turn herself in.

More than likely she would have won, at least more than 1/3. What would have made sense is for JR to tell her this and use her to take everything from Cliff and Pam - a missed opportunity of great drama and realism. It’s unlikely a court would allow Rebecca to give 2/3’s of Herbert’s estate to Rebecca when Herbert didn’t know about these children and would have expected 100% to go to his daughter. You speak as if Rebecca created this fortune. More than likely the estate would have been in a trust (which would explain a lot we saw on TNT as well as with Miss Ellie suddenly giving 1/2 of South Fork to John Ross).

Now I’ll agree Rebecca should have left something to her children and even her creating BarnesWentworth was understandable, but simply because Katherine is unlikable doesn’t mean she would be greedy for expecting to inherit her father’s money. I for one would not have found her greedy. Pathetic yes - but got other reasons, including allowing these two to take 2/3s of her fathers estate.

Now if the two, Herbert and Rebecca, had known about this and agreed, we’d have a different situation (they could have even provided secret children if Herberts). Often blended families find a compromise similar to an even split. I can tell you I have experience with this with my father’s mother’s estate and my father’s estate, both including blended families, one including a court case and the other a greedy sibling. It is also very dependent on state law and there could be some peculiarities In Texas law which could have proven interesting. But I strongly disagree with Rebecca being greedy for fighting for her fathers money against two people she barely knew.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I disagree. It was obviously Katherine’s Father who created the money. And there were hints that she was up set, statements like Cliff a d her father’s company. In fact more than likely Herberts estate would have been trust to protect it from taxes, but such would have also protected it for her only child. Now if Rebecca sine his was part of the work of creating this fortune, I might agree a d certainly as his spouse is entitled to something, even something she can pass on, but what she did is out of the norm, and would not be expected of the way such vast estates are managed. Pathetic was taking a share of man’s money from your sister, whether she complained or not.

Is there even one scene where Katherine says she resents Pam for getting the money her mother gave her?

Yes, it was obvious that Herbert made a lot of money. It's also obvious he couldn't take it with him when he died, so what's the point? It wasn't his money anymore after he died. He chose to leave it to his wife. His decision. He could have left it, or part of it, to Katherine but chose not to. Maybe he had a reason for not leaving Katherine money. It's not too hard to think of some reasons why he might have decided not to, is it?

Was there anyone who felt bad for Katherine because she only got about half a billion dollars?

There weren't a whole lot of people watching Dallas every week hoping the show would get into the details of how "vast estates are managed" or wanted to see them get into "How will we protect out vast estate from taxes? How do we get around the tax laws? Should we put it into a trust"? I know there are some people who would find that entertaining, but it's a little niche audience. The vast majority of the Dallas audience would have found that type of content about as entertaining as having a root canal.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Pam had a very bad habit of blaming the Ewing’s for anything that went wrong in her family. Rebecca got just as obsessed with the Ewing’s as Cliff did. It wasn’t Bobby’s or JR’s fault she got in a plane just to stop JR.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
Is there even one scene where Katherine says she resents Pam for getting the money her mother gave her?

Yes, it was obvious that Herbert made a lot of money. It's also obvious he couldn't take it with him when he died, so what's the point? It wasn't his money anymore after he died. He chose to leave it to his wife. His decision. He could have left it, or part of it, to Katherine but chose not to. Maybe he had a reason for not leaving Katherine money. It's not too hard to think of some reasons why he might have decided not to, is it?

Was there anyone who felt bad for Katherine because she only got about half a billion dollars?

There weren't a whole lot of people watching Dallas every week hoping the show would get into the details of how "vast estates are managed" or wanted to see them get into "How will we protect out vast estate from taxes? How do we get around the tax laws? Should we put it into a trust"? I know there are some people who would find that entertaining, but it's a little niche audience. The vast majority of the Dallas audience would have found that type of content about as entertaining as having a root canal.

What it is, is realism vs. soap opera fantasy. When it was good, early on, it made an effort to be real. The writers didn’t have to go into details to still be accurate. TNT didn’t go into details at all, but it’s handling of Rebecca’s estate had more realism without mentioning the word trust. In fact I think people would have bought what TNT did better if they had mentioned the word trust. But early on people were entertained and the story didn’t have to go into fantasy to do it. So as the writers took more liberties the audience dwindled, it wasn’t a matter of the audience knowing the details, it was a matter of the effort to tell a real story about a wealthy family verses the carelessness of a soap. Maybe you’d have like a UFO siting too.

