Peter Cook: "Donna Reed is a far better Miss Ellie than Barbara Bel Geddes"

From a June 1985 interview.

The Donna Reed quote is at the very end, but it needs to be viewed from 9:07 to give it context:

The audience falls about laughing before he even finishes the sentence.


Donna's episodes of Dallas were still airing in the UK at the time. Another four episodes of Season Seven remained at the time of airing (and I imagine the interview may have been filmed a little earlier still).

I thought it interesting that even at this relatively early stage, Donna's Miss Ellie performance was a punchline, so unpopular that liking it would be considered perversity.
 

James from London

International Treasure
Great find! I guess it's indicative of how "small" the culture was at the time (only three and a half channels, etc) that everyone immediately gets the reference.
 
Great find!

You can probably guess how I came to find it considering who's seated next to Peter.


I guess it's indicative of how "small" the culture was at the time (only three and a half channels, etc) that everyone immediately gets the reference.

Absolutely. And Dallas was one of the biggest things within that small culture. He could have obliquely referenced specific current events from the series and they'd probably still have got it.


With our cultures much more distinct at the time, I think it's interesting to get a British take when the subject turns to American TV in the third part (from 7:50 onwards).

On American sitcom contracts:
Clive James said:
I hear they're a bit like the Church Of Scientology. They're almost impossible to get out of once you're in them.

Peter's experience of being asked to stay away from set during contract re-negotiations sounds a little similar to Larry Hagman.

I wonder if the story of Peter's friend driving himself into a tree to get out of doing a series is true? It's very funny either way. As is his impersonation of Redd Foxx.
 

James from London

International Treasure
I think it's interesting to get a British take when the subject turns to American TV
Yes, Wogan got a lot of mileage from that on his weeknight talk show too and guests like Kate O'Mara were very obliging. Towards the end though, it got a bit same old, same old. He'd interview a British actor who'd just come back from Hollywood and more or less say, "Tell us something about how mental the Americans are so we can have a cheap laugh at their expense and feel superior." (Bless 'im.)
 
Last edited:
Yes, Wogan got a lot of mileage from that on his weeknight talk show too and guests like Kate O'Mara were very obliging.

I think it's a very British way of expressing fascination or even admiration. It's a way of taking a closer look at something that seemed exotic and exciting - and perhaps even useful - while appearing not to give a hoot.

It's similar to how the British car industry of the time gently scoffed at German efficiency or Japanese reliability while knowing they could only benefit from taking on and learning from some of those models.
 

Chris2

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I don’t think she was treated well, but she should have known better. She had been in the business for over forty years, and she should have known that she wouldn’t be positioned to succeed in that role. If she wanted to work that badly, she was still enough of a name that she could have found other work.
 

Angela Channing

Telly Talk Veteran
Donna Reed wasn't a better Miss Ellie than Barbara Bel Geddes but I didn't mind her in that role. It was a pity they never wrote any meaty storylines for her beyond taking down Jock's portrait. Had she been given more time to grow into the role I think more viewers would have come around to accepting her as Ellie.

It's interesting that Peter Cook should reference a Dallas character in that way.

It reminds me of an interview that Stephen Fry did at around the same time (it might have been with Wogan but it could have been with someone else) when out of the blue he declared his love for Dallas and described Dynasty as being "rubbish".
 
Last edited:

Grant Jennings

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
I really think the cast and crew of Dallas did a disservice to Donna Reed by not pulling her aside and talking her out of taking Miss Ellie in a different direction. Her choice to base her interpretation of Miss Ellie on the well-coiffed socialites she knew in real life is perfectly valid and may have worked if she was creating the role but for her to deliver a performance that differed so significantly from her much beloved predecessor was a huge mistake.

The same thing happened to Karen Cellini on Dynasty when she decided Amanda Carrington (who had been moody and introverted when portrayed by Catherine Oxenberg) was a happy, outgoing person.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
Re-casting core characters in primetime rarely works. I still say BBG should have been sent off somewhere on Grandma'sSickIsland while Donna Reed is Jenna's favorite aunt who arrives for Jenna's prospective wedding to Bobby. She can flirt with Clayton.

Bobby can take down Jock's portrait, of, better, Ellie once she recuperates.....

I mean, is it that hard?

4fbae40484846c8ae7d8d9603e57aca6.jpg



As we've discussed before, a little CGI could be in order;

Killing poor Donna Reed one final time | Forums for television shows past and present (tellytalk.net)
 
Last edited by a moderator:

DallasFanForever

Telly Talk Supreme
I had nothing against Donna Reed as an actress. Saw many of her movies from the 50s on and I liked her, but there’s only one Miss Ellie. Donna Reed was just miscast in the role. I totally agree with @Snarky's Ghost that casting her as a relative instead of Miss Ellie would’ve been a much better way to go. As far as who takes down Jock’s portrait without the Ellie character present, that’s an interesting question. I guess I can see that task falling to Bobby but J.R. would’ve fought the decision a lot harder if it didn’t come from his Mama. Was it believed at the time that BBG would never return? Or was it assumed that Donna Reed was just a place keeper until BBG was ready to return? I was kind of young at the time and I honestly can’t remember
 

Ukdallasfan

Telly Talk Fan
I agree with all that’s been said. Donna I think was meant to be a permanent replacement for Barbara but it became clear pretty quickly that it wasn’t working. I saw an interview with Larry done by John Barrowman in which he basically blamed Barbara’s agent for messing up the financial side of the contract renewal. He said it had nothing to do with her heart condition. She wanted more money and if she’d asked him for advice he would have helped her. Larry was the master of negotiation on that show. Poor Donna won a shit load of compensation for being let go but died very soon thereafter of cancer. I watched her in It’s a Wonderful Life over Christmas and she was an able and charismatic actress. Problem was in Dallas she just wasn’t BBG
 

Chris2

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Although the official reason was that Barbara was retiring for “health reasons”, Entertainment Tonight (back when it was fairly respectable and before it went tabloid) reported Barbara was making it known that she was available for TV pilots.
 
Top