The truth about the Ewing-Barnes Feud

Zeus89

Telly Talk Newbie
I've been trying to work out what was the true story behind it, was Digger right or was Jock?

In the early years of Dallas it is not painted as black and white as the later years, Jock shows some signs of once being a ruthless man who would have done what Digger suggested. However Digger over the course of the series is reveled to be a liar and Murder, so is hardly trustworthy .

I came to the conculsion in the end that the Ewing fortune was built upon the stolen skills of Digger, but Jock did it as a way to save himself from loosing it all on one of Diggers wild drinking sessions.

I do belive Diggers side of things, in terms of being conned, however I believe Jock did those things out of survival.

Your thoughts on this?
 

lbf522

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I love your analysis. I had long wondered myself as to the who was at fault in this matter. Jock himself once remarked that he was ruthless and what we today would call a robber baron.

Then there is Digger. I do believe that he was a part of Jock's success but his negative side like his drinking caused problems for Jock. As one poster put it best, why didn't Digger try and strike out on his own? If he could smell oil under the ground, he would be in demand from other oilmen.
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
later on they made Jock out to be a saint, but in the early years it was ambiguous and I thought his "real power is something you take" speech to Bobby was meaningful in that context.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
I love your analysis. I had long wondered myself as to the who was at fault in this matter. Jock himself once remarked that he was ruthless and what we today would call a robber baron.

Then there is Digger. I do believe that he was a part of Jock's success but his negative side like his drinking caused problems for Jock. As one poster put it best, why didn't Digger try and strike out on his own? If he could smell oil under the ground, he would be in demand from other oilmen.

Yes he was a Robber Barron of sorts.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
It's notable that Sam Culver, who was considered one of the most important politicians in Texas history said to Jock about Digger : "I think you did as well as you could have by him." We never saw anyone outside of the Barnes family, anyone reputable who was around at the time to be able to know firsthand, disagree with this.
 

Mustard

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
They are both to blame. Let's not forget that Jock stuck by Digger longer than other people did. Jock even fell out with his own brother Jason over Digger, to the extent that Jason said he had enough and left Texas for Alaska and the wandering life. Jock stuck by Digger for so long because Digger was excellent at sniffing oil and knowing exactly where to dig to find oil. Jock could even tolerate Digger's crazy drinking and excesses to an extent, and on the odd occasion would even join in. Digger went too far with this though, becoming one of those self-pitying alcoholics who wields grudges.

On the other hand, Jock was always thinking business, thinking money, thinking big. He was hard working and disciplined, contrary to Digger being hard working on some occasions while being reckless and hedonistic the rest of the time. Jock admitted in a scene on Dallas to envying Digger's girlfriend Eleanor Southworth, and he kept the secret about his first wife Amanda out of fear of never getting with Ellie. Miss Ellie leaving Digger for Jock in 1936 created some bitter resentment on Digger's part, but business deals still carried on between them for a few more years. There came a time, around 1939 when Jock decided that Digger was now more trouble than he was worth, and registered a field in Jock's name only. When Digger found out, he was spitting mad. As Ewing Oil grew and grew, so did Digger's resentment. By this point, Jock wants nothing to do with Digger until Digger is humble enough to admit to his crazy mistakes and apologize. Digger thinks that Jock is the one who cut him loose and left him and his family the much poorer relations compared to the rich Ewings, stealing what was his.

Fast forward to 1978 and the fifth Dallas episode called "Barbecue", the irony is that Digger was on his best behaviour for a while, while Jock had drank too much beforehand and was out of order.
 
Last edited:

Mustard

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
I love your analysis. I had long wondered myself as to the who was at fault in this matter. Jock himself once remarked that he was ruthless and what we today would call a robber baron.

Then there is Digger. I do believe that he was a part of Jock's success but his negative side like his drinking caused problems for Jock. As one poster put it best, why didn't Digger try and strike out on his own? If he could smell oil under the ground, he would be in demand from other oilmen.

Digger was in demand from other oilmen. He drank that money too, and alienated them far sooner than Jock. The irony with the Barnes-Ewing feud is that Digger resents Jock more than the other oilmen precisely because Jock stuck by him for so long, long enough to form a close bond that turned to loathing.

I have to admire Digger in some ways because he's so full on, so stubborn and lived so long being a crazy alcoholic, yet if he wanted to get sober to earn some money in the oil fields so he could drink more then he would. Other alcoholics are just very different to this. If Gary Ewing falls off the wagon, it's not long before he hits rock bottom and cuts the most pathetic figure. When Digger is drunk, he's usually just a pain in the backside or dwelling in nostalgia, but towards the end of his life ended up in the drunk tank a few times.

When Jock hears about this, he scoffs and sneers "same old Digger Barnes". Digger is that typical genius sort of person who has an extraordinary gift, yet also has an amazing talent for self-destruction.
 
Last edited:
Top