If Dallas Had Taken A More Positive Approach

Herofan

Telly Talk Active Member
You're absolutely right. Patrick Duffy insisted that Bobby have a definitive death scene. I've gotta think that at least part of that was his idea to motivate himself to work harder on achieving his next goal, to become a movie star. There is a temptation to not go all out when you know you have a plan B. It's an escape plan for when things start getting tough. Then you know: "I don't have to make this work because I have a safety net."

I don't believe in operating that way. I don't believe in "plan B." It makes failure very likely. Without a plan B you have no choice but to eventually succeed. No matter how many times you fail you must continue to move in a forward direction towards achieving your goal.

Patrick Duffy decided to come back to Dallas after less than a year of going after his goal. That worked out for him only because they decided to go to such extreme lengths as to say an entire season never happened and kill the credibility of their show so that he got his plan B anyway. It worked out alright for him because they did that for him. What if they hadn't? How much more motivated would he have been to do whatever was necessary to make his plan A work? Extremely.

Was Patrick Duffy getting offers right and left while on Dallas? Did he have some promising things on his plate when he left Dallas, or did he just assume his phone would be ringing when he left? It didn’t take him long to decide it wasn’t a good career move.
 

Seaviewer

Telly Talk Warrior
They could have also had Bobby wake up to some very different situations and we as the viewers gradually learn what happened and what led up to them. Maybe Ewing Oil is gone. Maybe Pamela has moved away from Dallas.
That would have at least avoided the rehashing of some of the plot elements already introduced but the cardinal sin is still the erasure of a year.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Was Patrick Duffy getting offers right and left while on Dallas? Did he have some promising things on his plate when he left Dallas, or did he just assume his phone would be ringing when he left? It didn’t take him long to decide it wasn’t a good career move.

As far as I know, he was not getting offers right and left while on Dallas and he assumed his phone would be ringing when he left. I would think he also went looking for work after he left. He didn't look for long before he decided he wanted to come back to Dallas. Had Dallas not been willing to construct the whole idea of the dream season, had they said told Patrick Duffy they weren't willing to damage the credibility of their show by bringing back a character the audience had seen die in no uncertain terms, then like it or not, Patrick Duffy would have been forced to either continue pursuing his goal of becoming a movie star, or accept work he would have found much less appealing.

Dallas probably thought they were doing Duffy a favor by going to such extreme lengths to make it possible to bring Bobby back, but they were killing their show's credibility in the process. They weren't doing themselves any favors and I don't necessarily know that they ended up doing Patrick Duffy a favor.

It's a pity that the people running Dallas weren't willing to proceed in the way they had planned, once Patrick Duffy told them he was leaving permanently. I believe the end result would have been that Dallas would have been better off without the embarrassment of saying "it was all a dream" and that Patrick Duffy would likely have realized his dream of becoming a movie star. Instead of everyone going all out in the direction they'd planned, they all failed to commit to their decisions.
 

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
@Kenny Coyote made a very interesting point about the fact that what was happening in the 1970s set the stage for viewers to want a character like JR. I was in grammar school at the time, but from what I have read most of that decade seemed to embrace the "sensitive man," typically played by Alan Alda. JR was, of course, anything but that.
It would make sense to me that with all the frustrations that Kenny mentioned, the recession, oil crisis, and especially the humiliating Iran hostage situation, that people would be yearning for someone to come along, grab the bull by the horns and get things done.
This raises another question: What amount of unethical or immoral behavior will people tolerate in someone who "gets things done?" History has shown us peope will accept quite a bit. However, when ot comes to a television character who we watch religiously, when does he or she crosss that line where people are turned off? Would people have been appalled by JR at the beginning of the decade?
JR certainly did appalling things, but I have to admit the two scenes that bothered me the most are quite different. The first is what he did to Laurel. This just seemed to cross the line into inhuman behavior. Why exactly I don't know, since JR did other really terrible things. For example, when he had men steal baby Lucy right out of teenage mom Valene's arms, that was heartbreaking, but it also provided a lot of depth to the backstory of four characters, six of you include Jock and Ellie. That act also revealed the family dynamics, which were so integral to our fascination with the Ewings and it provided a motive, albeit a weak one, for JR to do that. However, the Laurel incident was just cruelty for the sake of cruelty.
The second scene that was cringeworthy to me was when that Halleyville sheriff had the audacity to visit JR at Ewing Oil and threaten him. This was when I wanted to see JR unleashed and rip that sheriff apart, turn Halleyville into a parking lot, and make the sheriff spend the rest of his days collecting the money from the meters for the Ewings. JR, true man of action, reduced to letting this clown threaten him??? Oh, no. Just no.
I think my point is that JR could be unethical and at times downright evil, but he still had qualities you could respect, and he was, ironically one of the most likable characters ever on t.v. imho. That either says something about the writing, the acting, the time period, or me.
 

