Back in 1987 I heard a different explanation for why VP left, which came directly from Larry Hagman, since it's from an interview he did for one of the shows which reported entertainment news. Probably it was Entertainment Tonight. It's very possible that the real reason for VP leaving is somewhere in between the reasons you gave and the following explanation.
The explanation was that she wanted to become a movie star and wanted to start working on that goal before she started losing her good looks. I don't know how it is now, but back in the 80s, if a woman hadn't made it in movies by around age 40, she probably never would because there were few significant roles for older women.
So, her decision to leave in 1987 probably had about as much to do with her being tired of playing Pam as Patrick Duffy's decision to leave in 1985 had to do with him being tired of playing Bobby - they must have had days at work where their jobs seemed repetitive because almost everyone has days like that - but Victoria Principal's decision was primarily based upon having to go after her dream while she was still young enough to have a reasonable shot at succeeding.
Larry Hagman said he completely understood her decision to leave because she was talented and so good looking that she had a legitimate shot at becoming a movie star but only if she didn't wait any longer to go after it. He added that men had a lot more opportunities after a certain age than women did in the movie business.
VP got a starring role in a made for TV movie that same year, so she did go after that goal. She went on to make several made for TV movies but that's as far as she got - only made for TV movies.
I saw one of her movies - "Mistress." I remember thinking it was alright but that's about all I remember; it was so long ago.