But "what character most people think of first when they think of Dallas" isn't what this contest is about.
I know, but the reason why he's the character most strongly associated with the show - because he was so damn entertaining, is related to this contest.
Try as the writers did to drag Pam's name into the tired last few seasons, they couldn't do too much damage because it's unthinkable VP would have been part of anything that made her character into a tired old mess. It's a shame Duffy can't say the same.
Unless someone is so wealthy they don't need to work anymore, there are plenty of times when people go to work even if the work they're given isn't necessarily the best material they've ever had to work with. People go to work to make money and they were making a lot of money in Dallas. Why would you walk away from the ATM machine when it's still spitting out twenties?
Duffy found out the hard way that he wasn't as in demand for major Hollywood movies as he thought he would be. Most actors don't have the luxury of walking away from anything that isn't up to their artistic standards. Case in point: The made for TV movies Victoria Principal made after she quit Dallas are hardly high quality art. If she'd been offered a role in a big movie with a great script co-starring someone of the caliber of Jack Nicholson don't you think she'd have taken that instead? The list of options for actors, especially ones who have become identified with one particular role can be very limited.
I think Patrick Duffy did as well with the material he was given in the late seasons as anyone could have. The quality of the writing went downhill in the late seasons of Dallas so the stories weren't as good. The casting of new characters was especially bad in the late seasons (James and Michelle, I'm looking at you).
If you were to make a convincing case that Duffy and Hagman, for that matter, just "phoned in their lines" and weren't giving their best effort to work with the material they were given, I'd say that they share the blame for the decline in the quality of Dallas in the late seasons. As far as I can see though, as actors, they did what they could with the material they were given. You can't make chicken salad out of chicken shit.