Season 6 and the Seven Deadly Sins

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
Dallas for at least the first 6-8 seasons was epic. Many have said almost biblical in a sense, comparing it to the story of Cain and Abel.

Season 6 was masterful in the way Jock's will and the battle for Ewing Oil touched the lives of all the characters. What's even better was that it revealed their humanity, warts and all.

In the Old Testament Book of Job, the devil confronts God about the very moral and righteous Job, saying he's only "good" because everything is going Job's way. Once life gets hard Satan predicts Job won't be such a faithful follower.
In many ways the "Jock's will " storyline does the same thing. JR is the "evil"one to whom all the characters love to feel superior, but as JR himself pointed out at the end of the season, nobody's "hands are clean." What's brilliant is that the "sins" they commit are for the most part understandable.
You could say Jock through the terms of the battle for Ewing Oil was testing everyone to see how resistant they really were to the seven deadly sins.
So are there any true innocents by the end of season 6, untouched by the seven deadly sins(pride, envy, lust, sloth, gluttony, greed, and wrath)?

1. Pride

JR and Bobby- it motivates them to fight for Ewing Oil

Pam- She has no problem passing judgement over JR, Bobby and Cliff, but won't admit for a second that she's not as moral as she feels. She abandoned her husband in the middle of one of the most stressful situations of his life, takes their son, and then heads off on a romantic vacation with Mark. She does, however, in season 7 own up to Bobby that a lot of their marriage woes were her fault, but never gets specific.

Sue Ellen. Her pride played a part in her not fully acknowledging her alcoholism(until the dream season), nor taking responsibility for the fact that it affects other people's lives, i.e. Mickey.
Pride, along with insecurity, may also be the root of her narcissism and even her being in denial about JR for most of that season.



Gary- He storms out of SF after being humiliated by the provisions in Jock's will. Okay, it's embarrassing but he lets his pride get in the way of a more important reason to stay: his daughter. He barely spends any time with her, which Lucy acknowledges, forgetting that she must be mourning the death of the man who was her de facto father. If Jock could speak from beyond the grave he would say, "See, this is why I put those provisions in the will. You're too immature. Here you go abandoning your daughter again."

Valene. It happened on KL, but such is the reach of the almighty Jock. When Gary invites her to go to the reading of the will because there's a chance she might be in it, she declines. I don't blame her, especially since Gary had just dumped her for a certain blue-eyed she-devil. However, when she asks Lillimae,"Why on earth would he think I'd want to go to Dallas?" her mother could have responded, "Well, you have a daughter there who's probably mourning the man who raised her and now needs her mama. You're always complaining you never got to be a mother to her, so swallow your pride and go be one."

2. Envy
Katherine coveting her sister's husband. Katherine was great her entire time on the show, but I liked her more here, the lonely, jealous sister, than the psychotic they turned her into. However, her story could be a cautionary tale of how envy can lead one to madness. You're a beautiful woman, Kathy! If Bobby is out of reach, I'll go out with you. No? Aw:(


JR'S understandable envy of Jock's preference for Bobby over him and Miss Ellie's favoritism of Gary. JR worked all his life in Ewing Oil, so it's lind of insulting that Jock would put him in competition with Bobby. Still, this envy was a major motivation in some of his most nefarious deeds.

3.Wrath

Ray's anger against JR in the finale is understandable, but it almost got him, JR, Sue Ellen and John Ross killed. Plus, he needs to remember he was instrumental in the scheme that led to Mickey's accident.

Rebecca -Her anger at the Ewings became fanatical and led to her death

Cliff- His anger consumed his life and destroyed many, if not all, of his relationships.

4. Lust

JR for all the many and obvious reasons
Mark- It may have turned into love later on, but initially it was his reason for going after a married woman.
Holly- she had her office in her bedroom. I'm guessing she's not exactly Eleanor Roosevelt.


5. Gluttony
Possibly Sue Ellen if alcohol falls under this category.

6. Greed
All of them? They complain about JR's tactics, but no one was willing to give up their lifestyle in protest. They are complicit in a sense because of that.

6. Sloth- I don't think anyone was depicted as lazy. Maybe Holly not doing enough research on how to run an oil company and into JR himself before aligning with him.
Of course, maybe Sue Ellen since it wasn't until a couple seasons later that she actually got a job. She did have her charities, though.


So who's innocent?
Clayton. Seems to be, if you overlook the previous season when he almost proposed to his son's ex, Sue Ellen. It's not a sin, but it sure as heck is awkward.
Miss Ellie. Yes she tried to break Jock's will, but that came more from fear of it destroying her family than a "sin."
Donna. I love her, but she does have pride issues. I can't recall anything that made her hands dirty in season 6. Can anyone else find fault with her during this storyline?

