Sue Ellen and Cally

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
The casting of Peter was always my biggest issue with that storyline. IMO, Peter was the most miscast character up to that point.

I believe @Snarky Oracle! suggested the actor that played Peter's friend Jerry would have been a better casting choice, and I tend to agree.

Although, others have suggested Atkins' casting brought an additional level of romantic incompetence to the story: two star-crossed, ineffectual lovers who had a clandestine relationship which somehow didn't matter... PeeWee couldn't get it up, and Swellin never took off her clothes -- and yet they thought they had something special... Sort of... Maybe... I guess.
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
they set it up one way - racy promotional photos, sex-deprived Sue Ellen ogling shirtless sweaty twenty-something guys playing football in the grass… and then had Peter dress and act like a prepubescent boy (I’m surprised he didn’t wear a cutoff t-shirt to the Oil Barons’ Ball), with Sue Ellen dressing and styling herself like someone several years older than her look in previous seasons. It’s like they didn’t trust the audience to appreciate the unconventional age difference without beating them over the head with it.

I don’t know if creepy and unsettling rather than titillating was what they’d intended to go for with the storyline, but it kind of seems like they ran with that as the season progressed..
 
Last edited:

Holly Harlot

Telly Talk Newbie
I also found it odd that when JR found out, he threatened to ruin Peter's life. Surely he couldn't have seen him as a serious threat. He must have known Sue Ellen wasn't going to run off with that child. So I'm thinking it must have just been used as a power play to intimidate Sue Ellen. That whole plotline was gross and one of the worst mistakes on the show.
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
hm, maybe Peter really was something of a coke fiend and that’s what gave him the delusion that Sue Ellen would leave Southfork and move in with him in that crummy apartment.. and he was actually after her money to support his habit. This would also explain his abrupt dropout from SMU.

As JR once said to Dallas Police Vice Department stalwart Matt Henderson, he’s always willing to help law enforcement keep Dallas clean and vice-free.
 

Bobby Southworth

Telly Talk Fan
Top Poster Of Month
hm, maybe Peter really was something of a coke fiend and that’s what gave him the delusion that Sue Ellen would leave Southfork and move in with him in that crummy apartment.. and he was actually after her money to support his habit. This would also explain his abrupt dropout from SMU.
Now.. there's that backstory I was asking for. A little explanation for his behavior.. :D

He looks even younger in that picture.. Did someone photo-shop Ricky Schroder when he was on Silver Spoons? Dang..
 
Top