Jimmy Todd
Telly Talk Mega Star
Dallas for at least the first 6-8 seasons was epic. Many have said almost biblical in a sense, comparing it to the story of Cain and Abel.
Season 6 was masterful in the way Jock's will and the battle for Ewing Oil touched the lives of all the characters. What's even better was that it revealed their humanity, warts and all.
In the Old Testament Book of Job, the devil confronts God about the very moral and righteous Job, saying he's only "good" because everything is going Job's way. Once life gets hard Satan predicts Job won't be such a faithful follower.
In many ways the "Jock's will " storyline does the same thing. JR is the "evil"one to whom all the characters love to feel superior, but as JR himself pointed out at the end of the season, nobody's "hands are clean." What's brilliant is that the "sins" they commit are for the most part understandable.
You could say Jock through the terms of the battle for Ewing Oil was testing everyone to see how resistant they really were to the seven deadly sins.
So are there any true innocents by the end of season 6, untouched by the seven deadly sins(pride, envy, lust, sloth, gluttony, greed, and wrath)?
1. Pride
JR and Bobby- it motivates them to fight for Ewing Oil
Pam- She has no problem passing judgement over JR, Bobby and Cliff, but won't admit for a second that she's not as moral as she feels. She abandoned her husband in the middle of one of the most stressful situations of his life, takes their son, and then heads off on a romantic vacation with Mark. She does, however, in season 7 own up to Bobby that a lot of their marriage woes were her fault, but never gets specific.
Sue Ellen. Her pride played a part in her not fully acknowledging her alcoholism(until the dream season), nor taking responsibility for the fact that it affects other people's lives, i.e. Mickey.
Pride, along with insecurity, may also be the root of her narcissism and even her being in denial about JR for most of that season.
Gary- He storms out of SF after being humiliated by the provisions in Jock's will. Okay, it's embarrassing but he lets his pride get in the way of a more important reason to stay: his daughter. He barely spends any time with her, which Lucy acknowledges, forgetting that she must be mourning the death of the man who was her de facto father. If Jock could speak from beyond the grave he would say, "See, this is why I put those provisions in the will. You're too immature. Here you go abandoning your daughter again."
Valene. It happened on KL, but such is the reach of the almighty Jock. When Gary invites her to go to the reading of the will because there's a chance she might be in it, she declines. I don't blame her, especially since Gary had just dumped her for a certain blue-eyed she-devil. However, when she asks Lillimae,"Why on earth would he think I'd want to go to Dallas?" her mother could have responded, "Well, you have a daughter there who's probably mourning the man who raised her and now needs her mama. You're always complaining you never got to be a mother to her, so swallow your pride and go be one."
2. Envy
Katherine coveting her sister's husband. Katherine was great her entire time on the show, but I liked her more here, the lonely, jealous sister, than the psychotic they turned her into. However, her story could be a cautionary tale of how envy can lead one to madness. You're a beautiful woman, Kathy! If Bobby is out of reach, I'll go out with you. No? Aw
JR'S understandable envy of Jock's preference for Bobby over him and Miss Ellie's favoritism of Gary. JR worked all his life in Ewing Oil, so it's lind of insulting that Jock would put him in competition with Bobby. Still, this envy was a major motivation in some of his most nefarious deeds.
3.Wrath
Ray's anger against JR in the finale is understandable, but it almost got him, JR, Sue Ellen and John Ross killed. Plus, he needs to remember he was instrumental in the scheme that led to Mickey's accident.
Rebecca -Her anger at the Ewings became fanatical and led to her death
Cliff- His anger consumed his life and destroyed many, if not all, of his relationships.
4. Lust
JR for all the many and obvious reasons
Mark- It may have turned into love later on, but initially it was his reason for going after a married woman.
Holly- she had her office in her bedroom. I'm guessing she's not exactly Eleanor Roosevelt.
5. Gluttony
Possibly Sue Ellen if alcohol falls under this category.
6. Greed
All of them? They complain about JR's tactics, but no one was willing to give up their lifestyle in protest. They are complicit in a sense because of that.
6. Sloth- I don't think anyone was depicted as lazy. Maybe Holly not doing enough research on how to run an oil company and into JR himself before aligning with him.
Of course, maybe Sue Ellen since it wasn't until a couple seasons later that she actually got a job. She did have her charities, though.
So who's innocent?
Clayton. Seems to be, if you overlook the previous season when he almost proposed to his son's ex, Sue Ellen. It's not a sin, but it sure as heck is awkward.
Miss Ellie. Yes she tried to break Jock's will, but that came more from fear of it destroying her family than a "sin."
Donna. I love her, but she does have pride issues. I can't recall anything that made her hands dirty in season 6. Can anyone else find fault with her during this storyline?
Afton. Sure, she slept with Gil Thorpe, but she did it to help Cliff, and obviously not for any personal gain. In fact, it was made clear he was a pretty gross person.
Season 4 she's definitely guilty of lust and greed, going after JR. Also, tackiness in the extreme, doing it with him in JR and Sue Ellen's bed.
(Afton also recalls the Greek figure Cassandra in season 6 and 7. No one ever listens to her when she warns them about Katherine or gives Cliff some good advice.)
The two most innocent are Lucy and Mickey, and they suffer the most. This brings us back to the question in the Book of Job, why do innocent people suffer? This is also a question explored by many, many philosophers, theologians, and all of us regular folks on this planet.