Afton. Sure, she slept with Gil Thorpe, but she did it to help Cliff, and obviously not for any personal gain. In fact, it was made clear he was a pretty gross person.
Season 4 she's definitely guilty of lust and greed, going after JR. Also, tackiness in the extreme, doing it with him in JR and Sue Ellen's bed.
(Afton also recalls the Greek figure Cassandra in season 6 and 7. No one ever listens to her when she warns them about Katherine or gives Cliff some good advice.)

The two most innocent are Lucy and Mickey, and they suffer the most. This brings us back to the question in the Book of Job, why do innocent people suffer? This is also a question explored by many, many philosophers, theologians, and all of us regular folks on this planet.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
So who's innocent?
Clayton. Seems to be, if you overlook the previous season when he almost proposed to his son's ex, Sue Ellen. It's not a sin, but it sure as heck is awkward.
Miss Ellie. Yes she tried to break Jock's will, but that came more from fear of it destroying her family than a "sin."
Donna. I love her, but she does have pride issues. I can't recall anything that made her hands dirty in season 6. Can anyone else find fault with her during this storyline?

This is a great thread and I want to get back to it when I have time to go into the rest of it, but right now I'll respond to the above quote. Clayton was trying to get Sue Ellen to marry him and bought her an engagement ring. If you're not supposed to covet your neighbor's wife, then I would think it would follow that you shouldn't covet your son's fiance or even ex-fiance. The way I see it, that's almost like incest. I can't imagine doing it. What if Sue Ellen had married Clayton? Does Dusty call her "mom"?

Miss Ellie: I think "pride" certainly applies there, because she's claiming to know Jock's will better than Jock's literal will! If a woman has been married to a man for that long and claims to love him as much as she said, how could she take away his right to see to it that he wills the product of his life's work to the one he wants to will it to? Imagine Ellie willing Southfork to Gary and then she dies before Jock does. What if she's looking down from heaven at Jock and sees him overturning her will because he says "Gary is too irresponsible to handle Southfork and will ruin it", so instead he gives half to Bobby and half to JR? I don't think Miss Ellie would be too pleased!

If Ellie has any faith in Jock's judgement and any respect for what is literally his last request, she has got to allow things to go the way Jock's will stipulates. Anything else is a big betrayal on her part. Also, nobody knew it at the time, but Jock was doing it to teach the two of them to respect each other's abilities. That's great. He hadn't been able to get that accomplished during his life, but even in death, he's still hopefully teaching them that valuable lesson. Ewing Oil needs both of them working together because each has unique gifts and talents the other doesn't! Together they could take Ewing Oil to far greater heights than either could on his own.

People might argue over how much they really learned the lesson, but even if they didn't, it was still an amazing effort on Jock's part to do his best to teach them the lesson. Of course, some people are unteachable, but that's on them. I've got nothing but admiration for a man who does his very best to try to teach his sons what they need to know. If he gives 100% and they still don't learn, he can still be proud that he gave it his best effort.

A lot of people are afraid to try something because they might fail, so they end up not even trying. They won't pursue their dream because they're afraid to fail. I look at like this: If you give something your best shot and you know you gave it all you had, even if you don't achieve your goal, you can be proud of yourself for having given it your best effort. As long as you give it your best effort, I don't see that as failure. The real failure in life is to have such a great fear of failure that you don't even try to go after what you want.

Donna: I don't know how much of this specifically applies to season six because it was an ongoing thing with her. How many times did Ray want to try something to expand his horizons and she'd try to discourage him? She'd say something like: "Where's that cowboy I married"? Did that get old or what? Meanwhile, she's going from one career to the next and acting like "Well of course I try new things; how can you not"? But then she does that to her own husband! She'd tell him she just wanted him to stay a cowboy and give him all sorts of reasons never to venture out of this little space she had created for him. Ray was supposed to stay within those very confining boundaries while Donna has the gall to tell Ray: "People grow or they die"! It was the perfect example of someone who says: "Do as I say - not as I do."

Otherwise, I see Donna's big mistake in season six as getting involved in the contest for Ewing Oil. She actually changed jobs so she could get on a commission to try to help Bobby win. In fact, there's a scene where Bobby says to Donna that the first thing she should do once she becomes part of the committee is to rescind JR's variance. We all know what that led to - Jr's variance got rescinded so that he lost his ability to run his gas stations. That led to him deciding to sell oil to Cuba. Ray and Bobby set up Walt Driscoll and he ends up crippling Mickey Trotter, who ends up dead. Had JR just stuck to running gas stations, Mickey wouldn't have died,but Donna and Ray both got involved in the contest with horrible consequences. It also defeated the purpose of the will. It's supposed to be a one on one contest, but then Donna and Ray both help Bobby and it's no longer a matter of which brother is the best oilman but of which guy has the biggest gang.

