Semi final match 1 (Ellie): Although Sue Ellen for quite some time was better known as the lip quivering long suffering wife of JR and then later as a successful business woman I will vote for Ellie. Ellie played mainly by Barbara Bel Geddes was the down to earth no nonsense character; with a deep love of the ranch, originating from her Southworth side of the family, as I said before.
When Donna Reed was cast as Ellie Southworth Ewing Farlow I didn’t think her new interpretation was awful. Owing to having just married burly Clayton I suppose it was important for the character to return, after their honeymoon. It was a sort of can’t do right for doing wrong scenario.
Semi final match 2 (Bobby): Lucy shone like she never did before or again for that matter when she got involved with Mickey Trotter. She found a bit of happiness with Doctor Mitch Cooper but Charlene Tilton’s character was under written, compared to the likes of Pam and Sue Ellen. IMHO Bobby deserves more to be in the final. Despite giving up on Pam during the original show I feel that he became less of a joke; than his brother JR, during the twilight years.
In the revitalised show the youngest son became a bit like Jock. However he was grumpier than Jock could ever possibly have been and along with some other traits (including being married to ‘Annie Get Yer Gun’) the older grey haired Bobby wasn’t a nicer person. All in all TNT aside Bobby (CBS/Lorimar 1978 – ’85; 1986-’91, 1996 and 1998) should be a final contender.
Bobby has a heart to heart with Ellie, in the kitchen of Southfork. He wants to convince his mother to have Jock declared legally dead. Ellie believes that he is still alive somewhere in the jungles of South America, as no body was ever located. Bobby watches on and listens, as his mother can’t hold back the tears, (a scene from season 4, DVD-5, 1981-’82):
Ellie: “No! No! This house is still Jock’s house. This family is still Jock’s family. You’re Jock’s son and I’m Jock’s woman and the rules we live by are the rules he made. That’s the way it will be. He’s alive, Bobby!”
Bobby gets up out of his chair and goes to console a distraught Ellie: “Mama!”
Ellie: “As long as I believe he’s alive, he’s alive!!!”
Freeze frame; fade to black, the closing credits commence and the theme tune starts.