Season 6 was masterful in the way Jock's will and the battle for Ewing Oil touched the lives of all the characters. What's even better was that it revealed their humanity, warts and all.
In the Old Testament Book of Job, the devil confronts God about the very moral and righteous Job, saying he's only "good" because everything is going Job's way. Once life gets hard Satan predicts Job won't be such a faithful follower.
In many ways the "Jock's will " storyline does the same thing. JR is the "evil"one to whom all the characters love to feel superior, but as JR himself pointed out at the end of the season, nobody's "hands are clean." What's brilliant is that the "sins" they commit are for the most part understandable.
You could say Jock through the terms of the battle for Ewing Oil was testing everyone to see how resistant they really were to the seven deadly sins.
So are there any true innocents by the end of season 6, untouched by the seven deadly sins(pride, envy, lust, sloth, gluttony, greed, and wrath)?
1. Pride
JR and Bobby- it motivates them to fight for Ewing Oil
Pam- She has no problem passing judgement over JR, Bobby and Cliff, but won't admit for a second that she's not as moral as she feels. She abandoned her husband in the middle of one of the most stressful situations of his life, takes their son, and then heads off on a romantic vacation with Mark. She does, however, in season 7 own up to Bobby that a lot of their marriage woes were her fault, but never gets specific.
Sue Ellen. Her pride played a part in her not fully acknowledging her alcoholism(until the dream season), nor taking responsibility for the fact that it affects other people's lives, i.e. Mickey.
Pride, along with insecurity, may also be the root of her narcissism and even her being in denial about JR for most of that season.
Gary- He storms out of SF after being humiliated by the provisions in Jock's will. Okay, it's embarrassing but he lets his pride get in the way of a more important reason to stay: his daughter. He barely spends any time with her, which Lucy acknowledges, forgetting that she must be mourning the death of the man who was her de facto father. If Jock could speak from beyond the grave he would say, "See, this is why I put those provisions in the will. You're too immature. Here you go abandoning your daughter again."
Valene. It happened on KL, but such is the reach of the almighty Jock. When Gary invites her to go to the reading of the will because there's a chance she might be in it, she declines. I don't blame her, especially since Gary had just dumped her for a certain blue-eyed she-devil. However, when she asks Lillimae,"Why on earth would he think I'd want to go to Dallas?" her mother could have responded, "Well, you have a daughter there who's probably mourning the man who raised her and now needs her mama. You're always complaining you never got to be a mother to her, so swallow your pride and go be one."
2. Envy
Katherine coveting her sister's husband. Katherine was great her entire time on the show, but I liked her more here, the lonely, jealous sister, than the psychotic they turned her into. However, her story could be a cautionary tale of how envy can lead one to madness. You're a beautiful woman, Kathy! If Bobby is out of reach, I'll go out with you. No? Aw
JR'S understandable envy of Jock's preference for Bobby over him and Miss Ellie's favoritism of Gary. JR worked all his life in Ewing Oil, so it's lind of insulting that Jock would put him in competition with Bobby. Still, this envy was a major motivation in some of his most nefarious deeds.
3.Wrath
Ray's anger against JR in the finale is understandable, but it almost got him, JR, Sue Ellen and John Ross killed. Plus, he needs to remember he was instrumental in the scheme that led to Mickey's accident.
Rebecca -Her anger at the Ewings became fanatical and led to her death
Cliff- His anger consumed his life and destroyed many, if not all, of his relationships.
4. Lust
JR for all the many and obvious reasons
Mark- It may have turned into love later on, but initially it was his reason for going after a married woman.
Holly- she had her office in her bedroom. I'm guessing she's not exactly Eleanor Roosevelt.
5. Gluttony
Possibly Sue Ellen if alcohol falls under this category.
6. Greed
All of them? They complain about JR's tactics, but no one was willing to give up their lifestyle in protest. They are complicit in a sense because of that.
6. Sloth- I don't think anyone was depicted as lazy. Maybe Holly not doing enough research on how to run an oil company and into JR himself before aligning with him.
Of course, maybe Sue Ellen since it wasn't until a couple seasons later that she actually got a job. She did have her charities, though.
So who's innocent?
Clayton. Seems to be, if you overlook the previous season when he almost proposed to his son's ex, Sue Ellen. It's not a sin, but it sure as heck is awkward.
Miss Ellie. Yes she tried to break Jock's will, but that came more from fear of it destroying her family than a "sin."
Donna. I love her, but she does have pride issues. I can't recall anything that made her hands dirty in season 6. Can anyone else find fault with her during this storyline?
Afton. Sure, she slept with Gil Thorpe, but she did it to help Cliff, and obviously not for any personal gain. In fact, it was made clear he was a pretty gross person.
Season 4 she's definitely guilty of lust and greed, going after JR. Also, tackiness in the extreme, doing it with him in JR and Sue Ellen's bed.
(Afton also recalls the Greek figure Cassandra in season 6 and 7. No one ever listens to her when she warns them about Katherine or gives Cliff some good advice.)
The two most innocent are Lucy and Mickey, and they suffer the most. This brings us back to the question in the Book of Job, why do innocent people suffer? This is also a question explored by many, many philosophers, theologians, and all of us regular folks on this planet.