Match 5: My vote goes to Ellie. The beloved family matriarch was for the most part always around to offer support, to be an earthy wife to Jock and later Clayton plus mama totally remodelled in season 7 (DVD-8). Unlike others I accepted the two Ellies. However I can understand the reasoning behind the less fandom, for Ellie II.
Jenna who was played by three actresses had a good back story but when the ex wife of Elvis landed the role things didn’t always play out all that well, with all due respect to Priscilla.
Match 6: Lucy has the edge here. Gary and Val’s daughter was a spoiled brat when DALLAS started and then she slowly morphed into a respectable young woman. Charlene Tilton’s character did get a bit of a mixed bag, writing wise though. When she shone Lucy sparkled with the best of them.
‘Who Shot JR?’ – “It was you Kristin!” Oh yes Sue Ellen’s younger sister in the spring of 1980 had the oil tycoon near dead, in a cliff-hanger to beat all cliff-hangers. IMHO Kristin was an entertaining character who will go down in history, for this reason.
Ellie goes to Ewing Oil, for a showdown with Bobby and JR. She means business….(a scene from season 9, DVD-10, 1986-’87):
Ellie: “Hello Phyllis!”
Phyllis: “Hello Mrs. Ewing!”
Ellie: “Is JR in his office?”
Phyllis: “Ah yes he is but ah.”
JR on the phone: “Say I’ll get back to ya! Mama what brings you here?”
Ellie goes around to JR’s chair: “Sit down JR, where I can see you and get your brother in here.”
JR: “Something the matter?”
Ellie: “Now JR!!!!”
JR buzzes Bobby, on the phone: “Bobby, mama is in my office. She wants to talk to both of us. Can you come in here, a minute please?”
Bobby: “Be right in.”
Bobby: “Mama. JR. What’s going on?”
Ellie: “Sit down Bobby! I want to talk to you and JR.”
Bobby: “Sure!”
Ellie: “I always thought no matter what happened I’d standby my family. It was always that way with the Ewings. It was always the family, against all outsiders. We always stuck up for each other, even when we knew we were wrong. But no more, it as gone too far and I won’t defend either of you, any longer. I can’t!”
Bobby: “Mama what do you mean?”
Ellie: “I’ve thought about this a lot and believe me this is one of the hardest things, I’ve ever had to say but as far as I’m concerned you two don’t deserve to own Ewing Oil!”
JR: “Well mama this is daddy’s company, you’re talking about.”
Ellie: “Don’t you ever, ever speak his name in front of me again. You disarm his name and his company and I guess that’s what hurts me the most because you’re daddy would have been so ashamed of you. I know he would because I sure as hell am!”
JR: “Well mama I know you’re upset but can we talk this over?”
Ellie: “I have nothing more to say. You are both on your own now and as far as Ewing Oil goes it should have died with your daddy. It would have saved us all, a lot of trouble.”
Ellie leaves the company, founded by her husband and her sons, sitting like two reprimanded children.