Not One Nice Redeeming Character In The Whole Show

Angela Channing

Telly Talk Veteran
Larr y Hagman often told the story of when he was looking for a new acting role, he and his wife Maj were reading potential scripts in different rooms and he heard Maj whooping with excitement about Dallas because there was "not one nice redeeming character in the whole show".

I always had difficulty getting my head around this description because the 5 episode miniseries pilot for Dallas focussed heavily on Pamela and she was saintly. Pamela became like a mother for Lucy and was an advocate and supporter for her when she was having problems at school. Pamela forgave her new family for causing her miscarriage. Ellie surely was also a nice character.

Was it that both Pamela and Ellie were strong women why they weren't considered to be nice?
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
Larr y Hagman often told the story of when he was looking for a new acting role, he and his wife Maj were reading potential scripts in different rooms and he heard Maj whooping with excitement about Dallas because there was "not one nice redeeming character in the whole show".

I always had difficulty getting my head around this description because the 5 episode miniseries pilot for Dallas focussed heavily on Pamela and she was saintly. Pamela became like a mother for Lucy and was an advocate and supporter for her when she was having problems at school. Pamela forgave her new family for causing her miscarriage. Ellie surely was also a nice character.

Was it that both Pamela and Ellie were strong women why they weren't considered to be nice?
Even Pam was minutes away from cheating on her husband with a sunken-chested cowboy in a shabby wooden shack next to a dismal pond barely 24 hours after their marriage in Digger’s Daughter!
 

James from London

International Treasure
I always kind of assumed the draft he originally read wasn't the one that was eventually filmed. And/or maybe it was simply Maj's opinion that none of the characters were that sympathetic.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
The only character that never once got corrupt was Dave Culver as far as I know.

Pam was a good person, but far from perfect. Anything that went wrong, she blamed the Ewing’s and left her husband.

Miss Ellie and Bobby were also good people. But they at times got caught up in the “Ewing brand.”
 
Last edited:

tommie

Telly Talk Hero
I always kind of assumed the draft he originally read wasn't the one that was eventually filmed. And/or maybe it was simply Maj's opinion that none of the characters were that sympathetic.

Could also be their interpretation of the script too - I guess it's possible to see Pam as more devious than she turned out to be and miss Ellie could've also had script notes with stuff that she's wary of Pam. I also think it's important to remember that this was done when Little House on the Praire and The Waltons were the big shows on television centered around families, so the contrast was probably more stark to them back then.
 

James from London

International Treasure
Could also be their interpretation of the script too - I guess it's possible to see Pam as more devious than she turned out to be and miss Ellie could've also had script notes with stuff that she's wary of Pam. I also think it's important to remember that this was done when Little House on the Praire and The Waltons were the big shows on television centered around families, so the contrast was probably more stark to them back then.
Yes, I was just thinking about that. If I remember, Bobby and Pam's promiscuous pasts (he was a "playboy", she was "semi-trashy") were intended to be emphasised more than they ended up being (although the implications were certainly there) and, as you say, maybe that was unusual for romantic leads in more wholesome TV times. And Miss Ellie isn't actively nice to Pam (or anyone else for that matter) until the second episode, which presumably wasn't the script the Hagmans originally read. Also, the Ewings are clearly corrupt and everyone in the family seems fine with that.
 

Jock's Ghost

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
Larr y Hagman often told the story of when he was looking for a new acting role, he and his wife Maj were reading potential scripts in different rooms and he heard Maj whooping with excitement about Dallas because there was "not one nice redeeming character in the whole show".

I always had difficulty getting my head around this description because the 5 episode miniseries pilot for Dallas focussed heavily on Pamela and she was saintly. Pamela became like a mother for Lucy and was an advocate and supporter for her when she was having problems at school. Pamela forgave her new family for causing her miscarriage. Ellie surely was also a nice character.

Was it that both Pamela and Ellie were strong women why they weren't considered to be nice?
The show we saw was likely rewritten a few times. Softened up maybe in some parts
 

Jock's Ghost

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I think it's debatable if Ellie actually was such a nice character. She basically allowed JR to run Valene off the ranch and then took in baby Lucy with no questions asked. Surely she must've known something was up there?