It became a much different thing when all these various people become complicit in interfering in the nature of a one on one contest by all ganging up on one of them. If they didn't want the contest to hurt the family, the very best thing to do would have been to leave the thing between JR and Bobby. Once you pick a side and start helping that side, then you're responsible for what happens as a result. Once they all get involved, none of them have clean hands anymore. If you want to have clean hands, don't get involved in something that doesn't have anything to do with you, or shouldn't.
 

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
@Kenny Coyote, you make very valid points about Clayton, Miss Ellie, and Donna.
Donna's rationale, if I recall correctly, for discouraging Ray from trying different things was that in her opinion he was doing them for the wrong reasons. That doesn't justify her not supporting him and deciding for himself what he wants to do. That's her pride right there.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
@Kenny Coyote, you make very valid points about Clayton, Miss Ellie, and Donna.
Donna's rationale, if I recall correctly, for discouraging Ray from trying different things was that in her opinion he was doing them for the wrong reasons. That doesn't justify her not supporting him and deciding for himself what he wants to do. That's her pride right there.

Thanks Jimmy!

Yes, I agree that Donna's rationale for the "do as I say - not asI do" behavior we're talking about was one designed with Ray's best interests at heart, but isn't it a little suspect how time and again, whenever Ray wanted to branch out, Donna was right there, reminding him he was a 'cowboy" (apparently for life)?

Donna may very well have wanted to protect Ray from making a mistake such as rushing into a new business without first properly educating himself (or becoming educated by others) on that new business. I think there is certainly an element of that in it.

I think there's another element to it as well though. After all, this is Dallas, where none of the main characters are entirely good or entirely bad. They all exist on a continuum that ranges from very heavily flawed to much less flawed. They've all got some part of themselves that is very admirable and they've all got at least some part of themselves that could use some improvement. That's about the most subtle way I can put it!

I think in Donna's case, she really liked being the one in the marriage that was "the great success story." Almost every time she embarked on a new business venture, she was met with tremendous success. That was her "spot" in the marriage or her "position" - the incredibly competent, continually successful one who got all of the spotlight. She got all the spotlight, she loved it to death and she didn't want to relinquish one bit of it.

You mention envy as one of the seven deadly sins. It's my perception that she loved being in that spotlight so much that envy was what got in the way of her talking to Ray about goals he'd like to achieve and instead of continually shutting him down, she could have said: "This is what I've learned about becoming a success. Allow me to share it with you."

I think an envy free Donna would have loved to have done that, because when you see how important it is for people to grow as individuals, why wouldn't you want it for the one you love the most? Of course you would want that for them too. Except then envy enters the picture and Donna realizes, if she helps Ray become a bigger success in his own right,she's going to have to share that spotlight with him and she sees that very much as her domain. I guess greed describes this better than envy although it's probably some combination of the two. If she shares the spotlight with Ray, then she relinquishes that position in the marriage of being the success in the marriage. Then she becomes just one of two successes in the marriage.

I can certainly see that happening and believe me, the spotlight is addictive! Fame is one hell of a drug! The thing is, fame or "the spotlight", or however you want to put it, is not a fixed quantity. If Donna shares it with Ray, it doesn't have to mean that her share of the spotlight has to diminish because there is plenty for both of them. Besides, I don't see Ray as so ambitious that he'd ever get into the mindset of wanting to have as much fame, as much attention as Donna got anyway. I do think Ray wanted to branch out from just being a cowboy to at least some extent. I think Ray wanted to grow a little and have some variety in his career. No matter how much he may have loved being a cowboy, being a cowboy is not all there is to life. People have to have other things to feel complete.

I think Ray would have appreciated it a lot more if Donna had approached him from the standpoint of: "If you want this particular project or business so badly, then let me help you go about it in the right way."

That makes it so much more positive, because instead of being negative and saying it's too much for you and you're going to get hurt and you're supposed to just be a cowboy anyway, Donna would have come at it from a standpoint of: "I believe you can do this, and if you want it that badly, then I want it for you just as much, so let's figure out a way to maximize your chances of success."
 
