Kenny Coyote
Telly Talk Star
This thread makes you appreciate what good storytellers the people who produced and wrote Dallas were.
An interesting idea which I've never thought of. Could explain the often contentious relationship between Miss Ellie and JR and the shocking truth could have exploded onto the screen after Jock's death.I recently watched the episodes with Jock's first wife, Amanda, and I personally think it would have been more interesting if she had been his mother. It still would have thrown J.R. into an identity crisis, perhaps even more so than if Jock hadn't been his father.
Sometimes I think they were setting things up for digger to be J.R.'s father. Many of you have mentioned specific conversations during the show where they were laying the goundwork.Though I mentioned this in "old soapchat", I've always been curious about the conversation JR Ewing has with the unknown person in the opening scene for "Dallas: The Early Years." Upon reflection JR repeats a conversation he had with Jock and he says, "Once he even said. You wouldn't be here if it wasn't for Digger Barnes."
I know others had suggestions behind the meaning of this however I've always remembered it as ambiguous. As David Jacobs wrote the movie I'd love the opportunity to ask him was there anything more to it, or is my imagination running away from me.
Perhaps the writers/producers danced with the idea but shelved it after the "Who Shot JR?" sent Dallas into the stratosphere. Then of course we lost Jock so again the writers may have felt no need to revisit the idea and thought best to have full blood brothers fighting it out for Ewing Oil.Sometimes I think they were setting things up for digger to be J.R.'s father. Many of you have mentioned specific conversations during the show where they were laying the goundwork.
And imagine this: Ray (who J.R. called a bastard) would be Jock's true son. But J.R. would not be.
The irony. . .
Sometimes I think they were setting things up for digger to be J.R.'s father. Many of you have mentioned specific conversations during the show where they were laying the goundwork.
And imagine this: Ray (who J.R. called a bastard) would be Jock's true son. But J.R. would not be.
The irony. . .
I don't understand why I always seem to hear that people like this idea so much. I mean, do they want JR to kill himself or something? Because I can imagine that he just probably might do that if that turned out to be true.
Think JR would officially be the biggest villain of all time if he 'sold' his niece to an Arab harem
What I wanted to see: In season 5 (dvd), JR accepts his divorce with Sue Ellen, hooks up with Katherine after that reporter scene they had, then they eventually fall for each other and get married. No cheating, divorces, Mandy, Cally, or dumbed-down JR in the later years. JR gets to be president of Ewing Oil since Katherine doesn't let Bobby use that stupid Tundra Torque which made his totals for the contest higher than JR's. Katherine gets to be president of Wentworth Tool and Dye and does not have to share anything from Wentworth Industries because she won a case against Cliff and Pam in court over Rebecca's will. Cliff does not aquire Gold Canyon 340 because Katherine never lent him the money because she already has everything Wentworth. Oh, and the dream never happens because Katherine is happy with JR doesn't get crazy for Bobby and try to kill him. JR and Katherine kick everyone's asses in business and live happily ever after. And that is my wonderful version of Dallas. lol. The End.
It was a great episode but the Kit Mainwaring story ,could have been stretched out serial wise for quite a while with Kit struggling with his sexual its and he jilting Lucy at the altar only for JR to blackmail him into marrying her
Have you ever thought of adding Channing and Gioberti to your name?![]()
So I know that the Knots and Dallas universes were forever separated after Pam's dream, but here's the storyline I always wish had happened.... Now, people have mentioned the possibility of JR being Digger's son, but I have a different idea... Picture it... Dallas, in the late 80s... Gary visits Miss Ellie with important news: He wants to share with her that she has twin grand babies, after Gary has just learned for sure that Val's twins are indeed his. Gary shows Miss Ellie pictures on the back patio of Southfork... then she gets this look on her face. She has several questions: Have the babies received sufficient medical checkups? Are they healthy? Any problems? Any indications of one neurofibermitosis? Gary asks why... Miss Ellie breaks down and finally admits that Digger was his father. That is the true reason why Gary was always a "different" Ewing... also, that's why Jock never could connect to him... in the back of his mind, Jock always suspected something was off.... Miss Ellie's second pregnancy and Jock's returning from war. He always wondered if Digger was keeping her company while Jock was away.
