If Bobby was a jock in high school...

Sarah

Moderator Emerita
Who was JR? Obviously I didn't go to school in America, but I'm sure the 'types' that guys and girls fit into in school are similar across the board. I see JR as a popular hunk, who the impressionable ladies of a certain class were after. Maybe some of the ones who knew they didn't have a chance fancied him anyway, and although the cheerleaders fawned over him, he wasn't really into cheerleaders.

I think I started thinking about this after watching 13 Reasons Why....All the jocks and hunks in it have my heart racing! :p
 

ArchieLucasCarringtonEwing1989

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
You should watch RIVERDALE @Sarah, that's based on the American comic series THE ARCHIE COMICS, its probably a bit more cheerful than 13 REASONS,

But still set in a stereotypical All American high school, I highly recommend it.

Bobby in high school, I imagine him wanting to fit in with the hippies, given his birth date of 1949, he would be class of 1967, however seeing as he'd want to fit in with his more conservative father and older brother I think he would become a jock with a heart.
 

Presea

Telly Talk Addict
Who was JR? Obviously I didn't go to school in America, but I'm sure the 'types' that guys and girls fit into in school are similar across the board. I see JR as a popular hunk, who the impressionable ladies of a certain class were after. Maybe some of the ones who knew they didn't have a chance fancied him anyway, and although the cheerleaders fawned over him, he wasn't really into cheerleaders.

I think I started thinking about this after watching 13 Reasons Why....All the jocks and hunks in it have my heart racing! :p
Since this was from Ultimate Dallas, I don't take it very seriously since they say stuff that was never referenced to in the show, but it mentions that Sue Ellen was a varsity cheerleader. Lol. I imagine that JR didn't want anything to do with the more curious bookwormy intellectual type back in college or high school. That and ones were also/or into things like working on student government issues or the newspaper. He wanted people-pleasers. Maybe he didn't like a lot of other cheerleaders, but I could see him sleeping with a lot of them. I'm sure he was a huge hit at fraternity parties. Lol.
 

Sarah

Moderator Emerita
Well Bobby was definitely a jock, it's obvious, but Sue Ellen was nevvvvvvvvvvvvver a cheerleader. No way.
 

Presea

Telly Talk Addict
Well Bobby was definitely a jock, it's obvious, but Sue Ellen was nevvvvvvvvvvvvver a cheerleader. No way.
Cheerleading gets sort of a nasty stereotype in the US now, and it doesn't necessarily equal slutty, bitchy, or dumb. I think it might have been different back in the 60s, but the only way I see Sue Ellen being one then was if Patricia had told her to do it in order to increase social standing or something. The Ultimate Dallas site says some things that weren't mentioned on the show and sound more like what a fan believes to have happened. It did say that Sue Ellen had a degree in French. Although it was never mentioned on the show what she studied in college, this actually sounds like it could have been true since I see her as maybe an English major or something else like that. It would have been interesting if we got more details in the show about the characters' past like that. But the part about her becoming super popular and begged to join every sorority in her freshman year by basically being...shy and just smiling a lot is totally unrealistic. In real life, you don't get popular by barely talking to people and just being pretty. It just doesn't work that way. Trust me, I know.
 

Justine

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
It would appear I'm in the minority but I could TOTALLY see Sue Ellen as a cheerleader. In fact, I think she'd be the head cheerleader and the captain of the debate team and the president of the book club and the lead in the school play and whatever else she could possibly be the absolute best at so she could please Patricia and be the ultimate all-rounder. With that said, I don't think for a minute she would have been comfortable as such a prominent character in school but that's the wonderful element of Sue Ellen's personality; that she will always put herself under pressure to be perfect and liked.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
Linda was perfect casting as she looked exactly like a '60s beauty contestant (not that the 1982 videotape with 42 year old Gray as a 21 year old Sue Ellen wasn't pushing it a bit).

Cheerleader? Maybe not. Drill team? Yes, absolutely.

critique-dallas-episode-95-anniversary-1.jpg


I mean, at least put her in a dark gown so her waistline looks younger...
 

