Should DALLAS have turned more dusty and gothic in its closing years?

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
... I mean, after Pam disappeared?

7219-13780.jpg
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
Like how so?

I'm not entirely certain what you mean by Gothic but anything that took a more serious tone would have been better than the self-parody.

Yeah, "gothic" may be too strong a word, but I always picture DALLAS becoming a little rawer, edgier, darker in its closing years in an artful way that Katzman would likely have never permitted.

In fact, the show quite obviously did the opposite.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Jock Ewing Fan

Telly Talk Star
I think that over time, Dallas lost that element of old, pre ww2 west and it had more of the Dynasty glamour elements in its stories.
Ray's character as a cowboy-turned-Ewing paired with the highly skilled Donna was a major loss, because it represented that dynamic-
a changing American West that still had its roots in a grittier time. The range war story was an attempt to revive that element, I suppose.
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
And this would be more in keeping with the original direction of the show.

Compare the opening to Romeo and Juliette.

By the end of the mini series you just KNOW that things are not going to end well for these characters.


By the way, a few of us on these boards have been to the gas station in Prosper, Texas where they filmed the Pam and Bobby car scenes.

Click on the link below to see the gas station in 1978 and how it looks today.

 
Last edited:

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
I mean, after Pam disappeared?
Dallas missed that moment after the death of Bobby. Patrick's departure was the opportunity the writers had squandered. The Dream Season began with the right approach by putting Pam in the Ewing Office.

Heck the drama was just sitting there just waiting to be told...JR versus Pam or JR versus the world. This was the time to turn Dallas dark with an unrelenting JR determined to squash anyone or anything getting in his way. Bobby wasn't there anymore to reign him in. The only character left to dampen JR's spirits would have been Miss Ellie. Oh the drama that could have been played out for the next 2 years watching JR punish those standing before him or JR burning out physically or mentally from the drain of high stakes drama. I say 2 years because lets face it...Victoria was leaving.

JR.jpg​
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
Dallas missed that moment after the death of Bobby. Patrick's departure was the opportunity the writers had squandered. The Dream Season began with the right approach by putting Pam in the Ewing Office.

Heck the drama was just sitting there just waiting to be told...JR versus Pam or JR versus the world. This was the time to turn Dallas dark with an unrelenting JR determined to squash anyone or anything getting in his way. Bobby wasn't there anymore to reign him in. The only character left to dampen JR's spirits would have been Miss Ellie. Oh the drama that could have been played out for the next 2 years watching JR punish those standing before him or JR burning out physically or mentally from the drain of high stakes drama. I say 2 years because lets face it...Victoria was leaving.


Some people have theorized that Angelica Nero, a character created by Katzman, was brought in to steal Pam's thunder so the latter wouldn't have the professional conflict with JR you describe. (Although Katzman had limited impact on the scripting that year, billed only as a "creative consultant.")

So maybe that's what "The Mummy's Revenge" referred to when Victoria left.

Even Larry called the writers "male chauvinist pigs."
 

the-lost-son

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I would have liked a darker tone very much.

But I strongly suspect higher management had a significant influence (in the later years, too) and I have a hard time blaming Leonard Katzman only for the bad last 4 years. With him in charge Dallas became the phenomenon first. But the last years were so unlike the first ones, it's baffling.

Nobody here liked this comedy approach.
But I think as comedies dominated the late eighties (Bill Cosby, Roseanne) they tried to mix Dallas with comedy elements because management (probably) regarded it as successful. Around that time so much money was involved. Think about Duffy's return deal which included a significant raise, a one million dollar signing bonus and a contract lenght for 3(!) years. Then Dallas got renewed for the last to years combined which was exceptional because of its poor ratings at that time. But CBS was in a very bad shape back then and obviously did not have any alternatives to replace Dallas with. You have to keep in mind that Dallas was a global success too and international sales were essential (which made a continuation of TNT Dallas so complex btw). It's very likely that higher management CBS/Lorimar had their demands towards the production and didn't put their (financual) fate in the hands of just one producer. The more money involved the greater the need to protect their investment.

In my opinion - the dream season was influenced by Dynasty (No. 1 the year prior, I can't see Phil Capice making all these drastic changes without interference), the next one by Miami Vice (Bobby/JR/Ray chasing BD Calhoun with gunsten suddenly). Even the ranch war and Miss Ellie's murder she wrote plot seemed like someone of higher management pitched an idea.

So personally I would have preferred a more serious tone but looking at the top ten in late 80s TV it probably never would have been green-lighted by the show's financiers.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
In my opinion - the dream season was influenced by Dynasty
No argument here. It's like Dallas got sucked into the vortex of Dynasty's short lived success. I'd imagine Aaron Spelling popped the champagne bottles over that little win. Dynasty however was about to learn the fickle nature of viewers...those pesky little people who will only tolerate silly plots for so long.

Some people have theorized that Angelica Nero, a character created by Katzman, was brought in to steal Pam's thunder so the latter wouldn't have the professional conflict with JR you describe.
When I had an opportunity to re-watch the Dream Season there was a feeling the character of Pam was side-lined. To make matters worse the character of Mark was returned from the dead because you know, Pam needed a man in her life to justify her existence.

