Match 1. Miss Ellie - Ray hits the target a few times for his role in several of great storylines including Mickey Trotter, Donna's baby and bonding with Tony. However, Ellie lands combination punches of consistently being a more interesting character, even though she loses points for her participation in the ghastly murder mystery and Pride storylines. By being involved in so many great scenes and plots that far outweigh the crud of which she was part, Ellie wins on points.
Match 2. Jock - In the words of Ellie "Jock was a great man". He was such a strong character and have such an impact on the show that even after his death, it only took his portrait to cast a massive shadow over so many subsequent events. When Sue Ellen was at her peak she was unrivalled but at her depths I was bored with her, for example during the Nicholas Pearce plot and almost everything connected with Don Lockwood. On balance, Jock wins on points.