The Lucy Failure

JRandSueEllenForever

Telly Talk Member
Did Dallas fail Lucy or did Lucy fail Dallas?

Lucy was never one of my favorite characters. In the beginning I thought she was an exceptionally bad actress and her character wasn’t very likable. From her fling with Ray (who was old enough to be her father and turned out to be her uncle) to her many other failed relationships, one engagement that was really a business deal with uncle JR, and another engagement to a homosexual, and a failed marriage, the girl never caught a break. Let’s not forget the rape, the abortion, and the long line of ne’er do well losers who used her for her money. She seemed to simply lurk around at Southfork, sneer at and insult JR, and vote against him to oust him from Ewing Oil. It’s as if the writers didn’t know what to do with her, and when they did, no one cared except to feel sorry for whatever misfortune she endured.

The one time I actually liked Lucy was season six when she met Mickey. Finally she had a love interest with whom she had real chemistry, and she feel deeply and sweetly in love. I enjoyed her scenes with him, their cocky and humorous banter back and forth and later their tender, heartfelt confessions. They seemed like soulmates to me. Finally she had happiness! She was likable! Then what does Dallas do? They kill Mickey off after only one season.

Really?

Then more failed relationships. Then she reconciles with Mitch (oh please!) with whom she had zero chemistry before and STILL doesn’t. Remarried him and moved to Atlanta. But she was back when that failed yet again. Surprise...NOT!

So whatever happened to her? In the TNT reboot, she’s still lurking around at the occasional Southfork parties, seemingly single and never having any children. Evidently she was just an afterthought to them too.

Maybe she should have been on Knots Lamding with her parents all along.
 

pete lashmar

Telly Talk Addict
I've always been under the impression that if Lucy wasn't in Dallas it wouldn't have been any different - her character just wasn't needed or important.

CT wasn't the best actress anyway - though she did improve - and her storylines were never great, so the writers had problems with her too.

If Lucy had been written as an intelligent character, with a bit more class, but still sassy and naughty then I think she could have been a far better character.
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
Her age and position in the family made her an isolated character in a rather isolated environment (which made her modelling career such a mind-boggling event) and she wasn't an essential part of the feuds and business storylines.
She changed from Enfant Terrible to Poor Little Rich Girl, perhaps they didn't want us to dislike her too much.

I think, all things considered, they haven't done such a bad job with her. Maybe she should have been given less-but-more-effective screen time.
Still, I can't imagine Dallas without Lucy.
 

ArchieLucasCarringtonEwing1989

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
I think Lucy had potential its just the writers had no idea how to utilise her, however there were tidbits to how she really was, she wasn't interested in Ewing Oil, in fact I recall that she seemed very interested in Southfork and the land, just like her father, grandmother and every Southworth ancestor before her, she wasn't really a Ewing by nature, the writers should've played this up more.
 

Sarah

Moderator Emerita
Great thread!

My first thought is that she was failed by the writers. Charlene was only 17 years old when Dallas started with no acting experience. She was thrust into this what would become global success.

I can’t imagine anyone else as Lucy - mainly due to her unique long blonde hair and small stature. I think she gets a hard time. She will always be an original Ewing to me and part of my family.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
Oddly enough, Lucy fared far better when writers made her smart, astute.
 

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
I'll never forget what Terry Wogan called the character - the poisoned Dwarf!

I actually like Lucy. She had a few good storylines but ultimately the writers weren't sure which direction to take the character because she was so young. :)
 

Laurie Marr

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
In terms of the plotting of the show, she was an inspired creation: the outsider on the inside, the focus of inter-generational conflict, the living antidote to the family’s own self-mythologising about the bonds of family, the inheritor of a grudge against JR. Let’s not be delicate here, though. Charlene Tilton just didn’t have the acting chops to fully explore these dramatic possibilities.
 

Karin

Moderator
Staff Member
More could definitely have been done with Lucy on the show. Maybe they could have had her married to Mickey. Or they could have given her a child at some occasion.

The way they kept using Steve and Charlene for guest spots with no content or clue to what they Ray and Lucy were up to these days on Dallas TNT was a disgrace and a huged missed opportunity. They should have used these characters better.

Maybe she should have been on Knots Lamding with her parents all along.

No not from the beginning. But when she had run her course on Dallas they should have moved her and Mitch to Knots Landing instead of Atlanta when they wrote her out of the show at the end of the 84/85 season. Gary and Val were main characters on Knots Landing so the storylines possibilities with Lucy on the show with all her relatives, her parents, step-mother, step-siblings, actual siblings (although they were still babies), step-father, her grandma, her uncle and aunt were endless.
 
Top