I like some aspects of this a lot, very creative, and find other aspects questionable. I appreciate the amount of thought you put into it! So I'll comment on it section by section.
I agree. It ended the series for me. It was a waisted opportunity. I’d have turned JR up a notch. They loved to hate him so let’s hate him. Conspire with Katherine to over turn Rebecca’s will and strip Pam and Cliff of everything, then destroy Katherine to get it. Prove paternity, that Christoper is JR’s biological child and take him and Bobby’s inheritance from Pam - the only way she can keep Chris is to sell JR his share of EO for a cut rate price, except Jack. Everyone else sells to JR once he has control. Clayton and Miss Ellie flee Southfork for Knots Landing. She turns Southfork over to him and he starts to drill for oil. And he goes after Jeremy Wendell beating him in one deal after after another. Making him so bad no one can believe it.
Helping Katherine strip Pam and Cliff of everything gives Katherine a significant role and she was underutilized. I found her confession on the courthouse steps to be ridiculous, so I'm certainly in favor of making Katherine more clever. After losing Patrick Duffy, they can't afford to underutilize the main cast they have left and this would make Katherine part of the main cast.
But then it says "destroy Katherine to get it. " I'd rather that not happen. Concentrating all that power in JR or any one character makes the other characters less capable of having an impact on how things evolve. I like characters with efficacy. No, that doesn't make a "chauvinist", contrary to what a few people here apparently believe. I didn't write most of the female characters on Dallas to be ineffectual, did I? I just call things like I see them. Don't shoot the messenger!
So, why "destroy Katherine" now that you have her in a position to be able to do some interesting things? Having lost Patrick Duffy would make me want to get the most out of the remaining characters I have. People tend to not like new characters once a show has been established as having a certain core ensemble, so I'd want to get the most out of the tried and true characters who I know interest the Dallas audience!
I'd have JR exact a fee for obtaining Howard Wentworth's estate for Katherine - one third of it goes to JR and Katherine is still very wealthy in her own right.
Taking Christopher from Pam is brutal, but would be the impetus to get an Emmy award winning performance out of Victoria Principal! Imagine the performances losing Christopher could have brought out of her.
I can't imagine the Miss Ellie that we grew to know and love would ever "flee Southfork" because she's angry at how JR is behaving. Why would she be the one to leave? It's her house! Besides, giving JR Southfork would be a reward for what he's done. Only bad parents reward bad behavior. It encourages more of the same behavior, so why would she do that? So she and Clayton stay. JR also stays because this is Dallas and if they don't live together at Southfork, it's not.
Besides, Barbara Bel Geddes and Howard Keel are two of the best actors in the ensemble. They're not expendable.
Since I wouldn't want to portray JR giving up his son at any price, he keeps Christopher and Pam sells him the Ewing Oil shares because she's distraught and just wants rid of anything to do with Ewing Oil.
I like the idea of JR going after Jeremy Wendell and having Wendell featured as a main cast member as well. William Smithers was one of the best actors they had; he deserves to be in more scenes.
Except with Sue Ellen - turn that around and make him the loyal loving husband. Sue Ellen finds herself pregnant again, but nearly dies giving birth to their daughter Ellie. JR and her become closer, a romance to end all romances ensues. She stands by JR. JR is right, Jock promised him Ewing Oil and Herbert’s will promises his business to Katherine and Grandpa Southfork always says Southfork would be JR’s one day. In return JR protects Sue Ellen at all cost. He even turns over day to day running of EO to retire Southfork and be with his family.
Excellent! Did anyone really feel the need to see JR and Sue Ellen continue to be so hostile to each other? I'd certainly had my fill of it. I like your way of resolving things between them in a positive way. To me, "drama" doesn't equal constant negativity, but apparently to some of the producers of today's shows it does, which makes them unwatchable. I watch TV to be entertained - not to see constant misery.
Now there has to be more than JR taking over the family and winning through a scorched earth policy and growing into his father. This should be a foundation for what follows, an opportunity to shake everything up.
Maybe Pamela marries Jeremy Wendell to protect her and Christopher from JR after Cliff takes up drinking and nearly dies.
Ooh, Pam and Jeremy? I just don't see any possible chemistry there. John Beck did a fine job as Mark Graison so I'd have him return, pretty much the way they had him return. That was good, and he and Pam make a much better and more likely couple than Pam and Jeremy Wendell would, in my opinion. Mark would help Pam recover from losing Christopher, and he'd become a major adversary for JR. So with him battling Wendell, which I thought was great, and then having to deal with Mark too, JR would have his hands full.
I'll leave it there, I think Donna going after JR too would get repetitious. I wouldn't want Dallas to become "JR vs The World. "
Donna and Ray would either reach an understanding, where they have reasonable expectations from their marriage and end up happy together, or things get worse and worse until they divorce. People seem to love the couple of Dona and Ray, so why not have them end up being happy together? Not everything has to be bleak just because it's drama. Good drama is like a rollercoaster ride - full of highs and lows.
Thanks Stevew for the story, you're a good writer.
Edit: Cliff's descent into alcoholism, just like his father before him is a good idea and Ken Kercheval would have done an amazing job with it! I'd like to see Pamela be the one who does everything she can to save Cliff from himself. What do you think happens? Does she succeed in saving Cliff from becoming another Digger?