Snarky Oracle!
Telly Talk Supreme
It's very difficult to have a discussion with folks who idealize JR and/or Sue Ellen, and are perplexed/frustrated by those who don't.
Committing rape wasn't any more true to JR's character than committing murder was, until the episode where he probably raped Holly. I don't know since I didn't see it, but to me there was a heavy implication he raped her. Not everyone sees it the same way which is understandable since it was left to our imaginations what actually happened.
Laurel wasn't raped. Laurel was given an opportunity. JR said if she did a favor for him, he'd do a favor for Clayton. She was free to accept or decline. I find it diminishes the seriousness of rape when the word is thrown around in that way, when actual rape victims would have loved to have been able to say "I decline" and have it end right there.
It's very difficult to have a discussion with folks who idealize JR and/or Sue Ellen, and are perplexed/frustrated by those who don't.
There is a scene in the book The Perks of Being a Wallflower where a teenage male has his girlfriend perform oral sex on him. She doesn't want to because she knows someone is watching them. She tells him, "No," and cries but does it anyway. The characters in the book call this rape. I know many people who consider this rape.
What is your opinion?
Ooh, that's right on the edge - that's a tough question. My opinion ( which I realize legally is a non-issue because the law is the law) is that if he used physical force it is rape, and if he were ding something to her and she explicitly told him to stop and he did not stop, those are both rape. If she says "no" but then without him exerting any force, she goes ahead and does it, it means she's emotionally conflicted over it, but has consented anyway so its not rape.
These are all obviously undesirable, but I believe specificity in language is important and rape is the worst type of undesirable sexual behavior - actually combination of sex and violence that is a felony. Just as we distinguish between misdemeanors and felonies, I think it's important that we don't say to a woman who was raped by a man who broke into her home when she was alone, put a knife to her throat during the rape that her experience was the same as that if the girl you just described in "perks Of Being A Wallflower." Not that we don't still take that girl's situation seriously, but she didn't suffer the violence the women in the other example had to endure.
This is a sensitive subject, so I want to make it very clear that I'm not condoning either situation; I'm saying they are different. As an analogy, I consider felonies different from, and worse than misdemeanors but don't condone either of them. My point is that specificity is important so that we don't say the person who commits a misdemeanor has done the same thing as the person who commits a felony and they both deserve equal punishments.
I can't say any of those questions ever troubled me watching this story.
I found that scene very powerful, very moving. I felt like that conflict in Bobby, between his loyalty to his family and his own sense of morality, had been established early on and this was the pay off to it.
The question I asked regarding his integrity - that his words (spoken at Jock's trial) and his actions (over the following two weeks contradicted each other - is related to something you had mentioned previously:
This situation, which began with Cliff instigating Jock's trial, depicts an absence of conflict between Bobby's loyalty to his family and his morality. Cliff did something so inexcusable that JR vowed to run him out of the state if Texas, and Bobby replied that JR would have to get in line behind him, it's one of those rare situations where JR and Bobby both agreed that the same thing had to be done and the only question was which one of them would have the honor of doing it.
JR seemed to be fine with letting Bobby be the one to get to do the job. There again, there is no conflict. Bobby wants to get to do it and JR is alright with that. Over the next two weeks Bobby does nothing to run Cliff out of Texas. Maybe you'd think if Bobby lacked the integrity to do what he said he'd do then JR would do what he originally wanted to do himself anyway, except there was one big problem with that. Two weeks later JR was in the hospital because someone had shot him. That looks like valid excuse to me as to why JR didn't pick up the slack when Bobby wouldn't or couldn't make good on his word.
There is conflict here but it isn't between Bobby and his family. The conflict is between what Bobby says he will do and what he actually does. Bobby says a lot but does nothing. Bobby didn't even try to make good on his word. Bobby has both morality problem and an integrity problem. Bobby's words and his actions blatantly contradicted each other! Bobby proves to be a hypocrite - one who claims to have moral standards or beliefs to which his own behavior doesn't conform.
That by itself would have been disappointing, that Bobby either wouldn't or couldn't do what he said he wanted to do, but then Bobby makes things worse. Bobby makes it clear that he didn't just fail to do, or forget to do what he said he would do to Cliff for trying to send his Jock to prison for a crime he didn't commit. Now Bobby decides that instead of running Cliff out of Texas, he's come up with something even more appropriate: Bobby wants to reward Cliff by making him a partner in the Ewing 23 oil field!