Imagine the possibilities! JR could threaten to sue for money Gary inherited after Jock died. Imagine Cliff going to Knots Landing to connect to a half brother he never knew he had. What do you all think? I think that if we want to entertain the idea that Digger would father a child by Ellie, it would make MUCH more sense if it were Gary rather than JR.
Perhaps the writers/producers danced with the idea but shelved it after the "Who Shot JR?" sent Dallas into the stratosphere. Then of course we lost Jock so again the writers may have felt no need to revisit the idea and thought best to have full blood brothers fighting it out for Ewing Oil.
JR and Sue Ellen should never ever have been parted in the way they were in the final seasons leading up to Linda's departure. The best thing would have been for JR to crack on and notice what a great partner (in and out of bed!) he had with Sue Ellen and not wreck his marriage (and the show) by getting involved with Kimberley. It destroyed the show in my opinion and Dallas was never the same. JR should have had Sue Ellen has his business ally. Jackass.
I certainly would have used this as the explanation for the re-casting of Southfork after the 1978 miniseries. Even if you didn't see it. I always picture that opening scene of the 1978/79 season around the pool with family --- only with workers walking around the roof partially covered in plastic and some fleeting reference between Jock and Miss Ellie over backgammon about the recent tornado and its damage to the house.Richard Channing said:As Texas is prone to tornadoes, I think a twister hitting Southfork could have made for a very exciting season finale. Someone could be driving back and trying to get home before the storm hits and their car gets flipped. Ray could be out trying to round up the cattle (kind of like in 'Winds of vengeance' but obviously this would be a much more dangerous and dramatic scenario) and not make it back in time, so is missing. At least part of Southfork would be destroyed, and I wouldn't mind seeing Lucy get sucked out of her bedroom, possibly never to be seen again. A couple of people should get flattened as the roof collapses on them. Probably very elaborate and expensive for them to actually do, but it would have been fun.
Pretty much, yes. Although I'm not sure that Miss Ellie was "overstepping her place". But JR's turning belly-up during the custody hearing certainly felt forced and contrived.I would have liked to have seen them make the custody trial in season 5 a lot more involved and intense. I wanted to see a hard fought court battle between JR and Sue Ellen where they both pull out all the stops and go all out to try to win custody of John Ross.
I'm watching it right now. JR says: I'm gonna get my boy back if I have to tear her little black heart out." I wanted to see Sue Ellen fight back the same way.
JR takes Sue Ellen aside right before the court case and says "Sue Ellen, I'll fight you till you're in the streets with nothing more to your name than the clothes on your back and a little tin cup in your hand."
Sue Ellen: You wouldn't do that
J.R.: Wouldn't I? You know me better than that. You're not gonna win, honey and even if you do, I have the time and the money and the power to keep you tied up in litigation forever...I'm prepared to fight you till hell freezes over if that's what it takes to get my boy back."
J.R. didn't follow through on that but I wish he had because an all out battle in court between JR and Sue Ellen where each uses everything possible to win would have been great to watch. I wanted to see each try to drag the other through the Texas mud from one side of the state to the other.
Apparently J.R. didn't follow through because Miss Ellie had threatened him. She said that if he did that she'd make sure that he got voted out of power in Ewing Oil and replaced by Bobby.
That's overstepping her place to try to keep him from making the best legal case possible to get his son back. I can't picture her taking kindly to anyone telling her what she can and can't say in court if she were in a similar situation. I picture her saying something along the lines of "What I do to ensure I get my son back is none of your business."
Even if she had followed through on her threat, that arrangement they had at the time was only to be used while Jock was on his business trip. Those stipulations would all become nullified as soon as he returned, or as it turned out, until Jock's will was read. I guess they just didn't want to take the story in that direction but I think it would have been very interesting and entertaining to watch that type of a court battle. It's something we never got to see between JR and Sue Ellen despite all the animosity between them and despite how strongly each felt about John Ross. Don't you think it would have made for some compelling TV?
There were possibilities. I have said that JR and Sue Ellen having a daughter after John Ross might have been good. I felt that remarrying Ellie was a mistake and that they should have had her be like Victoria Barkley.