I've always theorized there was a story being played out in the halls of Lorimar and CBS. Far too many non-creative types sticking their noses in and meddling with a once great series. All the drama was behind the scenes and not on screen.
 

Monzo

Telly Talk Star
But CBS was in a very bad shape back then and obviously did not have any alternatives to replace Dallas with.
We still have to be thankful that CBS was in such a bad shape at the time, otherwise we wouldn't have gotten season 14 or even season 13.

Not sure about a darker Dallas, maybe it would have been similar to Falcon Crest's final season, so I prefer the later Dallas we got.
 

pete lashmar

Telly Talk Addict
As Dynasty got more outrageous Dallas should absolutely have got darker.

I remember that producers created the Haleyville storyline because they felt the previous series had been too business orientated and felt they needed to change the focus of the show, which of course was ridiculed by the viewers they had left.

The only scene worth it's salt in the last 4 seasons was when Cally met Sue Ellen at the oil baron's ball....which was exceptional. But that was it.

So many wasted opportunities and so many wasted characters gone, that the fans loved.
 

Toni

Maximum Member
- A Ewing wife is murdered in a crossfire.
- Bobby gets involved with terrorists unwillingly.
- Sheila often wears black.
- Jordan Lee is murdered inside a phone booth.
- JR gets drugged at the asylum.
- Bobby tells Cally: "This family is cursed, keep yourself away from us".

I think this was a good start toward gothic within the first 5 episodes. But instead...here comes Jeannie!! Maybe it should have been Barbara Carrera playing Angelica Nero again. Nobody would have noticed at this point! Michelle and James weren´t fun anymore this season, and every character who wasn´t missing (like Cally, Clayton) hardly had something to do. The Malibu affaire was laughable, and so was that awful Debra Lynn. But the season started well for a last season (which I think Katzman always suspected that would be).

1645295027382.png
"Oh yes, Mrs. Ewing! We bought Ewing Oil!
Where did you get the idea to hire me? A dream?"​
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
As Dynasty got more outrageous Dallas should absolutely have got darker.
This is why both series were working so well. For those wishing to enjoy that guilty viewing experience they would watch Dynasty for it's outrageous plots. Dallas - I consider - had set itself apart by taking a more serious tone. But when Dynasty had beaten Dallas in the ratings for a Nano second it would appear Dallas had to be tweaked because apparently this is what the viewers were demanding. This kind of explains Angelica Nero.

The Dallas producers should have had more faith in their brand and the viewer. Let Dynasty have their market. There was room for both. As long as both series were winning their respective time slot against the opposition did it really matter about being No.1? What would have been brazen from the CBS hierarchy would be them moving Dallas into the same time slot as Dynasty and see who could deliver the knockout punch.
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
I think there is something dark and dusty about late eighties/early nineties US prime time soaps.

1645300632130.png
1645300741256.png 1645301081158.png

It's like you know it belongs to your (respective) favourite soap, but at the same you're not sure that everybody else knows. Did it really happen or is it the result of reading too much fan fiction? I think I once described them as Club Members Only seasons or made-on-demand episodes. There was no real reason for them to still exist, but they did!
The beautiful nature and beautiful skies in Dallas and Falcon Crest...it was all gone! Everything happened on ugly sets in Dark & Dusty Corners...for those who just couldn't stop watching.
And it makes so much sense that it happened in the dusty and forgotten late eighties that was just waiting to be awakened and metamorphosed by the nineties.
It had absolutely nothing to offer, the decade was sick and tired of itself but it had no clue yet where to go from there. It was unknowingly waiting for Laura Palmer to wash ashore at Twin Peaks.
I think the earliest nineties still had that hazy dusty uncertain atmosphere, like, let's try this. Let's try Laura Palmer. Let's try Guru Josh. But at least it wasn't trapped in the dark and dusty end-of-the-decade corner anymore.

The last 3 seasons of Dallas are very frightening - but not always for the best reasons.
Many people HATE them, personally I love J Eddie Peck and Alex Barth and Joanna Sills. My Dynasty dreams always happen in the Carlton, there's a lot of confusion because everybody is trying to figure out who's still in it and who's not.
Still freshly traumatized by the Dynasty's dark and dusty ending and unsuspectingly wandering into Twin Peaks....I think it explains a lot.
 

James from London

International Treasure
There was no real reason for them to still exist, but they did!
The beautiful nature and beautiful skies in Dallas and Falcon Crest...it was all gone! Everything happened on ugly sets in Dark & Dusty Corners...for those who just couldn't stop watching.

This is great. It's not quite the same thing, but it reminds me of once watching an art student friend paint a picture. She got to a certain point and I said, "That looks brilliant. You should stop there." But she said she needed to carry on, to see what would happen next. Those later seasons I find increasingly fascinating to explore. As you say, they didn't need to happen, but it's like they just kept on going, almost organically, almost by accident. Speaking purely personally, I'm less interested in what they should have been than what they are, and what in retrospect that tells us about the series and the genre and the time as a whole.
 
Top