Last edited:

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
Great analysis of Donna's character,
@Kenny Coyote. I always liked Donna, but as you said, the characters on Dallas were very human. None of them were perfect.
It would be intimidating for a lot of men to be married to Donna. Everything she did became a success. Perhaps the way she didn't encourage Ray in new business ventures really preyed on his insecurities.
I would have liked to have seen a plotline in which JR and Donna have some major conflict. I don't think she'd necessarily beat JR, but she'd be a formidable opponent. It would also reveal new layers of her character. She may even be humbled a bit, and need Ray as the strong one. Susan Howard and Larry Hagman are both great actors. They'd really make such a plot work.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
6. Sloth- I don't think anyone was depicted as lazy. Maybe Holly not doing enough research on how to run an oil company and into JR himself before aligning with him.
Of course, maybe Sue Ellen since it wasn't until a couple seasons later that she actually got a job. She did have her charities, though.

This intrigued me: Could there be one of the seven deadly sins that season 6 didn't display? I went to read about sloth and found this: Unlike the other capital sins, which are sins of committing immorality, sloth is a sin of omitting responsibilities.

Of the seven deadly sins, Gary was practically tailor made to display slothUnlike the other capital sins, which are sins of committing immorality, sloth is a sin of omitting responsibilities. You mentioned Gary under pride and showed how he ran away as soon as he didn't like the stipulation that for a certain period of time, he was limited to only the use of the interest on his ten million dollars. His vanity (part of pride) made him decide to run back home and in doing so he neglected his responsibility as a father to Lucy. Neglect of responsibility is sloth.

Gary is such a good example of sloth because it sloth isn't the commission of immorality but a sin of omission of morality in the form of responsibilities. It was said that whenever Gary was asked to take any responsibility, he would be right out the door.

Sue Ellen's drinking problem was one of both gluttony (excess in drink and illicit sex) but then became one of sloth - omitting her responsibility to deal with her drinking problem and her adultery problem. After a long period of time she did address the drinking problem, and then even her illicit sex problem once she finally got a divorce and then as far as we know, was faithful to the movie script writer from England. Even while she was with him, she still had that problem with wrath which she displayed when she dedicated about a year of her life towards making a movie strictly for hurtful purposes. That form of wrath was Cliff's specialty since he practically dedicated his entire adult life to revenge, if we take him at his word. I think Cliff's initial motivation may have been revenge, but he certainly envied what the Ewings, and especially JR, had.

JR'S understandable envy of Jock's preference for Bobby over him and Miss Ellie's favoritism of Gary.

JR displays a lot of the seven deadly sins, but I don't know that this was one of them. In this case his parents were neglecting their responsibility to not show favoritism among their children. Does it qualify as envy for JR to wish his parents would start acting like good parents and stop showing favoritism to Bobby and Gary? What's your opinion in that?
 

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
This is an interesting take on sloth. It shows how our human frailtfra can sneak up on us in ways we don't see. For example, Gary was working over in Knots Landing, and they often showed him exercising pretty intensely at the gym,so he probably would never consider sloth to be a weakness of his. However, he put very little time into being a father to Lucy, so sloth would definitely apply.
Regarding gluttony, C.S. Lewis writes about a character in The Screwtape Letters about a character who is guilty of this vice, yet eats very little. What she does is use her extreme pickiness about food to control and antagonize everyone around her.
I think JR's resentment of his parents unequal treatment of their children counts as envy, even if one can hardly blame him at all. He resents what his brothers have and it seems to motivate him to do malicious things, especially in the case of Gary.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
This is an interesting take on sloth. It shows how our human frailtfra can sneak up on us in ways we don't see. For example, Gary was working over in Knots Landing, and they often showed him exercising pretty intensely at the gym,so he probably would never consider sloth to be a weakness of his. However, he put very little time into being a father to Lucy, so sloth would definitely apply.
Regarding gluttony, C.S. Lewis writes about a character in The Screwtape Letters about a character who is guilty of this vice, yet eats very little. What she does is use her extreme pickiness about food to control and antagonize everyone around her.
I think JR's resentment of his parents unequal treatment of their children counts as envy, even if one can hardly blame him at all. He resents what his brothers have and it seems to motivate him to do malicious things, especially in the case of Gary.

I don't know what Gary may have done on KL, so I'm describing him from the perspective of the Dallas series specifically. It wouldn't surprise me if they changed the character so he'd be viable as a main character.

Would a character being oblivious fall under the category of one of the 7 deadly sins? Take Miss Ellie for example. She's fairly good, but she could really be oblivious at times, such as with Clayton. When Clayton wanted to talk about where to live, Ellie acted surprised as if: You're suggesting we should do anything other than have you sell you ranch, leave your business,your town with your friends, so you can move into my ranch, into the house my ex-husband built, to live with adult children?

