If John Ross were a major character, who should he be like?

If John Ross were a major character, who should he be like?

  • As seen in TNT (a 40 year old looser)

    Votes: 4 33.3%
  • Jock

    Votes: 1 8.3%
  • Clayton

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • JR

    Votes: 3 25.0%
  • Bobby

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Other (please detail)

    Votes: 4 33.3%

  • Total voters
    12

Jabari Lamar

Telly Talk Fan
Sort of Other. From the start I thought he should have been more like Bobby, with Christopher more like J.R. But if we're continuing from TNT he's already established. So he's sort of like J.R. but with a bit more of a conscious. And I'd want Pam to be his equally devious partner.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
Sort of Other. From the start I thought he should have been more like Bobby, with Christopher more like J.R. But if we're continuing from TNT he's already established. So he's sort of like J.R. but with a bit more of a conscious. And I'd want Pam to be his equally devious partner.

To me he was a lot like Jock, devious JR with a conscious, but without the cowboyism and tough man bravado. Of course maybe he grew into that. What we saw was like a teenage / early 20s boy.

I agree I wanted Christopher to be mire like JR as well but what they did was weird. I almost want to write him off because his character wasn’t even entertaining to me. At least I could root for John Ross as the underdog in TNT. Chris I just wanted to run over with my car. Both were entitled brats.

And I agree if he’s with Pamela they need to be equals.
 

Jabari Lamar

Telly Talk Fan
The writers screwed up Christopher's character, and poor Jesse Metcalf got a bad rap for it, IMO. I might go ahead and recast him (explained away as reconstructive plastic surgery needed after he survived that explosion), but I can't write out the character, he's too important to the legacy of the original series. Plus there's still a lot of potential drama to mine between him and Lucas, when you bring that character in.
 

Seaviewer

Telly Talk Warrior
So he's sort of like J.R. but with a bit more of a conscious
I voted other. They hinted at it on and off but I'd make more of the idea that his inclination was to be like his father but he was struggling against it.
Plus there's still a lot of potential drama to mine between him and Lucas, when you bring that character in.
Yes, that inherent conflict was always the greatest missed opportunity in TNT Dallas - and it could also allow a bigger role for Ray than stumbling around as an extra at weddings.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
I voted other. They hinted at it on and off but I'd make more of the idea that his inclination was to be like his father but he was struggling against it.
Yes, that inherent conflict was always the greatest missed opportunity in TNT Dallas - and it could also allow a bigger role for Ray than stumbling around as an extra at weddings.

I like Lucas but I’m actually thinking smaller roles for original cast.

I’m also included that he be more like Jock and Clayton - but I’m see other idea. While John Ross is the character everyone so far must have his personality is far from agreed upon.
 
Last edited:

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I like Lucas but I’m actually thinking smaller roles for original cast.

I’m also included that he be more like Jock and Clayton - but I’m see other idea. While John Ross is the character everyone so far must have his personality is far from agreed upon.

I think it would make much more sense for him to be more like Clayton because he has no memory of Jock.
 

Michelle Stevens

'The Lovely Michelle'
I hate to say it but I went with the TNT, 40 year-old loser. John Ross was kind of a lonely but entitled brat toward the end of the original series and I'm sure some of that would have bled over into his high school and college years as being son of a wealthy oil man. It seemed during TNT Dallas John Ross struggled with his father's legacy, his place in the Ewing family and rightfully so. I think it would have made him more interesting being somewhat of a loser like Gary was from time to time in the views of some of his family. I couldn't imagine his '91-'12 years being too idyllic having his mother married in England for some time and his father doing whatever (attempted suicide '91?, WestStar Chairman '96?, mental institution '12?) until we see him again in '12. Having to compete with James and Cally's child could have given an added dynamic if written well. I do think John Ross should have been the main character of any future Dallas franchise.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
I posted this thread on TNT:


I’m having trouble seeing John Ross as he was on TNT. I get the JR (I explored this in A of my A or B thread, through both John Ross and Christopher) and I get the “other” comments but I just have trouble with the TNT characterization. I’d appreciate your comment on the TNT thread if this was your vote.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
I hate to say it but I went with the TNT, 40 year-old loser.
I voted the same way. I don't wish John Ross to be an imitation of JR or some clone of Jock. I would like to see John Ross tortured by the legacy bestowed on him...being JR's son and Jock's grandson. There has always been this idea the first (Jock) creates the wealth, the second (JR) inherits it and the third (John Ross) blows it. Any continuation has to see John Ross struggling to succeed. I want to root for him. I don't want the "love to hate" attached to him like we did with JR. That's been done.

Every-time I watch the infamous kitchen scene between John Ross and Sue Ellen this is the John Ross I want to see. Stifled with self-guilt. Carrying the weight of the Ewing name.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
I voted the same way. I don't wish John Ross to be an imitation of JR or some clone of Jock. I would like to see John Ross tortured by the legacy bestowed on him...being JR's son and Jock's grandson. There has always been this idea the first (Jock) creates the wealth, the second (JR) inherits it and the third (John Ross) blows it. Any continuation has to see John Ross struggling to succeed. I want to root for him. I don't want the "love to hate" attached to him like we did with JR. That's been done.

Every-time I watch the infamous kitchen scene between John Ross and Sue Ellen this is the John Ross I want to see. Stifled with self-guilt. Carrying the weight of the Ewing name.

I like the idea. Of course in the original it was JR who blew it and TNT was trying to show John Ross and Christopher restore it. Would you think he’d feel guilty if he succeeded in pushing out the rest of the family. Like would he feel guilt for his brothers being excluded and his cousins being excluded? Would he feel guilt for the terrible things Ewing’s did, maybe guilt for global warming even? So maybe ruthless like JR but less able to justify it? Maybe giving away money (blowing it) to handle those feelings of guilt?
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
There has always been this idea the first (Jock) creates the wealth, the second (JR) inherits it and the third (John Ross) blows it. Any continuation has to see John Ross struggling to succeed. I want to root for him. I don't want the "love to hate" attached to him like we did with JR. That's been done.
Of course in the original it was JR who blew it and TNT was trying to show John Ross and Christopher restore it.
Both very good points. I wish they had explored it more in TNT Dallas.
 
Last edited:

stevew

Telly Talk Star
Both very good points. I wish they had explored it more in TNT Dallas.

I think more about families like the Ford’s and Rockefeller's when I think of the Ewing’s. In such a case the first generation does create the wealth and the second plays a role in that creation with their father. The third doesn’t blow it but creates something more than wealth, they create real power. To me what TNT explores were bratty children and they certainly exist, just as guilt ridden children exist (why do I have money to live this way when I never did a thing for it and others go hungry in a capitalist society) but there’s also that child that creates real power. Because real power isn’t something you take, it’s something people give you, even if they don’t know they are doing it, you just have to be strong enough to use it. That’s what I was hoping they’d explore - this very issue of power. The quote from Jock was sitting there waiting to be used, and they did, they just weren’t string enough to carry it out. They were stuck on a teen drama, imo.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
They were stuck on a teen drama
A series needs to have a preconceived idea what it is. Writers cannot have it both ways. Writing characters carrying on like teenagers but expected to make adult decisions doesn't wash with me at all. My initial reaction is an eye-roll followed quickly by pressing a button on the remote. When Lorimar Dallas began Patrick Duffy was aged 29. When TNT Dallas began Josh Henderson was aged 31 however the difference in delivery is noted. I'm not blaming Josh at all...just that writing team.

When I revisit Lorimar Dallas I never feel Bobby was treated like he was fresh out of High School. His character is treated with the respect a 29 year old desires. But times are changing. Just the other day while out purchasing some groceries here is a man clearly in the his mid-late 30's dressed like what the 18 years old are wearing today. It looked sad.

As I've noted many times on this forum. My target audience for a Dallas continuation is geared towards those on the 49+ side. Treat the characters and audience with respect and you could be on a winner.
 
Top