Justine

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
Linda was perfect casting as she looked exactly like a '60s beauty contestant (not that the 1982 videotape with 42 year old Gray as a 21 year old Sue Ellen wasn't pushing it a bit).

Cheerleader? Maybe not. Drill team? Yes, absolutely.

So, I had to search what a drill team even was (because, up until now, little British me had never heard of it before) but, yeah, I can see Sue Ellen as part of that.
 

Toni

Maximum Member
I don´t see JR as the popular boy, at least it´s not what "The Early Years" seemed to hint (which, after all, was David Jacobs´ take on that...). All of us, I guess, think of a younger JR as one looking exactly as Major Nelson. But I´d say that he had a few personal issues, maybe difficulty to pass all the exams without daddy´s influence, a tendency to overweight before to becoming an adult (he certainly had it in his forties), or the jealousy of Bobby´s (and Gary´s!) success with ladies. JR might try to compensate for it with the most expensive cars, the biggest Stetsons, or using the BBQ´s to become popular by inviting his favorite female schoolmates.

images

About the cheerleaders' thing, JR would probably go for the easiest girls, with no discrimination or compromise from him. And Sue Ellen, well, I can´t see her being a cheerleader either. I can hear Patricia saying "what a common thing to do for a future socialite like you, darling". I envision Sue Ellen as more shy, of course snobbish, and probably already developing a double personality of "trophy wife" (with claws painted in red) and "troubled, potentially alcoholic woman" (the show did specify that she first got drunk in her prom ball).

images


"I think I´m a bit tipsy now...ooops!"
​
And, honestly, Bobby also would have a dichotomy in him: the perfect son for both his parents who always did what they wanted, and the "little big man" who wanted to be a knight in a white horse (which he obviously achieved when he married the ever-dependent, ever-lovely Pammy). That naive, sweet, also lovely Bobby who I´d say bonded more strongly with young foreman Ray Krebbs (his then-unknown half-brother) than with JR or Gary.

images


"Oh my God. I´ve seen the most beautiful woman in the world!
It´s that actress in the afro who´s filming "Earthquake"!"

​
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
Cheerleading gets sort of a nasty stereotype in the US now, and it doesn't necessarily equal slutty, bitchy, or dumb. I think it might have been different back in the 60s,
It was. It was totally different.

Along the same lines, in the '50s and early-'60s, male sports achievers could easily appear in the high school drama club play, and no one thought anything about. After that, however, that was pretty much universally seen as loser-nerdy and absolutely homo.

Why did that change, one wonders?

64cheer.jpg
 

Toni

Maximum Member
Yeah your comment, @tommie, made me think of this:

And yeah too: cheerleaders have changed a lot with times...

 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Who was JR? Obviously I didn't go to school in America, but I'm sure the 'types' that guys and girls fit into in school are similar across the board. I see JR as a popular hunk, who the impressionable ladies of a certain class were after. Maybe some of the ones who knew they didn't have a chance fancied him anyway, and although the cheerleaders fawned over him, he wasn't really into cheerleaders.

I think I started thinking about this after watching 13 Reasons Why....All the jocks and hunks in it have my heart racing! :p

I would say that J.R. would have been popular in high school because of his charisma. Whether you like him or you don't like him you can't deny he was charismatic. He would have been that way in high school too because it's something that's an innate quality. You can't learn to be charismatic - you either have it or you don't.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
I would say that J.R. would have been popular in high school because of his charisma. Whether you like him or you don't like him you can't deny he was charismatic. He would have been that way in high school too because it's something that's an innate quality. You can't learn to be charismatic - you either have it or you don't.
No, you can learn to be charismatic. Enough for people to buy it. Charm can be a science.

JR seemed to have a lot of insecurity, especially about holding a party no one comes to, or that everybody leaves. He might not have been the most successful highschool kid.

So he learned to over-compensate.

4ead159c4f1636ee3d0557542196d25b.jpg
 

tommie

Telly Talk Hero
JR was probably "Pleasantly Plump" in High School... but it's also where he mastered sociopathic tendencies (that he learned from Jock).
 
Top