the process of diminishing JR

the-lost-son

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
After Lenny Katzman returned to season 9 (DVD10) he made some remarks about the dream season:
„JR was whipped at every turn. Everybody was pushing him around. I did give warnings a long the way (as consultant) . I kept saying that we‘ve got the best character on television and we‘re making a wimp out of him. In season 9 you‘re going to see the real JR again.“

I fully agree. The first time I wondered what‘s wrong here when JR was deceived by Mandy Winger (spying for Cliff). Ole JR would have anticipated/figured that one out easily. When he was slapped in his own office to the ground I felt only pity for him- first by Mark Graison and then by Matt Cantrell (the low point).

So it was a wise decision to make JR more ruthless again. In my opinion that worked only partially. I did not like how weak JR seemed dealing with B.D. Calhoun who walked around Southfork, Ewing Oil, kidnapping Sue Ellen and JohnRoss. Ole JR would have got some hired hands to settle the matter and not Bobby/Ray to save the day. Obviously they wanted to portray Calhoun as a real threat, but for me it emphasized JR’s weak- and helplessness.
It was an improved situation nonetheless but still miles away from the old JR who threw over some foreign countries, drove people out of town or put them in prison. His former chilling threats (notable examples to Alan Beam/Kristen, Sue Ellen, Edgar Randolph) became increasingly empty. E.g. his remark to Jerry Kenderson about breaking his legs didn‘t feel menacing ( compared to threatening Sue Ellen to force her to an abortion early on.)

But although Katzman was aware of the danger („If you diminish JR, you diminish the series.“) the development to weaken JR continued for the next 4 years. The guy who was put in a mental institution or forced to marry in Halleyville did not resemble the character I was once rooting for. They had great storylines in the past and when one of his schemes backfired (mortgaging Southfork, asian oil leases) the audience loved it when he came back on top (e.g. I was cheering when he sold his shares to Vaughn Leland.)

Despite all its shortcomings, TNT Dallas‘ version of JR resembled more the character‘s early years which was very good. Apparently season 2 (TNT) was supposed to end with JR reuniting with SueEllen and back in the seat of EwingOil/Energy.

Two question:
1. Why did they go down that route? Why did they keep diminishing JR although they knew better?
In so many aspects they tried (unsuccessfully) to keep the old formula of Dallas (e.g. the McCay clan as replacement rivals for the Barnes, attempts to recreate the Bobby/Pam magic). It‘s a complete riddle to me why they never returned to the old JR of the years 78-85. Any ideas?
2. When was the first time/first plot you were wondering why JR was suddenly so weak/helpless?
 

DallasFanForever

Telly Talk Supreme
Two question:
1. Why did they go down that route? Why did they keep diminishing JR although they knew better?
In so many aspects they tried (unsuccessfully) to keep the old formula of Dallas (e.g. the McCay clan as replacement rivals for the Barnes, attempts to recreate the Bobby/Pam magic). It‘s a complete riddle to me why they never returned to the old JR of the years 78-85. Any ideas?
2. When was the first time/first plot you were wondering why JR was suddenly so weak/helpless?
I think it’s only fair to say that J.R. wasn’t the only character being diminished as time went by. This seemed to be a problem with most of the characters in my opinion. I think we tend to notice it more with JR because firstly, he became the lead character, and secondly, because the changes in the character weren’t subtle. JR not acting like JR anymore is much more noticeable to us than if it were the other characters.

The first time I noticed JR changing was during the dream season. Granted it really didn’t happen but for arguments sake I felt he was really toned down a lot that season. The whole Marinos Shipping storyline made him look really weak. It seemed like Angelica was always one step ahead of him for 95% of that story. I kept waiting for him to throw her out of Dallas or have her and her henchmen escorted out but it never happened. Even at the end when he finally turns the tables on her she gets the last laugh with the bombs.