Yeah, why would that be unreasonable? Ellie makes no sacrifices and Clayton makes all the sacrifices, which apparently to her is reasonable. She's just so out of it! She's oblivious to anything that doesn't involve her desires, while never trying to see anything from Clayton's perspective. I lost some respect for Clayton when he caved in to all her demands.
 

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
I don't know what Gary may have done on KL, so I'm describing him from the perspective of the Dallas series specifically. It wouldn't surprise me if they changed the character so he'd be viable as a main character.

Would a character being oblivious fall under the category of one of the 7 deadly sins? Take Miss Ellie for example. She's fairly good, but she could really be oblivious at times, such as with Clayton. When Clayton wanted to talk about where to live, Ellie acted surprised as if: You're suggesting we should do anything other than have you sell you ranch, leave your business,your town with your friends, so you can move into my ranch, into the house my ex-husband built, to live with adult children?

Yeah, why would that be unreasonable? Ellie makes no sacrifices and Clayton makes all the sacrifices, which apparently to her is reasonable. She's just so out of it! She's oblivious to anything that doesn't involve her desires, while never trying to see anything from Clayton's perspective. I lost some respect for Clayton when he caved in to all her demands.

This is a good observation, Kenny. I think Miss Ellie's actions might fall under pride here. Perhaps she's too proud to realize Southfork is not the center of everyone's universe?
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I think JR's resentment of his parents unequal treatment of their children counts as envy, even if one can hardly blame him at all. He resents what his brothers have and it seems to motivate him to do malicious things, especially in the case of Gary.
This is a very good point, Jimmy.
Larry Hagman made J.R. the Magnificent Bastard, and the one we love to hate. But if you don't SEE Larry's brilliant portrayal, and only read about J.R. and his background on paper, then he is actually a sympathetic character.
 
Last edited:

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
This intrigued me: Could there be one of the seven deadly sins that season 6 didn't display? I went to read about sloth and found this: Unlike the other capital sins, which are sins of committing immorality, sloth is a sin of omitting responsibilities.

Of the seven deadly sins, Gary was practically tailor made to display slothUnlike the other capital sins, which are sins of committing immorality, sloth is a sin of omitting responsibilities. You mentioned Gary under pride and showed how he ran away as soon as he didn't like the stipulation that for a certain period of time, he was limited to only the use of the interest on his ten million dollars. His vanity (part of pride) made him decide to run back home and in doing so he neglected his responsibility as a father to Lucy. Neglect of responsibility is sloth.

Gary is such a good example of sloth because it sloth isn't the commission of immorality but a sin of omission of morality in the form of responsibilities. It was said that whenever Gary was asked to take any responsibility, he would be right out the door.

Sue Ellen's drinking problem was one of both gluttony (excess in drink and illicit sex) but then became one of sloth - omitting her responsibility to deal with her drinking problem and her adultery problem. After a long period of time she did address the drinking problem, and then even her illicit sex problem once she finally got a divorce and then as far as we know, was faithful to the movie script writer from England. Even while she was with him, she still had that problem with wrath which she displayed when she dedicated about a year of her life towards making a movie strictly for hurtful purposes. That form of wrath was Cliff's specialty since he practically dedicated his entire adult life to revenge, if we take him at his word. I think Cliff's initial motivation may have been revenge, but he certainly envied what the Ewings, and especially JR, had.



JR displays a lot of the seven deadly sins, but I don't know that this was one of them. In this case his parents were neglecting their responsibility to not show favoritism among their children. Does it qualify as envy for JR to wish his parents would start acting like good parents and stop showing favoritism to Bobby and Gary? What's your opinion in that?

At the end of Taste of Success, Bobby, in the den with JR and Jock, takes a call from Les Crowley confirming he was able to raise the money to acquire Jim Redfield's refinery. We cut to JR's bedroom where he rants to Sue Ellen about how Bobby was able to do something he's never been able to pull off, ending the scene (and the episode) with "I'm going bring Bobby down. I'm going to cut him out if I have to destroy Ewing Oil to do it."

That was definitely envy!
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
At the end of Taste of Success, Bobby, in the den with JR and Jock, takes a call from Les Crowley confirming he was able to raise the money to acquire Jim Redfield's refinery. We cut to JR's bedroom where he rants to Sue Ellen about how Bobby was able to do something he's never been able to pull off, ending the scene (and the episode) with "I'm going bring Bobby down. I'm going to cut him out if I have to destroy Ewing Oil to do it."

That was definitely envy!

It was. I think the line "if I have to destroy Ewing Oil to do it" was mostly said to get people to tune in the next week though. Would he have done something to hurt the company to get Bobby out? Yeah, but would he purposely destroy the whole company? I seriously doubt it. He has nothing left to run if he does!
 
Top