CeeCee72

Telly Talk Star
@Jimmy Todd That Laurel thing bothered me too. Very much.

JR had done so many horrible things, but always before there was some REASON (even if it was a bad one). He raped Laurel. And for what? He had his choice of beautiful women. There was no reason for him to do that other than he COULD.

And before anyone points out that he had "forced" Sue Ellen in "Black Market Baby" she clearly consented at the end of that scene. And yes, he blackmailed her back into his bed by setting up Peter, but he never forced her (he came up to the line before a phone call interrupted him, but when they finally had sex she was a willing participant).
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
@Kenny Coyote made a very interesting point about the fact that what was happening in the 1970s set the stage for viewers to want a character like JR. I was in grammar school at the time, but from what I have read most of that decade seemed to embrace the "sensitive man," typically played by Alan Alda. JR was, of course, anything but that.

I believe JR was a reaction to it. The response was so overwhelmingly positive that it makes me think people had to be tired of seeing of seeing the "sensitive man" as you described it and were ready for something very different. Having a character like JR Ewing get that much screen time and having all the other characters on the show continually talk about him was a big risk. It was something that hadn't ever been proven to work before.

It would make sense to me that with all the frustrations that Kenny mentioned, the recession, oil crisis, and especially the humiliating Iran hostage situation, that people would be yearning for someone to come along, grab the bull by the horns and get things done.
This raises another question: What amount of unethical or immoral behavior will people tolerate in someone who "gets things done?" History has shown us peope will accept quite a bit. However, when ot comes to a television character who we watch religiously, when does he or she crosss that line where people are turned off? Would people have been appalled by JR at the beginning of the decade?

It was an example of a perfect moment in time. The right actor was in the right place to play the right character for that particular time. I don't even think the public knew they were ready for it but their response shows they were. Had JR come along at the beginning of the 70s, I don't believe people would have been ready for him yet.
 

Chris2

Telly Talk Dream Maker
The Laurel rape is gross. And it’s something the JR of the early years of the show wouldn’t have done. That character always had a logical motivation to do what he did, and the writers were no longer following logic in the later years of the series.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
The Laurel rape is gross. And it’s something the JR of the early years of the show wouldn’t have done. That character always had a logical motivation to do what he did, and the writers were no longer following logic in the later years of the series.

That was a very good example of everything they should not have been doing. The idea I based this thread on - "If Dallas Had Taken A More Positive Approach" - is something I laid out the concept for in the opening post. There is that approach and then there is what JR did to Laurel. The two approaches couldn't be any more different. It is a perfect example of the kind of thing that not only wasn't going anywhere productive but actually turned people away from the show.

It's amazing to me that they became that lost for a direction for the character of JR. They over a period of years, carefully built him into the most talked about character on TV. When a show has been fortunate enough to have had that type of success in creating a character that tens of millions of people watch weekly, they've created a very valuable commodity. That they'd be so careless with how they took care of something that that had made them that much money tells me their minds had lost focus on what mattered and creatively, they had nothing left in the tank.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
The Laurel rape is gross. And it’s something the JR of the early years of the show wouldn’t have done. That character always had a logical motivation to do what he did, and the writers were no longer following logic in the later years of the series.


The main objective of the early writers looks to have been to tell a good story. The main objective of the later writers seems to have been: What can we think of that will be bigger and more spectacular than the last thing we did? Writers of the later years were interested in creating visual excitement. Writers of the earlier years were primarily interested in creating emotional excitement.
 
Top