Now maybe that had a lot to do with the lack of Bobby being there? Certainly a lot of characters that season were different without him but this was the season I noticed JR changing in regards to his toughness. And I don’t think he was ever the same. There were still periodic flashes of the old JR but he never recovered.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
After Lenny Katzman returned to season 9 (DVD10) he made some remarks about the dream season:
„JR was whipped at every turn. Everybody was pushing him around. I did give warnings a long the way (as consultant) . I kept saying that we‘ve got the best character on television and we‘re making a wimp out of him. In season 9 you‘re going to see the real JR again.“

I fully agree. The first time I wondered what‘s wrong here when JR was deceived by Mandy Winger (spying for Cliff). Ole JR would have anticipated/figured that one out easily. When he was slapped in his own office to the ground I felt only pity for him- first by Mark Graison and then by Matt Cantrell (the low point).

So it was a wise decision to make JR more ruthless again. In my opinion that worked only partially. I did not like how weak JR seemed dealing with B.D. Calhoun who walked around Southfork, Ewing Oil, kidnapping Sue Ellen and JohnRoss. Ole JR would have got some hired hands to settle the matter and not Bobby/Ray to save the day. Obviously they wanted to portray Calhoun as a real threat, but for me it emphasized JR’s weak- and helplessness.
It was an improved situation nonetheless but still miles away from the old JR who threw over some foreign countries, drove people out of town or put them in prison. His former chilling threats (notable examples to Alan Beam/Kristen, Sue Ellen, Edgar Randolph) became increasingly empty. E.g. his remark to Jerry Kenderson about breaking his legs didn‘t feel menacing ( compared to threatening Sue Ellen to force her to an abortion early on.)

But although Katzman was aware of the danger („If you diminish JR, you diminish the series.“) the development to weaken JR continued for the next 4 years. The guy who was put in a mental institution or forced to marry in Halleyville did not resemble the character I was once rooting for. They had great storylines in the past and when one of his schemes backfired (mortgaging Southfork, asian oil leases) the audience loved it when he came back on top (e.g. I was cheering when he sold his shares to Vaughn Leland.)

Despite all its shortcomings, TNT Dallas‘ version of JR resembled more the character‘s early years which was very good. Apparently season 2 (TNT) was supposed to end with JR reuniting with SueEllen and back in the seat of EwingOil/Energy.

Two question:
1. Why did they go down that route? Why did they keep diminishing JR although they knew better?
In so many aspects they tried (unsuccessfully) to keep the old formula of Dallas (e.g. the McCay clan as replacement rivals for the Barnes, attempts to recreate the Bobby/Pam magic). It‘s a complete riddle to me why they never returned to the old JR of the years 78-85. Any ideas?
2. When was the first time/first plot you were wondering why JR was suddenly so weak/helpless?
First, I agree with and your statement regarding TNT, except as soon as he was dead they went back to weak JR, hence he left his son nothing really, and his master piece was pathetic. Hence JR and now John Ross were weak and pathetic.

Question 1: I think they went the route they did because they didn’t were sappy in thinking in black and white terms and good always wins and good guys are all good and they just couldn’t commit to shades of gray and bad guys coming out on top. JR was more than a v BBC as guy, he was every man’s bad side, pretentious, arrogant, powerful. We didn’t just love to hate him, we felt bad for him and we felt jealous of him. The later writers just never got that complexity and so turned him into a joke. TNT didn’t get it either, for them he was all scoundrel.

Question 2: I don’t know but I look forward to the answers which follow.

Opening of Season 1 of TNT should have been JR running Ewing Industries (based on Koch Industries), the biggest, baddest m.f.er ever. He should have been objecting to John Ross with Elena, setting him up with an Anderson grandchild, and not Cliff going after Chris’s technology but JR setting him up to take it away, all the while battling Bobby in court for the mineral rights to SF, where he agrees to sharing them (with Gary) and slant drilling in return for Bobby giving him the house and putting the land into a foundation to protect it. Then Chris says to JR, I want you to teach me business as John Ross asks Bobby to teach him ranching. And then JR brings Lucas home to stir up trouble for Bobby - and we’re off.
 
Top