The reason I asked if people think the range war could have been done in a way that was believable. To me, it looked like something out of the old West that only worked then because it was relatively lawless, but you would know more about that than I do as far as how believable their approach was.
I enjoyed the range war storyline, mostly because I'm a real George Kennedy fan.
And it was more realistic than you might think. Here is a peak behind the scenes from here in Texas:
With my job, I have to get onto ranches similar to Southfork once a week or so. Many times there is a gate that requires a code to get onto the ranch. You would be amazed at how many codes are still on the default of 1234 or 1111. Or what's even more funny, you can look and see where somebody has taken a pencil and written down the code right next to the keypad! So getting onto Southfork would be no problem. Let's also remember that even if they beefed up the gates, there are still miles of fences that are designed to keep cattle in, not people out.
but in a 1980s setting, to try to take Southfork by force and intimidation seems like something that would only have gotten McKay put in prison.
This is also more realistic than people might think.
The 1980's were definitely modern times, but let's set the scene in rural areas:
There were no cell phones yet, so even if you were driving by and saw something suspicious, you had no way to call it in.
Security cameras were still very expensive, and installing a security camera in the middle of nowhere would be require getting electricity out there, along with a way to record the video. So most places did not have any security cameras.
Before we all had phones with cameras built in, a camera was something you kept at home. So even if you saw Carter's crew riding across a pasture with guns drawn, you'd have no way to document it.
So here's what could happen, even in the modern 1980's. Carter's crew comes out to Southfork looking for trouble. They run into Clayton's hired hands and Carter's crew tries to intimidate them and even shoots at them. I've never seen a radio in the ranch trucks, so that means somebody has to drive back to find a phone. Then they get to a phone and call Clayton. Clayton calls the sheriff. By now almost an hour could have passed. And let's say it takes a Sheriff's Deputy an hour to get out to Southfork. So at least a couple of hours have passed since the incident.
Pretty easy for Carter to deny everything and it is Clayton's word against Carters.
So I agree with Kenny, it wouldn't be realistic here in 2020. But during the original run of Dallas, before cell phones, camera phones, and security cameras, range wars could (and did) happen.