Either way, I'm sure it's just Larry being hyperbolic.
Exactly. Why did Ellie allow Val to be ran off? Its neat they acknowledged that when Gary and Val remarried.
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
I'm sure there's a second part to what Larry said, something like "even mama was a schemer". UD is down but they have the original script hosted there usually, I remember there's an entire scene with Aunt Maggie preaching religious stuff at Pamela which we never saw, I'm sure there are more scenes that changed around through the development of the show.
I found it here via thetelevisionpilot.com - http://jordanl3.sg-host.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/Dallas.pdf

it’s always struck me how much survived to the screen near verbatim, and how succinctly and effectively Jacobs laid out the characters’ motivations. You can see how the casting changed the characters (Victoria’s Pam came across more spunky than saucy, etc.) but so much was already in place.

The religious Maggie was the most significant thing that didn’t make the cut from what I recall, and hey, even she showed up a handful of episodes later, minus the scripture.

Is this really what David Jacobs is referring to in interviews when he describes basically whipping out a first draft in a weekend? Seems too fully-formed for that!
 
Last edited:

Miss Texas 1967

Telly Talk Addict
I found it here via thetelevisionpilot.com - http://jordanl3.sg-host.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/Dallas.pdf

it’s always struck me how much survived to the screen near verbatim, and how succinctly and effectively Jacobs laid out the characters’ motivations. You can see how the casting changed the characters (Victoria’s Pam came across more spunky than saucy, etc.) but so much was already in place.

The religious Maggie was the most significant thing that didn’t make the cut from what I recall, and hey, even she showed up a handful of episodes later, minus the scripture.

Is this really what David Jacobs is referring to in interviews when he describes basically whipping out a first draft in a weekend? Seems too fully-formed for that!
Thanks!

I love reading the scripts, the screen directions and expository info give a lot about the character motivations and often explicitly state what the writers intended for the audience to gather from a particular scene.

It was always obvious that Pam pushing Bobby into the business ended up being bad for their marriage as well as Bobby's familial relationship with JR and Jock at times however it's super well signposted here. Pam doesn't know what a mess she's about to get them all into but David Jacobs does :laughing:
 
Last edited:

Chris2

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Ellie says in the episode where she gives Gary and Val the Seaview Circle house that she should have stood up to Jock and JR over their taking baby Lucy, but she wasn’t strong enough. Weird, because she always seemed plenty strong. But at least they tried to explain why she did nothing. If I were writing the series, I would not have had Valene be so friendly towards her.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Ellie says in the episode where she gives Gary and Val the Seaview Circle house that she should have stood up to Jock and JR over their taking baby Lucy, but she wasn’t strong enough. Weird, because she always seemed plenty strong. But at least they tried to explain why she did nothing. If I were writing the series, I would not have had Valene be so friendly towards her.

Even a strong person has moments of weakness. Plus, even though Ellie didn’t do anything to stop Jock and JR. Valine knew she wasn’t the main one behind it. Back then, Jock most likely ruled the Ewing family with an iron fist and JR was his muscle and Ellie’s job was to stay home, be seen and not heard and raise the kids.
 

DallasFanForever

Telly Talk Supreme
I think what I like about the miniseries more than anything is how so many of the characters are not entirely written as being heroes or villains but instead they tend to exhibit traits of both sides. The heroes are presented as having their faults from the very beginning; Pam, Bobby, Miss Ellie, etc, while the villains are also quite complicated and at times come off as quite like able.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I think what I like about the miniseries more than anything is how so many of the characters are not entirely written as being heroes or villains but instead they tend to exhibit traits of both sides. The heroes are presented as having their faults from the very beginning; Pam, Bobby, Miss Ellie, etc, while the villains are also quite complicated and at times come off as quite like able.

Where in that mini series did JR come off as likable? The first time we ever see JR he’s rubbing down his secretary. Lol
 
Top