Jock says there is no way he could ever be partners with the man who almost sent him to prison for a murder that he had nothing to do with. Bobby reacts as if he's been mortally wounded. Except JR is the one who gets shot. Bobby just can't understand why cutting Cliff in on the profits of Ewing 23 isn't even a better way to handle the situation than his original plan of running Cliff out of the state. Bobby isn't mortally wounded but he may be morally wounded, or more to the point, he doesn't have any clue as to what he stands for. First he wants to punish Cliff and then he wants to reward Cliff. Only a man bereft of morals wouldn't be able to decide whether he should punish or reward someone for instigating a trial that almost sent his father to a prison for a crime he didn't commit.
I find the discussion that's been going on here very easy, and it's interesting. This is one of the best discussions I've seen here in months. It's a matter of attitude - you either enjoy finding out what other people think or you don't. There is nothing difficult because it's not a contest. If someone looks at it as a contest, that the goal is to try to change someone's mind, then what do they expect to get if they "win"? A cookie?
To me, "idealizing JR and/or Sue Ellen" would be to consider them capable of doing no wrong. That's a moral judgment I have yet to see anyone make. Morality varies from one person to the next. My morality is different from yours, which is different from someone else's, etc.
If you want a more objective criteria, JR and Sue Ellen, got more viewers than any other couple at that time or since that time, which is what they were designed to do, so from a commercial success standpoint they've been the most ideal TV couple to come along so far.
If you look for positive things you can find them. If you look for negative things you can find them too. People decide what they choose to look for. They're two distinct mindsets and which one you choose comes down to which one you believe will lead to a more productive, more enjoyable life.
The only point of all your posts is to praise JR and Jock. It's kinda whack.
I guess I just got carried along by the story rather than waiting for Bobby to make good on something he’d said in the heat of moment three episodes earlier. I mean, I don’t even remember him saying it so maybe he didn’t either. Or maybe he just discreetly changed his mind. Or maybe it’s a bit like when a character gets really angry and says, “I’m gonna kill ya!” to someone but then they don’t kill them, but it was worth it just for the threat cos it was such an exciting moment. Or maybe Bobby is a bit of a hypocrite. All of which are fine by me.
As far as JR’s sexually abusive behaviour is concerned, it’s only a phone call that saves Sue Ellen from very obvious danger in the opening scenes of Killer At Large. This is her punishment for the Peedur affair so she can be ‘where I want you when I want you.’ There’s no more stark demonstration that rape has more to do with power than with sex. JR’s treatment of Holly Harwood was not, therefore, a misrepresentation of a character that -for all his devilish high jinks and good ol boy bonhomie - was deeply unpleasant and profoundly dysfunctional.
I've been doing a re-watch, so I just so that within the last few days. Yes, when JR said however the trial turns out, he's going to drive Cliff out of Texas and Bobby responded: "You're have to get in line behind me, brother."
I listed that as my first choice for the time they took a character too far because Bobby does a compete 180 just two episodes later. If he'd changed his mind because he thought that was too extreme, I'd have been fine with that. That's not what what he did. In two weeks Bobby went from wanting to drive Cliff out of Texas for what he did to Jock, to not only wanting, but insisting that Jock allow Cliff to become a business partner of his.
Bobby had no conviction in what he said. This isn't like Bobby losing his temper over a bad joke; this was a situation that could have easily ended up with his father spending he rest of his life in prison. Then to take the character to such a naive, simple-minded place, to where Bobby couldn't understand why it's unreasonable to expect Jock to make Cliff a business partner of his after what Cliff did to him, was so absurd it makes this qualify as my top choice for taking a character too far (and within much too short of a time period).
That's true. But their viewpoints don't tend to be quite as pathological as the Jock/JR defenders (and, especially in the past, the Sue Ellen defenders).It's equally frustrating to try and have a conversation with some who think Pam is capable of no wrongdoing or that Pam and Bobby had a perfect marriage. It works both ways.
That's true. But their viewpoints don't tend to be quite as pathological as the Jock/JR defenders (and, especially in the past, the Sue Ellen defenders).