I don’t recall Katherine being up set with Pam but she was with Cliff getting any part of her father’s company, and rightfully so in my opinion. As far as we know, Herbert expected Rebecca’s only heir was Katherine so he had no reason to say otherwise, and you can be sure that’s exactly what her lawyer would have said if she’d had fought for her rightful inheritance. We just don’t know as the writers didn’t flush out a lot of details. I for one do feel bad for Katherine in regards to this a d it’s not about the size of them money. To go from an only child to having Pam and Cliff for siblings, then to loose her mother and have to share with them (though she wasn’t such a great catch as a sibling herself). You might not feel bad for her, and that’s fine, but more than likely precedent would have been on her side, so a great deal of American society would have been on her side regarding the estates of Katherine and Rebecca.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I don’t recall Katherine being up set with Pam but she was with Cliff getting any part of her father’s company

Cliff wasn't getting a part of her father's company at that time. He was only getting a job there then - not ownership.

When it was good, early on, it made an effort to be real.

Season six wasn't good?

I for one do feel bad for Katherine in regards to this a d it’s not about the size of them money.

Very few would feel bad for Katherine knowing the type of woman she was. You have a different way of looking at it and there's nothing wrong with that, but for a TV show to try to appeal to a tiny portion of their audience instead of the rest would be a terrible decision.

I can think of plenty of reasons why Katherine's father wouldn't have thought it would be a good idea for her to be given a lot of money. Had he wanted to leave her some of the money he instead left to Rebecca, he could have, but chose not to. What does that tell you?
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
Cliff wasn't getting a part of her father's company at that time. He was only getting a job there then - not ownership.



Season six wasn't good?



Very few would feel bad for Katherine knowing the type of woman she was. You have a different way of looking at it and there's nothing wrong with that, but for a TV show to try to appeal to a tiny portion of their audience instead of the rest would be a terrible decision.

I can think of plenty of reasons why Katherine's father wouldn't have thought it would be a good idea for her to be given a lot of money. Had he wanted to leave her some of the money he instead left to Rebecca, he could have, but chose not to. What does that tell you?

I said early on, not season 6.

“Very few would” - you have a very bad habit of speaking for what you seem to think is the silent majority instead of speaking just for yourself.

When the show attempted a realistic story, even without diving into the minutia, it appealed to a massive audience. When it took on an unrealistic nature, as you’re supporting here, its audience actually dwindled - in fact the further from believable it got the smaller it’s audience got. The terrible decision was to leave a credible story for sloppy, sensational ideas. Herbert’s wishes tell me nothing because we don’t know what they were; you’re just guessing. I can guess too. He set up a trust which Rebecca ignored - and my guess is actually more believable than yours.

While we disagree on the impact such a story line would have had on the characters, I do agree “It could have been a lot of fun.” I believe if done well it could have made Katherine a more sympathetic character (despite your representation of the silent majority), and thus give an entire new twist to the story, energizing new life into show when it needed it most, even show a depth to Katherine which went beyond the naive, Bobby obsessed child and showed a very capable and intelligent adversary to JR, the Ewing’s in general, and even the Barnes. But much like with Wendell they took at great opportunity with a (potentially) competent adversary and just watched them wimpier away.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I said early on, not season 6.

“Very few would” - you have a very bad habit of speaking for what you seem to think is the silent majority instead of speaking just for yourself.

I'm not speaking just for myself; I'm basing it on my observations of what people said about the show. Who else besides you is saying six wasn't good?

Herbert’s wishes tell me nothing because we don’t know what they were; you’re just guessing. I can guess too. He set up a trust which Rebecca ignored - and my guess is actually more believable than yours.

We don't have to guess because we saw the reading of Rebecca's will. Clearly, Herbert willed all of his company to Rebecca. He could have willed some of it to Katherine but chose not to. There is nothing that indicates he left Katherine a trust Rebecca ignored. That's sheer speculation on your part.

I believe if done well it could have made Katherine a more sympathetic character (despite your representation of the silent majority), and thus give an entire new twist to the story, energizing new life into show when it needed it most, even show a depth to Katherine which went beyond the naive, Bobby obsessed child and showed a very capable and intelligent adversary to JR, the Ewing’s in general, and even the Barnes

That people didn't see Katherine as sympathetic isn't my opinion; it's my observation of what other people say about her. She tried to seduce her own sister's husband. She wrote a fake letter to help split up Pam and Bobby. Those aren't things that endear her to people.

Think about what you're saying about your idea making Katherine more sympathetic. Pam and Cliff end up growing up deprived of a mother, but as some consolation Rebecca at least left them what she did in her will. Then Katherine tries to take away the money Rebecca gave to Pam and Cliff and you think the fans would be cheering for Katherine? Really?
 
Top